This is a broad topic but I'll give a few thoughts.

First off Spectrum is a (often large) set of compute elements embedded in S3 that can do some aspect of the query plan. These part centered around applying WHERE conditions and performing aggregation (GROUP BY). There are also aspects of the query plan that cannot be perform in the S3 layer such as JOINs and advanced functions such as window functions.

The next thing to understand is that while these embedded compute elements are close to S3 in terms of access speed, the S3 service is far away from the Redshift cluster (network distance). If the large amount of data stored in S3 can be pared down to a small set that is shipped to Redshift then Spectrum can be a huge performance improvement. However, if the large amount of data stored in S3 needs to be moved to the Redshift cluster completely to perform the query then there can be a large hit to performance.

Spectrum can be a huge benefit; allowing for a very large amount of data to be filtered down quickly by a fleet of small compute elements. This can result in a big win in performance and in the amount of data that can be addressed.

With these in mind you will want to have data in Spectrum that your query plan will want to get a subset transferred from S3 to redshift. This in general will apply to your fact tables and not to your dim tables. However, if your queries aren't going to apply a WHERE clause to the fact table or aggregate the data down then you won't see the advantages. Also for this to work the WHERE clause needs to apply to a column in the fact table as JOINs cannot be done in S3 so filtering on dim columns won't help. Similarly and GROUP BY needs to be applied only on the fact table columns or this won't reduce the data coming to Redshift from S3.

So fact tables.

Data generally gets into Redshift through S3 and this can be done with the COPY command. You can also get data into Redshift from S3 using Spectrum. This can be a useful tool if other tools are also using S3 for this shared data. S3 can seem like a common data store for separate data systems. This can be useful for some data solutions.

You also bring up very large, infrequently used data. Like older historical data that is usually needed but is sometimes needed. This can be helpful in that older data can be offloaded from the Redshift cluster and the access time for this data isn't important as it is very infrequently used. There is a potential issue - The Redshift cluster can only work on a certain size of data given it's disk space and memory. So you can clog up your cluster if the amount of historical data is too large. This may mean that looking at the full set of historical data in one query may not be possible. Again if the data is aggregated or filtered in S3 this issue isn't a problem.

Bottom line - Spectrum is a great tool but isn't the right tool for every problem.

Answer from Bill Weiner on Stack Overflow
🌐
AWS
docs.aws.amazon.com › amazon redshift › database developer guide › amazon redshift spectrum
Amazon Redshift Spectrum - Amazon Redshift
Using Amazon Redshift Spectrum, you can efficiently query and retrieve structured and semi-structured data from files in Amazon S3 without having to load the data into Amazon Redshift tables. Redshift Spectrum queries employ massive parallelism to run very fast against large datasets.
🌐
AWS
docs.aws.amazon.com › amazon redshift › database developer guide › amazon redshift spectrum › getting started with amazon redshift spectrum
Getting started with Amazon Redshift Spectrum - Amazon Redshift
In this tutorial, you learn how to use Amazon Redshift Spectrum to query data directly from files on Amazon S3. If you already have a cluster and a SQL client, you can complete this tutorial with minimal setup.
Discussions

amazon web services - When to use Redshift Spectrum for your Redshift data warehouse - Stack Overflow
I am still new to Redshift service and quite confused of when to use or what data to put into Spectrum. Suppose I have star schema data warehouse on Redshift, should I put fact table or dim table i... More on stackoverflow.com
🌐 stackoverflow.com
Recently Active 'amazon-redshift-spectrum' Questions - Stack Overflow
Stack Overflow | The World’s Largest Online Community for Developers More on stackoverflow.com
🌐 stackoverflow.com
Challenges that you want to highlight with Amazon Redshift
Even teams at AWS use snowflake now… It’s based on some old PostgreSQL 9 apis but also doesn’t support the PostgreSQL data types well so it’s a leaky abstraction. You have to manage partitions and keys. It’s sort of a disaster given other options. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/dataengineering
42
24
May 18, 2023
Amazon Redshift Spectrum - Serverless Datawarehouse
umm, while spectrum is neat, it is not serverless, you have to pay for the redshift cluster whether you are using it or not. Athena is 'serverless' in the current parlance of managed, pay for what you use model of things like dynamodb or lambda. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/aws
1
21
April 27, 2017
People also ask

