Idk why but Sinister (2012) REALLY got me the first watch. Subsequent ones not so much, but the first was a strong one. Answer from stardragonfruit_0813 on reddit.com
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/moviesuggestions › looking for horror movies that will scare the sh*t out of me
r/MovieSuggestions on Reddit: Looking for horror movies that will scare the sh*t out of me
October 30, 2023 -

Is it me, or have horror movies been largely unimpressive in recent years? There are a few solid ones that come to mind - Talk to Me, The Barbarian - but nothing that has truly kept me up at night.

I’m by no means a horror aficionado, so I would love to get some horror movie suggestions, all years and sub-genres are welcome! I’m not a huge fan of slasher films though (I just don’t find them scary) and lean more towards movies that are creepy/uneasy, psychological, and have a strong story.

🌐
IMDb
imdb.com › list › ls058956587
horror movies which are actually scary and not gory
List your movie, TV & celebrity picks. ... After his wife meets a grisly end, Jamie Ashen returns to his haunted hometown of Ravens Fair to find answers. His investigation leads him to the ghost of a ventriloquist named Mary Shaw who seems to have ties to his entire family treeDirectorJames WanStarsRyan KwantenAmber VallettaDonnie Wahlberg · scared me out of my pants...a little gore and a great atmosphere and mood created in this movie
Discussions

Horror movie that genuinely scared you?
Idk why but Sinister (2012) REALLY got me the first watch. Subsequent ones not so much, but the first was a strong one. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/horror
189
77
September 16, 2024
Best scary movies that are as scary as sinister
Hi anyone can recommend genuine good horror movies IMO sinister is one of the best ive seen its well written and not cheesy and the vibe is scary instead of constant jumpscares More on reddit.com
🌐 r/horror
22
12
October 4, 2021
What’s a horror movie that absolutely terrified you? I legit can’t find any horror movies that actually scare me
Sinister, last shift, terrified, hell house llc, host, oculus More on reddit.com
🌐 r/HorrorMovies
467
228
July 5, 2023
I want your absolute most terrifying movie recommendations

You've already seen Hereditary. In my opinion that is the scariest movie.

More on reddit.com
🌐 r/movies
477
318
December 4, 2018
🌐
Rotten Tomatoes
editorial.rottentomatoes.com › guide › best-horror-movies-of-all-time
200 Best Horror Movies of All Time | Rotten Tomatoes
November 6, 2025 - Critics Consensus: Well-crafted and gleefully creepy, The Conjuring ratchets up dread through a series of effective old-school scares. Synopsis: In 1970, paranormal investigators and demonologists Lorraine (Vera Farmiga) and Ed (Patrick Wilson) Warren are summoned to the home of [More] Starring: Vera Farmiga, Patrick Wilson, Lili Taylor, Ron Livingston ... Critics Consensus: A welcome return for director Richard Stanley, Color Out of Space mixes tart B-movie pulp with visually alluring Lovecraftian horror and a dash of gonzo Nicolas Cage.
🌐
BuzzFeed
buzzfeed.com › ravenishak › scariest-movies-to-watch
28 Horror Films That "Scarred" People For Eternity, And I Didn't Know Half Of These Existed
October 5, 2025 - "I watch this movie like twice a year because I think I love it, and then I watch it, and it traumatizes me all over again. One of my favorites to show people, though, for sure, even though it messes with my head every time." ... "Archaeologist Scarlett Marlowe (Perdita Weeks) has devoted her whole life to finding one of history's greatest treasures: Flamel's Philosopher's Stone.
🌐
Hollywood Reporter
hollywoodreporter.com › lists › 25-best-horror-movies-of-the-21st-century-ranked
The 25 Best Horror Movies of the 21st Century, Ranked
September 29, 2025 - THR's chief film critic ranks the 25 best horror movies of the 2000s, from satires to fairy tales, haunted house stories and possession yarns.
🌐
Hulu
hulu.com › guides › horror-movies-on-hulu
42 Best Horror Movies of All Time | Hulu Guides
October 1, 2025 - The best horror movies of all time are streaming now, including ‘Saw,’ ‘Scream,’ ‘The Omen,’ and more.
🌐
Netflix
netflix.com › browse › genre › 6057
Scary Movies | Netflix Official Site
Be afraid. Be very afraid. Our scary movie collection is about to bring the screams. So lower the lights and lock the doors. It’s thriller time.
Find elsewhere
🌐
IMDb
imdb.com › search › title
Top 50 Horror Movies
One year after the supernatural nightmare at Freddy Fazbear's Pizza, Abby runs away to reconnect with her animatronic friends, uncovering dark secrets about the true origins of Freddy's and unleashing a horror hidden for decades · Dr. Victor Frankenstein, a brilliant but egotistical scientist, ...
🌐
Quora
quora.com › What-are-some-of-the-scariest-and-actually-good-horror-movies
What are some of the scariest and actually good horror movies? - Quora
Answer (1 of 2): These is just ones I thought were very good and very scary: The Exorcism of Emily Rose- Jennifer Carpenter gives an AMAZING performance. No easy answers as to what happened.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/horror › horror movie that genuinely scared you?
r/horror on Reddit: Horror movie that genuinely scared you?
September 16, 2024 -

I’m watching a horror movie with a couple of friends tonight and none of us get scared easily. I need a movie that you still remember to this day, if it’s the plot twist that blew your mind or scary scenes. I’m more interested in movies from 2010 and up, but it’s okay if it’s older.

