Sadly, most mattresses these days have some type of foam in them, which means the top comfort layers will wear down noticeably around the 3-5 year mark. Only way to get around this issue is to either buy a customizable bed (like Savvy Rest, Naturepedic EOS or Spindle, as popular examples) where you can replace layers as they wear out, or buy a traditional coil bed that has no foam in it at all (like brands like Vipsprings or Savoir). The downside of the traditional coil beds is that they're never as 'plush' as beds with foam, but honestly I'd just use a topper if that's the case because at least then, when it inevitably wears down in 3-5 years like all foam soft layers do, you can replace it without buying a new bed. For a truly long-lasting bed you'd want one with coils + wool/cotton/horsehair/flax (natural materials only) and maybe some microcoils for a bit more plushness. If it has any latex or foam of any type in it, it won't be as long-lasting as you'd like it to be, sadly :( Prepare to pay an arm-and-a-leg for this type of bed, though: most beds that solidly-built with no foam in them will run you at least $4k for a Queen. Answer from SorcererLeotard on reddit.com
Mattress Nerd
mattressnerd.com › home › best mattress › best innerspring mattress
Best Innerspring Mattress (2026) | Mattress Nerd
In all models, the Signature offers excellent airflow and temperature neutrality thanks to the pocketed coil layer. Keep in mind that the Signature lacks the traditional responsive feel of an innerspring mattress, which will be a drawback or a plus, depending on your preferences.
Published 1 month ago
Mattress Firm
mattressfirm.com › shop › pocketed-coil-firm-mattresses
Pocketed Coil Firm Mattresses | Mattress Firm
These mattresses are also a thoughtful gift for college students settling into a new apartment, parents who value a restful night’s sleep, or anyone preparing a guest room for holiday visitors. The firm, responsive feel of the best innerspring mattresses with pocketed coils is particularly beneficial as the seasons shift, providing a stable foundation that adapts to heavier bedding and layered blankets without losing its supportive qualities.
Please help me choose the right pocket coil for DIY Hybrid - Arizona Premium Mattress - Mattress Underground
I’ve been sleeping on a very old ~9" innerspring mattress on a ~7" box spring for far too long and its time for a new one. My brother has a tulo Liv all foam from Mattress Firm and it is medium-firm. I consider it too firm and I don’t like how flat I lay on it so I don’t think I want ... More on forum.mattressunderground.com
0
August 11, 2022Ultimate Dreams Pocketed Coil Mattress - General Mattresses Questions - Mattress Underground
I’d like to say first that this forum is fantastic and while mattress shopping is still overwhelming I feel like I’m not going in blind anymore. I’ve been eyeing the different Ultimate Dreams latex mattresses and noticed when I looked today that there’s a new innerspring version that ... More on forum.mattressunderground.com
0
June 14, 2013The good ol’ days / quality innerspring
I totally recommend Avocado Mattresses. They have quality materials and killer springs! More on reddit.com
40
71
October 17, 2024Best mattress under 1000 - Suggestions that don't compromise on quality?
Look at Costco. Lots of good mattresses, decent prices and a fantastic return policy. Get the pillow top separately though. It wears out and it's less expensive to replace a topper than the whole mattress. Also, make sure to rotate the mattress every 6 months to make it last longer. More on reddit.com
69
14
June 3, 2025Do more pocket coils make a better mattress?
While the number of pocket coils in a mattress can affect its overall support and durability, it's not the sole factor determining the mattress's quality. Other factors, such as the gauge of the coils, the quality of materials used in the comfort layers, and the mattress's overall construction, also play crucial roles in determining how well the mattress performs.
Therefore, while more pocket coils may contribute to better support and responsiveness, it's essential to consider the mattress's overall design and construction.
amerisleep.com
amerisleep.com › blog › mattress guides › innerspring vs pocketed coil mattresses
Innerspring vs Pocketed Coil Mattresses - Amerisleep
Will coil mattresses last as long as foam mattresses?
