Kaya DOES NOT have her own movie.

Felicity Merriman DOES have her own movie, and her best friend, Elizabeth Cole is a side character: Felicity: An American Girl Adventure, which is a live action.

Caroline Abbott DOES NOT have her own movie.

Josefina Montoya DOES NOT have her own movie.

Marie-Grace Gardner and Cecile Rey DO NOT have their own movie.

Kirsten Larson DOES NOT have her own movie.

Addy Walker DOES NOT have her own movie.

Samantha Parkington DOES have her own movie, and her best friend, Nellie O'Malley, who becomes her adopted sister, is a side character: Samantha: An American Girl Holiday, which is a live action.

Rebecca Rubin DOES NOT have her own movie.

Claudie Wells DOES NOT have her own movie.

Kit Kittredge DOES have her own movie, and her best friend, Ruthie Smithens, is a side character: Kit Kittredge: An American Girl, which is a live action.

Nanea Mitchell DOES NOT have her own movie.

Molly McIntire DOES have her own movie, and her English friend, Emily Bennett, is a side character: An American Girl on the Home Front, which is a live action.

Maryellen Larkin DOES have 2 of her own movies: Maryellen & The Brightest Star (YouTube Short Movie) and An American Girl Story- Maryellen 1955: Extraordinary Christmas (Amazon Special), which are both live action.

Melody Ellison DOES have her own movie: An American Girl Story- Melody 1963: Love Has to Win, which is a live action.

Julie Albright DOES have 2 of her own movies : And the Tiara Goes To...(A Julie Albright Movie) (YouTube Short Movie), when her best friend, Ivy Ling, is just a side character, and An American Girl Story- Ivy and Julie 1976- A Happy Balance, which has both Ivy and Julie as the main characters, which are both live action.

Courtney Moore DOES have her own movie, Meet Courtney: An American Girl, which is a stop motion.

Isabel and Nicki Hoffman DO NOT have their own movie, but they do have their own cartoon YouTube series from the American Girl channel: Isabel and Nicki's Super Duper Twin Adventures.

Which American Girl historical movie was your fave, and which historical doll who doesn't have their own movie should've had their own movie?

Hey Everyone,

I just got into a little kerfuffle in the comments of TikTok about Addy and wanted to know what y’all think. Before I start, yes AG should absolutely diversify the historical line more but I think that what they did with Addy is a great way to introduce young children to what happened with slavery and the struggles that even freed slaves & African Americans faced. I think if they didn’t have a doll representing this part of history it would be a huge disservice. Anyway here was the conversation, which was made on a satire video about doll brands having a lack of diversity.

Original Comment: “American Girl doll Abby was pretty much like this lol I used to read the catalog and damn near everything was slave themed” My Comment: “Everything was slave themed? No. She and her Mom escape slavery in the first book and the rest of her story is their journey/struggle in freedom” OC’s Reply: “The fact that you even typed that trying to disprove my statement is baffling, yiu can't be that dense”

So like am I incorrect? I had Addy growing up and she has always been one of my favorites and one of the reasons I’m really into that era of history so maybe I’m biased.

I LOVED the historical doll movies as a kid my absolute favourite being Samantha’s movie, still watch it every now and then. It has got me thinking, I wonder why Kristen or Addy didn’t get a movie. A movie about Kaya would’ve been really interesting as well. Do you think this is something American girl potentially missed the mark on not continuing to make these movies?

I know Melody kinda got a movie but it didn’t feel the same as the older ones. I learnt a lot from these movies, like the orphan train, dresses made out of chicken food bags, victory gardens just to name a few, I’ve even gone on to research more about the history as an adult. It’s a shame we didn’t get more movies like those ones.