Hello! I have been struggling to find a decent well priced bed in a box. Preferably it would be available through amazon, but if not that's alright too! I am 5'3", around 230 pounds, sleep 75% of the time on my stomach and 25% on my side, I prefer more firm mattresses, and I tend to sleep a bit warm. What suggestions do you have for affordable bed in a box's that would work best for me? Thank you!

Edit: I have decided to go with the Helix Twilight Luxe. I'll update what I think about it after I get it.

Update: I've been using the Helix Twilight Luxe for about a month now, and I am really liking it so far! The reviews that I saw about it not having great edge support when sitting on the edge of the mattress are true, but it isn't that terrible and also wasn't really a priority for me. It is very firm and perfect for sleeping on my stomach and not causing soreness when sleeping on my sides. There was no chemical smell or anything when unpacking it, and while the box said it would be completely decompressed within 2 hours, I waited about 2 days before using it, and it was perfect. Overall, this mattress is much better than my last one was, and I would recommend it if you don't plan to sit on the edges too much and aren't able to go to a mattress store in person.

I'm finally making the big move from Chicago to LA next month and I'm trying to figure out the whole mattress situation.

I've been sleeping on the same hand-me-down mattress for like 6 years now and it's basically a taco at this point (the middle is super sunken it difficult to get out in the morning). I'm NOT bringing this torture device with me to California.

I'm looking for the best mattress in a box that won't completely destroy my moving budget. My new place is a second-floor apartment with narrow stairs, so something that comes compressed seems ideal. Plus I'll be dead tired after the move and just want to flop onto something comfortable without dealing with traditional mattress delivery windows.

I've been down the review rabbit hole for DAYS and my brain is fried from all the marketing buzzwords... like can we just talk about actual comfort and not make it sound like I'm sleeping on a NASA experiment?

Anyone have personal experience with mattress in a box brands that are actually good? I'm a side sleeper who runs hot, so something with decent edge support that doesn't sleeps hot would be ideal. Budget is around $800 for a queen.

Can't wait to join you all in the land of perfect weather and terrible traffic next month!

Looking for a new mattress and I don’t like the heavy legacy mattresses as they are expensive and also don’t want to deal with delivery etc. I like the box type. My partner always sweats at night so something that’ll cool him down would be great, I am a back or side sleeper. Please no unboxing chemical odor, I can never get rid of them

I put off getting a new mattress for fourteen years because they’re so expensive in stores. I finally bought one on Amazon after my mom had ordered on Walmart’s website.

I was very apprehensive because we couldn’t try it but I read hundreds of reviews.

It was super cheap. Less than $200 for a queen. This was five years ago.

It’s the best mattress I’ve ever had.

Getting it in the mail is much better than getting it delivered by the store.

ETA: It was ZINUS 10 Inch Support Plus Pocket Spring Hybrid Mattress

I’m a veterinary student, AKA, I ain’t got no money. I’m thinking about getting a box bed so I don’t have to worry about delivering a mattress to my gated apartment complex

I ONLY sleep on my side and I also am a touch overweight. I don’t mind firmer mattresses, I can sleep pretty easy on futon or a dorm cot.

Ideally I’d like to not spend more than 700, which I know greatly reduces my options

Thanks for any help!

I've seen many discussions about the "best mattress in a box" Reddit users can recommend popping up on various subreddits. So, I decided to dive in and create a concise review based on what Reddit users say about the best mattress in a box.

If you're after the best mattress in a box, (and I know a lot of you are), Reddit users usually have great suggestions. The top picks are high-quality, trusted brands, and mattresses tailored to your unique sleeping needs. Here’s a list of the best mattresses in a box Reddit user recommend.

Best Mattress in a Box Reddit Users Recommend

1. Helix Midnight Luxe – Best Mattress in a Box Reddit Users Recommend

Reddit users recommend the Helix Midnight Luxe as the best mattress in a box due to its excellent comfort and support. The Midnight Luxe features a hybrid design, combining memory foam and pocketed coils to provide optimal pressure relief and spinal alignment, making it ideal for all sleep positions.

