I actually doubt the extinction were as total or global, on no less than three fronts. First up is palynology shows global disruption to food webs at the K/Pg, though it was not equally severe everywhere. Floras of the Antarctic Kingdom bounced back soon enough. Second is the matter needs 'slices of time' recorded in the sedimentary rocks, that must be suitably fossil yielding, from at least the late Masstrichtian to early Danian - Hell Creek is very informative for this reason, but cannot represent a global picture. Third is the size filter selecting K/Pg survival, really ought to have let through a number of Campanian-Maastrichtian coelurosaurs. The smaller alvarezsaurs were apt to survive, as were petite long tailed pennaraptorans such as Hesperonychus and Rahonavis. Not a lot is known of Palaeocene birds still. It's still possible that toothed Ichthyornis type forms, and even enantiornitheans survived. It's obvious the latter included more than only avisaurids, in the latest Cretaceous. No one same would deny dinosaurs were victims of the K/Pg but the way people think about that, involves a fair few assumptions that can't be justified simply by repetition. Answer from ProfessionalTiger594 on reddit.com
Reddit
reddit.com › r/paleontology › when did the dinosaurs go extinct... exactly?
r/Paleontology on Reddit: When did the dinosaurs go extinct... exactly?
January 4, 2024 -
Some questions I've been tinking about.
How quickly did every last dinosaur go extinct? Were there many species of dinosaur that held on multi generationally, if so for how long? Is there, or would there ever be evidence of dinosaurs more recent than 66 mya? Was there any part of earth that was kinda okay-ish for any amount of time after the impact?
Dinosaur nerds, help me here please.
Edit: yes I know about the origin of birds thank you, I shouldn't have clarify 'non-avian' dinosaurs because we all know.
Thank you all for your responses, I got quite a lot. It was more of a discussion than anything, and a question as to what we do currently know and what we could possibly know.
Thanks everybody
Top answer 1 of 26
93
There are no dinosaur fossils found above the K-T line. Unless....you count birds and most people these days do. There is no way to know how many 'generations' it took for them to completely go extinct as dating techniques have a large enough fudge factor, that you are probably looking at hundreds within that fudge. They can narrow this down by using multiple techniques, but you'd still be looking at several hundred thousand years of variance.
2 of 26
34
We can give estimates to the million years mark, but as of now we don’t have the technology to go as specific as generations. Birds are still around so a branch of Dinosaurs do still live on.
Britannica
britannica.com › science › earth science, geologic time & fossils › dinosaurs
Dinosaur - Extinction Causes, Evidence, & Theory | Britannica
4 days ago - Mass extinctions often come to ... biodiversity. Just as new species constantly split from existing ones, existing species are constantly becoming extinct....
When did the dinosaurs go extinct... exactly?
I actually doubt the extinction were as total or global, on no less than three fronts. First up is palynology shows global disruption to food webs at the K/Pg, though it was not equally severe everywhere. Floras of the Antarctic Kingdom bounced back soon enough. Second is the matter needs 'slices of time' recorded in the sedimentary rocks, that must be suitably fossil yielding, from at least the late Masstrichtian to early Danian - Hell Creek is very informative for this reason, but cannot represent a global picture. Third is the size filter selecting K/Pg survival, really ought to have let through a number of Campanian-Maastrichtian coelurosaurs. The smaller alvarezsaurs were apt to survive, as were petite long tailed pennaraptorans such as Hesperonychus and Rahonavis. Not a lot is known of Palaeocene birds still. It's still possible that toothed Ichthyornis type forms, and even enantiornitheans survived. It's obvious the latter included more than only avisaurids, in the latest Cretaceous. No one same would deny dinosaurs were victims of the K/Pg but the way people think about that, involves a fair few assumptions that can't be justified simply by repetition. More on reddit.com
If 70% of life died from the last extinction ~66 million years ago, why were dinosaurs hit the hardest?
Dinosaurs weren’t necessarily hit hardest (though larger creatures definitely were hit hard). Even among mammals it was brutal. Whole groups were wiped out (North American metatherians, for example). Pterosaurs were wiped out. Only half of the crocodyliforms made it. Belemnoids and ammonoids got wiped out. Mosasaurs and plesiosaurs were gone. People focus on the dinosaurs, but pretty much anything big got hammered, as did most of the specialists. The dinosaurs that made it (a small fraction of the birds) were small generalists able to eat seeds and bugs. That’s how extinctions go. Niches get emptied and then refilled. More on reddit.com
How Do We Know What Dinosaurs Went Extinct in What Era?
