Mendota and Enviro are probably the best for quality materials, user friendly controls and great support for their products. They are a bit pricey compared to Heat n Glo. Rather than looking for a brand. Maybe look for a reputable dealer in the area and ask for their opinion. But Mendota and Enviro are great options nonetheless. Answer from ThatFireplaceGuy on reddit.com
🌐
The Stove Shop
fireplaceexperts.com › home › our top gas fireplace insert for heat in 2026
Best Gas Fireplace Insert for Heat in 2025
2 weeks ago - If you plan to install a gas fireplace insert in your living room, we recommend the Escape from Heat & Glo. It give you the most bang for your buck! The heat output and gorgeous flame with the anti-reflective glass make this gas fireplace insert ...
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/fireplaces › what gas insert is best?
r/Fireplaces on Reddit: What gas insert is best?
June 30, 2023 -

I am converting my wood fireplace to gas and am looking for the best natural gas insert. Reliability, efficiency, and heating are the qualities I am looking for.

The house is a two story cape cod and has about 1,000 sq ft on the first level with an open floor plan and two bedrooms. I am looking for something that will heat the first level. The house also has oil heat which is getting expensive.

I am lucky enough to have several makes to choose from. I believe the size is 30”

Heat & Glo

Enviro

Quadra-Fire

Jotul

Mendota

Pacific Energy

Regency

And I am sure even more.

What would you choose and what would you stay away from?