It features a breathable Tencel cover and gel-infused memory foam to keep you cool overnight. The zoned lumbar support enhances back support, reducing aches and pains. This mattress is designed for those looking for a balanced blend of softness and firmness, ensuring a restful sleep.

• Who Should Use It:

  • Ideal for side sleepers looking for targeted pressure relief and improved comfort.

  • Perfect for hot sleepers with its cooling gel-infused memory foam technology.

  • Great for those needing extra lumbar support to alleviate back pain.

• Who Shouldn't Use It:

  • Not suited for those who prefer an all-foam mattress without any coils.

  • Avoid if you need a very firm mattress for minimal sinkage and maximum support.

  • Not ideal for budget shoppers looking for the lowest-cost mattress option.

• Specifications:

  • Type: Hybrid (Memory Foam and Coils)

  • Profile: 13.5 Inches (High Profile)

  • Firmness: Medium Plush (5.5 out of 10)

  • Positions: Side and Back Sleepers

  • Max. Weight: 250 to 300 lbs. (Per Sleeper. See Helix Plus for Additional Weight Support)

  • Comfort: Cooling Quilted Pillow Top, Responsive Foam, and Copper Gel Memory Foam

  • Support: Memory Plus Foam and Zoned Body Shape Layer

  • Cooling: TENCEL or GlacioTex Cooling Cover, Cooling Quilted Pillow Top, and Copper Gel Memory Foam

  • Trial Period: 100 Nights

  • Warranty: 15 Year Warranty

  • Shipping: Free Shipping

  • Score: 5.0/5.0

• Features:

  • Hybrid construction offers a blend of contouring memory foam and supportive coils.

  • Breathable Tencel cover enhances airflow, keeping the mattress cool and fresh.

  • Zoned lumbar support ensures proper spinal alignment, reducing back discomfort.

• Durability:

  • Premium materials ensure long-lasting comfort and structural integrity over time.

  • Reinforced edges prevent sagging and maintain mattress shape for years.

  • High-density foams resist wear and tear, providing consistent support night after night.

Check their mattress in a box page for their best prices: Helix Midnight Luxe

2. Nolah Evolution 15" – Best Mattress in a Box for Side Sleepers Reddit Users Recommend

Reddit users recommend the Nolah Evolution 15" as the best mattress in a box for side sleepers due to its exceptional comfort and advanced cooling features. Its hybrid design with foam and coils offers a plush yet supportive surface that reduces pressure points, ensuring a restful sleep.

It features innovative Zoned AirFoam for temperature regulation with a high-quality coil system for added support. The mattress is designed to provide optimal spinal alignment and motion isolation, making it a top choice for those who share their bed or tend to sleep hot.

• Who Should Use It:

  • Ideal for side sleepers looking for a pressure relief, with its plush yet supportive feel.

  • Hot sleepers benefit from its advanced cooling features from the Zoned AirFoam.

  • Those sharing a bed will appreciate its excellent motion isolation properties.

• Who Shouldn't Use It:

  • Stomach sleepers might find it too soft for their needs, lacking the necessary firmness.

  • Budget-conscious buyers may consider it pricey compared to other options.

  • Heavyweight sleepers over 230 lbs might require a firmer mattress for better support.

• Specifications:

  • Type: Hybrid (Memory Foam and Coils)

  • Profile: 15 Inches (High Profile)

  • Firmness: Plush (4.5 out of 10), Luxury Firm (6.5 out of 10), and Firm (7.5 out of 10)

  • Positions: Side, Back, and Stomach Sleepers

  • Max. Weight: 250 to 300 lbs. (Per Sleeper. See Nolah Evolution Comfort+ for Additional Weight Support)

  • Comfort: Cooling Quilted Euro Topper and Zoned AirFoam

  • Support: CoreComfort Support Foam and HDMAx Tri-Zone Coils

  • Cooling: ArticTex Cover, Cooling Quilted Euro Topper, Breathable AirFoam, and AirBreath Gusset

  • Trial Period: 120 Nights

  • Warranty: Lifetime Warranty

  • Shipping: Free Shipping

  • Score: 5.0/5.0

• Features:

  • The hybrid design with foam and coils provides balanced comfort and support.

