I went by the Wirecutter recommendation too. Now I exfoliate my body on sandpaper sheets every night. Do with that what you will. Answer from jersey385 on reddit.com
Brooklinen
brooklinen.com › products › down-alternative-comforter
Down Alternative Comforters | Brooklinen
Lightweight: Perfect for hot sleepers. Cloud-like softness that comforts without the weight. 650 fill power. *br**br* All-Season: Our most versatile comforter. Ideal comfort that lasts year round. Like the Goldilocks of comforters. 700 fill power.*br**br* Heavyweight: For those who like it extra cozy, this comforter is luxurious and fit for snuggling.
Brooklinen
brooklinen.com › products › down-comforter
Down Comforter | Lightweight, All-Season, Ultra-Warm | Brooklinen
Lightweight: Perfect for hot sleepers. Cloud-like softness that comforts without the weight. 650 fill power. *br**br* All-Season: Our most versatile comforter. Ideal comfort that lasts year round. Like the Goldilocks of comforters. 700 fill power.*br**br* Heavyweight: For those who like it extra cozy, this comforter is luxurious and fit for snuggling. 750 fill power. The Responsible Down Standard (RDS) certification ensures to the highest possible standard that our down comes from ducks and geese that have been treated humanely.
Brooklinen down comforter vs quince down comforter vs ?
I went by the Wirecutter recommendation too. Now I exfoliate my body on sandpaper sheets every night. Do with that what you will. More on reddit.com
Been sleeping under Brooklinen Down Comforter and Sateen Duvet Cover for last few weeks. . .
I don't think most complaints on the sub for Brooklinen has to do with their down comforter quality or their duvet covers; it's mostly for their sheets being rough-as-shoe-leather and flimsy material that breaks down quickly and tears very easily in comparison to other sheet sets. In fact, the consensus for Brooklinen is that their duvet covers tend to be nicer quality than their other products (especially their sheets) and I don't think I've seen many negative reviews for their comforters/inserts at all, come to think of it. The biggest complaint I see is that its longevity and fabric quality (for the sheets, at the least) has degraded over time or is not worth the price tag; it also seems that most positive reviews for the brand are from the 'honeymoon period' and not long-term (over a year, etc). I'll be curious to see if (after a year or two) the material for the duvet cover is still holding strong. If it does then that's great! Thanks for your review about it; all info is good info, in my book :) More on reddit.com
Brooklinen duvet comforter with Down Alternative: dry cleaning "if needed"?
unless you are sleeping without a top sheet washing your duvet cover every 1-2 weeks is crazy overkill. if you have been doing so that often its extremely unlikely the duvet itself even needs to be washed More on reddit.com
Advice on Comforter
Here's some of the options I'm looking at but none of them say anything about shedding in the reviews, I just really don't want to have another nightmare scenario I am so tired of sweeping my room hahaha https://www.thewoolroom.com/us/product/us-size-deluxe-washable-wool-comforter-light-200/ https://www.potterybarn.com/products/hydro-cool-comforter/ https://www.restduvet.com/products/evercool-comforter https://www.potterybarn.com/products/sleepsmart-temperature-regulating-down-duvet-insert/ More on reddit.com
Videos
Amazon
amazon.com › Brooklinen-Comforter-Insert-All-Season-Warmth › dp › B08KYF3R2Y
Amazon.com: Brooklinen All Season Luxury Down Comforter, 100% Natural Canadian Duck Down Duvet Insert - 700 Fill Power, 100% Cotton Shell, Baffle Box Construction, Full/Queen Size Comforter : Home & Kitchen
ALL SEASON COMFORTER: Insulating but not hot, our All Season Full/Queen Duvet Insert is the goldilocks of goose feather down comforters: it's not too hot, not too cold, it's just right. With its 700 fill power, our All Season Extra Fluffy Duvet Insert is breathable and the perfect fit for year round comfort and every type of sleeper. THE PERFECT FIT: However you sleep, we’ve got bedding comforters to match your needs. This All Season Comforter measures 90” x 90”, the perfect fit for Full and Queen size beds. We recommend pairing your Brooklinen Comforter with a Full/Queen Duvet Cover to maximize the lifespan of your product.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/bedding › brooklinen down comforter vs quince down comforter vs ?
r/Bedding on Reddit: Brooklinen down comforter vs quince down comforter vs ?
