November 25, 2025 - The choice between being overweight and using this specific product is an example of a false dichotomy. In reality, there are many options other than the two mentioned, such as losing weight independently or using a different program. Similarly, false dichotomies can be used in various types ...

January 13, 2008 - Meat Versus Veggies: People eat either lots of meat or no meat whatsoever and the two groups inevitably clash. "Balanced diet"? What is that? Neutrality Backlash: When a False Dichotomy is enforced by one side or both extremes via active hostility ...

March 10, 2022 - In 2001, then-president George W. Bush was quoted making the following statement to Congress in response to the attacks on 9/11: “Every nation, in every region, now has a decision to make. Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists.” In the time since, President Bush has been criticized for his all-or-nothing

March 2, 2022 - This is a false dichotomy, as it suggests there are only two possible options for vaccine efficacy: (1) the vaccines stop 100% of infections or (2) the vaccines are completely ineffective.

Other examples of false dichotomies include George Bush saying “Either you are with us or you’re with the terrorists”, and the demand made in an Ulster pub, “Are you a Catholic or a Protestant?” Both of these example ignore possible third options that might involve some degree of agreement or disagreement with either side of the dichotomy: I might disapprove both of terrorism and of George Bush’s ‘War on Terror’, and I might disagree with both Catholic and Protestant beliefs whilst sharing to some extent the culture of each.

April 23, 2024 - Some forced choice posts seem innocent. One popular media star asked her followers to decide whether America’s most important strength was diversity or freedom.

The choice to either leave or stay in the Middle East is a false, dangerous, and unnecessary one.

Answer (1 of 6): “He hates Trump. He must be a Democrat.” “Don't believe Evolution? You must be Christian.” “If you don't make dinner we'll have to eat leftovers.” “She refuses to drive, she must be a hippy.” “My kid doesn't like Drake. He must love Death Metal.” “He refuses to date a Transs...

If the vaccine doesn’t prevent a person from getting infected and spreading SARS-CoV-2, why get vaccinated? This is an example of false dichotomy because it assumes only two options — the vaccine works or it doesn’t, but most things are not either-or situations.

Examples of false dichotomies are provided, such as saying the only choices are to give all undocumented immigrants amnesty or deport them all, when other options exist in between those extremes.

Second on his list—after the collective inability to focus on more than one public-health intervention at a time (because “journalists constantly look for new stories,” among other things)—came “false dichotomies,” or the persistent temptation to reduce complex problems to a “two-sided caricature.” Yong’s examples included “mild” versus “severe” illness (a “mild” COVID infection might not feel mild at all to the infectee), “sick” versus “recovered” (what about those with long COVID?), “saving lives” versus “saving the economy” (the latter cannot operate without a good baseline of public health), and “lockdown” versus “let it rip” (language that put one in mind of a light switch when many policy choices existed between the extremes).

July 24, 2023 - False dilemma fallacy exampleEither you support this new legislation to give the police more power, or you want society to descend into chaos! A false dilemma (or false dichotomy) is a common type of fallacy. It often appears in political speeches and advertisements, as well as informal everyday conversations.

April 18, 2023 - It’s not uncommon on Social Media to be met with some strange takes on subjects that are pretty well grounded, like the False Dichotomy. Folks can make mistakes, but instead of realising that and learning from that they often double down. Today we are going to be discussing the False Dichotomy. What it is, how it ought to be used, and an example of someone dancing around the fact that they don’t know what they are talking about.

Over the past months, logical fallacies and cognitive biases have relentlessly distracted from critical appraisal and transparent communication of the scientific evidence related to COVID-19 [17]. Confirmation bias, availability bias, motivated reasoning, the Dunning-Kruger effect, black-or-white fallacy (also known as false dilemma, false dichotomy, either/or fallacy, or false choice), straw man fallacy, ad hominem fallacy, appeal to emotion, appeal to ignorance, and appeal to authority fallacies have all run rampant across social media.

Whenever you present someone with a limited number of choices, when in reality there are more choices, you are committing this fallacy. For example, one individual recently gave me a menu of 5 choices to help reduce someone's insulin resistance.

This dichotomy overlooks the possibility that someone might support progress but have reservations about the specific policy. "If you're not part of the solution, you're part of the problem." This statement falsely implies that there are only two roles one can play in addressing an issue, ...

January 3, 2024 - In Exercising: A lot of people on social media that have devoted their life to exercising espouse a common mantra: either max-out or go home. No middle road in this mindset. Not pushing yourself to the point of pain is the same as sitting on ...

This example demonstrates how a false dichotomy breaks down. Because a vote against the dam project is a vote for continued drought (while a vote in favor is a vote to improve drought conditions), anyone against the dam project wants the Western US to remain drought intolerant.