I think there are some perfectly decent ones. I thought that the Sonic Movie, especially Sonic 3, was actually pretty enjoyable. And I had a great time with the One Piece live action, it wasn’t amazing or anything, but still pretty solid imo, like a 8/10. Answer from Gokuto7 on reddit.com
🌐
Rotten Tomatoes
editorial.rottentomatoes.com › guide › all-disney-live-action-remakes-ranked
Disney Live-Action Remakes (Lilo & Stitch), Ranked by Tomatometer | Rotten Tomatoes
May 23, 2025 - Critics Consensus: Pete's Dragon continues Disney's current live-action winning streak with an update that gives the original a visual overhaul without overwhelming its sweet, soulful charm.
🌐
IMDb
imdb.com › list › ls569014186
Live-action remakes
Here is a list of live-action versions of popular cartoon shows.
Discussions

Has there even been a good live action remake or adaptation?
I think there are some perfectly decent ones. I thought that the Sonic Movie, especially Sonic 3, was actually pretty enjoyable. And I had a great time with the One Piece live action, it wasn’t amazing or anything, but still pretty solid imo, like a 8/10. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/fixingmovies
115
34
June 14, 2025
What are some of the Live action Disney remakes that are ACTUALLY good
Here's a list of them: And that was the list More on reddit.com
🌐 r/Schaffrillas
141
152
June 29, 2023
Have there been any live-action-remakes of animated films that actually make a case for themselves along side the originals?
SPEED RACER (2008) is probably the best example of a pure version of this. Whether you enjoy it or not, they absolutely hit what they were aiming for in terms of adapting a cartoon into an entire live-action visual language. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/movies
147
4
October 15, 2025
How did Disney manage to fail almost every single live action remake?
One of the biggest issues with the remakes were that the originals all generally had really tight and efficient scripts. The remakes all had to justify their existence, and therefore added unnecessary elements to pad it out. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/movies
5673
21606
January 1, 2023
🌐
Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org › wiki › List_of_remakes_and_adaptations_of_Disney_animated_films
List of remakes and adaptations of Disney animated films - Wikipedia
1 day ago - This is a list of live-action or photorealistic remakes produced by Walt Disney Pictures of its animated feature films. The list also includes the films' sequels and spin-offs within their fictional universe.
🌐
Deadline
deadline.com › lists › disney-live-action-remakes
Disney Live Action Remakes: From 'Cinderella' To 'Dumbo'
July 17, 2025 - Disney has remade several of its animated classics into live-action feature films recently, like 'Pete's Dragon,' 'The Jungle Book' and 'Aladdin.'
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/fixingmovies › has there even been a good live action remake or adaptation?
r/fixingmovies on Reddit: Has there even been a good live action remake or adaptation?
June 14, 2025 - Though I think Disney has had their fair share of good remakes, The Jungle Book, Aladdin, Cruella. And personally I love TLOU season 1 and Fallout, I think they were very well done. More replies More replies More replies More replies ... For live action remakes, it already peaked in '96.
🌐
ComicBook.com
comicbook.com › home › disney’s next live-action remake finally confirms its cast (including a former dc star in the lead)
Disney's Next Live-Action Remake Finally Confirms Its Cast (Including a Former DC Star in the Lead) - ComicBook.com
1 week ago - It perhaps isn’t a coincidence that the more modern Lilo & Stitch (the original animated movie premiered in 2002) was the much bigger hit. Remaking titles that strongly resonate with younger audiences as opposed to going decades back into Disney history seems like the way to go. ... The Status of Every Upcoming Disney Live-Action Remake: What’s Confirmed, What’s Cancelled & What’s Rumored
Find elsewhere
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/schaffrillas › what are some of the live action disney remakes that are actually good
r/Schaffrillas on Reddit: What are some of the Live action Disney remakes that are ACTUALLY good
June 29, 2023 - And some people consider it a Disney live action remake, even if it's a sequel to a live action film, but TRON: Legacy is one of Disney's best films. It does the legacy sequel thing much better than the new Star Wars films.
🌐
Decoding Everything
decodingeverything.com › brief-history-of-live-action-remakes-dragons-lion-king-beauty-and-the-beast
Why We're Stuck In An Endless Hell of Live Action Remakes
September 22, 2025 - The real Live Action Remake craze started more than a decade later, when the former Disney Studios Chief who had overseen Dalmatians, Joe Roth, came back to his old company with a pitch: a radical new take on Alice in Wonderland, written by Beauty and the Beast screenwriter Linda Woolverton.
🌐
The Everymom
theeverymom.com › home › disney live-action remakes: a look at what’s been released and what’s in the works
Disney Live-Action Remakes: What's Been Released and What's in the Works
October 20, 2025 - My sister and I always vowed to keep her Disney movies—and her VCR—to share them with our own kids one day. I know my grandma would be so excited to know that not only do we cherish the collection, but Disney is actually remaking some of those classic movies into live-action revivals.
🌐
CBR
cbr.com › home › movies › movie lists › every disney live-action remake in the works after moana
Every Disney Live-Action Remake in the Works After Moana
November 19, 2025 - Disney's live-action reboots have been controversial, but successful enough for the studio to continue for the foreseeable future. Despite Snow White's failure last year, Disney seems committed to making more live-action remakes of its most iconic properties, with several in the works for after Moana.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/movies › have there been any live-action-remakes of animated films that actually make a case for themselves along side the originals?
r/movies on Reddit: Have there been any live-action-remakes of animated films that actually make a case for themselves along side the originals?
October 15, 2025 -

