Consumer Reports
consumerreports.org › appliances › heating, cooling & air › fireplaces › fireplace insert ratings
Fireplace Ratings & Reviews - Consumer Reports
No one tests fireplaces like we do. Get ratings, pricing, and performance for all the latest models based on the features you care about.
Consumer Reports
consumerreports.org › appliances › heating, cooling & air › fireplaces
Best Fireplace Reviews – Consumer Reports
View our ratings and reviews to find the best fireplaces.
Videos
18:54
Top 5 Modern Gas Fireplaces ( Which Linear Gas fireplace is the best?!
08:05
What’s the best gas fireplace for the money? (The biggest secret ...
05:33
TOP 5: Best Gas Fireplace Inserts 2025 - YouTube
18:31
These Are The BEST TRADITIONAL GAS FIREPLACES You Can Buy For Your ...
09:05
Best Gas Fireplace Inserts 2025 - (Watch Before You Purchase) - ...
09:12
Best Bang for Your Buck Gas Insert Fireplace? | Heat & Glo SupremeX ...
How does the Xtrodinair fireplaces rate?
We are not a Fireplace Xtrordinair dealer, so we cannot provide much information on those models. We apologize for the inconvenience.
efireplacestore.com
efireplacestore.com › top-rated-fireplaces.html
Best Gas Fireplace & Top Rated Wood Fireplace Manufacturers (2025)
Hello! I am looking for a natural gas fireplace insert for my house. I am in need of recommendations. I would like to build a mantel around it. I would also like to use it as a supplement heat source for my house. My house is only 800 square feet. I am lo
If you are looking to keep costs down and want maximum efficiency, I recommend considering a ventless natural gas fireplace as these would not require any additional vent components to be ordered and installed. Additionally, purchasing a direct vent fireplace would require sizing up in order to heat the space required to account for lower efficiency. If you do not mind having a manually-lit standing pilot system that would only turn the burner flame Off and On with one of the control options I'd mentioned, this would be a millivolt aka standing pilot system and would be the more affordable opt
efireplacestore.com
efireplacestore.com › top-rated-fireplaces.html
Best Gas Fireplace & Top Rated Wood Fireplace Manufacturers (2025)
Consumer Reports
consumerreports.org › appliances › fireplaces › recommended › c201055
Fireplace Ratings & Reliability - Consumer Reports
The latest performance Ratings & Reliability of all fireplaces
Flame Authority
flameauthority.com › flame authority › knowledge base › best gas fireplace brands: top-rated fireplaces for your home this 2025
Best Gas Fireplace Brands: Top-Rated Fireplaces for Your Home this 2025
June 18, 2025 - From direct vent and vent free fireplaces to gas inserts and high-efficiency fireboxes, explore top-rated options from Napoleon, Monessen, Empire, and more. Whether you're updating an existing fireplace or adding a new focal ...
Renovation Reserve
renovationreserve.com › renovation reserve › reviews › best gas fireplace manufacturers: features & styles compared
Best Gas Fireplace Manufacturers: Features & Styles Compared – Renovation Reserve
February 17, 2024 - Regency Fireplace Products also deserves a mention. With a strong focus on both design and efficiency, Regency offers a broad selection of gas fireplaces that are built to last. Their commitment to sustainability and energy efficiency makes ...
Thegreatfirecompany
thegreatfirecompany.com › blogs › learning-center › best-gas-fireplace-insert
Best Gas Fireplace Inserts | Top-Rated Gas Fireplace Inserts 2025 – The Great Fire Company
August 22, 2025 - The Great Fire Company carries the top models from the most trusted brands in the industry, at the lowest prices online, guaranteed. With world-class customer service every step of the way, what more could you ask for? Here’s a quick look at the best-rated gas fireplace inserts:
The Spruce
thespruce.com › best-gas-fireplace-inserts-4169551
The 5 Best Gas Fireplace Inserts of 2025
August 18, 2025 - Gas fireplace inserts provide more efficient heat than burning wood, so we researched both ventless and direct-vent models for heat output, aesthetics, safety features, and more to find the best options.
eFireplaceStore
efireplacestore.com › top-rated-fireplaces.html
Best Gas Fireplace & Top Rated Wood Fireplace Manufacturers (2025)
December 21, 2018 - You'll find our highest rated models for every category including electric fireplaces, wood burning fireplaces, gas fireplaces and even ethanol fireplaces.
Flame Authority
flameauthority.com › flame authority › knowledge base › best gas fireplaces: expert choices for cozy living spaces this 2024
Best Gas Fireplaces: Expert Choices for Cozy Living Spaces this 2024 – Flame Authority
May 28, 2025 - Upgrade your home's ambiance and warmth with our exquisite selection of gas fireplaces! From efficient Direct Vent models to versatile Ventless options, we've curated the best to suit your needs. Worried about making the right choice? Don't be! Our comprehensive reviews and expert guidance ...
Consumer Reports
consumerreports.org › cro › news › 2009 › 01 › don-t-let-energy-savings-go-up-and-out-the-chimney › index.htm
Don't let energy savings go up and out the chimney
Another energy-saving option is a direct-vent, sealed-combustion natural-gas fireplace. We've found that these units have an annual fuel-utilization efficiency (AFUE) of about 70 percent compared with only 25 percent for a conventional fireplace.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/fireplaces › what is the best brand of gas insert fireplaces? give me all the pros/cons
r/Fireplaces on Reddit: What is the best brand of gas insert fireplaces? Give me all the pros/cons
January 24, 2024 -
I am in no way knowledgeable and experienced in the fireplace industry. I’ve learned about all this through my previous Reddit posts and google. You all have steered me away from basic logs. We are looking to maximize efficiency and heat our entire living room.
Also decided I want the direct vent option.