As a general rule, coil mattresses break down faster than all-foam mattresses. While lower gauge coils and pocket coils keep their shape longer, all coils will eventually lose tension. When this happens, your mattress can develop soft spots, sagging, and warped areas. Latex and memory foam mattresses don’t have this problem. They don’t have any coils to break down. That means the mattress’s durability depends on the quality, density, and chemical makeup of the foams. As a rule of thumb: Denser foams will outlast lighter foams. Natural foams like latex will outlast synthetics like polyurethane
eachnight.com
eachnight.com › mattress-guides › pocket-coil-mattress-buying-guide
Pocket Coil Mattress Buying Guide + Top Brands List - eachnight
Are pocket coil mattresses good for you?
Pocket coil mattresses can be a good option for many people, particularly those who prefer a mattress with more bounce and support. The individual coils in pocket coil mattresses conform to the body's shape, offering customized support and relieving pressure points, which can contribute to better sleep quality. The pocketed coils also isolate motion better than traditional open springs.
However, personal preferences, such as firmness level and sleep position, should also be considered when determining if a pocket coil mattress is the right choice for you.
amerisleep.com
amerisleep.com › blog › mattress guides › innerspring vs pocketed coil mattresses
Innerspring vs Pocketed Coil Mattresses - Amerisleep
Videos
04:48
Best Innerspring Mattress 2025 | My Top 5 Picks! - YouTube
10:50
Best Innerspring Mattress | Top 7 Beds! (MUST WATCH) - YouTube
13:20
7 Best Innerspring Mattress in 2025! Sleep Better Tonight - YouTube
07:46
Best Innerspring Mattresses 2024 - Our Top 5 Picks! - YouTube
09:06
Best Innerspring Mattress - Counting Down The Top 5 Coil Beds! ...
04:17
Best Innerspring Mattress 2025 - Top Picks From Dr. Jordan Burns ...
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › does anyone have an innerspring / pocket coil / spring hybrid mattress that's actually been good for several years?
r/Mattress on Reddit: Does anyone have an innerspring / pocket coil / spring hybrid mattress that's actually been good for several years?
January 2, 2024 -
I'm trying to buy a new mattress arter my Simmons Beautyrest developed some major depressions after only about 2 years (and I only weigh 125 pounds!). I cut it open hoping I could just replace the comfort layer(s) but to my dismay, the coils themselves are mushed down in those areas. So it's time to buy another, already.
I'm looking for something spring-based. It seems that latex has the ability to be the most long lasting but I don't like the feel of latex.
So does anyone have a mattress that's been good for several years so far? Every single mattress and brand on here, even if well-reviewed elsewhere, still seems to have tons of people complaining about their mattress developed depressions or started sinking in very little time.
TLDR: I'm looking for info on which brands and even specific mattresses are LONG LASTING.
Top answer 1 of 4
5
Sadly, most mattresses these days have some type of foam in them, which means the top comfort layers will wear down noticeably around the 3-5 year mark. Only way to get around this issue is to either buy a customizable bed (like Savvy Rest, Naturepedic EOS or Spindle, as popular examples) where you can replace layers as they wear out, or buy a traditional coil bed that has no foam in it at all (like brands like Vipsprings or Savoir). The downside of the traditional coil beds is that they're never as 'plush' as beds with foam, but honestly I'd just use a topper if that's the case because at least then, when it inevitably wears down in 3-5 years like all foam soft layers do, you can replace it without buying a new bed. For a truly long-lasting bed you'd want one with coils + wool/cotton/horsehair/flax (natural materials only) and maybe some microcoils for a bit more plushness. If it has any latex or foam of any type in it, it won't be as long-lasting as you'd like it to be, sadly :( Prepare to pay an arm-and-a-leg for this type of bed, though: most beds that solidly-built with no foam in them will run you at least $4k for a Queen.
2 of 4
2
Mfrm employee here! I've got a beautyrest black hybrid I've had for several years still going strong The Alcove was my master bedroom for about 2-3 years before I gave it to my oldest because I won a free bed from work. So I got the Nadia (beautyrest all foam). My oldest still sleeps on it, and she's had it for.. 4-5 years? She weights more than you do. It's held up great.
