Dorm mattresses are brutal, so adding a topper is a must. I tried the Sleep Mantra topper during my time, and while it’s plush, breathable, and fits Twin XL perfectly, it’s more on the soft side. It adds a nice cushioned layer but may not be firm enough if your son prefers medium firm. For solid support, I’d recommend looking into a medium firm memory foam or a thinner latex topper. those offer better structure for someone who doesn’t like super soft options. Good luck with the dorm setup! Answer from UpstreamSquad on reddit.com
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › twin xl matress topper recommendation?
r/Mattress on Reddit: Twin XL Matress topper recommendation?
July 3, 2024 -

(Sorry for the typo in the subject line. I'm not able to edit it)

My son is going to college next month and is trying to figure out what mattress topper to buy. The mattress they provide is like a cot mattress, and this will go on top of it. He is 5'8" and weighs 168 pounds. He likes a bed that's medium to medium-firm (he finds the tempurpedic topper to be too soft). The bed will be twin XL, so it needs to come in that size.

Any advice appreciated!

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › best mattress topper for dorm twin xl?
r/Mattress on Reddit: Best Mattress Topper for Dorm Twin XL?
December 24, 2024 - Hey everyone! I’m moving into a dorm soon and trying to make my Twin XL bed as comfy as possible. I know dorm beds can be super stiff and not exactly…
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › recommendation request: twin xl that feels like tempur-pedic serenity topper
r/Mattress on Reddit: Recommendation request: Twin XL that feels like Tempur-pedic Serenity Topper
February 8, 2023 -

My partner and I currently sleep on a queen-size Vibe Gel Memory Foam mattress w/ a 3-inch Tempur-pedic "Serenity" topper.

This is the topper: https://www.costco.com/serenity-by-tempur-pedic-3-inch-mattress-topper.product.4000042059.html, and I believe this is the mattress (I don't remember precisely): https://www.amazon.com/Vibe-12-Inch-Memory-Mattress-Queen/dp/B074NDQ143

The mattress was too firm for comfort on its own, so we tried the topper, and we like the way it feels.

The main issue with this setup is that we can still feel each other's movements.

When we visited some friends, we slept on a pair of twin XL mattresses side-by-side, and we loved that we couldn't feel each other getting up or changing positions in the night. So that's the setup we're shopping for now.

I basically see two options:

  • Get two cheap twin XLs and just get two of the same mattress toppers.

  • Get two higher quality twin XLs that match the mattress topper feeling.

Some more relevant details:

  • We both sleep on our backs

  • I don't think we sleep hot. We just shed a layer of covers in the summer and add it back in the winter months. We definitely don't wake up with any noticeable amount of sweat.

  • Our budget is ~$1000 total (not including new bed frame)

I appreciate any tips!

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/frugal › need a matress topper for school. any advice?
r/Frugal on Reddit: Need a matress topper for school. Any advice?
October 22, 2014 -

I'm getting a twin XL mattress topper for my dorm mattress. I didn't want something cheap, but wanted a fair value but not pay $150+. Since getting a new matress isn't ideal for a dorm, I thought I might get something that would last me 3-4 years through college. Any advice where to go and what to get?

🌐
Sleepopolis
sleepopolis.com › home › mattress topper reviews › best twin xl mattress topper
Best Twin XL Mattress Topper (2025) | Sleepopolis
August 5, 2025 - Are you looking for the best twin XL mattress topper? In this article, we'll go over some of our top choices for twin XL toppers, based on testing in the Sleepopolis mattress lab.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › best mattress topper? is getting a brand name one worth it or an amazon one will do?
r/Mattress on Reddit: Best mattress topper? Is getting a brand name one worth it or an Amazon one will do?
March 9, 2022 -

Last year I had a decent topper from bed bath and beyond for my twin xl and this year I’m looking for a full topper to put on the mattress my apartment came with. All the recommendations for toppers online are like $300-500. There’s also the Casper one which looks thin for $230.

