You want to use the mode 'L' instead of 'LA' as the parameter to the convert() method. 'LA' leaves an alpha channel and then the numpy.asarray doesn't work as you intended. If you need the alpha channel, then you will need a different method to convert to a numpy array. Otherwise, use mode 'L'.
Answer from Justin Peel on Stack OverflowYou want to use the mode 'L' instead of 'LA' as the parameter to the convert() method. 'LA' leaves an alpha channel and then the numpy.asarray doesn't work as you intended. If you need the alpha channel, then you will need a different method to convert to a numpy array. Otherwise, use mode 'L'.
It looks like you're using a version of PIL prior to 1.1.6, where they introduced the methods so that numpy would know what to do with an Image. So you're just getting img_as_np as a one-element array containing an Image object (which is what Out[4] is showing you).
You instead need to do something like np.asarray(img.getdata()), which will give you a num_pixels x num_channels array of integers between 0 and 255 (at least for the png I tried). You may want to do
img_as_np = np.asarray(img.getdata()).reshape(img.size[1], img.size[0], -1)
to lay it out like the image (transposed). You might also want to divide by 255 to get float values between 0 and 1, if that's the format you're expecting (as does e.g. matplotlib's imshow).
Try it and see!
from PIL import Image
import numpy as np
# Other answer method
im1 = Image.open('gray.png').convert('L')
im1 = np.stack((im1,)*3, axis=-1)
# Your method
im2 = Image.open('gray.png').convert('RGB')
im2 = np.array(im2)
# Test if identical
print(np.array_equal(im1,im2))
Sample Output
True
I would say the one aspect that is different, is that the method in the other answer will work (insofar as it actually makes a greyscale image where R=G=B) even if the input image is colour, whereas your method will produce a colour image.
I was working on doing a similar thing, and I'm not sure why but I ran into a bunch of issues. In the end this worked for me pretty well without loss of any data.
from PIL import Image
import numpy as np
img=np.array(Image.open(filename).convert('L'))
and to convert back:
import imageio
array = array.astype(np.uint8)
imageio.imwrite(newfilename, array)
edit: this only works for black and white images. Color images need 3D arrays rather than 2D arrays
Applying grayscale conversion to list of numpy array of images using Python
python - Converting 2D Numpy array of grayscale values to a PIL image - Stack Overflow
Converting grayscale images to binary and storing in a numpy array in python - Stack Overflow
Convert colour to grey scale numpy array - Part 1 (2018) - fast.ai Course Forums
I think the answer is wrong. The Image.fromarray( ____ , 'L') function seems to only work properly with an array of integers between 0 and 255. I use the np.uint8 function for this.
You can see this demonstrated if you try to make a gradient.
import numpy as np
from PIL import Image
# gradient between 0 and 1 for 256*256
array = np.linspace(0,1,256*256)
# reshape to 2d
mat = np.reshape(array,(256,256))
# Creates PIL image
img = Image.fromarray(np.uint8(mat * 255) , 'L')
img.show()
Makes a clean gradient
vs
import numpy as np
from PIL import Image
# gradient between 0 and 1 for 256*256
array = np.linspace(0,1,256*256)
# reshape to 2d
mat = np.reshape(array,(256,256))
# Creates PIL image
img = Image.fromarray( mat , 'L')
img.show()
Has the same kind of artifacting.
If I understood you question, you want to get a grayscale image using PIL.
If this is the case, you do not need to multiply each pixels by 255.
The following worked for me
import numpy as np
from PIL import Image
# Creates a random image 100*100 pixels
mat = np.random.random((100,100))
# Creates PIL image
img = Image.fromarray(mat, 'L')
img.show()