December 8, 2024 -
Hey guys, brooklinen down comforter all season vs ultra warm. Let me know what you guys think. Also, brooklinen was rated top down by wire cutter and 2 different top 10 sites. It’s $360 on sale. My problem Is that it’s 85% Hutterite duck down and 15% Hutterite feathers compared to Quince 100% down. Quince luxe down looks legit but seems like most people love the brooklinen down. Quince luxe is $379 and the premium is $299.
Or if anyone has any other recommendations let me know .
Thank you!
Top answer 1 of 9
11
I went by the Wirecutter recommendation too. Now I exfoliate my body on sandpaper sheets every night. Do with that what you will.
2 of 9
9
For what it’s worth, I have quince linen bedding and I love it. I’ve purchased their sunglasses, luggage etc. Their return policy is fantastic - you have 365 days. They honor that policy, too. Great customer service. It is why I keep going back. You have nothing to lose by trying the Quince one for a few months.
Amazon
amazon.com › Brooklinen-Alternative-Comforter-All-Season-Hypoallergenic › dp › B08KWJV93K
Amazon.com: Brooklinen All Season Luxury Down Alternative Comforter – Full/Queen Comforter Size, Cozy, Soft Bedding with 100% Cotton Sateen Shell, Vegan and Baffle Box Construction – Ideal for All Sleepers : Home & Kitchen
PREMIUM ALTERNATIVE FILL: Our Down Alternative Comforter is made with RPET (Recycled Polyethylene Terephthalate) microfiber sourced from recycled plastic bottles, providing a plush, vegan-friendly alternative to down.
Apartment Therapy
apartmenttherapy.com › brooklinen-all-season-down-alternative-comforter-review-37078551
I Tried the Brooklinen All-Season Down Alternative Comforter (My Honest Review) | Apartment Therapy
June 27, 2025 - I wasn’t looking for a comforter that was so light that it’d be too cool on colder nights, but I was afraid of leaning too far onto the warmer bedding side that it would totally defeat the purpose of my search. Thank goodness that all-year-round bedding options exist! I had the chance to try out the All-Season Down Alternative Comforter from Brooklinen and found out that it was exactly what I didn’t know I needed.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/bedding › been sleeping under brooklinen down comforter and sateen duvet cover for last few weeks. . .
Been sleeping under Brooklinen Down Comforter and Sateen Duvet Cover for last few weeks. . . : r/Bedding
May 9, 2022 - My only gripe so far was that I had a few loose threads on the comforter. For how much it costs it should definitely have 0 loose threads. I'm also using it with the Luxe duvet and I can definitely say that feels excellent. ... I'm almost 4 months in and I wash my sheets weekly and I like them. However, they do feel less substantial than other sheets and now I'm concerned my suspicions could be true. I LOVE the duvet. Here's my objective review and pics https://www.thebossysauce.com/thebs/brooklinen-bedding-vs-quince-sheets-review-brooklinen-vs-quince
eBay
ebay.com › home & garden › bedding › comforters & sets
BROOKLINEN LIGHTWEIGHT DOWN ALTERNATIVE COMFORTER 90" x 90" Full/Queen Hypoaller | eBay
BROOKLINEN LIGHTWEIGHT DOWN ALTERNATIVE COMFORTER 90" x 90" Full/Queen Hypoaller
Tap here for more details on BROOKLINEN LIGHTWEIGHT DOWN ALTERNATIVE COMFORTER 90" x 90" Full/Queen Hypoaller.
Price $167.99
Homes and Gardens
homesandgardens.com › shopping
I'd recommend the Brooklinen Down Comforter to (almost) anyone – here's how reviewing this lightweight layer went
I'd recommend the Brooklinen Down Comforter to (almost) anyone – here's how reviewing this lightweight…
I finally got my hands on the Brooklinen Down Comforter − it's the ultimate lightweight layer, but it won't suit cold sleepers or vegans
Architectural Digest
architecturaldigest.com › shopping › shopping › the best comforters and duvet inserts to grace your bed year-round
9 Best Comforters and Duvet Inserts, Tested by AD (2025) | Architectural Digest
November 21, 2025 - We’re big fans of Brooklinen, especially contributor Rebecca Grambone, who called this comforter “very high quality and luxurious and gave off strong hotel bed vibes.” Brooklinen’s high-quality bedding never disappoints, and their down comforter is no exception. It comes in three varieties: lightweight (650 fill power), all-season (700 fill power), and ultra-warm (750 fill power).