  • Zoned AirFoam enhances cooling, preventing overheating during sleep.

  • Targeted support and pressure relief ensure optimal spinal alignment for side sleepers.

• Durability:

  • Reinforced coils and high-density foam ensure long-lasting durability and support.

  • Edge support prevents sagging, maintaining the mattress's shape and usability over time.

  • High-quality materials resist wear and tear, offering consistent performance.

Check their mattress in a box page for their best prices: Nolah Evolution 15"

3. Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Cooling – Best Cooling Mattress in a Box Reddit Users Recommend

Reddit users recommend the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Cooling as the best cooling mattress in a box due to its advanced cooling technology and exceptional comfort. This hybrid mattress features a unique combination of materials designed to keep you cool throughout the night, ensuring a restful sleep.

It features TitanCool, a phase change material, with copper-infused foam to regulate body temperature, providing a cool and comfortable sleep surface. The Aurora Luxe's targeted support and pressure point relief make it an excellent choice for those looking for a balanced, supportive sleep.

• Who Should Use It:

  • Hot sleepers who need a mattress with advanced cooling technology.

  • Individuals looking for pressure relief and targeted support for improved sleep comfort.

  • People who prefer a hybrid mattress combining foam and coils.

• Who Shouldn't Use It:

  • Budget-conscious shoppers might find the Aurora Luxe too pricey.

  • Those who prefer a traditional innerspring feel may not like the feel of this mattress.

  • People looking for an extra firm mattress might find this one too soft for their liking.

• Specifications:

  • Type: Hybrid (Memory Foam and Coils)

  • Profile: 13.75 Inches (High Profile)

  • Firmness: Soft (3 out of 10), Medium (5 out of 10), and Firm (7 out of 10)

  • Positions: Side, Back, and Stomach Sleepers

  • Max. Weight: 250 to 300 lbs. (Per Sleeper. See Titan Plus Luxe by Brooklyn Bedding for Additional Weight Support)

  • Comfort: CopperFlex PCM, Supreme Response Comfort Foam, and Gel Swirl Memory Foam

  • Support: Supreme Response Comfort Foam and Zoned Coil Core

  • Cooling: GlacioTex Cooling Cover and CopperFlex PCM

  • Trial Period: 120 Nights

  • Warranty: 10 Year Warranty

  • Shipping: Free Shipping

  • Score: 5.0/5.0

• Features:

  • TitanCool technology actively regulates temperature for a cooler sleep experience.

  • Copper-infused foam layer provides antimicrobial properties and additional cooling.

  • Advanced hybrid design offers a balance of pressure relief and support.

• Durability:

  • High-quality materials ensure long-lasting performance and durability over the years.

  • Reinforced coils and durable foam layers prevent sagging and wear, maintaining comfort.

  • It comes with a 10-year warranty, showcasing Brooklyn Bedding’s confidence.

Check their mattress in a box page for their best prices: Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Cooling

4. DLX Premier Hybrid Mattress – Best Mattress in a Box for Couples Reddit Users Recommend

Reddit users recommend the DLX Premier Hybrid Mattress as the best mattress in a box for couples due to its great comfort and support. With a blend of memory foam and coil technology, it ensures a restful night's sleep by contouring to your body and reducing motion transfer.

It features advanced cooling technology to keep you comfortable throughout the night. The hybrid design provides an excellent balance of softness and firmness, making it ideal for all sleeping positions. This mattress is also praised for its durability and premium materials.