Just for a bit of context: we did not like Longlegs, Smile, Bird Box and found these boring, not scary, despite the hype. Movies that did scare us: The Autopsy of Jane Doe, Hereditary, The Visit, Dabbe 1.

Although these didn’t scare us, we really loved Us, The Conjuring series, Get Out, Black Box, Fractured, Prisoners, Marrowbone, Terrifier.

Top answer
1 of 90
77
Idk why but Sinister (2012) REALLY got me the first watch. Subsequent ones not so much, but the first was a strong one.
2 of 90
40
"A [horror] movie that you still remember to this day" 💀: Shutter (The very first/OG one. Thai horror) Art of The Devil (The first one because all the sequels sucked. Thai horror) The Eye (The very first/OG one. Chinese horror) The Tag-Along (The very first one because the sequels all sucked. Taiwanese horror) Incantation (Taiwanese horror) Bunshinsaba (Korean horror) Battle Royale (Japanese horror) Noroi: The Curse (Japanese horror) Evil Dead Event Horizon "Plot twist that blew your mind": Old Boy (The OG Korean one and not the English remake) Parasite (Korean thriller) Joint Security Area (Korean horror) The Skin I Live In (Spanish title: La piel que habito) The Others If you liked The Autopsy of Jane Doe, then some have said that The Taking of Deborah Logan has similar vibes and I kinda agree. Though, I find The Taking of Deborah Logan more impactful (not necessarily scarier than Jane Doe) because it's about mental health and that shit stuck with me. If you liked The Hills Have Eyes 1, Korean horror Bedevilled also has similar vibes but the build up to the killing spree is slower. Personally, I find Bedevilled a lot more intense and unrelenting in terms of how disturbing some scenes are. As for Hereditary, some of my friends said The Dark And The Wicked has similar vibes but I havent watched it so I can't tell for sure.
🌐
Netflix Tudum
netflix.com › tudum › articles › horror-movies
29 Best Horror Movies to Watch for a Good Scare - Netflix Tudum
The two-note theme that signals ... of the scariest — and most iconic — film scores ever written. But what’s most striking about Jaws all these years later is how withholding it is, the result being a suspenseful beachside horror that will keep you on the edge of your seat. The movie is a slow ...
Published   September 5, 2025
🌐
Fathom Entertainment
fathomentertainment.com › the best new horror movies of 2025: your ultimate guide to a year of fear
Scariest & Best New Horror Movies of 2025
August 19, 2025 - Sign us up. The Gorge is being described as a high-action, “genre-bending” love story with strong survival horror elements. While the plot is being kept under wraps, the sheer talent involved is undeniable.
🌐
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
Horror Movies That Are ACTUALLY Terrifying - YouTube
Horror Movies That Are ACTUALLY Terrifying Tired of “scary” movies that aren’t scary at all? This video is for you. Horror gets dismissed as cheap jump scare...
Published   August 20, 2025
🌐
Flicks
flicks.com.au › features › best-horror-movies-netflix-au
The best horror movies on Netflix Australia
November 5, 2025 - After the first three adaptations of R.L. Stine’s Fear Street (set in 1994, 1978 and 1666 respectively), this ultra-violent film returns to the cursed town of Shadyside in 1988, a serial killer turning the titular high school event into a ...
🌐
Empire
empireonline.com › movies › features › best-horror-movies
The 50 Best Horror Movies Guaranteed To Chill Your Blood
October 3, 2025 - Largely confined to an abandoned ... a horror movie. But there are creepy scares and gonzo gore by the bucketful, while Romero takes sly philosophical swipes at class and racial politics and mindless consumerism. A Day, a Land and a Diary would follow, but never quite reclaim these horror heights. To this very day, Dawn is still the best zombie movie ...
🌐
Quora
quora.com › What-s-a-really-scary-horror-movie
What’s a really scary horror movie? - Quora
Answer (1 of 22): As a horror fan, personally it is hard to find a horror movie that sends shivers down your spine. out of all the horror movies I’ve watched there’s one movie that kept me up at night. it’s a A24 movie and it’s called “hereditary’. a movie that has surface around ...
🌐
HBO Max
hbomax.com › collections › horror
Best Horror & Scary Movies | HBO Max
October 4, 2025 - You're going to want to keep the lights on for these. Stream slasher movies, spooky TV shows, and more haunting hits to get your heart racing.
🌐
Rotten Tomatoes
editorial.rottentomatoes.com › article › the-10-scariest-horror-movies-ever
The 10 Scariest Horror Movies Ever | Rotten Tomatoes
November 4, 2024 - You may not agree that The Exorcist is the scariest movie ever, but it probably also isn’t much of a surprise to see it at the top of our list — with a whopping 19% of all the votes cast.
🌐
BuzzFeed
buzzfeed.com › ravenishak › best-horror-movies
The Best Scary Movies To Watch For Guaranteed Screams
October 7, 2025 - I love scary movies and have never done that before or since. I’m going to have to look for those tapes!" ... "Bro, that scene where the giant guy appears out of the dark hallway behind that girl — it's easily one of my favorite cinematic shots in any movie. It was so eerie, yet so perfect." ... Warner Bros. Pictures / Via youtube.com ... "This movie ruined horror ...