I personally feel gen 2 is lighter compared to gen 1. Like 50% lighter. The other thing that I like about gen 2 is the magnetic charging :) it’s so convenient compared to the plug in and out gen 1. Last but not least, gen 2 has the double tap features to switch tools. this is not my favourite feature because I rarely use it, and it sometimes got tapped when I don’t want to so… but overall the gen 2 is just very different compared to gen 1. One more thing, it will depend on which gen your iPad that is compatible with the pens. Answer from mychelromance on reddit.com
Reddit
reddit.com › r/goodnotes › is there a notable difference between apple pen gens 1&2?
r/GoodNotes on Reddit: Is there a notable difference between Apple Pen Gens 1&2?
December 21, 2022 -
Sorry if this is the wrong place to ask but since I plan to be using the pen for goodnotes anyways I thought it’d be worth, I was wondering if it’s worth it to get the second generation of the pen or if the first will work just fine. I want to know if there’s and benefits to using the second generation pen on the app over the first or anything like that.
Top answer 1 of 8
22
I personally feel gen 2 is lighter compared to gen 1. Like 50% lighter. The other thing that I like about gen 2 is the magnetic charging :) it’s so convenient compared to the plug in and out gen 1. Last but not least, gen 2 has the double tap features to switch tools. this is not my favourite feature because I rarely use it, and it sometimes got tapped when I don’t want to so… but overall the gen 2 is just very different compared to gen 1. One more thing, it will depend on which gen your iPad that is compatible with the pens.
2 of 8
15
It depends on the ipad you have For example if you have the last ipad (i think 10), you will be limited to 1st generation, regardless which pen you prefer I don’t think you would choose the ipad according to the pen
Videos
07:32
Apple Pencil 1 vs Apple Pencil 2 - YouTube
03:42
Original Apple Pencil vs. Apple Pencil 2 - YouTube
05:54
Apple Pencil 1 Vs Apple Pencil 2 In 2023! (Comparison) (Review) ...
04:15
Apple Pencil 1 Vs Apple Pencil 2 In 2024! (Comparison) (Review) ...
07:35
DON’T WASTE YOUR MONEY! 2025 Apple Pencil Comparison - YouTube
Apple Pencil (1 & 2) vs real pencil: what is the difference?
The Apple Pencil models, both 1 and two, are able to create digital Art that can be transformed and used as a tool online. The uses for this in regards to art is virtually limitless as you’re able to design anything from blueprints, to sketches, to animation, cartoons (think toon boom), and do so very effectively, quickly and easy.
Another big advantage is that the format of the digital Art the Apple Pencil creates can be used online effectively.
As far as the difference in feel, you may want to experiment with a screen protector to see how it feels. In my experience I noticed it felt and drew on the screen just like a real piece of paper. Screen protectors such as ‘paper-like’ can also help improve this to make it feel even more like a real pencil.
Another big advantage is that the format of the digital Art the Apple Pencil creates can be used online effectively.
As far as the difference in feel, you may want to experiment with a screen protector to see how it feels. In my experience I noticed it felt and drew on the screen just like a real piece of paper. Screen protectors such as ‘paper-like’ can also help improve this to make it feel even more like a real pencil.
mediapeanut.com
mediapeanut.com › apple-pencil-2-vs-1-what-is-the-difference-compared
Apple Pencil 1 Vs 2- Key Differences Explained (Compared) 2025
How does the Apple Pencil 1 & 2 compare vs other stylus?
The Apple Pencil 1 and 2 models compared to other stylus does quite well. Other stylus just can't compete for the Apple Pencil on the iPad since they are considered third party stylus by apple and don't have the proper integration from my testing. Many of the cheap options stutter and lag and theres much delay as well as incompatibility amongst iOS apps.
However the adonit models appear to compare and perform the best if you aren't choosing either the apple Pencil 1 or 2 for the iPad. You can always go with a non active stylus instead of the active Apple Pencil stylus. The non-active, capacitive stylus are significantly cheaper, but pose no pressure sensitivity or can mislead consumers.
Other stylus that work very well as a alternate, third party stylus for the iPad:
Adonit Note+, Zagg Pro, Adonit Pixel, and Adonit Pro 4.
However the adonit models appear to compare and perform the best if you aren't choosing either the apple Pencil 1 or 2 for the iPad. You can always go with a non active stylus instead of the active Apple Pencil stylus. The non-active, capacitive stylus are significantly cheaper, but pose no pressure sensitivity or can mislead consumers.
Other stylus that work very well as a alternate, third party stylus for the iPad:
Adonit Note+, Zagg Pro, Adonit Pixel, and Adonit Pro 4.
mediapeanut.com
mediapeanut.com › apple-pencil-2-vs-1-what-is-the-difference-compared
Apple Pencil 1 Vs 2- Key Differences Explained (Compared) 2025
Can the Apple pencil 1 or 2 be used on the iPhone?
