Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › innerspring vs. pocket coil
r/Mattress on Reddit: Innerspring vs. pocket coil
July 6, 2025 -
Those who’ve bought both, what’s your opinion/preference? Innerspring is cheaper to buy (but harder to ship) and gives more bounce and uniform support, but has “motion transfer.” Pocket coil is easier to ship and gives “motion isolation” and costs more (in stores). They’ve both been around a long time, with pocket coil having the name “Marshall coil” originally. Regarding reliability, I’m not sure, but in reviews it seems L&P pocket coils fail quite a bit while you hardly ever hear about a failed innerspring (just the foam above it). Thoughts?
Top answer 1 of 5
2
It really comes down to the quality of steel when you’re measuring durability. Most innersprings are lower priced mattresses and going to use less costly materials.
2 of 5
2
It's been years since I've seen a spring break or poke out of a mattress but every one I've seen was an old school innerspring. Also, the old ones not so uncommonly could have the wires rubbing through the corners of the mattress over time. You generally don't have those issues with pocketed coils. I'd also be very interested to see numbers on how many of those pocketed coils systems you mention fail often, are in roll packed beds vs non roll packed. Speaking of which,I'm not sure what you mean by failing. How exactly are they failing?
Mattress King
mattresskingok.com › blogs › blog-sleep-health-lifestyle › innerspring-vs-pocket-spring-mattresses-what-s-the-difference
Innerspring vs Pocket Spring Mattresses: What’s the Difference?
Both innerspring mattresses and ... look for. Innerspring mattresses offer a bit more generalized support, while the individual coils found in a pocket spring mattress mean it can shape itself to your body easier....
Why do I sleep better on cheap innersprings (non-pocketed) than anything else? - General Mattresses Questions - Mattress Underground
Hi Phoenix, Until 2 years ago, I never owned anything but an old-school innerspring mattress with traditional non-pocketed coils. Most of that time was spent on a relatively firm (cushion firm) Sealy Posturpedic which was great for 8+ years until the very minimal amount of padding compressed ... More on forum.mattressunderground.com
0
February 3, 2015What's the Best Mattress | Pocket Coil vs Innerspring Coil
Pocket Coil vs Innerspring Coil · Mar 20, 2012 9:50 PM · Quote · Post Reply · View as Outline · Re: Pocket Coil vs Innerspring Coil · Reply #2 Mar 21, 2012 5:55 AM · Quote · Re: Pocket Coil vs Innerspring Coil · Reply #3 Mar 21, 2012 7:08 AM · Quote · Re: Pocket Coil vs Innerspring ... More on whatsthebest-mattress.com
Pocket coils vs all foam for higher BMI and pressure points - General Mattresses Questions - Mattress Underground
Which is better for a higher bmi with pressure points? all foam mattress or pocket coils and foam on top mattress? Would one be better then the other? Worse? Coils may hold up better/longer then foam but will they create pressure points? More on forum.mattressunderground.com
0
August 24, 2017Innerspring vs. pocket coil
It really comes down to the quality of steel when you’re measuring durability. Most innersprings are lower priced mattresses and going to use less costly materials. More on reddit.com
7
2
July 6, 2025Are pocket coil mattresses good for you?
Pocket coil mattresses can be a good option for many people, particularly those who prefer a mattress with more bounce and support. The individual coils in pocket coil mattresses conform to the body's shape, offering customized support and relieving pressure points, which can contribute to better sleep quality. The pocketed coils also isolate motion better than traditional open springs.
However, personal preferences, such as firmness level and sleep position, should also be considered when determining if a pocket coil mattress is the right choice for you.
amerisleep.com
amerisleep.com › blog › mattress guides › innerspring vs pocketed coil mattresses
Innerspring vs Pocketed Coil Mattresses - Amerisleep
Do more pocket coils make a better mattress?
While the number of pocket coils in a mattress can affect its overall support and durability, it's not the sole factor determining the mattress's quality. Other factors, such as the gauge of the coils, the quality of materials used in the comfort layers, and the mattress's overall construction, also play crucial roles in determining how well the mattress performs.