• Who Should Use It:

  • Ideal for couples looking for a mattress that minimizes motion transfer for uninterrupted sleep.

  • Great for all sleeping positions, providing a balanced mix of support and comfort for every type.

  • Perfect for those who sleep hot, thanks to its advanced cooling technology that keeps you cool.

• Who Shouldn't Use It:

  • Not ideal for those who prefer an ultra-soft mattress, as it offers a balanced firmness level.

  • People on a tight budget might find it slightly expensive compared to other options.

  • Not suitable for those who prefer a traditional innerspring feel over hybrid technology.

• Specifications:

  • Type: Hybrid (Memory Foam and Coils)

  • Profile: 14 Inches (High Profile)

  • Firmness: Soft (4 out of 10), Medium (6 out of 10), and Firm (8 out of 10)

  • Positions: Side, Back, and Stomach Sleepers

  • Max. Weight: 250 to 300 lbs. Per Sleeper. See DLX MemoryMax Hybrid for Additional Weight Support)

  • Comfort: Airsoft Viscose Fiber, LoftAdapt Foam, and FusionBalance Performance Foam

  • Support: LinkBridge Transitional Foam and Advanced Hybrid Technology Coil System

  • Cooling: Luxurious Hyperflex Fabric and Airsoft Viscose Fiber

  • Trial Period: 120 Nights

  • Warranty: Lifetime Warranty

  • Shipping: Free Shipping

  • Score: 4.5/5.0

• Features:

  • The hybrid design with memory foam and coils provides excellent support and comfort.

  • Advanced cooling technology ensures a cool sleeping experience, ideal for hot sleepers.

  • High-quality materials and construction offer long-lasting durability and a premium feel.

• Durability:

  • The hybrid design with memory foam and coils provides excellent support and comfort.

  • Advanced cooling technology ensures a cool sleeping experience, ideal for hot sleepers.

  • High-quality materials and construction offer long-lasting durability and a premium feel.

Check their mattress in a box page for their best prices: DLX Premier Hybrid Mattress

5. Puffy Lux Mattress – Best Mattress in a Box for Combination Sleepers Reddit Users Recommend

Reddit users recommend the Puffy Lux Mattress as the best mattress in a box for combination sleepers due to its adaptive comfort layers. These layers contour to your body, providing support and pressure relief, which is ideal for those who switch positions throughout the night.

It features a cooling cloud foam that regulates temperature, ensuring you stay cool and comfortable. The mattress also has a firm core support layer, which maintains spinal alignment, making it a perfect choice for people with back pain.

• Who Should Use It:

  • Ideal for combination sleepers needing support and pressure relief.

  • Great for hot sleepers, as cooling cloud foam helps regulate temperature for a cooler sleep.

  • Perfect for those with back pain, as Contour-Adapt Coils maintains proper spinal alignment.

• Who Shouldn't Use It:

  • Not suitable for those who prefer a very firm mattress; it may feel too soft for some users.

  • Unsuitable for budget shoppers; premium quality comes with a higher price tag.

  • Might not be the best for heavy sleepers; some may need a mattress with robust support.

• Specifications:

  • Type: Hybrid (Memory Foam and Coils)

  • Profile: 12 Inches (High Profile)

  • Firmness: Medium (6.5 out of 10)

  • Positions: Side and Back sleepers

  • Max. Weight: 250 to 300 lbs. (Per Sleeper. See Puffy Monarch Mattressfor Additional Weight Support)

  • Comfort: Cooling Cloud Foam and Plush Dual Cloud Foam

  • Support: Cloud Comfort Pressure Relief Foam and Contour Adapt Coils

  • Cooling: Cool Touch Quilted Cloud Cover, Climate Fiber Layer, and Cooling Cloud Foam

  • Trial Period: 101 Nights

  • Warranty: Lifetime Warranty

  • Shipping: Free Shipping

  • Score: 4.5/5.0

• Features:

  • Regulates temperature for a cooler and more comfortable sleep experience.

