Videos
Many Youtubers and experts are saying that a market Crash is about to come. They said "We are in a bubble that is itself in a bubble" and this crash will be larger than 2008. What are your views on this.
Seeing a lot of fear-mongering about the "impending market crash" on Twitter/LinkedIn. I decided to fact-check the claims and figure out what this means specifically for Indian investors.
TL;DR:
- Shiller PE is at 40.42 (elevated, but not a timing tool)
- Yield curve inverted for 2+ years (longest ever, but no recession yet)
- Magnificent 7 = 35% of S&P 500 (dangerous concentration)
- AI bubble has circular financing red flags (Nvidia → OpenAI → Nvidia)
- Buffett holding 28% cash (highest ever)
- Action: Reduce US exposure from 20% to 10%, increase gold/debt/cash
Not panic-selling. Just rebalancing based on elevated risk.
---
THE CLAIMS VS REALITY
Claim 1: "Shiller PE above 32 means crash is guaranteed!"
What's TRUE: Current CAPE is 40.42, which is 47.2% above 20-year average. This is expensive.
What's FALSE: It doesn't "guarantee" a crash or give you a timing signal. Markets stayed elevated for years in the 1990s.
What it actually means: Valuations are stretched. Future returns likely to be lower than past decade. Risk of correction has increased, but timing is unpredictable.
Think of it like a fuel gauge on empty—you know you're running low, but not the exact second you'll stop.
---
Claim 2: "Yield curve inversion means recession in 18 months!"
What's TRUE: US 2yr-10yr curve inverted Oct 2022 to Dec 2024 (longest inversion in modern history). Inversions have preceded every recession in past 50 years.
What's FALSE: The "18 months from Dec 2024 = crash" claim is speculation, not fact.
What happened: 24 months after Oct 2022 = No recession (yet). US economy grew 2.5% in 2024. Some economists think AI boom/fiscal stimulus extended the cycle.
The honest answer: Nobody knows exact timing. This is why risk management > market timing.
---
Claim 3: "Magnificent 7 = 47% of S&P 500!"
What's TRUE: There's dangerous market concentration.
What's FALSE: The "47%" number. Actual market cap weight = 35% (still very high).
Where the confusion comes from: The Mag 7 drove ~75% of S&P gains from Oct 2022 to Nov 2024. People confused "share of gains" with "share of market cap."
Why it matters: If these 7 stocks fall 20%, entire S&P could drop 15% even if other 493 stay flat. Similar to 1999-2000 when Nasdaq crashed 78%.
---
THE AI BUBBLE NOBODY'S TALKING ABOUT
This is the part that actually worries me.
The Nvidia-OpenAI circular financing scheme:
Nvidia invests $100B in OpenAI (along with Microsoft)
OpenAI uses that $100B to buy Nvidia GPUs (contractual requirement)
Nvidia reports "$20B in AI revenue growth!"
Wall Street celebrates, stock soars 200%
Reality check: Nvidia funded its own revenue
This is a closed-loop system. Not sustainable.
The math:
- $400B+ annual AI capex spending by tech giants
- $20B actual AI revenue generated (OpenAI's reported figure)
- 20:1 spending-to-revenue ratio
- OpenAI plans $1.4 trillion data center spending over 8 years
Where will this money come from? When investors realize AI companies can't generate enough revenue to justify valuations, that's when it breaks.
---
WHAT WARREN BUFFETT IS DOING
Berkshire Hathaway's cash: $325 billion (28% of portfolio) — highest allocation EVER.
What this tells us:
- He can't find attractively priced investments
- He's preparing for post-crash opportunities
- He's de-risking (sold Apple, Bank of America)
- He's NOT market-timing—just being cautious
---
HOW THIS AFFECTS INDIAN INVESTORS
"But I don't own US stocks!"
You probably do, indirectly:
US-focused mutual funds: Kotak Nasdaq 100, Motilal Oswal S&P 500, PPFAS Flexicap
Indian funds with US holdings: PPFAS has 30% US allocation, Parag Parikh owns Amazon/Google/Meta
Company ESOPs: Amazon India, Microsoft India employees = US parent stock
Nifty 50 contagion: In March 2020, S&P fell 34%, Nifty fell 38%. Correlation = 0.85.
Compare valuations:
- S&P 500 CAPE: 40.4 (+136% above historical average)
- Nifty 50 PE: 23.5 (+13.5% above average)
India is expensive but LESS overvalued. If US crashes 30%, India likely drops 15-25% due to FII outflows.
---
MY ACTION PLAN (NOT FINANCIAL ADVICE)
I'm not panic-selling. I'm rebalancing based on elevated risk.
Portfolio shift (over next 2-3 months):
Before:
- Indian Equity: 60%
- US Stocks/MFs: 20%
- Gold: 10%
- Debt: 10%
After:
- Indian Equity: 50% (reduce but don't exit—India growth story intact)
- US Stocks/MFs: 10% (cut by half—highest crash risk)
- Gold: 15% (crisis hedge, negative correlation)
- Debt/FDs: 20% (dry powder for buying dips)
- Cash: 5% (opportunity fund)
SIP changes (₹20k/month example):
Before:
- ₹12k → Indian large-cap
- ₹5k → US Nasdaq 100
- ₹3k → Mid-cap
After:
- ₹10k → Indian large-cap
- ₹2k → US fund (cut 60%)
- ₹3k → Gold ETF/SGBs
- ₹3k → Debt fund
- ₹2k → Cash (buy dip fund)
NOT stopping SIPs. Redirecting them.
---
"WHAT IF YOU'RE WRONG?"
Fair question.
If crash happens (30-40% drop):
- I followed this: Portfolio drops 15-20% (manageable)
- I ignored this: Portfolio drops 30-40% (devastating)
- Winner: Me, by a mile
If markets rally another 20%:
- I followed this: I gain 12-15% (decent)
- I ignored this: I gain 20% (better)
- Winner: I lost 5-8% upside (annoying but not catastrophic)
Asymmetric risk-reward: If I'm wrong, I miss 5-8% upside. If I'm right, I avoid 30-40% downside.
That's a 4:1 risk-reward ratio. Worth taking.
---
SOURCES (ALL FACT-CHECKED):
- Shiller PE data: Yale University (Robert Shiller's official dataset)
- Magnificent 7 market cap: Multiple sources confirm 35%, not 47%
- Yield curve: Fed data, inverted Oct 2022 - Dec 2024
- Buffett cash: Berkshire Q3 2024 filing
- AI bubble: Reuters, Bloomberg coverage of Nvidia-OpenAI deals
---
DISCLAIMER:
This is educational analysis, not financial advice. I'm not a SEBI-registered advisor. Market timing is impossible—these are risk indicators, not crystal balls.
Do your own research. Consult a professional before making portfolio changes.
---
Questions I'm expecting:
1. "Should I sell all US stocks?" → No. Reduce from 20% to 10% gradually.
2. "Is Nifty also at risk?" → Yes, but less overvalued. Will drop 15-25% if US crashes 30%.
3. "Stop SIPs?" → Never. Redirect them to safer allocations.
4. "How much gold?" → 10-15% of portfolio. It's insurance, not investment.
5. "When to go aggressive again?" → When CAPE falls below 25, market breadth improves, Fed cuts rates.
Happy to discuss in comments. What's your defensive strategy?
---
[Full analysis with all calculations + tools: https://www.toolsforindia.com/blog/3-warning-signs-market-crash-indian-investors.html]