Therefore, while more pocket coils may contribute to better support and responsiveness, it's essential to consider the mattress's overall design and construction.
amerisleep.com
amerisleep.com › blog › mattress guides › innerspring vs pocketed coil mattresses
Innerspring vs Pocketed Coil Mattresses - Amerisleep
Can you flip a pocket coil mattress?
Whether you can flip a pocket coil mattress depends on its design. Many modern pocket coil mattresses are designed to be one-sided and should not be flipped. Flipping such mattresses could result in discomfort and uneven wear.
However, some pocket coil mattresses may be designed to be flippable, typically with the same comfort layers on both sides.
amerisleep.com
amerisleep.com › blog › mattress guides › innerspring vs pocketed coil mattresses
Innerspring vs Pocketed Coil Mattresses - Amerisleep
Videos
Naturesembracelatex
naturesembracelatex.com › blogs › news › innerspring-vs-pocket-coil-mattresses-what-is-the-difference
Innerspring vs. Pocket Coil Mattresses: What is the difference? – Nature's Embrace Latex Mattresses
March 19, 2024 - In short, pocket coil mattresses offer better motion isolation. Because each coil is individually wrapped and operates independently of the others, motion does not transfer readily across the bed.
Tom's Guide
tomsguide.com › mattresses
Innerspring vs pocket coil mattresses: How to choose between them | Tom's Guide
November 4, 2025 - Let’s look at the major pros ... hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips. ... Pocket coil mattresses (also called pocket sprung beds) use individually wrapped coils....
Amerisleep
amerisleep.com › blog › mattress guides › innerspring vs pocketed coil mattresses
Innerspring vs Pocketed Coil Mattresses - Amerisleep
November 13, 2025 - Innerspring mattresses typically utilize a continuous coil system or an open coil system, where the springs act independently to conform to your body. In contrast, pocket coil mattresses consist of individually wrapped coils, ensuring better ...
Happsy
happsy.com › home › happsy blog
Choosing a Coil Mattress - Innerspring vs Pocket Coil | Happsy
March 22, 2024 - Pocket coil mattresses are often ... and pocket coil mattresses have their merits, pocket coil mattresses tend to offer superior support, comfort and motion isolation....
Seena
seenaliving.com › blogs › guides › innerspring-vs-pocketspring-mattress
Innerspring vs Pocketspring Mattress | Tasman Eco – Seena
October 9, 2022 - The minimum amount of pocket springs to look out for is 1,000 in a king size mattress and you should avoid mattresses with more than 3,000 springs as these are micro springs and will reduce the quality of support significantly. Innerspring mattresses are made of mostly metal coils, all of the coils/springs are connected in a single unit, meaning that all of the springs move together here.
Address 580 Hume Highway, 2170, Casula
Bear Mattress
bearmattress.com › blogs › news › what-are-the-differences-between-coil-and-innerspring-mattresses
What are the Differences Between Encased-Coil and Innerspring Mattress – Bear Mattress
October 30, 2024 - As for the actual metal coils, an encased-coil mattress will have cylindrical-shaped springs. Rather than narrowing in the middle like those of a traditional innerspring mattress, these encased coils will be uniform in width from top to bottom.
Mobile Mattress
mobilemattress.com.au › blogs › bedbuyingadvice › the-differences-between-pocketed-coil-mattresses-and-other-spring-types
The differences between pocketed coil mattresses and other spring types – Mobile Mattress
November 22, 2017 - Traditional innerspring mattresses are built with a network of interconnected coils, meaning movement on one part of the bed is felt everywhere. Pocketed coils, on the other hand, are individually wrapped in fabric and work independently, delivering ...
Mattress Underground
forum.mattressunderground.com › mattress talk › general mattresses questions
Why do I sleep better on cheap innersprings (non-pocketed) than anything else? - General Mattresses Questions - Mattress Underground
February 3, 2015 - Hi Phoenix, Until 2 years ago, I never owned anything but an old-school innerspring mattress with traditional non-pocketed coils. Most of that time was spent on a relatively firm (cushion firm) Sealy Posturpedic which was great for 8+ years until the very minimal amount of padding compressed enough over the years to start causing pressure points.
