You should never hire an FA for performance. You should hire them for comprehensive planning (tax planning, distribution strategies, retirement income analysis, estate concerns, etc.). If they aren’t doing all of that for you, what are you paying for? Edit: to clarify, anyone down playing the value of an advisor is an idiot. Most people (including those here) should be paying an advisor. Just make sure you’re getting real value from it. Answer from yerrmomgoes2college on reddit.com
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/investing › anyone using fisher investments and feel like it's worth it?
r/investing on Reddit: Anyone using Fisher Investments and feel like it's worth it?
August 16, 2024 -

I've (52M) been talking with a Fisher rep for awhile, I've been through the analysis process, and they make a fairly compelling case that, net fees, they could improve my returns 4 to 5%.

I'm skeptical, but I'm also a "set it and forget" it investor, about 10% bonds, 50% VOO, 10% VTI/small cap, and the rest in target date funds.

My portfolio is a little unbalanced and spread over a bunch of accounts I've accumulated over the years. Overweight in some areas, underweight in others. I could consolidate and balance, but I hate to think I'm leaving money on the table with a mostly hands off approach. Hoping to semi-retire in 10 years.

Anyone using Fisher, or other similar firm, and feel it's worth the fees?

EDIT: Fisher fee is 1.25. Most of my ETFs are .03 to .1

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/investing › should i go with fisher investments?
r/investing on Reddit: Should I go with Fisher Investments?
December 15, 2024 -

These guys have been after me for a while. They talk about how they differ from other firms. I’m curious as to any opinions you all have of them.

I have about $1MM over at Fidelity they Fidelity manages at a ridiculously low commission (~0.5%). This year it made around 15%. The downside is limited selection of investment choices.

My wife has a similar amount in TSP, and last year, it made 20%. I don’t have this years’ number yet, but choices are even more limited.

There’s more piles of money around for us, but this is the sort of stuff I’d be willing to have them manage.

I’ve just retired, and my wife has a few years left. She can take an in-service distribution.

Realistically, what kind of return would I expect from these guys?

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/m1finance › morgan stanley versus fisher investments?
r/M1Finance on Reddit: Morgan Stanley versus Fisher Investments?
May 4, 2025 -

I have been with Morgan Stanley (MS) since 2009. Husband and I are 72 and 74. Our returns have been low. I am wondering if I should switch to Fisher due to supposed better performance and fees (per the salesman). Our bonds at MS were switched to Blackrock (BR) so double fees - BR and MS. Also other MS fees are higher than what Fisher Inv. claim. Husband is taking out only his RMD. Currently we are living on SS and savings. Now we want to earn more on our investments. I am trying to decide if I should switch financial advisors or maybe just re-adjust our portfolio with MS to medium or medium/higher risk investments instead of the low risk ones we have been in? Any suggestions/recommendations?

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/cfp › fisher investments
Fisher Investments : r/CFP
January 18, 2025 - I have a client who has some money over there. My performance is beating them, but client likes having three 7 figure relationships. It’s annoying and he’s overpaying. I’d have him at 80 bps if he consolidated all with me, but even Jess than 1% if just the Fisher account came over
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/financialplanning › be very careful before using fisher investments
r/FinancialPlanning on Reddit: Be Very Careful Before Using Fisher Investments
March 8, 2025 -

I found a white paper online that I wanted to read, so I gave my contact info to Fisher to access it. Almost immediately they started calling and emailing me. I eventually picked up one of their calls just because I was curious. The guy from Fisher pitched me on managing my money in their fund. My first question was “How did your fund perform last year?” He said 21% gain after fees. I pointed out that S&P ETFs ($SPY) grew at about 25%. He wouldn’t believe me. He kept insisting that the S&P was only up 18% in 2024.

It’s one thing to be wrong, but this guy was so confident in his wrong information. He was either lying or had no idea what he was doing. Either way, it’s a big red flag for Fisher.

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/cfp › intel on fisher investments?
r/CFP on Reddit: Intel on Fisher Investments?
January 29, 2025 -

I am meeting with a prospect client next week that uses Fisher Investments. They booked a meeting with me as they wanted to learn more about government programs (we are in Canada, so things like CPP, OAS, etc.). Basically, they don't seem to get much planning help from Fisher.

Has anyone here worked for Fisher or know anything about their offering/program, fees, etc.? Any competitive intel on how to show what they do/don't do for clients would be a huge help in crafting my message.

I think they are a sales focused shop that has individuals close deals then pass off clients to servicing advisors who don't know much, but I could be wrong.

