Most people are probably better off with the flexibility of MR. Given you are a Marriott super-user, Bonvoy seems to make sense for you, so do it! Answer from Deleted User on reddit.com
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/amex › bonvoy brilliant better than amex gold for "all other purchases"?
r/amex on Reddit: Bonvoy brilliant better than Amex gold for "all other purchases"?
October 4, 2024 -

Background: I travel a lot and use Marriott extensively and find great value in Bonvoy Brilliant. I have the Amex Gold for restaurants and groceries. I don't usually buy flights due to family flight benefits.

A lot of threads don't like Bonvoy Brilliant for anything other than booking Marriott. However, in the "All Other Purchases" category (phone/utility bills, subscriptions, online and retail shopping etc.) it earns 2X (Bonvoy points estimated at ~0.7cpp * 2 = 1.4cpp) versus 1X with Amex Gold (MR ~ 1.1cpp). To me, it makes sense to tie all transactions that are not grocery or restaurants, which fall in the "All Other Purchases" category, to Bonvoy Brilliant instead of gold,, if you just had these 2 cards. Am I missing something?

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/amex › marriott bonvoy brilliant or bevy vs. amex gold
r/amex on Reddit: Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant or Bevy vs. Amex Gold
January 14, 2023 -

Hey, folks! My fiancé and I are Marriott loyalists and are trying to save up Marriott points for our honeymoon. I know that Amex points are transferable, so it seems like the Bevy and Gold earn about the same (aside from airfare, which we hardly do). Do I open both since the the Gold card pays for itself with its dining credits? Do I splurge and go for the Brilliant and the Gold for the hotel status benefits? Some other combo? Thanks!

Current Cards:

Blue Cash Preferred Hilton Honors

🌐
Join Kudos
joinkudos.com › blog › compared-amex-gold-vs-marriott-bonvoy-brilliant
Amex Gold vs Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant
Deciding which is better, Amex Gold or Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant, comes down to your primary spending habits and travel style.
🌐
American Express
americanexpress.com › us › credit-cards › card › marriott-bonvoy-brilliant
Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant® American Express® Card
Earn 6X Marriott Bonvoy points at Hotels participating in Marriott Bonvoy® and 3X points at Restaurants Worldwide. Enjoy luxury stays and travel perks. Terms Apply.
🌐
Bogleheads.org
bogleheads.org › board index › us investors › personal finance (not investing)
American Express Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant card - Is it worth it? - Bogleheads.org
For me the value in higher level Marriott status is the late checkout (2pm gold and 4pm platinum) which isn't always easy to get the property to let you use. You can combine with the $125 AMEX Mariott Bonvoy card and get 15 more elite night credits to start the year off at 30, which is a nice head start.
🌐
TikTok
tiktok.com › discover › marriott-brilliant-vs-amex-gold
Marriott Brilliant Vs Amex Gold | TikTok
August 18, 2025 - #fyp #foryou #smart #travel #amexplatinum #amex #houston #houstontx #adventure #advice #blowthisup #listen #money #moneytok #reallife #true #truestory ... ▪ Ever wonder how frequent travelers achieve elite hotel status without practically living in hotels? ▪ Our guest Kevin Zanes has a genius strategy for hitting Marriott Titanium status without staying 75 nights! ▪ By using the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant card and Marriott Business card from Amex, he racks up 40 nights right at the start of the year.
🌐
Yahoo! Finance
finance.yahoo.com › personal finance › credit cards
Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant American Express card: A premium card with tons of added benefits
Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant® American Express® Card
No promotional APR: The Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant card doesn't have a promotional APR offer for purchases or balance transfers, so the regular APR will apply to all transactions. Limited point redemptions: Although you can redeem your points in various ways, Marriott hotel stays offer the highest value. Other redemption methods offer significantly less value for your points. You can make a payment online or through the Amex ...
Rating: 3 ​
Find elsewhere
🌐
Cardcritics
cardcritics.com › credit-cards › card-issuer › american-express › marriott-bonvoy-brilliant-review
Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant Review | CardCritics™
It also comes with Hilton Honors ... and a wide range of travel credits. Although the annual fee is high at $895 , the card offers significantly more benefits than the Bonvoy Brilliant, with perks you can use on airlines, hotels and car rentals....
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/amex › is the amex bonvoy brilliant worth it as a daily driver vs amex gold?
r/amex on Reddit: Is the Amex Bonvoy Brilliant worth it as a daily driver vs Amex Gold?
December 25, 2022 -

EDIT - I will leave this up here in case someone else is as dumb as me but I didn't realize these were hotel-specific points and not just the standard amex points. Will not be switching cards. Thanks for the info reddit.

Hi,

I've been using the Amex Gold as restaurants were my biggest spender but I am starting to wonder if Amex Bonvoy Brilliant might be worth it.