Gouldsbrandsource
gouldsbrandsource.ca › blog › innerspring-vs-pocket-coil
What is the Difference Between Innerspring & Pocket Coil Mattresses? | Gould's Home Furnishings | Dryden, ON
May 20, 2022 - This coil system moves together as one, making it difficult to sleep with a partner as the bed will dip and move. A pocket coil mattress uses a different spring type that improves the old continuous design.
Sleep Junkie
sleepjunkie.com › innerspring-vs-pocket-spring-mattress
Innerspring vs. Pocket Spring Mattress: What's The Difference? - Sleep Junkie
3 weeks ago - Innerspring mattresses, known for their firm sleeping surface and airflow, are favored by stomach sleepers and individuals who sleep hot. Meanwhile, pocket spring mattresses feature individually wrapped coils and respond well to pressure points, reduce motion transfer, and promote proper spinal alignment, making them ideal for combination sleepers and couples.
BlvdHome
blvdhome.com › blog › wrapped-coil-vs-pocket-coil-mattress
Wrapped vs Pocketed Coil Mattresses: Differences Explained | BlvdHome
November 30, 2023 - Innerspring mattresses refer to traditional coil mattresses with interconnected metal springs, while coil mattresses include individually wrapped coils or pockets, providing more targeted support and less motion disturbance.
Whatsthebest-mattress
whatsthebest-mattress.com › forum › pocket-coil-vs-innerspring-coil › 28140-0-1.html
What's the Best Mattress | Pocket Coil vs Innerspring Coil
Pocket Coil vs Innerspring Coil · Mar 20, 2012 9:50 PM · Quote · Post Reply · View as Outline · Re: Pocket Coil vs Innerspring Coil · Reply #2 Mar 21, 2012 5:55 AM · Quote · Re: Pocket Coil vs Innerspring Coil · Reply #3 Mar 21, 2012 7:08 AM · Quote · Re: Pocket Coil vs Innerspring ...
Mattress Underground
forum.mattressunderground.com › mattress talk › general mattresses questions
Pocket coils vs all foam for higher BMI and pressure points - General Mattresses Questions - Mattress Underground
August 24, 2017 - Which is better for a higher bmi with pressure points? all foam mattress or pocket coils and foam on top mattress? Would one be better then the other? Worse? Coils may hold up better/longer then foam but will they crea…
Bestsleepcentre
bestsleepcentre.com › david's blog › explore different types of mattresses in winnipeg
Different Types of Mattresses Winnipeg – Best Sleep Centre Inc.
February 18, 2025 - Innerspring or Pocket Coil Mattresses have been around since the early 1900's and are constructed of steel coils that compress when weight is applied. Pocket coils help to disperse partner movement and are better suited for larger, heavier people vs.
Gardner Mattress
gardnermattress.com › home › gardner mattress’ blog › gardner mattress innerspring vs. pocketed coil mattresses
Gardner Mattress Innerspring Vs. Pocketed Coil Mattresses
October 13, 2023 - They’re attached by fabric for ... to be more conforming. Your more traditional Innerspring or continuous wire springs tend to be firmer, so they make more of an orthopedic or firm style of mattress....
MyBedFrames
mybedframes.co.uk › blog › open coil vs pocket spring mattresses: know the difference
Open Coil Vs Pocket Spring Mattresses: Know the Difference
February 14, 2025 - Pros: Open coils provide excellent support and are used for most orthopaedic mattresses due to their firmness. They tend to have more ‘give’ than pocket sprung mattresses, and are lighter and therefore easier to turn.
Mattressmill
mattressmill.com › mattresses › wrapped-coil-mattress
Wrapped Coil Mattresses | Bozeman, MT | Mattress Mill
Construction: A traditional innerspring mattress is constructed with an exposed continuous spring. An individually wrapped coil mattress differs in that each of its springs are separate within their own fabric pocket.