You have options. If a king, get a firmer bed you like and she can place a twin XL plush topper on her side. Or you can get a split King and you can each get separate twin XL mattresses for a little more $$. A bed bridge placed beneath mattress protector and fitted sheets help camouflage any dip in the middle. Want to get fancy? Do this with an adjustable (split king) base. Not difficult. Answer from bmc1129 on reddit.com
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › i like firm beds, but my girlfriend likes soft beds. any compromise besides those expensive remote controlled mattresses?
r/Mattress on Reddit: i like firm beds, but my girlfriend likes soft beds. any compromise besides those expensive remote controlled mattresses?
December 9, 2019 -

My girlfriend and I moved in together about a year ago and we sleep on my mattress. I have a firm mattress that I got from Walmart a couple years ago that I really like. I think it's fairly comfortable and I usually get a good night's sleep on it. lately I've been thinking about getting a bigger bed, we currently have a full and I'd like to go up to a queen. and when I mentioned it to her she was all for it because as it turns out, she HATES our current bed! I had no idea because she never mentioned it!

but anyways, we can't really go to a mattress store and lay in a bunch of beds during a pandemic, so any tips on finding a matress online that we could both like? I don't like soft beds because I tend to feel like I'm sinking into them, but she feels like sleeping on a firm bed is like sleeping on the floor. I'm a big guy, about 5'6" 260 lbs. and she's about 4'11" 180lbs.

I have a budget of about $700 for a new bed and frame, but I'm willing to go higher if necessary. any suggestions or tips? where should I look? would getting a box spring help either of us?

🌐
Nest Bedding®
nestbedding.com › blogs › news › 6797140-when-partners-disagree-on-the-feel-of-mattress
When Partners Disagree On The Feel Of A Mattress
October 28, 2012 - This is an excellent solution for customers who are not that far apart in feel. On Topper: Finding a mattress that works for the partner who prefers a firmer feeling bed, then finding a topper for the other partner's side. We carry organic wool toppers, latex toppers, foam toppers, memory foam toppers and other natural and non-toxic materials to soften up a mattress.
🌐
BabyCenter
community.babycenter.com › home › groups › bargain hunters
husband likes firm mattress. I like soft | BabyCenter
September 19, 2014 - DH and I went through this ridiculousness as well. He likes firm and I like less than firm. He moved into my place when we got married and within a year, he was done with my mattress. He purchased a firm foam mattress. Let's just say, I spent alot of nights on the couch because it was killing my back.
🌐
Quora
quora.com › How-can-you-compromise-with-your-partner-when-you-have-conflicting-preferences-in-terms-of-mattress-firmness
How to compromise with your partner when you have conflicting preferences in terms of mattress firmness - Quora
Answer: We solved that in 2 different ways. When we got married we bought 2 twin beds and pushed them together to make a king sized bed. My mattress was like a rock, he preferred a softer mattress. Then about 20 years ago we bought one of the beds that essentially had 2 air mattress chambers. Min...
🌐
Bedrooms & More
bedroomsandmore.com › home › blog › customize your mattress: when you and your partner sleep differently
How To Customize Your Mattress for Two Different Partners
April 23, 2025 - I didn’t realize that you could get a custom mattress with two different levels of firmness on each side. I like more plush and my husband prefers more firm.
🌐
Themattresstoppercompany
themattresstoppercompany.com › home › news › news
What If Me And My Partner Prefer Different Levels Of Firmness?
September 18, 2024 - Ah, the classic bedtime battle: one of you likes the bed soft and cushy, while the other prefers something firm enough to bounce a pound coin off. Sharing a bed is supposed to bring you closer together, not leave you divided over mattress firmness!
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › options for husband and wife with polar opposite mattress needs
r/Mattress on Reddit: Options for husband and wife with polar opposite mattress needs
March 22, 2021 -

My wife likes soft-to-medium mattresses. I like firm mattresses. We've tried a couple bed-in-a-box foam mattresses, with various foam and pillow toppers, to see if we could find an acceptable middle ground, but we've had no success so far. One of us is always waking up with considerable back pain.

We are considering a Sleep Number bed, so we can each have our own firmness. I'm hesitant, however, because I've read so many bad things about their beds and the company. Also the price seems a bit inflated (pun intended).

Are there other good options for couples with drastically different mattress needs?