The simple answer is the rocks they are found in. The earth is in layers, the deeper you go the more layers there are, and within these layers are smaller layers. If you pay attention to them and study them you can start to be able to piece Earth's history together, and with tools like carbon dating, we can guesstimate when and where they would've died off. Some are more obvious than others, but in the end I hope I was able to answer your question mate More on reddit.com
How long did it take dinosaurs to go fully extinct?
It looks like the dinosaurs were in decline for several million years before the impact event at Chixulub. As best we can tell the extinction of the large therapod and sauropod dinosaurs happened instantaneously, geologically speaking. That might mean days, months or even decades or more in reality; rock preservation in most places does not work at human timescale resolutions. Ir could be as long as centuries or millennia. I would personally put my money on decade to century scale; with only pockets surviving the first year, and perhaps some isolated pockets lasting over 1000 years (similar to mammoth post ice age). Edit: turns out my dinosaur knowledge was a few years out of date. Strike out the first sentence. Edit2: Following the OP edit, u/stringoflights adds the following and asked me to add it here for reference: Birds didn’t just evolve from dinosaurs, they are dinosaurs, and dinosaurs did not go extinct. We have more dinosaur species alive today than mammal species. It’s fine to pose a question about non-avian dinosaurs, but the fact that birds are dinosaurs is important when we are studying patterns of extinction. The bird “evolving back” from extinction that is mentioned in the edit is an example of iterative evolution. It is absolutely not a reason to ignore an entire radiation of dinosaurs, and it’s pretty important that that misconception is corrected. Iterative evolution means that the same or similar structures arose from the same source population at different times. It doesn’t mean the wholesale evolution of the same species twice. In the case of the Aldabra rail, which is what the edit mentions, the white-throated rail has colonized the island from nearby and evolved flightlessness more than once. More on reddit.com
Videos
00:58
How Did Dinosaurs Actually Go Extinct? - YouTube
09:55
How Long Did The Dinosaurs Actually Survive After The Asteroid? ...
26:04
The Extinction of the Dinosaurs - Everything You Need to Know - ...
54:05
What if The Dinosaurs Didn't Go Extinct - YouTube
03:55
What Exactly Killed The Dinosaurs? | Earth | BBC Earth Science ...
17:33
How dinosaurs went extinct | Dave Hone and Lex Fridman - YouTube
I actually doubt the extinction were as total or global, on no less than three fronts. First up is palynology shows global disruption to food webs at the K/Pg, though it was not equally severe everywhere. Floras of the Antarctic Kingdom bounced back soon enough. Second is the matter needs 'slices of time' recorded in the sedimentary rocks, that must be suitably fossil yielding, from at least the late Masstrichtian to early Danian - Hell Creek is very informative for this reason, but cannot represent a global picture. Third is the size filter selecting K/Pg survival, really ought to have let through a number of Campanian-Maastrichtian coelurosaurs. The smaller alvarezsaurs were apt to survive, as were petite long tailed pennaraptorans such as Hesperonychus and Rahonavis. Not a lot is known of Palaeocene birds still. It's still possible that toothed Ichthyornis type forms, and even enantiornitheans survived. It's obvious the latter included more than only avisaurids, in the latest Cretaceous. No one same would deny dinosaurs were victims of the K/Pg but the way people think about that, involves a fair few assumptions that can't be justified simply by repetition. Answer from ProfessionalTiger594 on reddit.com
American Museum of Natural History
amnh.org › exhibitions › dinosaurs-ancient-fossils › extinction › dinosaurs-survive
Birds = Dinosaurs, and Other Survivors of K-T Extinction | AMNH
An early relative of all primates, including humans, survived the extinction. Snakes: Although a number of snake species died out around 65 million years ago, snakes as a group survived. Turtles: Of the known species of turtles alive at the time of the dinosaurs, more than 80 percent survived. An avian dinosaur—an ancient flying bird—lived about 85 million years ago in what is now Kansas. Birds are living dinosaurs that survived the mass extinction event 65 million years ago.
