It depends on the job. A belt sander is pretty aggressive, so it’s good for heavy removal and it’s easy to go overboard with it. A random orbit sander is good for finishing/smoothing flat parts. Other shaped sanders are good for specific jobs, like corners, edges, etc. Sanding by hand gets generally better results on details, thin edges, etc. and between coats of finish. If you are removing large amounts of old finish look into chemical stripping. Answer from Karmonauta on reddit.com
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/woodworking › if you were to buy only one sander for furniture and small woodworking what would you use?
r/woodworking on Reddit: If you were to buy only one sander for furniture and small woodworking what would you use?
October 23, 2022 -

I’m looking at moving up from my little dewalt random orbital sander and am a bit of a loss where to start. I’m looking primarily for long lasting, comfortable and good dust collection. I’ve looked through Mirka, festool and 3M xtract. Curious what you guys would go with if you were buying one sander (and matching dust extractor)

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/woodworking › the right sander for furniture
r/woodworking on Reddit: The right sander for furniture
November 16, 2023 -

I've been building my shop over the past year and in turn moving from general construction tools to finer woodworking tools. This weekend while finishing drawers, I've realized I don't love my oribital sander and I would like to upgrade.

Currently I'm using the Milwaukee 4". The finish is just ok, the dust extraction is poor, the vibration is ok at best and the feel when the dust hose is attached is clunky. I'm looking at the festool, mirka and the eksand so far. The festool has had some bad reviews lately on the one with the handle, but overall a lot of people rave about these. I didn't see a lot of reviews here on the Mirka and the Eksand, but they seem to be quality tools.

I'm looking for some recommendations. I won't be doing much paint on my projects and I'm at the beginning so is line to start right. I have a big enough budget where most options are on the table as long as it makes sense. Any advise this sub can lend is highly appreciated.

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/furnitureflip › suggestions for orbital sander for newbie??
r/FurnitureFlip on Reddit: Suggestions for orbital sander for newbie??
August 18, 2023 -

Looking for suggestions for a random orbital sander. I’m currently considering the Ryobi orbital but I hear mixed reviews. I’ve done a couple furniture flips in the past (using my dads ancient sander). I am by no means a serious flipper or looking to sell my work, just updating some furniture we’ve been given. Looking for something that’s just best, all round orbital sander for furniture flip. Corded or cordless isn’t an issue. Just looking for something that takes the paint off with as little elbow grease as possible :) thanks!

Top answer
1 of 4
3
Ryobi is great. But other brands are pretty comparable, so I wouldn’t say it matters too much. Go with a corded (much cheaper) 5 inch and get various grits to go with it - I start with 80, then 120, then 220. Another option would be a multi-purpose tool if you think you’d use it for other things. Those will have a smaller triangular sanding attachment. Either way, you can find tons of great sanders and tools on FB Marketplace or OfferUp rather than spending money on something brand new.
2 of 4
2
A sander is always a good basic tool to own. I'm not a fan of Ryobi's. They are very entry level and you get what you pay for. At your level, which is casual, the minimum would be Ryobi, but consider spending a bit more to have a tool that is built strong to last. Look at Milwaukee or even Makita. I had a Bosch orbital that went through 5 kitchens and two housefuls of furniture and was still going. I love that thing, but it's worn out. I've got the cordless Milwaukee.... I love it, but the battery pack is a pain. It gets in the way on some angles and the battery going dead is annoying. I have several batteries to switch into because I gave the whole system with a couple drills and impact driver, but default back to my Makita corded plugged into a wet/dry shop vac more than anything. I have the fancy little air compressor one that you see on YT, too, but it's a pain to get the air compressor going and then turning it all the way off at night, draining it, etc. I just like the least amount of hassle to get the job done and move on to the next stage. I find a corded midlevel orbital sander with a little shop vac to be my 'go to' because it's versatile, quick to setup and put away. So, go with the best you can comfortably afford is my advice. Battery-powered means buying extra batteries or being stuck in the middle of the time you have to do the job - there goes your Saturday. So factor in the cost of extra batteries if you go that route.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/woodworking › sander recommendations
r/woodworking on Reddit: Sander recommendations
January 30, 2025 -

Ive been using a dewalt dcw 210 sander for a couple years now and im happy with it but im also not. Any amount of pressure I put on it, it quits spinning. Also it uses a battery very quickly and its difficult to sand for long periods due to a battery making it heavier on 1 side. At my work place we use indasa sanders which i like but they are pneumatic and my air compressor isnt big enough to handle it. Im looking for recommendations for a hand sander that can remove more wood faster then my current sander. Preferably corded 5" sander hook and loop with dust collector capability, that keeps spinning even with some pressure applied. I typically use pine, oak, and some walnut and maple.