  • Provides excellent pressure relief and adapts to various sleeping positions.

  • Maintains spinal alignment and alleviates back pain for improved comfort.

• Durability:

  • High-density foam layers ensure long-lasting support and prevent sagging.

  • Sturdy construction withstands regular use without losing shape or support.

  • Quality materials contribute to the mattress's durability, maintaining comfort over time.

Check their mattress in a box page for their best prices: Puffy Lux Mattress

Subreddit Sources Used To Research

• r/Mattresses

• r/MattressAdvisory

• r/BedFrameAdvisory

• r/BeddingAdvisory

looking for <$400 queen size 12 in. I keep reading the reviews on Amazon and it seems that firm isn't really my definition of firm. I don't want to sink into the bed even the slightest. Thank you!

edit: I actually ended up going with the Boring Hybrid https://www.boring.co/products/hybrid-mattress. I haven't had the time to make a proper review yet or dont know if I will ever do it. All I can say is that the mattress is simple but really comfortable for me.

Hello

After 7 years of sleeping on what I lovingly call ""the pit of despair"" (a hand-me-down that's basically a hammock at this point), I've finally saved up enough for a new mattress.

I've got about $1000 to spend for a queen, which seemed like plenty until I walked into a mattress store. The salesman kept pushing me toward mattresses that were WAY above my budget, claiming anything under $1500 would ""compromise my sleep health"" (eye roll).

When I insisted on staying under $1000, he showed me a few options that honestly felt like I was lying on a bag of potatoes. Then tried to upsell me on some cooling technology that supposedly uses ""cooling gel"" or something equally ridiculous. Like, what does that even MEAN??

I'm looking for the best mattress under 1000 that will actually last. I'm a side sleeper and weigh around 170lbs. I don't need bells and whistles – just something with decent support.

Has anyone found a quality mattress in this price range? Are online mattress companies worth considering? I was checking out Boring. I'm open to foam, hybrid, whatever - as long as it's comfortable

I purchased a 8 inch Zinus mattress from Walmart less than two years ago. It has lost its firmness and sinks in a bit. I am looking for one that is a bit firmer. Also looking for opinions for those who have had theirs a while and not just a month. Light sleeper if that is relevant. I am getting so many ads on social media now that I have starting looking for one. Of course they all have ‘rave’ reviews.

Mattress shopping is kicking my butt. Between trying to find the right firmness, staying cool at night, and getting enough support, it feels impossible to pick one. Analysis paralysis is real!

Did you find a mattress that was a total game-changer for your sleep? I’d love recommendations for one that’s supportive, sleeps cool, and holds up over time also something budget-friendly.

I’ve seen a lot about Tempur-Pedic, Purple, Casper, and Saatva. Any strong feelings (good or bad) about these?

I have tried a lot of mattresses over the years and had a lot of trouble finding one that was just right for me as I get pain sleeping. Most mattresses to me feel too firm so I wanted something softer but the softer ones I've tried usually end up being too soft so it's hard to find something very medium feeling. I just finished a 100 night trial with my Silk and Snow memory foam mattress and I've decided to post my findings for comparison on that and the other mattresses I've tried and what I have realized will work or not for people with different weights and sleep positions. I'm 5"8" and 150 lbs and mostly a side sleeper and my husband is pretty much the same but I will post what would work for other weights and sleep positions too. Also, note I live in Canada but some of these mattresses sell to the US too. EDITED TO ADD: None of these mattresses have gone to landfills. I kept and resold some and only a couple were returned that were donated to charities. The exchanged ones at Sleep Country are cleaned and resold as 'floor models'.

