🌐
Trustpilot
trustpilot.com › home › shopping & fashion › clothing & underwear › sportswear store › fanatics reviews
Fanatics is rated "Average" with 3.5 / 5 on Trustpilot
1 day ago - It is below: after which I promptly heard from Fanatics via email. They were attentive & qu... See more ... I ordered several items from Fantatics.com for Christmas. A majority of the items arrived as stated, but a couple of items were delayed until after Christmas. I asked to cancel those items, but was de... See more ... Overall love the app, love their products, however, recently purchased a rather expensive jersey and their tracking system “clear jet” is horrible.
Call   855-438-0679
Address   8100 Nations Way, 32256, Jacksonville
(3.5)
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/hockeyjerseys › are fanatics jerseys really that bad, or just worse when compared to adidas authentic jerseys?
r/hockeyjerseys on Reddit: Are Fanatics jerseys really THAT bad, or just worse when compared to Adidas authentic jerseys?
August 10, 2021 -

I understand when people say buy Adidas jerseys if you can because they’re better and closer to what players actually wear. I see that advice everywhere.

But I’m wondering if Fanatics jerseys are objectively bad to buy.

Where I live, it’s simply easier to find Fanatics branded stuff in the size I want (I’m a small dude so the smaller the better in terms of size). They also tend to be cheaper compared to Adidas stuff.

I know that all things being equal, Adidas would be better to have than Fanatics. However, I just find they’re not equal in terms of availability and price.

I’m just curious from people that have experience with both, are Fanatics actually terrible jerseys that people shouldn’t buy, or just lesser when compared to Adidas? Thanks.

Edit: Just wanted to add, I’m not a jersey collector or anything like that. Just looking for jerseys to wear occasionally to show I enjoy hockey.

🌐
TenereTeam
tenereteam.com › is fanatics legit? comprehensive review for your sport experience
Is Fanatics Legit? Comprehensive Review For Your Sport Experience
November 8, 2024 - Is Fanatics legit? We explore different aspects: customer reviews, product selection, authenticity, pricing, features, and return policies.
🌐
Spocket
spocket.co › home › blog › is fanatics legit?
Is Fanatics Legit? Uncover the Truth About This Sports Retailer
January 24, 2025 - Fanatics is dedicated to providing only officially licensed products, ensuring every item meets the highest standards of authenticity. Whether you’re purchasing a jersey, a cap, or a collectible, you can trust that all merchandise is authorized ...
🌐
Sitejabber
sitejabber.com › clothing & fashion › jersey › fanatics
Fanatics Reviews - Read 3,948 Customer Reviews of Fanatics | Sitejabber
We paid $160 for a jersey and it came with the wrong number on it. They have no customer service. It's like dealing with a government agency. I tried the online chat. That was a joke. I emailed twice but never heard back. They desperately need a competitor! Anytime there's not competition the customer service SUCKS!
Call   1666855140
Address   8100 Nations Way, 32256, Jacksonville
(1.9)
Find elsewhere
🌐
TikTok
tiktok.com › discover › fanatics-jerseys-review
Fanatics Jerseys Review | TikTok
4 weeks ago - Man I thought folks were lying about fanatics quality of jerseys… for something “authentic” I was very confused on the quality of my LSU Tigers Football jersey I ordered from the site. At the premium price I was expecting stitching and embroidery but that was FAR from what I received.
🌐
Trustpilot
trustpilot.com › home › sports › ball games › soccer store › fanatics reviews
Fanatics is rated "Bad" with 1.5 / 5 on Trustpilot
September 13, 2025 - Tracking said it’s on its way for 4 weeks. Even after speaking to a representative still no jersey. Guess my sister won’t get this $185 present. No way to recoup my money. Should have read the reviews.NEVER ORDER FROM FANATICS.
Address   US
(1.5)
🌐
HFBoards
forums.hfboards.com › home › eastern conference › atlantic division › florida panthers
Just how Bad Are the Fanatics Jerseys | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League
June 25, 2024 - I was at the FTL War memorial store today looking at the jerseys they had on the racks. Night and day comparing the two. I need to stock up on the adidas ones. Click to expand... Thanks for confirming what I suspected! I'll have to continue hunting for an Adidas one versus settling for a Fanatics jersey.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/hockeyjerseys › my opinion on the new fanatics jerseys from firsthand experience
r/hockeyjerseys on Reddit: My opinion on the new fanatics jerseys from firsthand experience
October 14, 2024 -

I know fanatics has a certain stigma about it, and some rightfully earned. But this past weekend my wife and I drove up to Dallas from Houston to see my hometown Islanders play. We got there early and had a chance to see the new fanatics premium jerseys and authentic pro (or whatever it's called).

