Mattress Underground has a great buying guide. It's one of the very rare reliable sources of mattress information. Most review sites are owned by mattress brands. Answer from snorkelvretervreter on reddit.com
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › best mattress at costco?
r/Mattress on Reddit: Best mattress at Costco?
November 15, 2024 -
Been mattress shopping for a few weeks now and its brutal. One person gives a mattress 5 stars, best sleep ever, and the next person says its garbage and the worst mattress they've ever tried.
So rather than risk it with a super-expensive mattress, I'm going to go the Costco route. Looks like there are a lot of options from Leesa to Casper to Simply Modern to whatever else.
Out of all the options at costco, I'm wondering what the best choice is? Let's say $1600 or less...
I'm leaning toward the Leesa Legend Hybrid or Casper. Would loooove some help here! I'm so nervous about making the wrong call!
Top answer 1 of 29
14
Mattress Underground has a great buying guide. It's one of the very rare reliable sources of mattress information. Most review sites are owned by mattress brands.
2 of 29
13
Last year we bought a Stearns Foster from Costco...we hated it, it was way too stiff for us. Sent it back after 6 weeks and got a different one...I don't remember which one...at first it was great but within 3 months it was way too soft. Sent that one back and got Costco's tempur pedic. That was 9 months ago and we still love it. Best sleep ever. Costco's return service was perfect.... same crew each time. They picked up and dropped off same day...let me take pictures for proof of pick up. It couldn't have been easier. I'm not saying you should get the same mattress we did, I'm saying if you get one you don't like the return process is easy.
Sleepopolis
sleepopolis.com › home › 10 best mattresses of 2025: over 500 tested by sleep experts › best costco mattresses (2025): a whole lot of quality at wholesale prices
Best Costco Mattresses (2025) - Tested by Experts
1 week ago - Edge support is less than I had on my previous non-box mattress, but it hasn’t bothered me yet. “ ... The Leesa Legend is built with luxurious materials like merino wool and organic cotton at a Costco price.
Help Undecisive Newbie Pick A Costco Mattress - Mattress Comparisons - Mattress Underground
Hi, so I definitely need a new mattress and I’ve been in analysis paralysis about it. Currently I sleep on an old innerspring mattress. I’ve read so many horror stories about mattress stores denying returns that I’ve decided just to buy from Costco because of their return policy. More on forum.mattressunderground.com
1
November 29, 2024Mattresses at Costco
Novaform, I’ve had 5 kings over the years. Cannot recommend them enough. More on reddit.com
32
14
August 22, 2024Costco Mattress Recommendation? - RedFlagDeals.com Forums
Yes, Costco will take back any mattress you order from them. Based on my heavy usage I don't think memory foam is the best for myself. I think the best route is a spring mattress with minimal foam or gel, and a quality topper for comfort. At least that is the conclusion I've come to after doing ... More on forums.redflagdeals.com
What are the undisputed best mattresses at Costco? : Mattress
It looks like the $1,800 Tempur-Pedic and $1,400 Avocado are highly rated as top-tier options in this sub—can anyone confirm? I’m thinking... More on old.reddit.com
Is a Costco mattress worth it?
In some cases, yes. Costco offers a wide array of mattress choices, which is great for those that don't know what they want and are on a tight budget, and would otherwise go into a mattress store. However, it may pay to buy direct from online brands, even those sold at Costco, for additional perks and discounts.
slumbersearch.com
slumbersearch.com › costco-mattress-reviews
Costco Mattress Reviews: Guide To The Best Brands (2025)
Are Costco mattresses any good?
Costco sells a wide array of mattresses and some of the options like the Cocoon By Sealy offer a lot of value and comfort. However, some customers report issues with durability, delivery, and returns, which may be alleviated buying direct from the brand.
slumbersearch.com
slumbersearch.com › costco-mattress-reviews
Costco Mattress Reviews: Guide To The Best Brands (2025)
Is the Costco Casper mattress good?