Mattresses I've tried:

*Naturelle Dunlop Latex mattress - I ordered this mattress and I got one that had 3 layers, firm on the bottom, medium in the middle and medium on top. It was extremely firm feeling like sleeping on a rock and I couldn't sleep on it without a memory foam topper. They had promised I could exchange the top layer for a softer layer and then suddenly wanted to charge me a bunch to ship the other layer so I put in a complaint about their company and I sold the mattress. **Who I would recommend a latex mattress for: Back and stomach sleepers over 200 lbs. I would recommend getting a soft layer on top or adding a topper especially if you are a side sleeper.

*Original Purple mattress - I bought this from someone selling it and found it comfortable for back sleeping but it was too firm for side sleeping. It slept cold even in the winter, which I didn't like and I also didn't like the stretchy sheets I had to use with it. I sold this one too. **Who I would recommend it for: Back sleepers. I'm not sure how it would be for stomach sleepers but for side sleepers, I've heard only the Purple 4 is cushioning enough.

*Juno mattress - I ordered this one and found the mattress to be too thin and firm. Because it only has two layers it is missing a the transition layer from the soft top to firm bottom so an adult will sink through the top layer to the firm layer unless you are very light weight. I missed my return date for this one and will be selling it. **Who I would recommend it for: children or lightweight teens or adults under 100 lbs.

*Simba 2500 mattress - I got this at Sleep Country and it was close to being what I wanted but I found it felt too soft under my hips as it felt like the lower part of my body was sinking into a hole. Although the mattress was one of the more comfortable ones I've tried, I exchanged this one. **Who I would recommend it for: Side sleepers or maybe back sleepers under 150 lbs who like a softer mattress.

*Casper Nova Hybrid mattress - I got this from Sleep Country too from my exchange. I got what was supposed to be a floor model but it was actually a return. It felt very broken in and too soft compared to the one we tried in the store and was very hot and uncomfortable to sleep on. I sank in way too much and it gave me back pain. It was also a couple inches short lengthwise and widthwise. I exchanged it. **Who I would recommend this for: Side Sleepers under 150 lbs who like something soft. If you are over 150 lbs you will probably find it too soft and hot unless you get a cooling layer added to it.

*Casper Original mattress - I got this from the Casper store and it felt too firm for me side sleeping. I would wake up with numbness and tingling in my arms. It got softer after a few months and more comfortable but it was also a couple inches short lengthwise and widthwise. I returned it. **Who I would recommend this for: Back and stomach sleepers under 200 lbs. This may not be firm enough for stomach sleepers but it too firm for most side sleepers.

*Silk and Snow original mattress - When I ordered this I had high hopes for it as it was supposed to be medium feeling but softer on top for side sleeping with high density memory foam. At first it felt a bit firm, then felt fine, then felt too soft and like my hips and sides sank in too much side sleeping. After trying it for a couple months I started getting lower back pain as it felt a bit too soft. I gave it the full 100 night trial thinking I would keep it but decided to start a return right as my trial ended. **Who I would recommend it for: Side and back sleepers under 150 lbs. My husband found it okay for all positions including stomach sleeping but when I looked at his alignment he definitely sank in more around the hips in all sleep positions and he's about 150 lbs.

*Emma mattress - I ordered this to compare to the Silk and Snow when I had it and I slept on it two days and was in pain everywhere as it was much firmer on top than they advertise and I didn't like the feel of the firm foam on top as it didn't feel like memory foam. I also was getting sick around the same time which made my body more sensitive so I tried it again when I was better and it was still too firm so I returned it. **Who I would recommend it for: Back and stomach sleepers over 150 lbs. It felt too firm for side sleeping.

*Douglas mattress - I ordered this after arranging my return for the Silk and Snow mattress. I tried it for a few months and at first it felt too firm but it gradually got a bit softer and more comfortable as time went on. It has a softer, slower memory foam feel on top which I like and is firmer in the middle and lower layers. I switched to a couple other mattresses after trying this one and got lower back pain on them so switched back to this one and then my lower back pain went away. So I am currently sleeping on this mattress again. It is still a touch firmer under my shoulders side sleeping but has better support than other mattresses for my lower back. The only downside to this is it is hot to sleep on. I have to use it without a mattress protector because the protector trapped the heat too much. **Who I would recommend it for: Side, Back and Stomach sleepers over 150 lbs.