I've been using the Amex Gold as restaurants were my biggest spender but I am starting to wonder if Amex Bonvoy Brilliant might work it. of person as well so this wouldn't be an "open to support my card collection" type of purchase but my main card for all purchases.

Here are my spending percentages from last year:

Merchandise & Supplies 32.46%
Business Services 25.48%
Restaurant 13.35%
Entertainment 10.20%
Transportation 7.40%
Other 5.38%
Travel 5.02%
Communications 0.39%
Fees & Adjustments 0.36%

Here's a table comparing the Amex Gold and Brillant reward points.

Gold Brillant
Annual Fee $250 $650
Restaurants 4x 3x
Flights 3x 3x
Groceries / Hotel 4x / 0x 0x / 6x
All other purchases 1x 2x
Other Benefits $120 uber/eats, $120 dining, hotel collection, standard amex not travel benefits (like no lounge) $300 dining, free night, marriot platnium (+25 nights added towards next tier), potential choice award, standard amex travel benefits (lounge, global entry)

So in my mind, I make at least 400 a year with global entry + food credit so it's just making that other 250 back. I know the free night is worth 85k pts which sites are saying is roughly $680 so I guess I could say "Just make sure to use the free night for a room or at least work roughly 34k points" and then I'm even. I am telling myself though that if I didn't have the card, I wouldn't have stayed that night anyway so it's not really a credit in my mind but rather now a good reason to stay at a Ritz or something for day night (but not considering this a credit towards getting my annual fee back). I do value the auto platinum but maybe not as much as $250. I think though the change of 1% lost in restaurants to a 1% gain in "all other purchases" based on my spending habits seems like it would produce more money which is a plus. My wife typically does most of the grocery shopping so not to worried about losing that 4% as well (as I am a man-child whom fuels with junk food and should not go to the grocery store hungry).

Just wanted to hear your thoughts on those cards. Also, any other recommendations if you have any (as everyone says go look at the Chase Sapphire) (Also one question if anyone knows, the global entry credit, is it a one-time credit spread out over 4 years? Meaning after global entry expires, which I think is 5 years, do I not get to get this 100 again and should I actually be thinking about this as a $350 card based on my brain?). Also in case it helps with the decision, no kids currently, cute doggo though, kids planned eventually.

🌐
Upgraded Points
upgradedpoints.com › home › credit cards
Amex Platinum Card vs. Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant Card [Comparison]
June 5, 2023 - So in this section, we’ll walk ... the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant card. The Amex Platinum card is truly the gold standard when it comes to a single card with the best airport lounge access....
🌐
NerdWallet
nerdwallet.com › back to nerdwallet homepage › travel › is the marriott bonvoy brilliant amex worth the $650 annual fee?
Is the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant AmEx Worth the $650 Annual Fee? - NerdWallet
August 28, 2025 - The biggest improvement on the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant® American Express® Card is the automatic elite status. Terms apply. Previously, the card would provide Marriott Bonvoy Gold Elite status.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/marriott › on the fence about the brilliant amex card
r/marriott on Reddit: On the fence about the Brilliant Amex card
April 30, 2025 -

I'm trying to figure out if this card will be worth it for me. I have an amex platinum so far, which has been great. I recently started a new job where I travel once a week, and I stay at a marriott hotel, and it got me wondering if getting a dedicated card would be worthwhile. I do also eat out often so the $25 per month would likely be used easily, and I do travel for conferences a few times a year so I could use the free night pretty easily as well.

Anything else I should consider? Does it sound like this is worthwhile for me?

