I'll just provide my two cents regarding quality: I absolutely agree that AE jeans are quite durable and hold up well. HOWEVER, if you're looking for something a step up, I'd recommend Madewell jeans. I have both AE and Madewell, and I find Madewell to just be nicer all around. They hold up better throughout the day (don't get too loose or baggy), they hold you in better and provide better shaping, and just generally look nicer on than AE. I think AE are great, but I typically use those as jeans where I don't care too much if I spill something, if I'm going somewhere I have to sit on the ground, etc. I prefer my Madewell jeans for everyday wear. I agree that it's always best if you can try on in-person first. I also am particular about how my clothes feel, and I'd say both are great. Just in terms of quality, Madewell are a step up from AE. FWIW, I've owned far more expensive jeans (Joes, Citizens, Hudson...) and I really think Madewell jeans are equivalent quality. Answer from blairworejeansonce on reddit.com