*Endy mattress - I tried this in a store and I found it to be soft on top but firmer underneath like the Douglas. The difference is that this has more of a foam feel on top that bounces back fast versus the douglas has more of a memory foam feel on top that's slower moving which I like more. This mattress is also supposed to be good for average weight sleepers but more for back and stomach sleepers. I wouldn't try this myself for side sleeping as I don't think it would be soft enough.

*Silk and Snow Hybrid mattress - I tried this one in a store and it felt supportive with the springs but it felt soft on top. It's supposed to be a medium firm feel but it felt a bit softer on top than I expected. When I layed on it my hips sank in more just like on the original Silk and Snow mattress which surprised me. I considered ordering this hybrid after returning my original Silk and Snow mattress as they said this one should be a bit firmer and a bit more supportive but I also read reviews saying it might feel a bit firm for side sleeping and that it's better for back and stomach sleeping and heavier weights. So I decided to go with the Douglas instead of this mattress.

*Polysleep mattress - This is a mattress I considered trying but I heard it might be a bit firmer for side sleepers. It's supposed to be better for average to heavier weight back and stomach sleepers. It may work for side sleepers too but I'm not sure. Depending on if I can try one somewhere I have considered getting this one if the Douglas doesn't work out.

My old mattress has finally given up on me—I’ve been waking up sore, and it’s definitely time for a replacement. The problem is, I don’t want to spend a fortune but still want something comfortable and supportive.

What do you think is the best affordable mattress right now? Any advice from your own experience would be super helpful—thanks!

a few years ago, there were soooo many mattress in a box brands it became the very problem they were hoping to solve (too many choice in a mattress store, overwhelmed clients... so it became too many box brands, just as overwhelmed clients).

Now the dust has settled a bit, is there a brand that stood out of the lot as higher quality instead of quickly obsolete gadget that doesnt stand the test of time?

thanks a lot

I did everything right. I researched, read reviews, even laid on this Sealy mattress in a showroom for 15 minutes while the salesperson awkwardly hovered. It felt amazing... until it didn't. After spending the last THREE YEARS on a mattress that cost me $850 and developed a body-shaped crater within 8 months, I'm super skeptical and literally trust no one.

The first 90 days were great, then it started freaking sinking in the middle. By the time I tried to use the warranty, they hit me with "normal wear and tear isn't covered" and "body impressions under ‘x’ inches aren't considered defects." EXCUSE ME?

Anyway. I'm now mattress shopping again, but THIS time, I want a simple, well-made mattress under $1000 that won't become a hammock within a year.

I'm looking at some online brands, but also considering going back to basics with something more traditional.

Has anyone found a good mattress under $1000 that's actually held up over time? What's your experience with hybrid vs all-foam designs? Any brands to absolutely avoid? (I’ve read that a lot of those trial periods often have ridiculous return processes and that most mattress reviews online are paid.)

Edit: WOW, didn't expect so many responses! I tried reading through all your suggestions, but they were too many… thanks so much everyone!

I ended up going with the Boring Hybrid Mattress (https://www.boring.co/products/hybrid-mattress) after a decision paralysis, since it checked all the boxes for me: under $1000, a 365 night trial period, good support, and plenty of positive reviews here on Reddit.

It might not be the most exciting pick, but it felt it was one of the safest bets. I’m super excited to finally try it out and see if it lives up to the hype (or at least doesn’t sag within 8 months)!

Hello Redditors,
I'm in the market for a new mattress and have narrowed my search down to a bed in a box type foam mattress. For the sake of changing things up, I have decided to stray away from the traditional coil spring mattresses ( no particular reason, I want change.) I know a couple of people who have bought foam mattresses online, their biggest complaint is that they find the mattress too firm; I have also read reviews online of the foam mattresses tearing or ripping... I have struggled to find legitimate reviews online that aren't sponsored or biased, so here I am.