Top answer
1 of 5
28
You should really be ready to go ALL IN on Marriott, and not just for work. It's the only way to make the $650 annual fee worth it to you. One night of work travel per week is going to result in ~52 nights a year. Add that to the 25 night credits you get from having the Brilliant card, and you're at 77, which just gets you Titanium status (75 nights/year required). Let's just assume that you get Titanium even if you don't do a full 52 nights of work travel, through some small vacations or whatever. Titanium status is often considered the first real worthwhile tier of status, because it's the first tier that you actually have to earn. Anyone who can open a Brilliant card can get Platinum, so there's a HUGE number of Platinum users competing for the same tier of benefits. As a Titanium, you'll trump them all, and there are significantly fewer Titaniums than Platinums because you can't instantly earn it. However, the experience with the average Marriott hotel in the US is extremely lackluster and the benefits don't confer you much. The breakfast often sucks (if it exists at all), lounges are just empty quiet spaces with some sodas, there are very few upgrades that exist and they're relatively meaningless, etc. At your average Fairfield, Springhill, Courtyard, etc. (the real road warrior hotels), the most you're going to get is some extra points and a late checkout. Where the Marriott points game really starts to shine is vacations, and especially vacations abroad (assuming you're in the US). This is why people play the points game, from both a points redemption perspective and benefits value perspective. At 52 paid nights a year at an average nightly cost of $150, with Platinum status (your first year) and the Brilliant card, you're looking at around ~170,000 points. Let's round it up to 200,000 to factor in your new card bonus and promotions. To put that amount of points into perspective, 200,000 points would get you 5 nights at an Aloft in Tokyo, or the JW Marriott in Cancun, or The Laguna Luxury Collection Resort in Bali, etc. At those properties you're going to enjoy free baller breakfasts, free lounge access throughout the day (often with enough food/drink to be considered a full meal experience, including alcohol), and because of your increased Titanium status, the likelihood of you getting upgraded will be very high. I just came back from a two-week trip to Japan and Bali, and I did a 5-night redemption at the Westin Tokyo for 320,000 points. I also used 5 Nightly Upgrade Awards to get upgraded into a 1 bedroom suite. This was a $5,000 redemption at the sticker price room rate, and the property was NICE. On par with a Ritz-Carlton or a St. Regis. Free buffet breakfast every day and 2-3 cocktails every night in the lounge. I also got upgraded at the St. Regis Bali and the Westin Tokyo without using NUAs, just as a result of my status. It would be hard to really make these points work as hard for you in the US, because the properties, benefits, and service just tend to be a lot more lackluster, while at the same time the costs of the stays (both in points and dollars) are a lot higher.
2 of 5
11
I have the Brilliant and only stay in hotels once a quarter, but the dining credit and 85k certificate alone pay for the annual fee for me. I see the certificate as treating myself to a luxury brand stay and just stay at Fairfields the other times.
🌐
FlyerTalk
flyertalk.com › flyertalk forums › miles&points › hotels and places to stay › marriott | marriott bonvoy › bonvoy brilliant and amex platinum?
Bonvoy Brilliant and AMEX Platinum? - FlyerTalk Forums
June 5, 2023 - Instead of the Marriott Brilliant (Amex), does anyone have thoughts on the Marriott Bold (Chase) in combination with an Amex (Plat, Gold or Green)? The Marriott Bold has no annual fee, and if you're Silver, it's 13/14x Bonvoy points per dollar spent at Marriott.
🌐
The Points Guy
thepointsguy.com › credit-cards › marriott-bonvoy-boundless-credit-card-vs-bonvoy-brilliant-amex
Marriott Bonvoy Boundless vs. Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant - The Points Guy
November 6, 2025 - Conversely, with a much higher $650 annual fee, the Bonvoy Brilliant is best for Marriott loyalists who want Platinum Elite status and can maximize its other benefits. Related: Free nights and easy status: Why I have 3 Marriott Bonvoy credit ...
🌐
Sealthedealtravels
sealthedealtravels.com › home › blog › reviews › credit card reviews › review: american express marriott bonvoy brilliant
Review: American Express Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant
May 11, 2024 - Since the requirement is to stay 50 nights in one calendar year, a Brilliant cardholder will need to stay at least 35 nights to reach Platinum Elite. Those who gets Gold Elite through the Amex Platinum will need to stay the full 50 nights.
🌐
The Points Guy
thepointsguy.com › credit-cards › who-should-get-marriott-bonvoy-bevy
Who should (and shouldn't) get the Marriott Bonvoy Bevy? - The Points Guy
September 25, 2025 - Cardmembers get a free night worth up to 35,000 points on the Marriott Bonvoy Boundless® Credit Card (see rates and fees) and Marriott Bonvoy Business® American Express® Card, and a free night award worth up to 85,000 points on the Ritz-Carlton™ Credit Card and the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant® American Express® Card. The information for the Ritz-Carlton Card has been collected independently by The Points Guy. The card details on this page have not been reviewed or provided by the card issuer. Related: 7 of the best hotel credit cards that come with an annual free night · Gold Elite status isn’t bad, but it’s not great.
🌐
The Points Guy
thepointsguy.com › credit-cards › is-marriott-bonvoy-brilliant-amex-worth-annual-fee
Is the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant Amex worth the annual fee? - The Points Guy
September 25, 2025 - With the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant Amex, you can earn 100,000 bonus points after spending $6,000 on purchases within the first six months of card membership.
🌐
Yourbestcreditcards
yourbestcreditcards.com › card-comparison › american-express-gold-card-rose-gold-card-vs-marriott-bonvoy-business-american-express-card
American Express® Gold Card / Rose Gold Card vs Marriott Bonvoy Business® American Express® Card - Your Best Credit Cards
July 9, 2023 - The Amex Gold is also featured in our 5 Best Credit Cards for Groceries / Supermarkets. Rates and Fees for the American Express® Gold Card Read more ... Avg. Min. Credit Score Good-Excellent ... 6X only applies to Marriott Bonvoy hotels booked directly with Marriott or the hotel.