Find elsewhere
🌐
The Mattress Expert
mattressexpert.typepad.com › the_mattress_expert › 2017 › 08 › i_like_firm_and_he_likes_soft_split-king_mattress-recommendation.html
I like firm and he likes soft. Split king mattress recommendation. - The Mattress Expert
Two twin XL sets costs hundreds of dollars more than a single king and you're left with a gap in the middle. Instead of memory foam, use latex for a topper...firmer for your side and softer for his.
🌐
Simply Rest
simplyrest.com › home › mattress resources › what to do when your mattress is too soft or too firm
What to Do When Your Mattress Is Too Soft or Too Firm | Simply Rest
March 21, 2023 - Memory foam mattresses and latex mattresses in queen and king sizes can sometimes be ordered with different levels of firmness on each side of a single bed to accommodate two people (Click the links to see our reviews and recommendations). Split-chamber beds like softside waterbeds allow each ...
🌐
Amazon
amazon.com › ask › questions › Tx3NDL86AAQZK9 › ref=ask_ql_ql_al_hza
Amazon.com: Customer Questions & Answers
I would say yes. My husband likes firm and I like soft, we got this and we both really love it. It's firm but cradles you so it feels soft at the same time. We put a my pillow mattress topper on it and it's perfect for both of us
🌐
Sleep Foundation
sleepfoundation.org › best mattress
The Best Mattress for Couples
The medium soft model earned the highest marks for motion isolation, so people who are easily awakened by their partner’s movements may want to consider this firmness level. ... All WinkBed mattresses feature a Euro-top surface padded with adaptive polyfoam. This material conforms to the body without hugging too closely, making the mattress a good alternative for people who don’t like sleeping on memory foam.
Published   July 3, 2025
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › hubby likes it hard; i like it soft.
r/Mattress on Reddit: Hubby likes it hard; I like it soft.
July 11, 2014 -

Help! My husband is a back sleeper and likes a firm mattress. I'm mostly a side sleeper who tosses and turns a lot and likes a soft mattress. Currently we sleep on what feels like a wooden pallet and I'm in pain.

I'm 5'1" 125-130 lbs; he's 5'7" and 165-170 lbs.

We want to spend less than $1200. Which online mattress would work for both of us, if any?! I'm considering Leesa because it seems like it would be a good balance of firm and soft. Thoughts?

🌐
Forbes
forbes.com › forbes homepage › forbes vetted › mattress & sleep › mattresses
Best Mattresses For Couples: We Retested Picks For Varying Needs
October 2, 2025 - Couples can also choose from three firmness levels (soft, medium and firm) and an optional 2-inch pillow top to suit different sleep needs and preferences. According to Chapman, who slept on this mattress for months, “I found the bed regulated my body temperature nicely and kept heat from getting trapped. My husband ...
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › me and my partner have different needs, what do we do?
r/Mattress on Reddit: Me and my partner have different needs, what do we do?
September 23, 2023 -

I'm small at 130lbs, he's tall and wide at 280lbs. He has sleep breathing and snoring problems as well due to obesity and bad allergies.

Our current mattress is a queen and firm, and I hate it. It's way too firm for me, and his body's width takes up over half. We're going to get a king, but can't agree on the firmness of the mattress.

I want something pretty soft, but if we get something soft, will his body degrade it quickly? Will he find it too uncomfortable over time? Will it make his breathing and snoring worse?

🌐
Sleep Foundation
sleepfoundation.org › mattress information
Do I Need a Firm or Soft Mattress? | Sleep Foundation
July 15, 2025 - Selecting a firmness level is an important step in your mattress search. Firmness is somewhat subjective, meaning that what feels comfortable to one person may feel too soft or too firm for another. Finding the right firmness level to suit your needs will require a bit of trial-and-error, but nonetheless, there are some important things to know when getting started. ... Comfort preferences This is the most subjective factor. What feels comfortable to you and your partner? Do you typically prefer soft beds, firm beds, or somewhere in-between?
🌐
NYTimes
nytimes.com › sleep › mattresses › how to choose a mattress
How to Choose a Mattress for 2026 | Reviews by Wirecutter
April 2, 2025 - If you sleep with a partner yet your preferences differ—say, you prefer firm but your mate likes something plusher—you’ll need to find a compromise. Lean toward what’s most comfortable for the partner who has musculoskeletal issues (such as lower back pain), said Cleveland Clinic’s Santhosh Thomas. If neither of you has an issue on that front, you could choose the firmer option and (for a king-size bed) attempt to make one side softer with a twin-size mattress topper.
🌐
CertiPUR-US
certipur.us › home › the soft vs. firm mattress debate: finding peace in the split
The Soft vs. Firm Mattress Debate: Finding Peace in the Split
March 11, 2025 - According to the Better Sleep Council, fifty-one percent of Americans said they prefer a “firm or very firm” mattress while 49 percent like their mattress “soft or very soft.” This means the average couple has about a 50-50 chance of ...
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › best beds for couples who like different mattress firmness?
r/Mattress on Reddit: Best beds for couples who like different mattress firmness?
September 23, 2024 -

My fiance and I have wildly different sleeping preferences - he likes firm and memory foam, while I like soft and pillowtop. We got a Sleep Number bed because you can set each side of the bed to what you want, but neither of us like it. When I lower the sleep number setting to make the bed “softer”, it just deflates and provides no support.

I was considering getting a King bed frame and putting two Twin XL mattresses in it. Even going that route though it’s difficult to find a plush pillowtop and a firm memory foam that are the same height. Has anyone gone the 2 twin XL route? Any complaints about feeling a seam down the middle? Do we have other options?

It looks like the Beautyrest Black series have some Twin XL mattresses that would work, but then all old the bed would be $4-5,000 which is far more than we’d like to spend. We were thinking under $2000. Is the Beautyrest Black worth the price?

Thank you!