An alternative one be one of the Amazon 3” toppers which have thousands of great reviews but I also read the ones that aren’t too good and I’m unsure on which one to get. Linenspa or Lucid 3” toppers are choices that looks solid based on reviews for $80. Wanted to know if any mattress experts think this is a solid way to go. I really want to prioritize good sleep and I’ve been sleeping so well back home with a great tempurpidic mattress and Casper pillows.

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › mattress topper help please! (vegan side-sleeper w/ twin xl)
r/Mattress on Reddit: mattress topper help please! (vegan side-sleeper w/ twin xl)
February 20, 2023 -

Hi! I am trying to buy a mattress topper and am having a difficult time finding a vegan mattress topper that is well-reviewed and not made of the smelly foam stuff. It needs to:

  • fit a twin xl bed

  • be soft because the hard college-provided mattresses make my joint pain worse (yay for joint hypermobility)

  • not have any down or wool (vegan)

  • ideally be made of organic and produced ethically

  • maybe be made of recycled synthetics, but I also have hyperhidrosis and don't want to turn my bed into a sweat cave... so would prefer something more breathable

I was originally thinking the Avocado vegan mattress topper in plush but have seen bad reviews, and the White Lotus Home organic cotton mattress toppers doesn't have many reviews.

p.s. Any sustainable vegan duvet insert/comforter recs would also be recommended. I loved the previous one I had since I was a toddler, but it was non-vegan and also it got damaged by wear over time and would litter feathers everywhere until it was kind of non-fixable. I also like the one I am currently borrowing from my parents, but it is the Ikea mulberry silk-filled one (also nonvegan), so I am not going to get one of these either.

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › dorm mattress topper
r/Mattress on Reddit: Dorm mattress topper
April 11, 2024 -

I’m looking for a new mattress topper for my twin xl bed. I bought this 4in memory foam topper and it is HARD AS A ROCK, while simultaneously acting as “the void” (ie. I sink in and have no support whatsoever)

I need something supportive (and maybe soft?) that wont mash in my shoulders when i sleep, and preferably within the $100-200 range. I’ve been looking at latex toppers, but i cant tell if they’re worth the hype yet.

Does anyone have any recommendations? I cannot go another night with this terrible shoulder pain 😭😭

Find elsewhere
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/ucla › best mattress topper?
Best mattress topper? : r/ucla
February 17, 2022 - Lucid Mattress Topperslept slept on it. ... i got a standard twin dorm bed mattress from bed bath and beyond and it is sooo comfortable. didn’t move to much since it was a bit short but its barely bothered me. there are twin xl available but those sell out quickly
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › mattress topper for twin xl
r/Mattress on Reddit: Mattress topper for twin XL
February 10, 2022 - Anyone have any experience with either Saavata or Sleepy Head mattress topper? It’s for my daughter’s college mattress. She suffers from a connective…
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/college › mattress and topper, twin xl sheets or larger?
r/college on Reddit: Mattress and topper, twin XL sheets or larger?
May 7, 2025 -

Hey all! Not 100% sure this is the right place to post this, but I'll ask anyway :/ I will be a college freshman this year and have been told to buy a mattress topper as the mattresses aren't very comfortable in the dorms. However, that will add some height to the bed, and I am worried the twin XL sheets I'm going to buy won't fit over the topper and mattress. Should I buy larger sheets to fit over the topper (maybe a full-size fitted sheet?)? Or will the twin XL sheets cover a mattress and topper? Sorry if this is the wrong place to post this!

Also, I'm purely talking about the fitted sheet, not a top sheet!