The Costco Casper mattress is based on their original mattress design, which is no longer sold directly by Casper. Its benefit is its affordable price for the brand name. While many find it suitable, there are some complaints of off gassing, firmness, and durability in some cases.
slumbersearch.com
slumbersearch.com › costco-mattress-reviews
Costco Mattress Reviews: Guide To The Best Brands (2025)
Videos
12:16
Best Costco Mattresses: Our Top 3 Costco Bed Picks (w/Alternatives) ...
10:29
Best Costco Mattress - 17 Mattresses Objectively Tested - YouTube
17:35
Tempurpedic Supreme Review - Costco's Tempurpedic Mattress Tested ...
07:05
Novaform Mattress Review - Is It The Best Costco Mattress?
Mattress Clarity
mattressclarity.com › home › best mattress
Best Costco Mattresses (2025) - Mattress Clarity
Finally, we look at whether or not mattresses come with “freebies.” This could include anything from sleep trials and delivery perks to accessories. This will sweeten the deal and make the mattresses worth the Costco membership. The same is true for all alternatives. Most of these beds are online mattresses only, so they come with extended sleep trials and lengthy warranties. ... Our team of certified sleep science coaches selected the best beds for side sleepers by seeking out beds with high pressure relief scores and a softer firmness level.
Published 3 weeks ago
Sleep Advisor
sleepadvisor.org › home › best mattress
Best Costco Mattress (2025)
February 11, 2025 - Sleep Science 14″ Firm – Best Firm Costco Mattress (Alternative: Plank Firm) At Sleep Advisor, we test mattresses in person to help us determine how they perform and who will feel most comfortable sleeping on them.
Slumber Search
slumbersearch.com › costco-mattress-reviews
Costco Mattress Reviews: Guide To The Best Brands (2025)
It has one of the highest ratings overall, as well as some of the best ratings for a foam mattress for spinal support and durability. There was definitely a break in period for about a week, but now I'm sleeping so soundly and not waking up at all during the night (which I used to do all the time). It is medium firmness as described - very good for your back! For years we wanted a Tempurpedic so when Costco.com offered them a couple of months ago, we took the plunge.
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
Best Costco Mattresses 2025 - Which Should You Choose? - YouTube
⏬Click the links below to get the BEST prices on the Costco mattresses and alternatives!⏬✅Kirkland Lakeridge - https://sleepopolis.co/KirklandLakeridge✅Kirkl...
Published June 9, 2024
NapLab
naplab.com › home › best mattress 2025 – 380+ beds tested & reviewed by our experts › best costco mattress: we test 17 costco mattresses
Best Costco Mattress - 17 Mattresses Objectively Tested
1 week ago - The Leesa Legend is only $1,049 for a queen-sized mattress, which is 31% less expensive than the average hybrid. If you’re on a tight budget and want the best performer from Costco, this is it.
Mattress Underground
forum.mattressunderground.com › mattress talk › mattress comparisons
Help Undecisive Newbie Pick A Costco Mattress - Mattress Comparisons - Mattress Underground
November 29, 2024 - Hi, so I definitely need a new mattress and I’ve been in analysis paralysis about it. Currently I sleep on an old innerspring mattress. I’ve read so many horror stories about mattress stores denying returns that I’ve decided just to buy from Costco because of their return policy.
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
Best Costco Mattresses - Our Top 4 Costco Bed Picks(w ...
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.
Costco
costco.ca › home › mattress buying guide
Mattress Buying Guide | Costco
That's why we’ve expanded our inventory to include a wide selection of premium-brand mattresses at price points that will fit everyone's budget. To make your shopping experience even easier, you can customize your search by bed size, brand, firmness level, and delivery time frame.
Mattress Reviews
mattressreviews.ca › home › articles › costco mattress reviews (2025)
Costco Mattress Reviews (2025) - MattressReviews.ca
3 weeks ago - Of the four mattress brands we tested and reviewed that are currently available at Costco, none earned an overall rating higher than 5.1/10. If you’re looking for a quality mattress, we recommend Douglas Original instead, which earned an overall rating of 9.9/10. Douglas is our number-one ...