When should I use Redshift spectrum?
Amazon Redshift Spectrum is an extension of Amazon Redshift that allows you to run queries against data stored in Amazon S3 without having to load the data into Redshift tables.
🌐
hevodata.com
hevodata.com › home › learn › data warehousing
Amazon Redshift vs Redshift Spectrum: 6 Differences in 2025
How do you use Redshift a spectrum?
Set up an IAM role, create an external schema, define external tables, and query the external tables using SQL commands.
🌐
hevodata.com
hevodata.com › home › learn › data warehousing
Amazon Redshift vs Redshift Spectrum: 6 Differences in 2025
What is the Redshift spectrum layer?
The Redshift Spectrum Layer refers to the architecture component of Amazon Redshift that enables querying data directly from Amazon S3.
🌐
hevodata.com
hevodata.com › home › learn › data warehousing
Amazon Redshift vs Redshift Spectrum: 6 Differences in 2025
🌐
AWS
docs.aws.amazon.com › amazon redshift › database developer guide › amazon redshift spectrum › amazon redshift spectrum overview
Amazon Redshift Spectrum overview - Amazon Redshift
Amazon Redshift Spectrum resides on dedicated Amazon Redshift servers that are independent of your cluster. Amazon Redshift pushes many compute-intensive tasks, such as predicate filtering and aggregation, down to the Redshift Spectrum layer. Thus, Redshift Spectrum queries use much less of your cluster's processing capacity than other queries.
Top answer
1 of 2
9

This is a broad topic but I'll give a few thoughts.

First off Spectrum is a (often large) set of compute elements embedded in S3 that can do some aspect of the query plan. These part centered around applying WHERE conditions and performing aggregation (GROUP BY). There are also aspects of the query plan that cannot be perform in the S3 layer such as JOINs and advanced functions such as window functions.

The next thing to understand is that while these embedded compute elements are close to S3 in terms of access speed, the S3 service is far away from the Redshift cluster (network distance). If the large amount of data stored in S3 can be pared down to a small set that is shipped to Redshift then Spectrum can be a huge performance improvement. However, if the large amount of data stored in S3 needs to be moved to the Redshift cluster completely to perform the query then there can be a large hit to performance.

Spectrum can be a huge benefit; allowing for a very large amount of data to be filtered down quickly by a fleet of small compute elements. This can result in a big win in performance and in the amount of data that can be addressed.

With these in mind you will want to have data in Spectrum that your query plan will want to get a subset transferred from S3 to redshift. This in general will apply to your fact tables and not to your dim tables. However, if your queries aren't going to apply a WHERE clause to the fact table or aggregate the data down then you won't see the advantages. Also for this to work the WHERE clause needs to apply to a column in the fact table as JOINs cannot be done in S3 so filtering on dim columns won't help. Similarly and GROUP BY needs to be applied only on the fact table columns or this won't reduce the data coming to Redshift from S3.

So fact tables.

Data generally gets into Redshift through S3 and this can be done with the COPY command. You can also get data into Redshift from S3 using Spectrum. This can be a useful tool if other tools are also using S3 for this shared data. S3 can seem like a common data store for separate data systems. This can be useful for some data solutions.

You also bring up very large, infrequently used data. Like older historical data that is usually needed but is sometimes needed. This can be helpful in that older data can be offloaded from the Redshift cluster and the access time for this data isn't important as it is very infrequently used. There is a potential issue - The Redshift cluster can only work on a certain size of data given it's disk space and memory. So you can clog up your cluster if the amount of historical data is too large. This may mean that looking at the full set of historical data in one query may not be possible. Again if the data is aggregated or filtered in S3 this issue isn't a problem.

Bottom line - Spectrum is a great tool but isn't the right tool for every problem.

2 of 2
2

In general, put everything into 'normal' Amazon Redshift.

Redshift Spectrum is handy for accessing data stored in Amazon S3 without having to load it into the Redshift cluster, but it will not be as fast as accessing data stored in 'normal' Redshift.

Therefore, it is useful for rarely-accessed data or for one-off queries on a dataset without having to import the data into Redshift.

Do not use Spectrum as part of your normal ETL flow. One exception to this might be if you are receiving 'landing' data via Amazon S3 (eg Seed Files) -- rather than importing the tables into Redshift, they could be referenced via Spectrum. However, normal loading tools such as Fivetran can load the data directly into Redshift, which is preferable to using Spectrum.

