ELI5: What is the argumentative difference between a "Bandwagon Fallacy," and "scientific consensus."
Can someone help me find an example of bandwagon fallacy in fairly recent news or headlines from somewhere?
Help finding real life examples of logical fallacies?
Is this bandwagon fallacy?
I see what you mean. The fallacy lies in the assumption that people are naturally good. The closest I can think of is false premise fallacy, since you say they're basing their argument on this belief.
More on reddit.comWhat is the bandwagon fallacy?
How does the bandwagon fallacy work?
What is the difference between ad populum fallacy and appeal to authority fallacy?
Videos
To be clear, I'm aware there is a difference, I'm just curious how the difference would be stated or determined in something like a debate style argument.
Take the following three statements:
"A large majority of people are doing it, therefore it must be right."
"A large majority of people are doing it, therefore the odds of them being wrong are small."
"A large majority of scientists agree that statement X is valid based on the interpretations of the data collected in research, therefore we should plan ahead assuming that X is correct."
In my opinion #1 is clearly fallacious, but #2 is a little more vague since we are talking more about odds of it being correct, rather than directly stating it is correct due to the majority holding that opinion. #3 though, is generally how scientific knowledge is developed and acted upon, however it still seems someone could argue that it's using the Bandwagon fallacy.