I was surprised at how well they held up to the adidas authentic ones. Although I kind of liked the dimples on the shoulders, them being gone isn't that big of a deal. The only bad thing I can say about the new premium ones is they seem to fit a bit smaller than the adidas ones did. I tried a 56 and it was definitely tighter than my Islanders 56 adidas Primegreen. Otherwise they were good and fairly priced compared to what adidas used to cost.

They had the authentic pro for $425 in the team store. It felt much heavier than the premiums. It was kind of cramped and crowded in the store so i didn't actually get to try it on. But maybe next time I go home to New York next year I can try one on at the Islanders team store and see.

I totally understand why Fanatics gets the negative press it does. But as someone who has been collecting hockey jerseys since the 1990's, I don't think this one was bad. It's not like we have a choice here for the next decade anyway. Unless they radically change them in the future i will be fine purchasing a premium Islanders one or other teams jerseys I like.

🌐
Worthepenny
footballfanatics.worthepenny.com
Check Futbol Fanatics Ratings & Customer Reviews
Out of the 27.35 I spent, I'm only getting back 10.35. Can you believe that? It's a total ripoff! Paying taxes twice and shipping is just ridiculous. To all potential buyers, this feels like some foreign business nonsense, and they've definitely lost my business!!!!!!!!
🌐
TealTownUSA
tealtownusa.com › home › stop calling adidas nhl jerseys authentic
Stop Calling Adidas NHL Jerseys Authentic - Teal Town USA
January 21, 2022 - Today, Fanatics produces replica jerseys for the NHL while Adidas offers an “authentic”. But now that Adidas and Fanatics are competing for your dollar, the price difference is much narrower at $129 for Fanatics and $179 for Adidas.
🌐
Influenster
influenster.com › retailers & services › fanatics › fanatics.com
fanatics.com
Its a great gaming site can buy jerseys Sportsbcards and more Its the Best You wont Regret it Go And Make an Account today ... Really good website for fanatics of a lot of sports , my husband is a baseball lover and he really like getting all His hats and shirt from fanatics because always Has a very good selection And also fast shipping and good prices
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/habs › fanatics jersey vs. fake jersey?
r/Habs on Reddit: Fanatics jersey VS. Fake jersey?
August 3, 2024 -

Hey guys, curious if you think this fanatics jersey is worth 100.00 (on sale) or if I should just go with a "made in China"/fake jersey? I know that is maybe not everyone's cup of tea to support a fake jersey but I have found them to be of decent quality...I have never bought a Fanatics jersey however.

https://www.tricoloresports.com/us/chandail-replique-homme-2017-rouge-avec-patch-fina.html

What do you guys think of Fanatics? I know fake jerseys don't always have exact colors and sizes for emblems but just curious what your 2 cents are if a Fanatics jersey over a fake would be worth it.

Top answer
1 of 12
30
I collect jerseys. I've got all different kinds. I think the hate against Fanatics replica jersey is greatly overblown. Is it on-ice quality? No... And it never claims to be. It's priced appropriately and, for what it's worth, is more comfortable than the authentic. If you're not a hobbyist who collects these things and you're just looking for something to wear to games or on the couch or looking for an entry into the hobby, the fanatics jersey is a completely reasonable option. Plus, if you spill a beer or drop food on it, you're not out $400. I would not recommend one of the fakes from China. They're not worth the money which is saying something because they're usually like $40. That said, lots of people buy them. Most of the jerseys I see at games are fakes and honestly, the NHL and Fanatics/Adidas/Reebok are to blame for that by pricing their fans out of the market. TL;DR: Fanatics $100 jersey is fine. Wouldn't recommend a fake. Follow your heart.
2 of 12
9
I remember your post from a couple weeks ago. I still strongly suggest that you not buy a fake. You may save a few dollars, but the quality is very poor. I can almost guarantee that if you buy something off DHgate, it will not look like the photo in the listing. You will not get something that looks good. Proportions, colors, and even the shape of the logo crest may be way off. That said, $100 Canadian is a more than fair price for a fanatics jersey. They’re more like long sleeve shirts than jerseys, but they’re still better than fakes. I have quite a few jerseys, including one fanatics which was gifted to me. I wear it when I’m watching games at home because I don’t mind it I get dog hair on it.