The BlackWidow Chroma V2 can feel exactly the same as your Ultimate, but you want to make sure you get it with the Green Switch. The BlackWidow Chroma V2 is available with (almost) all of Razer's switches, the Green (clicky and tactile, what you have on your Ulti), Orange (tactile on semi-quiet) and Yellow (linear and semi-quiet). If you get the Greens again, it will feel 100% identical. I would say go for the BlackWidow Chroma V2, but if you like the feel of Greens, you should also consider the Huntsman and Huntsman Elite, which feature the similar-feeling Purple switches and full RGB lighting. They're clicky and tactile, but have shorter throw and take less force to press, if you can imagine that. Also keep in mind that there is a rumor that the BlackWidow Chroma V2 "Elite" is coming soon, which is supposed to have the Huntsman Elite's media controls. Another keyboard I'd consider is the cheaper Ornata Chroma. It has the clickiest, most tactile switches of all, Razer's mecha-membrane. It's lower quality, in terms of construction and longevity, than a BlackWidow, but it's also substantially cheaper and I think the key feel is just as good (although appreciably different). That's a more affordable way to get clicky keys and full RGB per key lighting. Keep in mind though that, if you think you'll use macro keys, the BlackWidow Chroma V2 is the only one of these that has them currently. More on reddit.com

Mine still works but I gave it to a friend to enjoy. I’ve since bought the V2 and then gave that to my mom and now have the V4 Pro. More on reddit.com

this is the blackwidow keyboard line that reliably delivered keystrokes for almost a decade without having RGB problem, no bloated software, and notably best build among blackwidow product lines. it’s just so freaking big, More on reddit.com