I just finished building my new 13700K build and was originally going to go for a dark rock 4 but luckily saw that my motherboard (Asus Strix Z690-F) would not have enough clearance, so instead I opted for a Be Quiet Silent Loop 2 360mm and am very happy with it so far, the aesthetics are a massive bonus for me and I think a big tower cooler just can't match that, might be a personal thing though. From a performance standpoint it shouldn't matter much especially for gaming, I think a 240mm AIO would have been totally adequate as well if you don't have some long-duration, all-core workloads lined up, so far my silent loop 2 has been keeping temps very low during most games I've tried. The dark rock 4 will always have an edge on durability but be quiet do include refill liquid in their AIOs and claim refilling it every 2 years will prolong the lifespan of it, will need to see whether that's true for myself. Ultimately it comes down to aesthetics and whether you'll accept the slight extra risk of failure an AIO brings, but seeing as you previously had one I'm guessing that isn't a problem. Answer from Kartchampion on reddit.com
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/buildapc › be quiet dark rock 4 pro 250w vs aio
r/buildapc on Reddit: Be Quiet Dark Rock 4 Pro 250W vs AIO
November 13, 2022 -

Easy question, building a new rig with a core i7 13700k at the core and debating between a Be Quiet Dark Rock 4 Pro 250W or any AIO?

I previously been using an H100i for the last few years on the a 6700k and debating on switch back to air or getting a new AIO.

Thanks!

Top answer
1 of 3
4
I just finished building my new 13700K build and was originally going to go for a dark rock 4 but luckily saw that my motherboard (Asus Strix Z690-F) would not have enough clearance, so instead I opted for a Be Quiet Silent Loop 2 360mm and am very happy with it so far, the aesthetics are a massive bonus for me and I think a big tower cooler just can't match that, might be a personal thing though. From a performance standpoint it shouldn't matter much especially for gaming, I think a 240mm AIO would have been totally adequate as well if you don't have some long-duration, all-core workloads lined up, so far my silent loop 2 has been keeping temps very low during most games I've tried. The dark rock 4 will always have an edge on durability but be quiet do include refill liquid in their AIOs and claim refilling it every 2 years will prolong the lifespan of it, will need to see whether that's true for myself. Ultimately it comes down to aesthetics and whether you'll accept the slight extra risk of failure an AIO brings, but seeing as you previously had one I'm guessing that isn't a problem.
2 of 3
2
Linus Tech Tips tried this. Actually, if you compare Corsair AiOs with Noctua air coolers - Noctua always wins. More silent, better Temps, better reliability, better price. According to them, if you don't go with Noctua, you probably will have a hard time finding an air cooler capable of reaching "usual" AiOs. But: AiOs have different advantages. They do not bend the board, offer a cleaner look, have a higher temperature absorbing mass with a higher energy density and will definitely level out spikes in temperatures. Also, there are AiOs, that are way better than the default AiOs, everybody knows about. For me, I took weeks to look after every and each comparison of what not AiO cooling hot heads. And went with an Alphacool Eisbaer Pro Aurora 420. Alphacool usually produces open loop parts and the pump and reservoir is actually an open loop component and absolutely silent, refillable and has a joint to connect additional radiators without spilling (much) water. It also comes with a full copper radiator, very rarely seen on the market. Fully pared with an 7950x and Thermal Grizzly Liquid metal thermal paste, you see and feel the difference. 50°C idle, always below 80°C under usual loads. Still, benching will make it go up to thermal throttling (95°C) as it would with an open loop as well. Problem here is the massive IHS of the Ryzen 7000 series. Also, I used a CPU guard to protect the CPU components from liquid metal.
🌐
TechteamGB
techteamgb.co.uk › home › 2023 › july › 21 › air cooler vs aio liquid cooler - 240mm aio vs dark rock pro 4
Air Cooler vs AIO Liquid Cooler – 240mm AIO vs Dark Rock Pro 4 | TechteamGB
July 24, 2023 - The air cooler I’ve gone with here is the bequiet Dark Rock Pro 4 – an all black dual tower heatsink with two included fans (and mounting hardware for a third) – which should be a great fit for the Ryzen 7900X I’ll be using to test against. It’s worth quickly looking at the AIO – this is an asetek design with a pretty massive and hefty pump unit.
🌐
PCPartPicker
pcpartpicker.com › forums › topic › 301742-dark-rock-4-vs-aio-help
Dark Rock 4 vs AIO - Help? - PCPartPicker
EVGA CLC 280 (Toms Hardware 280mm AIO winner/recommendation) - Both use the same Asetek pump and seem to benchmark the sameish so to me it's a difference of RGB options, fans, and support.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/amd › would upgrading from a dark rock pro 4 to a corsair h100i be worth it?
r/Amd on Reddit: Would upgrading from a Dark Rock Pro 4 to a Corsair H100i be worth it?
February 25, 2019 -

Hey AMD,

Looking to see if anyone here has made the switch from air cooling to an AIO. I built my 2700x computer about 4 months ago and I'm pretty happy with it. Overclocked to 4.2 at 1.35v and it's paired with a Dark Rock Pro 4. In games my temps are around 35-40, rendering in Sony Vegas up to 45-50. With rendering the fans can get a little noisy.

