I'll just provide my two cents regarding quality: I absolutely agree that AE jeans are quite durable and hold up well. HOWEVER, if you're looking for something a step up, I'd recommend Madewell jeans. I have both AE and Madewell, and I find Madewell to just be nicer all around. They hold up better throughout the day (don't get too loose or baggy), they hold you in better and provide better shaping, and just generally look nicer on than AE. I think AE are great, but I typically use those as jeans where I don't care too much if I spill something, if I'm going somewhere I have to sit on the ground, etc. I prefer my Madewell jeans for everyday wear. I agree that it's always best if you can try on in-person first. I also am particular about how my clothes feel, and I'd say both are great. Just in terms of quality, Madewell are a step up from AE. FWIW, I've owned far more expensive jeans (Joes, Citizens, Hudson...) and I really think Madewell jeans are equivalent quality. Answer from blairworejeansonce on reddit.com
Discussions

American Eagle Jeans?
Hi! Please ensure your post is related to petite fashion and advice and follows our sub rules . Questions and outfit posts seeking specific petite-related advice, discussions, in-depth guides/articles, constructive reviews, tips, and sales/deals are allowed. Outfit posts and/or questions seeking general advice must be posted in our Daily General Questions threads. Outfit sharing posts must be posted in our biweekly OOTD threads. I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/PetiteFashionAdvice
31
30
January 8, 2023
affordable petite jeans that AREN'T american eagle?
Hi! Please ensure your post is related to petite fashion and advice and follows our sub rules . Questions and outfit posts seeking specific petite-related advice, discussions, in-depth guides/articles, constructive reviews, tips, and sales/deals are allowed. Outfit posts and/or questions seeking general advice must be posted in our Daily General Questions threads. Outfit sharing posts must be posted in our biweekly OOTD threads. I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/PetiteFashionAdvice
89
59
July 10, 2024
American eagle was my tried and true for years for my short legs. What jeans will work best for my body?
Hi! Please ensure your post is related to petite fashion and advice and follows our sub rules . Posts about general fashion advice must be posted in our General Questions threads. Outfit sharing posts must be posted in our OOTD threads. I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/PetiteFashionAdvice
33
45
October 3, 2025
Maybe this obvious but American Eagle sells jeans in size ...
Skip to main content More on reddit.com
🌐 r/PetiteFashionAdvice
August 21, 2021
🌐
Pumps & Push Ups
pumpsandpushups.com › home › ae jeans review: petite-friendly styles
AE Jeans Review: Petite-Friendly Styles - Pumps & Push Ups
September 12, 2024 - Petite-friendly jeans from AE via Pumps and Push-Ups Blog. Under $60 petite friendly jeans. Fall outfits with jeans.
🌐
Extra Petite
extrapetite.com › home › american eagle
american eagle - Extra Petite
Aerie sweater xxs (3 colors), Rag & Bone jeans sz 24 (25% off w/ FRIENDS) Sole Society heels 5.5 c/o, DIY leopard clutch (buy similar),…
Find elsewhere
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/petitefashionadvice › american eagle jeans?
r/PetiteFashionAdvice on Reddit: American Eagle Jeans?
January 8, 2023 -

First, I'm so grateful to have found this sub, at times like this I'm in awe of Reddit.

So, I've given up on jeans several times, because I believed that they simply aren't for me. I'm 4'10, 117ish and most of that is in my butt and thighs (you should seriously see my thighs) with a small waist and sensitive skin. But I've seen that AE jeans are recommended pretty consistently here. I've never shopped at AE, so not sure about their quality. Specifically, the prices give me pause-$60 is much less than I expect to pay for jeans- as I've gotten older and less broke I've found that it's often worth it to invest a bit for quality's sake. So how is the quality? And how do they feel? How would you describe the denim? Ya or nay for someone whose skin is particular?

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/petitefashionadvice › affordable petite jeans that aren't american eagle?
r/PetiteFashionAdvice on Reddit: affordable petite jeans that AREN'T american eagle?
July 10, 2024 -

i have always been loyal to american eagle for jeans. i'm probably one of their most devoted customers. however, i've gained weight and their sizing has all of a sudden begun running extremely small. i got my normal size in a new pair of AE jeans the other day and literally broke the button off while trying to close it because it was so tight. the quality and sizing are so awful all of a sudden.

after YEARS of loyalty, i need to find another brand of jeans that offer petite/"short" sizing, preferably in a similar price range as AE jeans.

i prefer super high-waisted, deep pockets, and stretchy waistbands. my favorite style of jeans are mom jeans but those seem to be going out of style so i'll settle for straight jeans now. if anyone knows good, affordable brands with these qualities please let me know!!

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/petitefashionadvice › american eagle was my tried and true for years for my short legs. what jeans will work best for my body?
r/PetiteFashionAdvice on Reddit: American eagle was my tried and true for years for my short legs. What jeans will work best for my body?
October 3, 2025 -

Help! Recently got some great advice on this sub about styling jeans (TY). I know I’ll need all of these in a short length, but always try on in store to check out the styles. Really struggling to find jeans that look nice and can be worn with a flat shoe/slip on sneaker. I’ve spent my whole life looking kind of “stumpy” in jeans bc I’m 5’1 and carry most of my weight/muscle in my bottom half. Jeans end up too baggy at the knees, so hemming isn’t always an option and then big in the waist, even if they fit my thighs.

Second to last pair is Abercrombie and I think fits the best. I’m open to all styles and grabbed all different ones today— some aren’t pictured bc they were laughable. How can I be a size 0, 2, and 4 all in the same store?! Last pic is jeans I grabbed at a boutique and LOVE, but the style requires a pretty high heel, which doesn’t work for every day. What are you guys with a similar height/build wearing to avoid that frumpy look?! Ty for any input!! 🩷

🌐
Coveteur
coveteur.com › 2017 › 08 › 15 › american-eagle-best-petite-denim-editor-review
An Editor Reviews American Eagle’s Petite Denim Offerings - Coveteur
October 1, 2025 - Every woman needs the perfect pair of black jeans, but honestly, I’m totally over the skin-tightness of skinnies. Enter this straight-leg option, which gives off the same sleek look without the risk of cutting off circulation. Styled with a black top, I was told this look is “very New York.” Sold! ... Say you’re looking to hop on a major trend, but aren’t willing to spend a ton because you’re still not exactly sure if it’s “you.” American Eagle is the answer.
🌐
Americaneagle
americaneagle.com.au › en-au › american-eagle › women › jeans
Women's Jeans: Baggy, Flare, Mom, Bootcut & More | American Eagle Australia
Slim JeansSkinny JeansStraight-Leg JeansLoose & Baggy JeansAthletic Fit JeansRipped & Distressed JeansAirFlex+ JeansBlack Jeans
🌐
Walmart
walmart.com › clothing
American Eagle Jeans Women
Shop for American Eagle Jeans Women at Walmart.com. Save money. Live better