Shop Houzz
shophouzz.com › collections › pocket-coil-mattresses
The 15 Best Pocket Coil Mattresses | Houzz
Shop online for Pocket Coil Mattresses. Browse a large selection of Mattresses in a wide range of sizes, finishes and styles.
Sleep Foundation
sleepfoundation.org › best mattress
Best Innerspring Mattresses of 2025: Coil & Spring Support
... The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid has an estimated lifespan of six to seven years. As with other hybrids, the pocketed coils provide a solid base that evenly distributes pressure to prevent excessive strain on any one area.
Published 2 weeks ago
Each Night
eachnight.com › mattress-guides › pocket-coil-mattress-buying-guide
Pocket Coil Mattress Buying Guide + Top Brands List - eachnight
November 23, 2025 - Below, we’ll talk about some ... a pocket coil mattress of either construction. Best Pocket Coil Mattress Overall: Amerisleep AS3 Hybrid...
Amerisleep
amerisleep.com › blog › mattress guides › innerspring vs pocketed coil mattresses
Innerspring vs Pocketed Coil Mattresses - Amerisleep
November 12, 2025 - Because they usually have a simple construction with thin comfort layers sandwiching the wire coil system, innerspring mattresses can be excellent budget mattresses. However, you can still find well-made innerspring beds as you browse luxury mattresses. When it comes to choosing a mattress, pocket coil mattresses are becoming a popular choice due to their unique features and benefits.
Mattressmill
mattressmill.com › mattresses › wrapped-coil-mattress
Wrapped Coil Mattresses | Bozeman, MT | Mattress Mill
Enhanced support, layers of foam, quilted padding make this mattress type a superior option for the best sleep. The coil count largely determines these prices. Generally speaking, the more springs within the mattress, the higher the price. Unlike traditional mattresses that feature a single unit of interconnected metal coils, individually wrapped coil mattresses are designed with separate coils encased in individual fabric pockets.
Mattress Clarity
mattressclarity.com › home › best mattress
The Best Innerspring Mattresses (2026): We Tested 100+ Beds
November 3, 2025 - Support and pressure relief are arguably the standout features in a really great innerspring mattress, and that calls for responsive steel coils and cushioning comfort layers. Supportive coils support a straight spine, while cushioning foams help absorb excess pressure on vulnerable areas like the hips, shoulders, and lumbar region. We prioritized innerspring models with individually pocketed coils, zoned coil systems for upgraded lumbar support and adaptive comfort layers that add cushioning without sacrificing pressure relief.
Puffy
puffy.com › blog › lux comfort › innerspring mattress vs pocket coil: which is better?
Innerspring Mattress vs Pocket Coil: Which is Better?
January 17, 2025 - Innerspring mattresses have metal coils that provide support and bounce, while pocket coil mattresses have individually wrapped coils that offer better motion isolation. Test different options: It's essential to try out different mattress options before making a decision. Visit showrooms or take advantage of trial periods offered by manufacturers. This way, you can determine which type of mattress provides the best sleep experience for you.
Mattress Underground
forum.mattressunderground.com › talk to the experts › arizona premium mattress
Please help me choose the right pocket coil for DIY Hybrid - Arizona Premium Mattress - Mattress Underground
August 11, 2022 - I’ve been sleeping on a very old ~9" innerspring mattress on a ~7" box spring for far too long and its time for a new one. My brother has a tulo Liv all foam from Mattress Firm and it is medium-firm. I consider it too fi…
Beautyrest
beautyrest.com › collections › shop-by-innerspring
Shop Innerspring Mattresses Online at Beautyrest.com
While best for back and stomach sleepers, an innerspring is a good choice for side sleepers and those that sleep in all the different sleep positions as well. Here at Beautyrest we upgraded the traditional innerspring system, and your sleep experience with our quilted innerspring mattresses' premier pocketed coil technology, providing support with exceptional comfort.