I admit I have a pretty cynical view of live action remakes of animated films. My gut always says "creatively bankrupt cash-grab" and broadly I feel that instinct has been proven right more often than not.

I'm cynical about remakes in general too, but I don't think they always have to be cynical cash grabs. Both versions of The Fly are great, and they're a fun double feature because they're quite different from each other.

The choice to be animated is a creative decision on a pretty structural level of what a film is, it's the aesthetic course everything will flow down, and those aesthetics mean something. I feel like it could be possible to do a live action remake of an animated film that really highlights the meaning of that creative choice, but I haven't actually seen that yet.

Hence this thread, have you ever seen an live action remake of an animated film that really made you feel like you'd seen a fresh angle on an idea, rather than seen an old idea with new clothes? A movie that feels like a separate, yet equally worthy product, from its original?

🌐
All The Right Movies
alltherightmovies.com › home › the real power of disney’s live action remakes
The real power of Disney’s live action remakes - All The Right Movies
September 8, 2022 - It has done that by literally rewriting ... reboots currently in development and pre-production, including Peter Pan, Snow White and the Seven Dwarves and Bambi....
🌐
Box Office Mojo
boxofficemojo.com › franchise › fr1715965701
Franchise: Disney Live Action Reimaginings - Box Office Mojo
Latest Updates: News | Daily | Weekend | All Time | International | Showdowns · Glossary | User Guide | License IMDb Data | Help
🌐
Yahoo!
uk.movies.yahoo.com › disney-new-live-action-remakes-090833325.html
All the live-action Disney remakes in development
March 25, 2025 - “The thing that stood out in Venom was the humour,” Watts says.Read More » · The director has said he suffers from agoraphobia
🌐
CBC
cbc.ca › kidsnews › post › poll-do-you-like-live-action-remakes-of-animated-movies
POLL — Do you like live-action remakes of animated movies? | story | Kids News
November 21, 2025 - Live-action adaptations of Snow White, left, and Lilo & Stitch, right, both came out this year. (Image credit: Disney) While these remakes can be popular with audiences, some people think they’re unnecessary.
🌐
No Film School
nofilmschool.com › disneys-live-action-moana-remake
Disney’s Live-Action 'Moana' Remake: Art or Just Another Cash Grab? | No Film School
Disney has been on this trend for the last twenty years, where they take one of their animated movies and then remake it into live action.
Published   November 18, 2025
🌐
Hollywood Reporter
hollywoodreporter.com › lists › movie-remakes-better-than-original
13 Movie Remakes Better Than the Original
November 24, 2025 - Perhaps the most glaring exception to this rule is the remake of 1991’s La Totale, an action comedy whose very logline felt made for Hollywood: A secret agent who leads a double life as a boring office grunt drags his unsuspecting family into his high-stakes affairs.
🌐
CBR
cbr.com › home › movies › movie lists › 8 weirdest disney live-action remakes (#1 is a fantasy cult classic)
8 Weirdest Disney Live-Action Remakes (#1 Is a Fantasy Cult Classic)
December 7, 2025 - Once known for vibrant animated classics, Disney has lately been very involved in live-action movies. And not original stories, but live-action remakes of classics like Cinderella, Beauty and the Beast, and The Lion King.