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r › Bedding › comments › 1efl69u › best_mattress_topper_for_a_dorm_bed_twin_xl
best mattress topper for a dorm bed twin xl?
There’s no hell like sleeping with a feather mattress topper below you and a cheap, polyester comforter on top. My mother is a hoarder, and when I came home for Christmas, she had found a twin-sized feather bed and put it on the full-sized mattress in the guest room.
🌐
Sleep Foundation
sleepfoundation.org › best mattress toppers
Best Twin XL Mattress Toppers of 2025 | Sleep Foundation
December 4, 2020 - The CopperFlex 201 Mattress Topper from Brooklyn Bedding offers great bang for your buck and long-term value. With 2 inches of memory foam padding, the topper adds plush cushioning to any sleep surface, and the twin XL size is a cost-effective ...
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › sleepyhead mattress topper alternatives
r/Mattress on Reddit: Sleepyhead Mattress Topper Alternatives
June 25, 2024 -

Hi everyone! I’m moving back into my dorm soon and I need a new mattress topper. My roommate has recommended the Sleepyhead one and I love how it feels but it is honestly pretty expensive for me. I’m willing to pay if there’s no better/similar quality at a lower price though I’d prefer to avoid that, which is why I’m here.

Things I’m looking for in my next topper are: at least 3”, memory foam, Certi-pur certified, cooling, included or available cover, slightly firm but still soft so that it forms to my body, etc. EDIT: need a twin xl size

If you have any recommendations please let me know! Or if I should just go with the Sleepyhead feel free to also comment that :)

Thank you all!

Top answer
1 of 5
2
Once you factor in the cover it isnt a big savings over what youre looking at, but the FoamforYou topper is most likely a better quality topper and at a better price($220). Its a cooling gel foam topper that is CertiPur, and 4lb density which is a higher density memory foam so it should be pretty durable. Then the feedback on it suggests its medium firmness as well. Then they have several separate covers for sale with the standard one being $80 in queen. One that I have personal experience with is the 4lb ViscoPLUSH from foam factory for $205 in queen. Theirs also has a separate Poly-Cotton Knit cover for $55, however this one isnt cooling gel. I think the feel of this one matches what you say perfectly, they list it as medium, some call it medium-soft. Your weight is a big factor in how that will translate to you personally, the more you weight the firmer you need. I personally think cooling gel is mostly a gimmick and the foam will heat up the same as you lay on it through the night, but not everyone agrees with me on that. The Foam factory one has much more feedback, is also high quality, and is very popular here. But the people who have gotten the one from Foamforyou seem to all swear its the best. Then if you just want a cheaper one you can always get something like The Linenspa gel topper off Amazon . If you only expect to get 1 or 2 years out of a topper something like this can be fine. When you do the math on it from the item weight though, its barley over 1lb density foam just for comparison. Extremely low quality memory foam, which if you havent figured yet by what ive been saying, density is the best measure we have to know the quality of a foam. It also has nothing to do with the firmness of the memory foam. Unfortunately there is no way to figure out the density of the Sleepyhead topper because they include everything in the item weight, box and cover.
2 of 5
2
I had 2 different toppers for the first two years I was at ASU. They were alright but I didn't really like them that much. This year I tried the sleepyhead one and it was definitely the best quality. I sleep way better on it. Just pressing on the foam you can tell a clear difference in quality but it's all about your priorities. I wanted to invest in something to get really good sleep so Sleepyhead was the better option if you can afford it.
🌐
By Sophia Lee
bysophialee.com › home › blog › this is the absolute best twin xl mattress topper for your dorm room
This Is The Absolute Best Twin XL Mattress Topper for Your Dorm Room - By Sophia Lee
November 5, 2025 - This is the mattress topper college students swear by. We can all agree that comfort is the last thing you think of when thinking of a dorm room mattress. So, wouldn’t you be surprised when I tell you that my bed at college was comfier than my bed at home?! Not only was I obsessed with this twin XL mattress topper in college, but so was my sister, my friends, and thousands of other college students who have purchased it after I have raved about it.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › any recommendations for extra firm twin xl futon or floor mattress?
r/Mattress on Reddit: Any recommendations for extra firm Twin XL futon or floor mattress?
October 19, 2025 -

I'm 6'3" and weigh 205 lbs so need a bed that's at least 80" inches long - preferably a Twin XL.

I can't handle soft mattresses - needs to be extra firm, closer to a floor or concrete than anything fluffy.

Would be great to get something that's made with more natural materials rather than overloaded with chemicals. That's just a wishlist thing though, I care more about the other aspects.