Has there even been a good live action remake or adaptation?
What are some of the Live action Disney remakes that are ACTUALLY good
Have there been any live-action-remakes of animated films that actually make a case for themselves along side the originals?
How did Disney manage to fail almost every single live action remake?
Videos
I admit I have a pretty cynical view of live action remakes of animated films. My gut always says "creatively bankrupt cash-grab" and broadly I feel that instinct has been proven right more often than not.
I'm cynical about remakes in general too, but I don't think they always have to be cynical cash grabs. Both versions of The Fly are great, and they're a fun double feature because they're quite different from each other.
The choice to be animated is a creative decision on a pretty structural level of what a film is, it's the aesthetic course everything will flow down, and those aesthetics mean something. I feel like it could be possible to do a live action remake of an animated film that really highlights the meaning of that creative choice, but I haven't actually seen that yet.
Hence this thread, have you ever seen an live action remake of an animated film that really made you feel like you'd seen a fresh angle on an idea, rather than seen an old idea with new clothes? A movie that feels like a separate, yet equally worthy product, from its original?