🌐
Default
preferredmutual.com › contact
Contact Us 800.333.7642 | Preferred Mutual
Contact Preferred Mutual today with questions or inquiries. Call us at 800-333-7642. Preferred Mutual provides home, auto and business insurance in NY, MA, NJ and NH.
Home
Preferred Mutual offers home insurance, auto insurance and business insurance. Learn how to get a free quote at Preferredmutual.com.
Terms Of Use
Preferred Mutual’s customer privacy policy educates our customers on how we use data we collect and how it is protected.
NYS Domestic Violence
Confidentiality Protocols for Victims of Domestic Violence and Endangered Individuals.
🌐
Default
preferredmutual.com
Home, Auto and Business Insurance | Preferred Mutual Insurance Company
Preferred Mutual offers home insurance, auto insurance and business insurance. Learn how to get a free quote at Preferredmutual.com.
🌐
Squeri
squeri.com › insurance-company › preferred-mutual-insurance-company
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company - Insurance Company
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company · Year Founded: 1896 · Home Office: New Berlin, NY · General Phone Number: (800) 333-7642 · Claims: Go to Website (Claims Page) Claim Phone Number: (800) 333-7642 · Payments: Go to Website (Bill Pay) Billing ...
🌐
Default
preferredmutual.com › info › faqs
FAQs | Preferred Mutual
Answers to questions about insurance and your policy with Preferred Mutual. Other insurance-related FAQs.
🌐
Default
preferredmutual.com › claims › report-a-claim
Report a Claim | Preferred Mutual
Preferred Mutual Insurance is ready to help you when you need it most. Report and track your claim online through our insured portal.
🌐
Better Business Bureau
bbb.org › us › ny › new-berlin › profile › insurance-companies › preferred-mutual-insurance-company-0041-73000340
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company | BBB Business Profile | Better Business Bureau
NYS Department of Financial Services Phone Number: (212) 709-3500 http://www.dfs.ny.gov · Business Categories · Insurance Companies, Insurance Services Office, Homeowners Insurance, Auto Insurance, Renters Insurance, Marine Insurance · "0/5 Stars.
🌐
Insurox
insurox.com › about-insurox › partners › preferred-mutual-insurance
Get free insurance quotes from Preferred Mutual Insurance in minutes | Insurox®
... By phone: You can file a claim 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Just call the claims hotline 800-333-7642 to get things started. And, if you need help immediately, they can arrange for roadside assistance.
🌐
Capital Region Chamber
members.capitalregionchamber.com › home › members area
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company Members Area - Capital Region Chamber
January 30, 2020 - Preferred Mutual Insurance Company provides home, auto and business insurance to individuals and business owners, through a network of over 500 independent agents throughout New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire. Headquartered in New Berlin, New York, we are proud to help the p...
Call   800-333-7642
Address   1 Preferred Way, 13411, New Berlin
🌐
G&N Insurance
insurewithgn.com › preferred-mutual-insurance-company
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company - G&N Insurance
July 1, 2024 - Preferred Mutual Insurance Company P.O. Box 419669 Boston, MA 02241-9669 · Note: Please include your policy number on the check.
Address   153 Cordaville Rd #310, 01772, Southborough
🌐
Yelp
yelp.com › financial services › insurance › home & rental insurance
PREFERRED MUTUAL INS - Updated June 2025 - 1 Preferred Way, New Berlin, New York - Home & Rental Insurance - Phone Number - Yelp
1 Preferred Way · New Berlin, NY 13411 · Get directions · Car Insurance Companies · Insurance · Independent Insurance Agent · Insurance Broker · Phone number · (607) 847-6161 · Get Directions · 1 Preferred Way New Berlin, NY 13411 ...
Find elsewhere
🌐
Default
preferredmutual.com › payments › quick-pay
Quick Pay | Preferred Mutual
Making life easier with quick payment options. Find out more about how Preferred Mutual makes payment easy.
🌐
Yelp
yelp.com › financial services › insurance
PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE - Updated August 2025 - 160 Fairview Ave, Hudson, New York - Insurance - Phone Number - Yelp
Phone number · (518) 828-4327 · Get Directions · 160 Fairview Ave Ste 123, Valley Ln Hudson, NY 12534 · Suggest an edit · Get access to customer & competitor insights.
🌐
LinkedIn
linkedin.com › company › preferred-mutual
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company | LinkedIn
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company | 6,068 followers on LinkedIn. PMIC provides property & casualty insurance coverage through a network of independent agents throughout NY, NJ, MA & NH. | Preferred Mutual, a property and casualty insurance provider, helping more than 235,000 customers and over 500 independent agent partners Live Assured every day through superior products and unsurpassed customer service.
🌐
Default
preferredmutual.com › payments › payment-options
Payment Options | Preferred Mutual
When it comes to paying your bill, it’s all about convenience, ease and choice. Choose the plan that’s right for you!