🌐
The Spruce
thespruce.com › best-gas-fireplace-inserts-4169551
The 5 Best Gas Fireplace Inserts of 2025
August 18, 2025 - With that in mind, we researched ... find the best options to replace any wood-burning fireplace. Best Overall: Napoleon B46NTR Direct Vent Fireplace at Fireplacesdirect.com Jump to Review...
🌐
Bob Vila
bobvila.com › reviews › major systems › hvac › the best gas fireplace inserts
The Best Gas Fireplace Inserts Top Picks - Bob Vila
September 27, 2023 - BEST DIRECT-VENT: Empire Tahoe Deluxe Direct-Vent Millivolt Fireplace · ALSO CONSIDER: Ashley Hearth Products 34,000 BTU Vent-Free Firebox ... Personal taste is a major factor when choosing things like gas fireplace inserts, but I have tried to remain objective and include a broad range of styles.
🌐
Thegreatfirecompany
thegreatfirecompany.com › blogs › learning-center › best-gas-fireplace-insert
Best Gas Fireplace Inserts | Top-Rated Gas Fireplace Inserts 2025 – The Great Fire Company
August 22, 2025 - The Superior gas fireplace inserts highlighted in this guide prioritize safety with features like automatic shut-off and ODS on ventless models. Always review the manufacturer's safety information and follow proper installation and maintenance guidelines for safe operation. At this point you should feel pretty confident in weighing your options for the best ...
🌐
Blazing Embers
blazingembers.com › home › blog › the evolution of gas fireplace inserts: a comprehensive review from embers living
The Evolution of Gas Fireplace Inserts: A Comprehensive Review from Embers Living - Embers Fireplaces & Outdoor Living
The Escape represents the pinnacle of Heat & Glo’s gas fireplace insert line. It is described as feature-rich and fully loaded, positioning itself as possibly the best in the market.
🌐
Family Handyman
familyhandyman.com › home › house & components › parts of house › fireplace
Best Gas Direct-Vent and Ventless Fireplace Inserts For Homeowners
February 4, 2021 - Dimmitt says a direct-vent insert is the best. “Those are much more efficient, and you’re not paying for heat that’s going up the chimney,” he says. Natural gas is generally cheaper and safer than propane, but propane is more energy ...
🌐
Hvac-for-beginners
hvac-for-beginners.com › gas-fireplace-insert-ratings.html
Gas Fireplace Insert Reviews - HVAC for Beginners
October 6, 2024 - They are easier to install as no venting is required and gas conversion is not required to burn LP gas. The brand offers an optional blower to distribute the heat throughout the room but it is not included as standard equipment. They have battery assisted piezo ignition and a remote control but the remote does not sense the room temperature. ... These inserts are made in Canada by Sherwood Industries Limited and they are backed by a very good warranty but they are only sold through a limited network of dealers in North America. The fireplaces have a fan to circulate the heat throughout the room and they have an intermittent pilot system with a remote control which saves energy.
Find elsewhere
🌐
Hearth.com
hearth.com › forums › main hearth forums › the hearth room - wood stoves and fireplaces
Who makes the best gas fireplace inserts? | Hearth.com Forums Home
November 22, 2006 - Reporting back as promised, I love my new insert. It has a ceramic firebox, so it takes about 22 minutes for it to reach heat equilibrium and the fan to activate. After I shut it off, the fan runs for about another 22 minutes. It is a very effective space heater, meaning it is about 300% better than the gas fired decoration (gas logs) it replaced. I'd do it again in a heartbeat. Highly recommended. Click to expand... Hello, I have the Heat & Glow FB Grand fireplace insert.
🌐
Friendly Fires
friendlyfires.ca › fireplace-insert-buying-guide-everything-you-need-to-know
Fireplace Insert Buying Guide: Everything You Need to Know - Friendly Fires
November 10, 2025 - In summary, a gas fireplace insert offers ease of operation, a cozy ambiance, high efficiency (often exceeding 80%), chimney sealing benefits, and enhanced home value, making it a worthwhile investment.
🌐
Consumer Reports
consumerreports.org › appliances › heating, cooling & air › fireplaces › fireplace insert ratings
Fireplace Ratings & Reviews - Consumer Reports
No one tests fireplaces like we do. Get ratings, pricing, and performance for all the latest models based on the features you care about.
🌐
Regency Fireplace Products
regency-fire.com › home › blog | your fireplace questions answered | regency › top 11 gas fireplace insert trends of 2021
The 11 Best Gas Fireplace Insert Trends of 2021
March 9, 2022 - Blowers with multiple speeds afford the greatest amount of comfort because they can be adjusted to circulate air softly or forcefully. Pick an insert with a warrantied blower that operates at a respectful noise level. Your local fireplace dealer can help you identify which gas fireplace inserts have the best blowers.
🌐
Best Home Gear
besthomegear.com › reviews › best gas fireplace insert for chimney (reviews 2026)
Best Gas Fireplace Insert for Chimney (Reviews 2026) - Best Home Gear
The Peterson “White Birch” natural gas fireplace insert creates a more than adequate 90,000 BTUs of heating capacity. The “Vented” Fireplace Log Insert includes heat-resistant, natural-looking five-piece “Birch” Logs and a G45 Dual-flame ...
Published   4 days ago
🌐
Welovefire
welovefire.com › home › articles, news and helpful tips › all about gas fireplace inserts: buying advice
All About Gas Fireplace Inserts: Buying Advice - We Love Fire®
March 21, 2023 - Extremely easy to operate, the comfort and atmosphere of beautiful flames to enjoy, efficiencies of +80%, eliminating that cold air down the chimney, and adding value to your home, YES a gas fireplace insert is most definitely worth it! There’s seldom a “best” of anything.
🌐
This Old House
thisoldhouse.com › home › an easy guide to gas fireplaces
All About Gas Fireplaces: Types, Costs, and Installation - This ...
They are significantly more efficient than wood-burning fires, producing more heat with less fuel. They may also offer enhanced safety features like automatic shut-off and oxygen depletion sensors.
Published   October 4, 2024
🌐
Bogleheads.org
bogleheads.org › board index › community › personal consumer issues
Seeking Advice on Choosing a Gas Fireplace - Bogleheads.org
Gas log chimney / vented or ventless provided little to none of what we wanted in a fireplace (warmth and ambience). Our very anecdotal experience of having owned one of each over the course of the last 30 years. By no means comprehensive but thought it could be helpful in the context of what other BH's contribute as well. Best. ... Thank you. That is very helpful. Interestingly I thought the gas logs they showed were incredibly realistic. Much more so than the insert.
🌐
Luxuryfire
luxuryfire.com › home › best gas fireplace inserts
Best Gas Fireplace Inserts | Top Direct‑Vent Gas Insert Heaters (2025)
... Scroll down for quick‑answer FAQs and a side‑by‑side comparison of six best‑selling inserts including Regency, SÓLAS, Valor, Enviro, Archgard, and Mendota so you can choose the best gas insert fireplace for your space and budget.
🌐
Regency Fireplace Products
regency-fire.com › home › for buyers › buyer's guide › gas fireplace inserts buyer's guide
How to Buy a Gas Fireplace Insert | Buyer's Guide from Regency
Modern gas fireplace inserts are installed into open masonry fireplaces by qualified gas contractors to stop cold chimney draft, increase home heating efficiency and improve indoor air quality. Every Regency gas fireplace insert provides beautiful fire ambience guaranteed by the best warranty ...
🌐
RedFlagDeals
forums.redflagdeals.com › gas-fireplace-insert-advise-recommendation-1236841
Gas Fireplace Insert advise/recommendation - RedFlagDeals.com Forums
The only hole I needed was to run the gas line into the house. Luckily, my meter is 6 feet away. ... will888 wrote: ↑I got mine at Marsh's fireplace. The model is a G3, there was no G4 back then. The features that impressed me was a low dial down to 6500 btu and the remote control. I followed pricing for a few months while I was doing my due dilligence. It does not look like fireplaces go on sale like electronics. The best I saw was like $100-150 off.
🌐
Houzz
houzz.com › discussions › 2364577 › 3-choices-for-gas-insert
3 choices for gas insert
My hubby and I would like to put in a natural gas insert into our masonry firplace. I have pretty much narrowed it down to three brands available locally. I worry about purchasing this kind of item off the internet. I would love to get people's opinion of these three different brands of gas ...