What I want to know is if upgrading to a H100i could bring the rendering temps down just a little or would it be a waste of money with little to no difference in temperatures/fan noise?

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/buildapc › air cooling dark rock pro 4 vs aio for 3900x?
r/buildapc on Reddit: Air cooling dark rock pro 4 vs AIO for 3900x?
August 31, 2019 - But at some point, you can only get so large with an air cooler, so you pretty much have to go large radiator AIO's. But those tend to be pretty pricey. ... Dark Rock Pro 4 for ease of mind and lower temps.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/buildapc › be quiet! bw007 280mm aio vs dark rock pro 4
r/buildapc on Reddit: be quiet! bw007 280mm AIO vs Dark Rock Pro 4
April 5, 2021 -

Just bought a new 11600k and heard reports of it running hot. I had already bought the Dark Rock Pro 4 and was wondering if the AIO would have been a better choice. Should I return the DRP4 or get the 280mm AIO?

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/buildapc › spare kraken x73 aio vs the dark rock pro 4
r/buildapc on Reddit: Spare Kraken x73 AIO vs the Dark Rock Pro 4
October 18, 2021 -

So i have a spare x73 that I'm thinking of returning. In my PC I currently have a 9900k cpu with a Dark Rock Pro 4.

My question is will I get lower temps that it warrants the upgrade? Right now the cpu is running quite hot when I oc it and it's under load.

EDIT: SORRY! I have a Fractal Design Torrent case

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/buildapc › shadow rock 2 vs dark rock pro 4 vs aio?
r/buildapc on Reddit: Shadow Rock 2 vs Dark Rock Pro 4 vs AIO?
December 18, 2018 -

I need some advice.

I'm planning to buy a new CPU cooler for my Ryzen 7 2700x.

So the question is: air cooler or AIO?

Then the next question would be: Shadow Rock 2 or Dark Rock Pro 4

I know that only one fan comes with the Shadow Rock 2, but i have one spare pure wings 2 anyway.

So that would be double fan with the Shadow Rock 2 and with the Dark Rock Pro 4.

Which cooler is better?

Additionally there is a big price difference.