Neither the Apple Pencil 1 or 2 can be used on the iphone. These two digital pencils can not be used on any device outside their compatible iPad. The iPhone can however be used with a capacitive stylus; which is significantly less costly than the price of the Apple Pencil 1 & 2.
mediapeanut.com
mediapeanut.com › apple-pencil-2-vs-1-what-is-the-difference-compared
Apple Pencil 1 Vs 2- Key Differences Explained (Compared) 2025
MacCase
mac-case.com › maccase › maccase company blog › how to tell the difference between 1st and 2nd generation apple pencil?
Tell the Difference Between 1st and 2nd Gen Apple Pencils?
December 18, 2023 - The 2nd generation Apple Pencil ... and wireless charging. ... 1st Generation: The original Apple Pencil lacks the magnetic attachment capability found in the 2nd generation....
AppleInsider
appleinsider.com › apple a-z › accessories and i/o › apple pencil › vs
Apple Pencil USB-C vs Apple Pencil Gen 1 and Gen 2 -- compared
The new Apple Pencil is even shorter at 6.1 inches, even though it has a sliding cap incorporated into its design. At 0.29 inches, its diameter is also a lot smaller than its predecessors, so it may feel a little thinner for users to grip when writing and drawing. There is also a very minor weight loss in the latest model, with it at 0.72 ounces versus 0.73 ounces for the first and second-gen models.
Published October 17, 2023
Top answer 1 of 10
10
The differences between the 1st and 2nd generation Apple Pencils are:
-price
-features
-ways of charging
-design
The first gen Apple pencil is very round and rather slippery. It'll just roll off somewhere. Might want to put like a skin or a rubber cover on it so it doesn't slide. It also uses the extremely akward and poorly design lighting connector top that plugs in either in the IPad or using the included adapter from the box. It also has a cap to cover the top. The 1st gen Apple pencil is only compatible with IPads that have the classic design (large black or white bexels with touch ID home button) and lighnting port such as the IPad Generation series or the older 5th gen IPad mini. The cost of the 1st gen pencil is under a $100.
The second gen Apple Pencil is the updated pencil that connects via magnets on the righhand side of the current (almost) all screen design IPads.These IPads are IPad Pro 2018- current year, IPad Air 4th gen and the new IPad Mini 6th gen. The pencil charges when connected on the side of the ipad via magnets and has features where you can double tap the squared off side to either erase or go back to previous tool. The pencil has a matte feel and due to having a squared off design on one side, it doesn't roll off (or at least not as easy.) The Apple Pencil 2nd Gen is $129.99. There is a lot more features available, but those are the main highlighted ones.
2 of 10
3
Pencil one requires a lightening port to charge. It is round in shape.
Pencil two connects magnetically to the USB-C equipped iPad, so it is a big improvement for connectivity. The Pencil two is closer in shape to a wooden pencil, so it can magnetically connect to the compatible iPads.
EveryiPad.com
everymac.com › systems › apple › ipad › ipad-pro-faq › differences-between-apple-pencil-1-apple-pencil-2-ipad-compatibility.html
Differences Between Apple Pencil 1, 2, USB-C, Pencil Pro: EveryiPad.com
(iPad Pro 3rd Gen with Apple Pencil ... the USB-C port for charging. Based on hands-on use, the Apple Pencil 2, or "2nd Gen" as it is referred to in some places, was a massive improvement over the original Apple Pencil:...
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
WHY PAY MORE? Apple Pencil 1 vs 2 - YouTube
Is the 2nd Generation Apple Pencil THAT MUCH better than the 1st Generation Apple Pencil? I get so many questions about whether there is enough of a differen...
Published January 18, 2022
Astropad
astropad.com › blog › which-apple-pencil-is-better
Apple Pencil 1 vs. 2: Which is the Best for You?
JavaScript is disabled in your browser · Please enable JavaScript to proceed · A required part of this site couldn’t load. This may be due to a browser extension, network issues, or browser settings. Please check your connection, disable any ad blockers, or try using a different browser
Apple Community
discussions.apple.com › thread › 252936293
HOW CAN I TELL IF MY PENCIL IS FIRST OR S… - Apple Community
The original, 1st gen Pencil does NOT magnetise to any iPad for charging. The 2nd gen Pencil looks more like a regular pencil with a flat side ( for magnetic charging on a 2018-2021 iPad Pro or iPad Aor 4 ) less slippery, NO chrome anything at the top of the Pencil.
Apple Community
discussions.apple.com › thread › 255067118
Apple Pencil 2nd gen incompatibility with… - Apple Community
Moving a lens to the side that takes away compatibility with the latest version of their Apple Pencil was just poorly thought out. The Apple Pencil 2nd gen with its magnetic pairing and charging is so much better than the alternative Apple Pencil 1st gen that requires an adapter and plugging ...