Give me all your recommendations please!
Top answer 1 of 7
3
I always recommend going to the local store and getting whatever they are most comfortable with. Most of the major brands are very similar in the end. Keep an eye on the options and make sure you get the ones you like. I would skip any kind of Bluetooth and go with the remote. Definitely a blower. Make sure you get 2 full liners all the way up. I really like reflective panels in an insert, really helps the flame seem bigger and brighter. Edit, I work at a fireplace dealer and could get pretty much anything and I picked a Heat n Glo Cosmo insert for my house, no logs and I added the stone kit over the crushed glass. Edit I also assumed you really want an actual insert.
2 of 7
1
I sell regency. Gi29 (medium) is nice.
Bob Vila
bobvila.com › reviews › major systems › hvac › the best gas fireplace inserts
The Best Gas Fireplace Inserts Top Picks - Bob Vila
September 27, 2023 - Electric models are the ultimate in ease of use, but the lack of real flame means they are not to everyone’s taste. For many people, a gas fireplace insert is the perfect compromise. Efficiency ratings upward of 70 percent make for far superior heat generation and lower fuel consumption when compared with open fires.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/fireplaces › quality of enviro gas fireplace inserts?
r/Fireplaces on Reddit: Quality of Enviro gas fireplace inserts?
April 25, 2023 -
We just purchased a house with traditional wood burning fireplace and we would like to convert it into a gas insert. A local installer recommended the Enviro E series. We really know nothing about gas insert makers and it's so hard to find any reviews online. There are some reviews on Houzz which are mostly negative but Im not sure how much we can trust those reviews. The installer also suggested Majestic Ruby series.Is anyone familiar with these two brands and know about the quality? Which one would you recommend or neither? Thank you
Top answer 1 of 5
3
I have Valor, it's really perfect. Notable because it's designed to not need a fan, so it's completely silent and works fine during blackouts.
2 of 5
1
One thing to keep in mind with fireplace reviews is that more often then not the homeowners aren't complaining about the fireplace. They are complaining about the installer. As to the quality itself. I have had a few issues with Enviro inserts but nothing more then you would have with any other brand. Most of the internals are fairly generic across different brands such as the remote system and valve system. As per a comparison to the Majestic Ruby. The Ruby is more of a budget insert. The Enviro's will offer a superior finish and viewing area. I generally only recommend the Ruby when someone just wants the best bang for their buck. Personally I prefer Enviro's logs to Majestics logs but everyone likes something different.
The Stove Shop
fireplaceexperts.com › home › best gas fireplaces for custom homes & builders in 2025
Best Gas Fireplaces for Custom Homes & Builders in 2025
August 9, 2025 - The 6K and 8K Series are the modern evolution of Heat & Glo’s most popular fireplaces. Builders trust these models because they work beautifully in almost any home design. Homeowners love the ability to customize everything from the interior ...
HVAC-Talk
hvac-talk.com › home › forums › the arpa zone/open membership discussion forums › fireplaces
Best gas fireplace? | HVAC-Talk: Heating, Air & Refrigeration Discussion
Mendota is the best fireplace out there. IMO ... The Best is one thats working!! Unvented not really good for full time use /combustion gases inside and added moisture,, The amount of water produced from burning a fuel is large, with over 4.8 ...
Blazing Embers
blazingembers.com › home › fireplaces › gas fireplaces › top 5 gas fireplaces
Top 5 Gas Fireplaces for Sale | Embers Living
Explore the best gas fireplaces for your home at Embers Living. We offer direct vent & vent free gas fireplaces of top brands at the best price. Order Now!
This Old House
thisoldhouse.com › home › an easy guide to gas fireplaces
All About Gas Fireplaces: Types, Costs, and Installation - This ...
We break down the different types of gas fireplaces for your home, questions to consider, key fireplace features, and costs.
Published October 4, 2024
Testmarket
testmarket.io › trend › gas-fireplaces › the-best-9-gas-fireplaces-of-february-2025-reviewed-by-testmarket-experts › 528
The Best 9 Gas Fireplaces of February 2025 Reviewed by Testmarket Experts
When it comes to finding the best gas fireplaces in 2023, it's essential to consider factors such as energy efficiency, design, and ease of installation. Gas fireplaces have evolved significantly over the years, with manufacturers focusing on creating models that are both environmentally friendly and aesthetically pleasing.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/fireplaces › what gas insert is best?
r/Fireplaces on Reddit: What gas insert is best?
June 30, 2023 -
I am converting my wood fireplace to gas and am looking for the best natural gas insert. Reliability, efficiency, and heating are the qualities I am looking for.
The house is a two story cape cod and has about 1,000 sq ft on the first level with an open floor plan and two bedrooms. I am looking for something that will heat the first level. The house also has oil heat which is getting expensive.
I am lucky enough to have several makes to choose from. I believe the size is 30”
Heat & Glo
Enviro
Quadra-Fire
Jotul
Mendota
Pacific Energy
Regency
And I am sure even more.
What would you choose and what would you stay away from?
Top answer 1 of 10
5
Mendota and Enviro are probably the best for quality materials, user friendly controls and great support for their products. They are a bit pricey compared to Heat n Glo. Rather than looking for a brand. Maybe look for a reputable dealer in the area and ask for their opinion. But Mendota and Enviro are great options nonetheless.
2 of 10
4
As a service tech, based on that list the heat n glo is what I go back to the least. Also the same company owns heat n glo and quadrafire( and some others not on the list) .
Popular Mechanics
popularmechanics.com › home › the 7 best gas fireplaces for a cozier home
The 7 Best Gas Fireplaces of 2024
December 27, 2023 - Nothing warms up a room like a gas fireplace and stately mantle. These are your best options for a worthwhile investment.