-What are your thoughts on the bed in a box style mattresses? Are they worth it? Which brand is the most reputable?

- I've heard pretty good things about Casper; however, they're impossible to find where I live. Does anyone here own a Casper mattress?

Thanks for reading!

Edit: Thanks for all the feedback folks! Looks like I'm going to pay a visit to Costco! thanks thanks!

Hi All,

I've been doing a deep dive into the world of online mattresses as it's time for an upgrade. (Currently sleeping on my friend's old Tuft and Needle he gave to me when he moved, just need a bigger one.)

Specs: ~150lbs, side/back sleeper, medium firm preference. Looking for something that works well for sex, sleeps cool, and has decent edge support

Budget: <$1000

Is is it possible to get unbiased feedback on which brand is my best bet in that price range? Between the Leesa, Helix, Purple, Casper, Love & Sleep, GhostBed, Brooklyn Bedding et. all - I can't come to any conclusions about which would be the best bang for my buck.

Any insight y'all can provide would be greatly appreciated!

Many Thanks :)

Hi, I’m moving to a studio apartment and was wondering what your experience has been with mattresses in a box and what seems to be the best value for your dollar.

I was looking into sales at BJs and Costco, but found that there are mattresses on Amazon that are cheaper. My budget is max $300 for a full size, but I’d be open to a queen. Any recommendations would be much appreciated! TIA.

My fiancée recently got sick of our sunken, old, pillow-top coil-spring mattress. So, I took the dive into mattress research a few weeks ago. It didn't take long before my text file of notes became overwhelmed and I needed a better solution.

So, being a spreadsheet nerd, I put together a Google Sheets file that would let me:

• Record all of the information I was gathering using handy drop-down menus

• See the information about all of the mattresses side-by-side

• Assign scores to the various aspects of each mattress to generate a total score for each mattress

• Create a chart with all of the mattress scores together

Here's the result: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/159u6tzctN6AgVMJ7VzEFjXm5aJjS4t300fRQtz-grRc/edit?usp=sharing

To edit the sheet, click File ► Make a copy.

The scores I assigned are totally arbitrary and based on our opinion and needs. Your final scores would (should!) be totally different.

For example:

• We valued firmness at 20% of the total score for the mattress.

• Warranty periods mean very little in our opinion, because there's no indication that most of these companies will last long enough to provide warranty service. So we valued the warranty period at 2% of the total score.

• We live in Canada (eh?). That means that availability is a problem, and returns are even more problematic. Ever tried to return a mattress to Amazon? No thanks. We assigned 20% of the final score to easy returns.

If you think this might be useful in your own research click File, and then click Make a copy. That will let you save your own editable copy. From there, play with the scores until they reflect your needs.

Happy hunting!

Edit: List of the foam mattresses on the spreadsheet, to make it easier for people to find this thread on Google:

• GhostBed

• Leesa

• Purple

• Silk + Snow

• O Mattress

• Endy

• Casper

• Helix

• Lull

• Brooklyn Bedding Aurora

• Saatva

• Loom & Leaf

• Novosbed

• Tuft & Needle

• Olive

• Bear

• Sealy Cocoon Chill

• Tempur-Pedic Flex

• Bed in a Box PacBed

• Bed in a Box Azul

The information in the spreadsheet is from March 2018.

I know this isn't strictly a "homeowners" question (renters need beds too?), but I figured some of you might have some experience.

Does anyone know of a source for a good comparative review of the various bed-in-a-box mattresses (Casper, Purple, Nectar), etc? I'm in the market, and I'm finding it very difficult to cut through the noise of ad-supported reviews (Everything is Awesome!) and marketing. I know that most of them have free trials, so it's not hugely high-risk, but I would like to be able to do some good comparative reading before I order...