Top answer
1 of 25
106
I worked at fisher. They lie constantly about giving tax & financial advice. They have CPAs who don’t give advice. They have CFPs who don’t give advice. Their portfolio they argue is benchmarked to the MSCI world but if you review the asset allocation more closely aligns to the Nasdaq which they in fact underperform. Long story short? The way to win is to argue they don’t need that much risk. Zero tax strategy - ask them to give you the feedback fisher had on their tax return/tax strategy - none. Zero financial advice - ask, other than the portfolio, what feedback fisher gave on their financial plan - nothing. Their portfolio is 60%+ in tech. I know this because I’ve taken 7 clients in the last 2 months from fi. The strategy their financial plan depends on with fisher absolutely is based on betting on the HOPE fisher can find markets despite the evidence. All the while paying 1.25%+ That seems like not just a waste but actually reckless. People who hire fisher want an investment manager & don’t actually care about tax or ongoing financial planning. People who actually want a financial planner, tax strategy to minimize withdrawals, rmd strategy, minimized taxes on ird/etc hire YOU. FUCK fisher. My least favorite competitor. Literally don’t provide end planning or financial planning to retirees. I wouldn’t be surprised if 10% of their clients are depletionary & they don’t realize it.
2 of 25
88
Just tell the client you’re a fiduciary and when they do better you do better.. but better. Lol
Find elsewhere
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/highyieldsavings › fisher investments reviews for 2025?
r/HighYieldSavings on Reddit: Fisher Investments Reviews for 2025?
November 12, 2024 -

I’ve been reading Fisher Investments reviews and have been in discussions with a Fisher representative for a while. After going through their analysis process, they claim they could improve my net returns by 4 to 5%, even after fees, which sounds appealing but also makes me skeptical. I’m a 52-year-old "set it and forget it" investor, with about 10% in bonds, 50% in VOO, 10% in VTI/small cap, and the rest in target date funds. My portfolio is spread across several accounts accumulated over the years, leaving it somewhat unbalanced—overweight in some areas and underweight in others. While I could consolidate and rebalance it myself, I can’t help but wonder if I’m leaving potential gains on the table with my mostly hands-off strategy. My goal is to semi-retire in 10 years, so I’m curious if anyone has experience with Fisher or similar firms and whether the fees are truly worth it.

Top answer
1 of 4
1
They are salespeople, great at sales but the facts are 98% of actively managed mutual funds failed to outperform the S&P 1500 over the past 10 years when you account for taxes and fees. If they claim that then tell them if they improve your net returns 4% you’ll give them 1% off the top. They won’t sign that sort or deal. https://stockanalysis.com/article/fisher-investments-review/#
2 of 4
1
i made the mistake of not doing my due diligence in July 2024 when i selected them as the new financial advisor. fisher will sell off most of your long term investments, including FAANG stocks that you have held for a long time, if they feel it doesn't align with their investment portfolio allocation strategy. they also don't believe in ETFs, claiming you will be paying them as well as the fee charged by the fund manager. they did that to my taxable trust account before reviewing the plan with me first, and I am now stuck with tens of thousands of tax bills due to the enormous realized capital gains from those long held positions that were sold. in addition, i expect them to manage losses in healthcare stocks they bought into, but they kept buying more shares. needless to say, i am not happy with their services because they seem to be more concerned with their hedge fund side of business and transactional, rather than tailoring the investment portfolio for individuals. the "financial advisor" assigned to me is more an administrator since there is a separate governance and analysts' team that determine the list of stocks to offer for the clients. i should have caught on the red flag when the VP told me typical financial advisor relationship only last 1 1/2 years in the industry. if you are happy with the returns with VOO, i would leave it alone or maybe divest some into another mid/small cap or some good dividend stocks to diversify.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/retirement › opinion on fisher investments?
r/retirement on Reddit: Opinion on Fisher Investments?
December 2, 2020 -

58 in February and able to retire anytime from large utility. I'm fortunate to have a traditional pension lump sum available around 700k and a 401k around 550 k. Recently spoke to a rep from Fisher who could actually manage my 401k while still employed through my fidelity account. Just weighing my options. Thanks in advance!

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/investing › thoughts on fisher investments?
r/investing on Reddit: Thoughts on Fisher Investments?
January 24, 2025 -

I am thinking of moving some money to a new investment firm and am wondering if anyone has experience with Fisher Investments or if you have other great firms you recommend. We have looked at J.P. Morgan, Mariner, Stonehage Fleming and a few others. Thank you!

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/investing › ep wealth vs fisher investments?
r/investing on Reddit: EP Wealth vs Fisher Investments?
March 6, 2024 -

I am retired at 54 with just over $1.2M invested. I understand the basics about wealth management but honestly just want someone else to handle it. I'm with EP Wealth and have been happy with them for the past 5 years. But there is always the question, could I be doing better? Fisher has been calling me, trying to get me to move over to them. Any opinions out there on EP vs Fisher?