🌐
Hevo
hevodata.com › home › learn › data warehousing
Amazon Redshift vs Redshift Spectrum: 6 Differences in 2025
January 12, 2026 - Amazon Redshift is one of the most ... Spectrum is an Analytical service provided by AWS that works on the data stored in Amazon S3 and provides faster results when compared to other generic solutions....
Find elsewhere
🌐
Hostingjournalist
hostingjournalist.com › video › amazon-redshift-spectrum-user-defined-data-handling-demo-amazon-web-services
Amazon Redshift Spectrum - User Defined Data Handling Demo
January 3, 2022 - Explore curated business videos on cloud, hosting, and data centers by HostingJournalist Insider Members and Editorial Staff, featuring interviews and more.
🌐
Stack Overflow
stackoverflow.com › questions › tagged › amazon-redshift-spectrum
Recently Active 'amazon-redshift-spectrum' Questions - Stack Overflow
I have very large (1 billion + records) files in S3, that I am querying via Amazon Redshift using Spectrum.
🌐
Medium
jelizaveta-malinina.medium.com › amazon-redshift-spectrum-cb3bb8591d2e
Amazon Redshift Spectrum
February 19, 2020 - If I had to put its definition into one sentence, I would say: “RS Spectrum is a feature within AWS Redshift data warehouse service that allows you to run fast, complex analysis on data stored in Amazon S3 buckets”. In other words, it eliminates ...
🌐
Jutomate
big-data-demystified.ninja › home › blog › redshift spectrum
Redshift Spectrum | Big Data Demystified
May 11, 2021 - https://docs.aws.amazon.com/redshift/latest/dg/r_CREATE_EXTERNAL_TABLE.html#r_CREATE_EXTERNAL_TABLE-parameters · Step 3: query the table · After we understand the concept we can query the table just like we query a normal table · Select * from spectrum.workers ·
🌐
AWS
aws.amazon.com › blogs › aws › amazon-redshift-spectrum-exabyte-scale-in-place-queries-of-s3-data
Amazon Redshift Spectrum – Exabyte-Scale In-Place Queries of S3 Data | Amazon Web Services
November 3, 2022 - You can use Spectrum to run complex queries on data stored in Amazon Simple Storage Service (Amazon S3), with no need for loading or other data prep. You simply create a data source and issue your queries to your Redshift cluster as usual.
🌐
AWS
aws.amazon.com › blogs › big-data › tag › amazon-redshift-spectrum › page › 2
Amazon Redshift Spectrum | AWS Big Data Blog
This post shows a step-by-step walkthrough of how to set up a cross-account Amazon Redshift COPY and Spectrum query using a sample dataset in Amazon S3. The sample dataset is encrypted at rest using AWS KMS-managed keys (SSE-KMS).
🌐
AWS
aws.amazon.com › about-aws › whats-new › 2017 › 04 › introducing-amazon-redshift-spectrum-run-amazon-redshift-queries-directly-on-datasets-as-large-as-an-exabyte-in-amazon-s3
Introducing Amazon Redshift Spectrum: Run Amazon Redshift Queries directly on Datasets as Large as an Exabyte in Amazon S3 - AWS
October 6, 2019 - With Redshift Spectrum, you can extend the analytic power of Amazon Redshift beyond data stored on local disks in your data warehouse to query vast amounts of unstructured data in your Amazon S3 “data lake” — without having to load or transform any data.
🌐
Sumble
sumble.com › tech › aws-redshift-spectrum
What is AWS Redshift Spectrum? Competitors, Complementary Techs & Usage | Sumble
November 29, 2025 - AWS Redshift Spectrum is a feature of Amazon Redshift that enables you to run SQL queries directly against exabytes of unstructured data in Amazon S3, without loading or transforming the data.
🌐
AWS
docs.aws.amazon.com › amazon redshift › database developer guide › amazon redshift spectrum › amazon redshift spectrum query performance
Amazon Redshift Spectrum query performance - Amazon Redshift
The Amazon Redshift query planner pushes predicates and aggregations to the Redshift Spectrum query layer whenever possible. When large amounts of data are returned from Amazon S3, the processing is limited by your cluster's resources. Redshift Spectrum scales automatically to process large requests.
🌐
Analytics Vidhya
analyticsvidhya.com › back-channel › download-pdf.php pdf
What is Amazon Redshift & Spectrum in AWS?
Analytics Vidhya is the leading community of Analytics, Data Science and AI professionals. We are building the next generation of AI professionals. Get the latest data science, machine learning, and AI courses, news, blogs, tutorials, and resources.
🌐
VSCO Engineering
eng.vsco.co › querying-s3-data-with-redshift-spectrum
Querying S3 Data With Redshift Spectrum | VSCO Engineering
Amazon Redshift Spectrum is a feature of Amazon Redshift that enables us to query data in S3. Our most common use case is querying Parquet files, but Redshift Spectrum is compatible with many data formats. The S3 file structures are described as metadata tables in an AWS Glue Catalog database.
🌐
LinkedIn
linkedin.com › pulse › redshift-spectrum-performance-tuning-cost-abhishek-joshi-
Redshift Spectrum: Performance tuning: cost optimization
Redshift Spectrum offers the capability to AWS customers to query data from files stored in the Amazon S3 bucket, without the need to set up servers/clusters and without the need for ETL process to import files in Redshift DB.
🌐
AWS re:Post
repost.aws › articles › ARJ9VDc8whS2a9o9vfqHxWHA › troubleshooting-redshift-spectrum-query-performance-and-errors-using-system-logs-and-views
Troubleshooting Redshift Spectrum query performance and errors using system logs and views. | AWS re:Post
September 30, 2024 - Redshift Spectrum feature allows efficient query and retrieving structured and semistructured data from files in Amazon S3 without having to load the data into Amazon Redshift tables.