The Dark Rock Pro 4 costs 72,85€

the Shadow Rock 2 cost only 37,75€

https://www.bequiet.com/de/cpucooler/1378

https://www.bequiet.com/de/cpucooler/446

Find elsewhere
🌐
TechSpot
techspot.com › products › cooling › be-quiet-dark-rock-pro-4-cpu-cooler.181981
Be Quiet! Dark Rock Pro 4 CPU Cooler Pros and Cons | TechSpot
February 19, 2024 - The Dark Rock Pro 4 is a powerful cooler, easily able to match performance to match many AIO 240mm liquid coolers. The core benefit is obviously fewer points of potential failure, and more piece of mind during prolonged operation.
🌐
Steam Community
steamcommunity.com › discussions › forum › 11 › 1736588252404406299
Corsair h100i v2 vs Dark Rock Pro 4 :: Hardware and Operating Systems
Originally posted by Rumpelcrutchskin:Dark Rock Pro 4 is better, also it would be more quiet and you dont have the pump noise. It has literally every conceivable advantage. Cooling performance, noise, reliability, price, build quality, brand ...
🌐
Linus Tech Tips
linustechtips.com › computer hardware › cooling
Dark Rock Pro 4 VS 360mm AIO - Cooling - Linus Tech Tips
May 24, 2019 - So the question is pretty simple, Which is better, the Dark Rock Pro 4, vs Corsair H150i PRO? The Dark Rock Pro 4 is over 3x cheaper, so if it offers comparable performance i will consider that over the aio. I am building into the Corsair 500D.
🌐
Tom's Hardware Forum
forums.tomshardware.com › home › cpus
[SOLVED] - Air cooler or AIO? EVGA CLC 280 vs Dark pro 4 | Tom's Hardware Forum
December 17, 2018 - ... What kind of RAM and case are you getting. The Dark Rock Pro 4 does introduce some clearance issues, so if you plan on getting a slim case that can't accommodate at 165mm cooler, or plan on getting RAM with tall heatspreaders then the AIO might be a better choice.
🌐
Tom's Hardware Forum
forums.tomshardware.com › home › cooling
[SOLVED] - Dark Rock Pro 4 or H150i PRO RGB for 3900x? | Tom's Hardware Forum
April 4, 2020 - IMO, there's really not much in favor of AIOs other than aesthetics, case clearance, and getting models below 360mm. What is your case? The Dark Rock Pro 4 does allow you to raise the fan so it sits on top of your ram, but you need extra case clearance to accommodate.
🌐
PCPartPicker
pcpartpicker.com › forums › topic › 315752-air-cooling-vs-water-cooling
Air cooling vs Water Cooling - PCPartPicker
I would look at price and how effective a cooler is and what you like the looks of. If you are really sensitive to PC noise but want to OC then get a Dark Rock Pro 4 or a NH-D15 or if you are really worried about reliability then air coolers with more than 1 fan has more redundancy for reliability.
🌐
PCPartPicker
pcpartpicker.com › forums › topic › 394811-dark-rock-pro-4-vs-watercooling
Dark Rock Pro 4 vs Watercooling - PCPartPicker
If you're looking to manually push clock frequencies with raised voltages those small performance gains can be marginally helpful. IMO, AIOs are more of an aesthetics choice or for the extreme overclocker a little added touch of temp-comfy'ness (although I haven't tried a 420mm unit yet...
🌐
Linus Tech Tips
linustechtips.com › the workbench › new builds and planning
Ryzen 7 3700x - Dark Rock Pro 4 or 240mm AIO? - New Builds and Planning - Linus Tech Tips
November 22, 2021 - Budget (including currency): £80 - £100 Country: UK Games, programs or workloads that it will be used for: Heavy gaming and video editing. Other details Looking for suggestions for cooling my 3700x. I currently have a Be Quiet! Dark Rock Pro 4 which idles around the low/mid 30s and mid 70s under ...
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/pcbaumeister › wakü vs dark rock pro 4
r/PCBaumeister on Reddit: WaKü VS Dark Rock Pro 4
January 21, 2023 -

Gestern kamen alle meine Komponenten an, also machte ich mich dran die Maschine zusammenzubauen. Gehäuse: Be Quiet Pure Base 500DX Mainboard: Asus Prime Z690-P CPU: i-5 13600KF (ja ohne integ. Grafikkarte, hab eh meine 3060 ti) Kühler: Arctic Liquid Freezer II 280

Im Prozess stellte sich aber heraus dass die Wakü zu groß (Radiatorhöhe 37mm) ist um am Deckel reinzupassen. Eine Frontmontage scheint mir aber suboptimal. Also heißts wieder zum E-Waren-Shop zu gehen und sich eine Alternative zu besorgen. Auf meiner Recherche stieß ich aber auf den Dark Rock Pro 4 und bin jetzt verunsichert. Das Teil hat enorm gute Bewertungen und ist um 40-60€ günstiger (und lagernd) als die alternative Wakü. Ich hab jetzt nicht besonders viele Resourcen um mir die teuerste und beste Wakü zu leisten, wär aber bereit mehr auszugeben, wenn es auf Dauer und insgesamt die besser Lösung ist.

Ich stehe in der Zwickmühle zwischen folgenden Wakü als Alternative:

  • Silent Loop 2 280 (146€)

  • MSI MAG Core Liquid 280R (130€)

  • Fractal Design Lumen S28 RG (134€)

Oder eben Dark Rock Pro 4 (87€) - günstiger und scheint gleich gut zu sein.

Bin offen für weitere Vorschläge und Meinungen!

🌐
Linus Tech Tips
linustechtips.com › computer hardware › air cooling
Dark Rock 4 Pro thoughts vs my "Old" AIO - Air Cooling - Linus Tech Tips
April 11, 2018 - Holy jesus marinara balls Air coolers are a bitch to install compared to AIOs now i understand why people say you should install it outside of the chassi. So i got my DR4P today and installed it as a sinlge fan orientation with Thermal Grizzlys Kydropnaut paste. Its damn near silent plus them van...
🌐
Enos Tech
enostech.com › home › reviews › air coolers vs aio coolers 240mm – which one really is better?
Air Coolers vs AIO Coolers 240mm - Which is best?
August 7, 2023 - No surprise there as the top 4 ... warranty period where all other coolers are 240mm AIOs. The bequiet! Dark Rock Pro 4 is in the 3 years warranty....