Nature
nature.com › nature communications › articles › article
Dinosaur biodiversity declined well before the asteroid impact, influenced by ecological and environmental pressures | Nature Communications
June 29, 2021 - Here we propose an explanation for variations and decline of dinosaur diversity through time, which not only relies on both abiotic (temperature) and biotic (herbivorous dinosaur diversity) factors, but also on intrinsic species age effect on extinction. However, our study comes with issues either related to the dataset or the analytical approaches. First, it is important to recall that our results hold for six species-rich families of the Cretaceous that are well represented in the fossil record. This does not represent a complete picture of the global diversification dynamics for all dinosaurs, but this study is a step forward in our understanding of the causes of dinosaur extinction.
Riverlegacy
nature-notes.riverlegacy.org › dinosaurs-did-not-all-go-extinct-theyre-still-around-and-theyre-everywhere
Dinosaurs Did Not All Go Extinct. They’re Still Around and They’re Everywhere! – Nature Notes
November 29, 2021 - Dinosaurs especially thrived during the Jurassic (201 million years ago to about 145 million years ago) and Cretaceous (145 million years ago to about 65 million years ago) periods of this era until they all went extinct at the end of the Cretaceous, about 65 millions years ago, very likely ...
BBC
bbc.com › future › article › 20220812-dinosaur-extinction-why-did-mammals-survive
How mammals won the dinosaurs' world
August 15, 2022 - "You come out on the other side, and all of a sudden the T. rexes are gone and the long-necked dinosaurs are gone, and the world is open." This mass extinction set the stage for a great profusion of diversification that eventually brought about blue whales, cheetahs, dormice, platypus and, of course, us.
Facebook
facebook.com › AnswersInGenesis › posts › despite-what-many-people-think-dinosaurs-didnt-die-out-millions-of-years-ago › 1289997809825439
Despite what many people think, dinosaurs didn't die out ...
We cannot provide a description for this page right now
Discover Wildlife
discoverwildlife.com › animal-facts › reptiles › facts-about-fifth-mass-extinction
Dinosaur mass extinction: what caused it, which dinosaurs went extinct, and how mammals survived - Discover Wildlife
September 15, 2023 - Mass extinctions aren't random, they're selective, and there are clues that help explain why some species were survivors while others were victims. One contributing factor is characteristics associated with feeding and diet. For example, after the fifth extinction, natural selection was biased against large bony fishes with fast-closing jaws. An ability to use available food sources could also be the reason why some birds survived when all other dinosaurs died out: the ancestors of modern birds ('neornithines') had solid beaks instead of tiny teeth, which probably enabled them to break-open seeds.
Natural History Museum
nhm.ac.uk › discover › dinosaur-extinction.html
What killed the dinosaurs? | Natural History Museum
The fossil record shows that for the first 175 million years of their existence, dinosaurs took on a huge variety of forms as the environment changed and new species evolved that were suited to these new conditions. Dinosaurs that failed to adapt went extinct.
National Geographic
nationalgeographic.com › home › science › why did the dinosaurs go extinct?
Dinosaur extinction facts and information | National Geographic | National Geographic
But so far, not a single trace of dinosaur remains has been found in rocks younger than about 66 million years. At that point, as the Cretaceous period yielded to the Paleogene, it seems that all nonavian dinosaurs suddenly ceased to exist.
Published May 4, 2021
UCMP
ucmp.berkeley.edu › diapsids › extinctheory.html
What Killed The Dinosaurs?
Two main camps exist in paleontology today, each having a different view of what killed the dinosaurs and other organisms at the K-T boundary. Controversy has surrounded the topic since 1980; it has become difficult for the public (and the scientific world at large) to understand the issue ...
U.S. National Park Service
nps.gov › subjects › fossils › extinction-events.htm
Extinction Events - Fossils and Paleontology (U.S. National Park Service)
February 28, 2025 - This includes not only the groups that are classically seen as dinosaurs, but also many early birds, including all those that had teeth or prominent hand claws. Pterosaurs also went extinct. Smaller land vertebrates, and those that could shelter in burrows or the water, were not as strongly affected.