Mattress Underground
forum.mattressunderground.com › mattress talk › general mattresses questions
Ultimate Dreams Pocketed Coil Mattress - General Mattresses Questions - Mattress Underground
June 14, 2013 - I’d like to say first that this forum is fantastic and while mattress shopping is still overwhelming I feel like I’m not going in blind anymore. I’ve been eyeing the different Ultimate Dreams latex mattresses and noticed when I looked today that there’s a new innerspring version that hasn’t been mentioned on here before (https://www.amazon.com/DreamFoam-Bedding-Ultimate-Pocketed-Mattress/dp/B00EVAT3LC).
Mattress Insider
mattressinsider.com › home › shop › 8″ park meadow encased coil mattress ii
Innerspring Mattress for Home: Coil Mattresses USA Made!
October 31, 2025 - Questions about home or custom mattresses? Give us a call, we’re open! 7 days a week, 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM MST ... Adaptive Matrix™ Encased Coils are the highest quality innerspring system currently available on the market.
Mattress King
mattresskingok.com › blogs › blog-sleep-health-lifestyle › pocket-spring-vs-memory-foam-which-is-better
Pocket Spring vs Memory Foam: Which Is Better? – Mattress King
Memory foam is just as supportive as a pocket spring mattress, but it supports by contouring itself to the sleeper’s body and relieving pressure. The average lifespan may be an important difference to some. While the individual coils in a pocket spring mattress allow for it to respond better ...
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › the good ol’ days / quality innerspring
r/Mattress on Reddit: The good ol’ days / quality innerspring
October 17, 2024 -
Remember the good ol’ days when a person could buy a quality innerspring mattress that felt good on the back and lasted for years? What has happened to humanity? I’m not interested in memory foam, cooling gel, or hybrid anything. All I want is to time warp back to an era before humans went around the bend and purchase a common sense king mattress. Any suggestions?
Top answer 1 of 4
13
I totally recommend Avocado Mattresses. They have quality materials and killer springs!
2 of 4
12
If you have an Original mattress factory by where you live that is exactly what they specialize in. You can get a basic innerspring paired with a box spring for $668 in Queen size there, as well as in Luxury firm and Plush . Basically everything they sell there is constructed old style with bonnell coils and made to be paired with a box spring. Even their memory foam mattresses are very high quality, made more like old school Tempur's used to be made with 8lb density memory foam in the comfort layer, 5lb density memory foam under that, and a 2.25lb polyfoam base.
GoodBed
goodbed.com › mattress-questions › 2095 › what-is-the-best-type-of-innerspring-mattress-for-limiting-disturbance-from-movements
Mattress Question: "What is the best type of innerspring mattress for limiting disturbance from movements?" - GoodBed.com
Mattress Types · Innerspring and Pocketed Coil · Types of Coils · Padding · Hybrids · Memory Foam · Memory Foam vs. Innerspring · Memory Foam and Sleeping Hot · Latex · All-Natural Latex · Blended Latex · Synthetic Latex · Talalay vs Dunlop · Adjustable Air Beds ·
TheComfyNorth
thecomfynorth.ca › home › best pocket coil mattress in canada: reviews and buying tips
Best Pocket Coil Mattress in Canada: Reviews and Buying Tips - TheComfyNorth
2 weeks ago - You’d want to consider the coil count, foam layers, edge support, and firmness when choosing a pocket coil mattress. In my opinion, the best pocket coil mattress is The Summerhill due to its excellent bounce and motion isolation.
Quora
quora.com › Which-is-the-best-mattress-to-opt-for-back-pain-Bonnell-Spring-or-Pocket-Spring
Which is the best mattress to opt for back pain, Bonnell Spring or Pocket Spring? - Quora
Answer (1 of 4): There are benefits to each style of coils depending on your sleeping style, your sleeping partners, the type of back pain that you have, and even the size of bed that you're getting. Generally a pocketed coil will relieve more pressure and, any of your sleeping Partners whether t...
NapLab
naplab.com › home › best mattress 2026 – 380+ beds tested & reviewed by our experts
Best Mattress 2026 – 380+ Mattresses Tested by Experts
5 days ago - The Winkbed is our #1 best mattress for 2026, considering 380+ mattresses tested. It is a 14″ hybrid with gel foam and a pocketed coil base. The Winkbed has deep sinkage with moderate bounce and above-average performance in every category we test.