Find elsewhere
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/woodworking › looking to upgrade my sander for furniture refurbishing and i'm overwhelmed!
r/woodworking on Reddit: Looking to upgrade my sander for furniture refurbishing and I'm overwhelmed!
November 12, 2023 -

Hey guys, I'm upgrading from my hand-me-down Black& Decker mouse sander and I'm looking for something under the price of $160, that is robust, efficient, Aunt will make my life easier. My current sander takes more time to sand than doing it by hand because it's so old. Any recommendations for something that will provide a smooth surface without gouging? I use the foam pads for preservation of detail. Thanks in advance!

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/woodworkingtools › what type of sander do i need?
r/woodworkingtools on Reddit: What type of sander do I need?
June 17, 2023 -

Hello,

So, like the title says, Im in the market for a sander. Mostly I sand by hand when I just need to get things smooth or ready for glueing.

Where I need to power tools are smoothing out glue-up edges (im a beginner, my glue-up have very non-aligning edges so I need to often smooth them out).

What I do currently is that I have one of those attachments for my drill that lets me but a sandpaper disc on it and it spins that around, kinda like a crappy orbital sander. Problem is that it is insanely hard to get that disc parallel to the workpiece while holding the drill essentially in the air and I end up making my pieces not square anymore and taking off more material from one side.

I think (and please tell me if im right) that a sander rests on the material so its easy to get the sandpaper parallel to the material. Is this correct?

If yes then need something that is decent at removing material but that I might also use for finish sanding.

The closest thing to my drill contraption I guess is an orbital sander since I understand that it also just spins the sandpaper around (vs alot of others, including random orbital, that just vibrate it). What type of sander would be best in my case?

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › klp › best-sander-for-woodworking
Best Sander for Woodworking - Reddit
I'm not against going with festool but I'm not sure it's worth it and there's so many options in not even sure what to get. Please help. Thank you. ... I have switched from using my orbital sander to using a pneumatic palm sander for most of ...
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/woodworking › which sander to use
r/woodworking on Reddit: Which Sander to Use
January 9, 2025 -

I have some old solid wood doors in my house I’d like to refinish. I plan to strip the paint (likely has lead in it), sand the doors down and repaint one side white and go with a dark stain on the hallway side. Which sander is better for this and stripping furniture/moulding in general? I have an orbital sander but would a sheet sander be better?

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/woodworking › is there a consensus "best" random orbit sander that's in the entry-level (~$150 or less) range? would love a smooth, low vibration, single hand ros without jumping all the way up to a mirka or festool
r/woodworking on Reddit: Is there a consensus "best" random orbit sander that's in the entry-level (~$150 or less) range? Would love a smooth, low vibration, single hand ROS without jumping all the way up to a Mirka or Festool
August 21, 2023 -

I've been running a Ridgid 5" ROS for years and years now, and it's slowly dying. It's a fine sander; it spins and sands. I have nothing positive or negative to say on it, mostly: It was a $60 ROS that lasted many, many hours of use. That said it left my hands quite tingly and I'd love a better sanding experience once it does kick it.

I would like to upgrade, and am looking for:

  • 5"

  • Low vibration as possible

  • Good dust collection (I use a vacuum attached almost always)

  • Good single hand ergonomics

  • Corded

From what I see, it feels like there are three tiers to look at:

  1. Big box tier: Ridgid, Milwaukee, Dewalt, Makita, Bosch etc. Range from $30-$100; people seem to like the Makita and Bosch ones best, but I've used many and they seem generally pretty similar... Currently looking at Bosch.

  2. Festool ETS line: Oddly all by itself in the middle of the price range, from what I've seen, about $250. Well loved, seems to check all the boxes but is more than I can probably justify with the amount I use it... Would also be concerned about busting it out for, say, cleaning up some decking if it's "too nice"

  3. Super high end. Mirka, 3M Xtract, etc. Insanely priced at like $500-$700, but universally loved. Would clearly be worth it if you were doing production work, but I am not.

Any suggestions on others to look at, that are maybe the best of tier 1, or somewhere between tier 1 and 2? Surprised there's not more middle ground options now that I'm looking!

Edit: Got the standard Bosch 5" and it's a HUGE step up from my Ridgid that was about the same price. Sands the same, way less vibration!

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/woodworking › just get the good sander...
r/woodworking on Reddit: Just get the good sander...
April 16, 2022 -

For years I couldn't understand why anyone would wanna spend the big bucks for a premium random orbital. I mean, my $45 black and decker sands, what could possibly be the difference? Well, my B&D finally died, and I decided to try out the Bosch GET65 and wow, it really is better.
Even with just a shopvac not a true dust extractor the dust pickup is noticeably better. That turbo mode with 80 grit will just eat through the roughest surfaces, turn it down with some 220 and you're done before you know it. Now i'm starting to wonder if another $300 to go up to a festool might not be completely insane

🌐
Salvaged Inspirations
salvagedinspirations.com › home › blog › best sander for furniture refinishing & pro stained finish | lilac desk makeover
Best Sander For Furniture Refinishing & Pro Stained Finish - Salvaged Inspirations
December 17, 2019 - And yes, I even bought my own Dewalt orbital sander because of your recommendation! ... Love me my Dewalt tools – the best on the market hands down! I was also going to PM you and ask what you were using to film.