Not to be rude, but this review kind of sucks. The Staub is a thicker pot and has a dark-colored interior. This thickness will take longer to heat up but retain heat better. The color will also contribute to additional heat retention. The review attributes Le Creuset's liquid retention to its lid, when in reality, it was actually just cooking at a lower temperature. When comparing these two products, you need to let the reader know what each product does best. However, this is probably impossible for this reviewer because they don't know how to test them properly. Answer from thelastsonofmars on reddit.com
The Kitchn
thekitchn.com › pros-and-cons-le-creuset-versus-staub-dutch-oven-253845
Le Creuset Vs Staub Vs Lodge Dutch Ovens (My Honest Review) | The Kitchn
October 28, 2023 - Staub Dutch ovens can be a little heavier than Le Creuset and the handles are not as roomy. ... Produced by an independent company based in the U.S. Independent reviews consider Lodge Dutch ovens to be about as durable as ones from Le Creuset ...
Reddit
reddit.com › r/castiron › dutch oven buying advice: lodge vs le creuset vs staub
r/castiron on Reddit: Dutch oven buying advice: Lodge vs Le Creuset vs Staub
October 14, 2019 -
I'm finally about to buy my first dutch oven. For those of you who have these brands' dutch ovens, is there really a difference that justifies the difference in price or Le Creuset costs more just because is more famous?
Top answer 1 of 5
7
Staub is my favorite, but they are all good. The only thing I hate about lodge is the rounded bottom that cuts into browning area. Lodge is by far the best value for your money if that matters to you, and they have great warranty service as well from what I’ve seen. I initially thought the Dutch oven my mom has been using for the past 10-15 years was a Le creuset, but it’s actually a lodge. Part of the Le creuset pricing is due to a large marketing budget and tighter quality control.
2 of 5
5
Americas test kitchen: https://youtu.be/KDfNwXXESiU
Videos
20:47
PODCAST Episode 107: Le Creuset, Staub, Lodge cast iron, Breville ...
04:19
Amazon Basics vs Lodge vs Staub vs Le Creuset Dutch Ovens - YouTube
Best Dutch Oven? I Tested the Top 9 Brands #lecreuset #staub #lodge #lodgecastiron #madein #tramontina #caraway #misen #greatjones | TikTok
19:16
The Le Creuset vs. Staub Debate is Officially OVER - YouTube
Eater
eater.com › shopping guides
Le Creuset vs. Staub vs. Lodge: Which Dutch Oven Should You Get? | Eater
May 14, 2025 - If you’re going camping, consider something like Lodge’s Cast Iron Camp Dutch Oven, specifically designed for that purpose. While still not cheap-cheap, the Staub 5.5-quart cocotte is a bit cheaper than the Le Creuset in some colors.
The Skillful Cook
theskillfulcook.com › home › cookware guides › le creuset vs staub vs lodge dutch ovens: tests with photos ([year])
Staub vs Le Creuset vs Lodge Dutch Ovens [Tests with Photos]
November 26, 2024 - Le Creuset is made of thinner iron than Staub, so it is a bit more responsive to temperature changes. Check Today's Price Full Review ... Company & env. impct9/10 ... Lightweight compared to other Dutch ovens of the same size.
Bon Appétit
bonappetit.com › shopping › shopping › staub vs. le creuset, which is better?
Staub Vs Le Creuset: Which Is Better? | Bon Appétit
August 8, 2025 - I’ve seen their durability up close in my own head-to-head tests over the years and in continual use of both Le Creuset and Staub in the Bon Appétit test kitchen. Many of the more affordable Dutch ovens—particularly the true budget models from Lodge Essentials and Amazon Basics— tend ...
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
Best Dutch Oven? I Tested Le Creuset, Staub, Lodge & More
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/cookware › we tested le creuset against staub to find the best dutch oven. le creuset won, but honestly, you can't go wrong with either. what's your favorite?
r/cookware on Reddit: We tested Le Creuset against Staub to find the best Dutch oven. Le Creuset won, but honestly, you can't go wrong with either. What's your favorite?
October 1, 2024 - My Lodge has a huge radius, so much less flat cooking surface area than the Le Creuset of similar size. This can also give better contact with your heating element · Light colored enamel (vs dark enamel on the Staub): Easier to see and monitor ...
Prudent Reviews
prudentreviews.com › home › cookware › staub vs. lodge: which dutch ovens are better?
Staub vs. Lodge Dutch Ovens (14 Key Differences) - Prudent Reviews
December 16, 2024 - Clearly, Lodge offers twice the colors that Staub has, but Staub provides a mix of glossy and matte shades in solid and gradient styles. Lodge Dutch ovens feature a smooth, light-colored interior, much like Le Creuset (another popular Dutch ...
Reddit
reddit.com › r/cooking › which one: staub or le creuset?
r/Cooking on Reddit: Which one: Staub or Le Creuset?
November 2, 2022 -
My husband is gifting me a good dutch oven for Christmas and I am torn between the Staubs and Le Creusets. I am looking at the traditional 6-7 qt. oven. I like to braise, so having the bigger one is nice. They're both similar in cost (Staub is a bit less), but a local store has a lovely Teal Le Creuset 7 qt. for $399 (they are typically $460).
Edit: I have a Lodge already. Have had it for years (10+). The enamel is scratched on the interior (we don't use metal utensils on it). It's my go-to for making bread and frying, but I want something nicer.
Edit 2: I think I'm going to go with a Staub!