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/investments › fisher investments
r/Investments on Reddit: Fisher Investments
July 5, 2024 -

I’m looking for feedback from people who have invested with Fisher Investments. What has been your experience with Fisher? I’m not looking for responses from people who are chiming in without actually having used them. ( Reddit is full of those people) I’m considering investing with Fisher, but I’d like to get some firsthand information before I can even think of considering investing. TIA

Top answer
1 of 3
4
I used to work there if this gives you any context in multiple capacities. You will be placed with a Investment Counselor after onboarding. Most of these individuals will never touch or make any decisions with your money. Your discussions with them can sometimes change the strategy from stocks to bonds but in the end, a different team is handling your investments in an enormous pool. Most of the frustrated clients were individuals who had specific needs that were not followed. One example is someone asked not to rebalance their taxable account until they knew that year's tax basis. The communication did not make it to the team handling the account and now they are paying taxes on realized positions. Another gripe was how a random Investment Counselor was assigned to you, sometimes it is someone who just passed their licensing tests and have little to no knowledge. Last big gripe was the salesperson who sold them on Fisher Investments was not honest about what they were selling. Once, they got into the system, the reality did not match the fantasy that was sold. My personal opinion was that clients did get many benefits from Fisher Investments. The big one was holding themselves back from trading at the lows when someone was nervous about the market. You are basically paying for the Investment Committee to tell your Investment Counselor that things are okay. If you know how to do this on your own...then you can simply buy index funds. If you need specific advise then pay an hourly financial advisor to help you through those 2-10 hours of work. Lastly, I thought the 1.2%+ fee of AUM was a little high for most clients. Overall, this is a good company that does help the client but most of their clients have the ability to perform similarly or better in index funds. Then if they have an edge case, pay an hourly financial advisor to save a lot more money. I doubt any client would pay $10,000+ a year (Fisher's AUM fee for $1M) for hourly advise in this arena. Edit typos.
2 of 3
2
Terrible shop.  Lost 1/3 of my portfolio value in a flat market.  Paid above market fees, and for way below performance.  What’s worst, is that even when the poertfolio they designed was hemorrhaging, they didn’t make a single trade - so your paying an above market fee for non-active management. Don’t let them BS you about remaining committed to an investment thesis.  When individuals stocks were down 60-80%, you need to reevaluate the thesis.  Never again.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/highyieldsavings › fisher investments reviews 2025: is it still worth it?
r/HighYieldSavings on Reddit: Fisher Investments Reviews 2025: Is it still worth it?
October 20, 2025 -

Been going back and forth with a Fisher Investments rep for a bit now, and they’re saying they could boost my net returns by around 4 to 5 percent even after fees. It sounds tempting, but also a little too good to be true. The way they present their analysis feels convincing, though part of me can’t shake the skepticism that always comes with big financial promises. For context, I’m 52 and more of a “set it and forget it” type when it comes to investing. My portfolio sits at around 10 percent bonds, 50 percent in VOO, 10 percent in VTI or small caps, and the rest in target date funds. It’s spread across multiple accounts I’ve built up over the years, which probably makes it less balanced than it should be. Some areas are clearly overweight, others underweight, and I know I could fix it myself with some rebalancing, I just never get around to it. That’s where Fisher caught my attention. They make it sound like they could simplify everything, fine-tune the allocations, and pull better returns out of what I already have. But the fees aren’t small, and I keep wondering if the results would really justify the cost or if I’d end up in the same spot, just with less in my pocket. My plan is to semi-retire in about 10 years, so I’m trying to make smarter decisions without getting too aggressive. Curious if anyone here has worked with Fisher or a similar investment firm. Were the fees actually worth it long-term, or would a well-balanced self-managed portfolio have done just as well?

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/personalfinance › opinions on fisher investments?
r/personalfinance on Reddit: Opinions on Fisher Investments?
October 22, 2020 -

TL;DR: What do people think of Fisher Investments?

Some background: During the correction around 2009 I decided that I was not the right person to be selecting own investments. At that time I didn't feel great about index funds so I went to Merrill Lynch. They did well for me for many years but in March 2020 I moved to Fisher because I felt that ML was not quite keeping up with the market after fees and wasn't giving me any additional benefit.

Since joining Fisher I've been matching/beating indexes after fees, which is good. I am ahead of where I would be if I'd been in index funds (by a small amount) plus they have been running Monte Carlo simulations for us, arranging calls with tax experts, and generally helping me get a handle on how our retirement will work. All good, no complaints.

The problem: In the last 14 months I've had 4 investment councilors which to be fair is not a critical role but still the turnover is a bit concerning. I'm relatively new to Fisher and while so far I'm happy with performance and value, I'm a bit concerned about this turnover.