I wrote about this exact thing in a review of the AfterShokz headphones on my blog. But here's the general idea...
The wording of the AfterShokz marketing material is very clever (from this page). They say:
Scientific studies have found that extended use of regular headphones and earbuds promote hearing loss and damage to the eardrum. Since AfterShokz headphones do not use the eardrums to transmit sound, they provide consumers with a quality stereophonic listening experience while reducing the risk of eardrum damage.
So their wording claims that earbuds promote hearing loss AND damage to the eardrum. The second thing they say is that AfterShokz reduces the risk of eardrum damage. Nowhere do they claim that it reduces the risk of hearing damage!
This web page by the National Institues of Health, has this to say about noise-induced hearing loss:
However, when we are exposed to harmful noise—sounds that are too loud or loud sounds that last a long time—sensitive structures in our inner ear can be damaged, causing noise-induced hearing loss (NIHL). These sensitive structures, called hair cells, are small sensory cells that convert sound energy into electrical signals that travel to the brain. Once damaged, our hair cells cannot grow back.
And this:
Exposure to harmful sounds causes damage to the hair cells as well as the auditory, or hearing, nerve.
Nowhere on that page does it say anything about eardrums or any connection between eardrum damage and hearing loss.
The conclusions that I take from this are:
- I ASSUME that damage to the eardrum is mostly from the "stick it in your ear canal" type of earbuds. From physical contact and not from high volume levels from the earbuds. I have absolutely nothing backing this up, except that it fits the rest of what I'm saying.
- IF #1 is correct then the AfterShokz marketing material is 100% correct (but misleading).
- The NIH says that hearing loss is caused from nerve damage or damage to the hair cells in your ear. Since both of these are still used by the AfterShokz headphones (otherwise you wouldn't hear anything), it is unlikely that these headphones will prevent hearing loss due to high volume levels.
- Turning down the volume is still the best way to prevent hearing loss.
So I have a late model Shokz and can tell you from experience: this "technology" is just hype and bullshit. It's just a speaker placed next to your ear, that's all. At best, what's left to be conducted through your skin and bones is just residual bass, maybe less than 5%. Plugged my ears with proper earplugs and played music in the Shokz. Nearly NOTHING is left, and I assure most of it is just normal sound still leaking through the earplugs, and appropriately muffed.
I don't know how no one ever tested or debunked this thing yet. I was first made aware of this possibility when I visited a Best Buy and tried on these eyeglasses (mind me, from Bose!) with tiny speakers attached. So, they don't purport to be "bone conduction" phones. They sound pretty much the same as my Shokz, it's the same experience.
Coming to think of it, how could it possibly work in the first place? Good sound is a lot more complex than just shockwaves.
My 2 cents.
Edit: I'm not saying the end result is unsatisfactory. I'm just saying it's not conducting any significant amount of sound through the puported means (bone conduction) and that's their entire claim to fame. Bone conduction. It's the deceitful nature of the purported technology itself that bothers me. Other than that, these headphones are good for the intended result - leave your ears free to outside noise.
Edit 2. Still not convinced? I have my Shokz on me now. If I slightly remove its contact with the skin, it should go silent, right? Well, it doesn't. Now try that with the screwdriver thing and see if you can hear anything.
Edit 3. Hey, look: all these "bone conduction" headphones have clear sound openings conveniently directed to you ear canals!
What are the best bone conduction headphones?
physiology - Are bone conduction headphones safer with regards to hearing loss? - Skeptics Stack Exchange
Bone-conduction headphones
How good is bone conduction? - General IEM Discussion - The HEADPHONE Community
Does Bone Conduction Headphones Damage Hearing?
Can I use bone conduction headphones with tinnitus?
Tinnitus typically is a product of the brain in response to hearing loss. Bone conduction headphones won’t cure your tinnitus, but they’re safe to use.
Can I use bone conduction headphones with hearing aids?
This depends on the design of your hearing aid. If you have in-the-ear (ITE) or invisible (IIC) hearing aids, you should be able to use bone conduction headphones with hearing aids without issue. However, if you have behind-the-ear (BTE), receiver-in-canal (RIC), or open-fit hearing aids, you could experience some discomfort when wearing bone conduction headphones because they may make contact with the top part of the hearing aid module.
Videos
I wrote about this exact thing in a review of the AfterShokz headphones on my blog. But here's the general idea...
The wording of the AfterShokz marketing material is very clever (from this page). They say:
Scientific studies have found that extended use of regular headphones and earbuds promote hearing loss and damage to the eardrum. Since AfterShokz headphones do not use the eardrums to transmit sound, they provide consumers with a quality stereophonic listening experience while reducing the risk of eardrum damage.
So their wording claims that earbuds promote hearing loss AND damage to the eardrum. The second thing they say is that AfterShokz reduces the risk of eardrum damage. Nowhere do they claim that it reduces the risk of hearing damage!
This web page by the National Institues of Health, has this to say about noise-induced hearing loss:
However, when we are exposed to harmful noise—sounds that are too loud or loud sounds that last a long time—sensitive structures in our inner ear can be damaged, causing noise-induced hearing loss (NIHL). These sensitive structures, called hair cells, are small sensory cells that convert sound energy into electrical signals that travel to the brain. Once damaged, our hair cells cannot grow back.
And this:
Exposure to harmful sounds causes damage to the hair cells as well as the auditory, or hearing, nerve.
Nowhere on that page does it say anything about eardrums or any connection between eardrum damage and hearing loss.
The conclusions that I take from this are:
- I ASSUME that damage to the eardrum is mostly from the "stick it in your ear canal" type of earbuds. From physical contact and not from high volume levels from the earbuds. I have absolutely nothing backing this up, except that it fits the rest of what I'm saying.
- IF #1 is correct then the AfterShokz marketing material is 100% correct (but misleading).
- The NIH says that hearing loss is caused from nerve damage or damage to the hair cells in your ear. Since both of these are still used by the AfterShokz headphones (otherwise you wouldn't hear anything), it is unlikely that these headphones will prevent hearing loss due to high volume levels.
- Turning down the volume is still the best way to prevent hearing loss.
From a letter to the editors of Hearing Journal:
The description of the Aftershokz bone-conduction earphones included the statement, “Because the headphones do not use the eardrums to transmit sound, they allow users to listen to music without risk of eardrum damage.” MP3 player earphones are not capable of producing levels great enough to cause an eardrum perforation, so users would not be at risk of eardrum damage from any type of earphone. Rather, listeners are at risk of cochlear damage from overuse of any type of earphone. The fact that these earphones use bone-conduction transducers does not inherently make them any safer than any other earphone, as bone-conducted sound is transduced by the cochlea similarly to air-conducted sound.
Hearing Journal: June 2012 - Volume 65 - Issue 6 - p 4 doi: 10.1097/01.HJ.0000415192.03538.d6 Departments: Letters to the Editor
"Letters: The Truth about Bone-Conduction Earphones" Portnuff, Cory AuD, PhD; Berger, Elliott MS