Reddit
reddit.com › r/costcocanada › mattresses at costco
r/CostcoCanada on Reddit: Mattresses at Costco
August 22, 2024 -
Has anybody bought a mattress from Costco? If so which one and how are you liking it? My warehouse currently has the Sealy Hollycourt Posturepedic (Item# 3061012), Novaform Comfort Grande Advance (Item# 1723203), and Casper memory foam (Item# 1271394). I'm thinking about getting a new queen mattress but don't know which one to go with.
Top answer 1 of 5
15
Novaform, I’ve had 5 kings over the years. Cannot recommend them enough.
2 of 5
9
Had a Novaform going on 10 years. It's ready to swap out at this point but has been pretty damn good overall. Funny side story - we bought it when we moved to our new place and had slept on a blow-up bed for a few nights while waiting for it to arrive. We unpacked it and were waiting overnight for it to fully expand per the instructions. I jokingly leaned over on it while my wife was unpacking some clothes... I passed out for almost 5 hours with my feet still on the floor. She still bugs me about it lol
Costco
costco.ca › home › furniture & mattresses
Firm Mattresses | Costco
$4,199.99 Sleep Science Copper Infused 35.6 cm (14 in.) Memory Foam Mattress with Q-Plus Adjustable Base
RedFlagDeals
forums.redflagdeals.com › costco-mattress-recommendation-2445091
Costco Mattress Recommendation? - RedFlagDeals.com Forums
April 28, 2021 - Based on my heavy usage I don't think memory foam is the best for myself. I think the best route is a spring mattress with minimal foam or gel, and a quality topper for comfort. At least that is the conclusion I've come to after doing some research.
Costco
costco.ca › home › furniture & mattresses › mattresses
Firm Mattress Collections | Costco
Anti-microbial mattress protection to keep the mattress fresh and clean · Cool Twist gel memory foam · Gel band support for the lower back and hips · Individually wrapped coil system with Best Edge foam encasement · Comfort level: Firm · Rated 3.6 out of 5 stars based on 38 reviews.
Costco
costco.ca › home › furniture & mattresses
Mattresses | Costco
Furniture & Mattresses · Mattresses · King · Queen · Double · Twin · Twin XL · Firm · Medium · Plush · Memory Foam · Innerspring · Hybrid · Choose the Right Mattress · Learn More · Cancel · Primary ·
Costco
costco.ca › home › 404 - product not found
Kirkland Signature by Stearns and Foster Lakeridge Queen Mattress or Set | Costco
Kirkland Signature by Stearns and Foster Lakeridge Queen Mattress or Set Luxury cushion firm euro-pillow top Comfort level: medium 36.8 cm (14.5 in.) mattress height 1744 IntelliCoil® HD for variable support Assembled in Canada, designed in Canada
NYTimes
nytimes.com › sleep › mattresses › the best mattresses for 2025
The 25 Best Mattresses of 2025 | Reviews by Wirecutter
November 25, 2025 - The Stearns & Foster Estate (Pillow Top Firm) does this with a classic-innerspring buoyant lift; the Tempur-Adapt (Medium Hybrid) offers support along with contour-curving pressure relief; and the all-latex Zenhaven offers good back support (for most people, anyway) along with supple cushioning. For more recommendations, see our guide to the best mattresses for stomach-sleepers. ... This Costco favorite is made from layers of foam that are as dense (and probably as durable) as the foam in many online mattresses that cost twice as much.
Costco
costco.com › home › mattresses › queen size mattresses
Queen Size Mattresses | Costco
A cozier option than the Cal king- ... a smart choice for an apartment, guest room or smaller bedroom. Browse Costco’s affordable selection of premium queen mattresses, and choose from luxurious memory foam, cooling latex, ultra-soft pillow top, or extra-firm suppor...
Costco
costco.ca › home › mattress pads & toppers
Mattress Pads & Toppers | Costco
Mattress Pads & Toppers · Suggestions: Check for typos and spelling errors · Try more general keywords · Try different keywords · Costco carries items in our warehouses which may not be available online. Visit your local Costco warehouse for current product inventory and to see if we stock what you are looking for.