Top answer 1 of 62
96
Flip a coin. They're both tops. Nobody Apparently everybody who is replying to me has both, so the people who have Le Creuset are going to tell you to get Le Creuset. The people who have Staub will recommend Staub. We have Le Creuset. Love it.
2 of 62
77
The Staub lid has these little nubbins that makes it self-basting. That might appeal if you like braising. It also has a dark interior that doesn't show stains like the LC. The downside of this is that browning a roux is more challenging without the sharp color contrast.
Food & Wine
foodandwine.com › staub-vs-le-creuset-comparison-8705472
Staub vs. Le Creuset: Which Is Better? Tested & Reviewed
September 5, 2024 - We’ve tested several Le Creuset and Staub pieces head to head. Here is our comparison of the most popular products from both brands, including which brand makes the best Dutch oven, skillet, and casserole dish.
NYTimes
nytimes.com › kitchen › cookware › the best dutch oven
The 2 Best Dutch Ovens of 2026 | Reviews by Wirecutter
March 5, 2025 - The Lodge hit the sweet spot for evaporation, creating a thick and flavorful stew. The more expensive Le Creuset yielded a similarly concentrated stew (losing 14 percent of its weight), so even though it has a few nicer features, such as a lighter ...
Prudent Reviews
prudentreviews.com › home › cookware › best dutch oven? i tested le creuset, lodge, staub, caraway, & made in
Best Dutch Oven? I Tested Le Creuset, Lodge, Staub, Caraway, & Made In
December 2, 2024 - I love Le Creuset’s color options, lightweight design, and large handles. Staub’s flat self-basting lid is fantastic. And I really like Made In’s large knob, big handles, and wide cooking surface. If you’re looking for the best value, I recommend the Lodge Essential Enamel Dutch oven.
Dutchovenscookware
dutchovenscookware.com › staub-vs-le-creuset-vs-lodge
STAUB vs LE CREUSET vs LODGE | Dutch Ovens & Cookware
August 19, 2021 - The Lodge Dutch oven was the biggest surprise, especially when you consider the price. At almost six times cheaper than the French Dutch ovens, you are not getting six times less cooking performance…in fact, you’re barely getting any loss in performance. Yes, the searing performance was a little away from the Staub but it wasn’t a million miles away from the Le Creuset.
Cooking Pot n Pans
cookingpotsnpans.com › home › dutch ovens comparison: staub vs le creuset vs lodge
Dutch Ovens Comparison: Staub vs Le Creuset vs Lodge
June 13, 2020 - Both the Lodge and Le Creuset have large handles and you can fit your fingers through them for a good grip. But Le Creuset has roomier handles because the loop is larger. With oven mitts, the Le Creuset might be easier to manage when taking ...
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
Does Staub Outperform Le Creuset? My Tests Reveal the Truth - YouTube
In this video, I give you a side-by-side comparison of Le Creuset vs. Staub. You’ll learn how their Dutch ovens differ in design, performance, weight, and mo...
Published June 13, 2023
KRTV
krtv.com › le-creuset-vs-staub-vs-lodge-how-to-pick-the-right-dutch-oven-for-you
Le Creuset vs Staub vs Lodge: How to Pick the Right Dutch Oven For You
January 18, 2023 - In addition, the surface can become pitted or scratched by metal tools or high heat, so proper care and precautions are necessary to preserve the cookware. Staub Dutch ovens are renowned for their superior quality and craftsmanship.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/buyitforlife › bifl dutch oven: lodge or staub?
r/BuyItForLife on Reddit: BIFL Dutch oven: Lodge or Staub?
January 20, 2025 -
We want a BIFL Dutch oven. Will the Staub Cocotte 7qt oval ($449) really give me any better performance than the Lodge 7qt oval ($100)? I’m leaning towards the Staub because I prefer the black interior, people trust the brand, and the sapphire color is gorgeous. But the price tag is astronomical compared to the Lodge of the same size. Anyone have the Lodge and been perfectly happy? Is the responsible thing to be frugal and purchase the Lodge because it performs just as well or to “buy once, cry once” and get the Staub?
Top answer 1 of 132
631
I have both. I’ve had my lodge for ~5 years and the Staub for around 3. Because the lodge has a lighter coating, it stains and I’ve noticed some chipping in the enamel. With the Staub I haven’t had any chipping. It does stain a bit on the outside but I think that will happen with any Dutch oven. Honestly though, the main thing that makes Staub win for me is the dimpled lid. It’s great at redistributing liquid when it catches steam.
2 of 132
327
I've heard the new Lodge is pretty good (Made in USA version). Should last a good few years, if not BIFL. Maybe get the Lodge to see if you even need a cast iron dutch oven in your life and if it wears out, upgrade next time? FWIW, I went Le Creuset and I love it. I use it several times per week.
Facebook
facebook.com › groups › sonomafoodies › posts › 1628100884459392
Staub or Le Creuset: Which Dutch Oven to Choose?
We cannot provide a description for this page right now
Curated Cook
curatedcook.com › home › staub vs le creuset dutch oven
Staub vs Le Creuset Dutch Oven and Lodge - Who is the Best?
July 4, 2020 - However, in the larger scheme of things, those are relatively small issues. What Staub does do better is its stunning color. Compared to Le Creuset, Staub is more attractive and grown up.
ChefKnivesToGo Forums
chefknivestogoforum.com › chefknivestogo old forum site
Cast iron Dutch ovens. To Staub or to Le Crueset? - Page 3 - ChefKnivesToGo Old Forum Site
It seems, at least in France, as if Le Creuset is the grandmother classic (nothing wrong with that and I will admit to being a grandmother) while Staub is the slightly "edgier" newcomer.