It sucks. Picked up for $18 at Costco. Does not look as tall/fluffy as the photo on the box. I let it open up for 6 hrs out of the plastic. Flimsy and too soft/weak. There is no support at all lol. Maybe it's suits some. But this is going to be returned. Answer from MrMach82 on reddit.com
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › tempur-pedic cloud pillow vs casper foam pillow?
r/Mattress on Reddit: Tempur-Pedic cloud pillow vs Casper foam pillow?
May 6, 2024 -

Hi all—I am looking for a new pillow! I currently have a down one from Brooklinen but it is not supportive at all for me. I've had pretty bad cervical neck pain. I did an MRI and found out I have mild arthritis in my neck. I know a pillow won't solve my pain but hopefully it can at least help!? I've settled on these two pillows and was wondering what you all thought?

I sleep mostly on my side and back. I am also on the smaller side so am not looking for anything with super high loft. Any help would be great! Looking to hear if anyone has any experiences with these pillows or which one they would recommend for me.

🌐
TikTok
tiktok.com › discover › costco-pillow-compare-tempurpedic-casper
Costco Pillow Compare Tempurpedic Casper | TikTok
December 1, 2025 - Tempur Pedic pillows, Costco, comfortable pillows, Tempur Pedic pillow Costco, feather pillows Costco, Costco cooling pillow, Costco serenity pillow, headboard pillow Costco ... These are NOTHING like the ones we tried in the store… Heavy as a brick, not comfy & dont even really cool…. Not refundable & we had no clue… @Tempur-Pedic do better Also terrible customer experience 0/10 would not recommend… They even came with a small stain 🤮 Not worth the $$$$ and now I’m stuck with them so I guess they’re just Mila’s pillows now #tempurpedic #pillows #donotbuy #customerservice
🌐
Sleepopolis
sleepopolis.com › home › mattress comparisons › casper vs tempur-pedic mattress comparison
Casper vs Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison (2026) | Sleepopolis
December 11, 2025 - Ever wondered how the Casper mattress compares to Tempur-pedic? Well it's time to find out! Read the full Casper vs Tempur-pedic mattress review here.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › casper vs costco casper in 2020...
r/Mattress on Reddit: Casper vs Costco Casper in 2020...
August 21, 2020 -

Has anyone tried both the 2020 version of the Casper Original AND the Casper Select from Costco? How do they compare in terms of feel?

Why I ask:
My fiance and I went to try the Casper at a local store today and actually loved it. While doing some more shopping though, we found that Costco also had a Casper Queen mattress that was $400~$500 cheaper than what Casper was offering both online and in-store.

Upon reaching out to Casper support to ask what the difference was, they told us that the Casper Select (Costco one) is in fact the older version of the current Original. The main differences are:
Casper Select/Older Original - 4 layers, top layer is breathable open cell foam, 12" height. Zip-off cover
Current Original - 3 layers, top layer has their new 'Airscape' foam for breathability. 11" height. They also removed the zipper on the cover so the top is no longer removable.

Again, I'm wondering if anyone's tried both of these and knows the difference in feel. We like the current original but if we can save $500 for a product that feels basically the exact same, then its a no-brainer. (Sleeping hot isn't an issue since it doesn't get crazy hot where we are)

-edit- To clarify, I havent tried the Costco Casper so dont know if it feels the same or not. Thats the part I'm hoping to get lucky and clarification on.

-edit2- The Costco Select Casper (aka the 2019 Casper Original) arrived two days ago. There was some chemical off-gassing scent, but not as much as others make it seem. It felt extremely soft during the first 24 hours and my body was slipping off everytime I sat on the edge.

48 hours later, it's definitely gotten more firm and is very close to the feel of the 2020 Casper we tried in stores. The edge support is also much better, although still lacking at the extreme edge of the bed (ie the last 2 inches).

I'll give it another 24 hours before making the call, but I'd say that the Costco was definitely the way to go vs the 2020 Original.

  • Similar edge support situation on both

  • Feel of 2019 is the same as the 2020 after expanding

  • 2019 still has the removable zipper-cover that got removed for the 2020

  • was $400 cheaper

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › any long-term costco tempurpedic supreme owners here? tried casper and avacado...
r/Mattress on Reddit: Any long-term Costco Tempurpedic Supreme owners here? Tried Casper and Avacado...
December 3, 2024 -

For context... I'm 6'0, 190lbs and have some si joint and lower back issues. I now know that I need a firm mattress for my back issues. I looked into building another DIY latex but I'm definitely not finding the $250 3" slabs that I used 8 years ago.

For the past 8 years, I've slept on a DIY Dunlop 12" latex mattress consisting of a 6" extra firm base, 3" firm, and 3" medium layers. It's now time to purchase a new mattress as one of the latex layers has separated/tore and in general feel that it's time to replace as a whole.

I've tried a Casper Wave Hybrid Snow and Avocado Green (firm or non-pillow top) mattress as a replacement but didn't get along with either. The Casper feels nice/plush when initially laying down for 5 minutes but after that, I sink in way too much and get lower back pain every morning as it is really really soft. The Avacado didn't feel as "premium or luxurious" as the Casper Wave but back pain was much less. However, the top comfort layer of latex is so thin, that I could literally feel the coils under my heaviest points when sleeping. They tried sending a 2" topper to use with it but it didn't help much. The zoning of the coils I didn't really like either. I also don't like the thick foam border that the Casper adds for edge stability as it causes me to roll towards the middle when you sleep close to the edge.

All that being said, I am tempted by the Tempurpedic Supreme Firm (all foam) at Costco. It's priced at $2200 and includes a $300 Costco gift card effectively making it $1,900. As with everything in life there are mixed reviews all over the internet for the Costco exclusive "Supreme" model.

It appears to be a mix of the Tempurpedic Adapt and ProAdapt models.

How are the quality of materials, durability long-term of the Supreme and also when compared to the Adapt and ProAdapt models solid officially by Tempurpedic?

Top answer
1 of 5
3
UPDATE: My Supreme medium was delivered a week earlier than expected and I've had it for two nights now. When you slap or smack the mattress with your hand, it has a very very firm/hard feel and the first night I thought that I actually slept well. The second night wasn't great. When I first lay down in a side position, my lower back and hips feel supported with some pressure on my shoulder. Then as time goes on, the hips continually sink-in as body heat warms up the foam and in the morning I had lower back pain. I took pictures laying on the mattress in a side sleeping position. The picture that was taken in 15 seconds shows a straight/aligned spine, no issues. Pictures taken after laying for 30 minutes shows the hips sinking in and an upwards curve of the spine similar to my old latex bed that became too soft over time. Don't know if I should try the firm Tempurpedic Supreme or move onto a different mattress altogether that has a zoned support system. Tempurpedic has the LuxeAdapt series which has a 5 zoned system but is way out of my budget. Looking at Costco, I see a new Novaform Legacy Premier ($1,200 king) that has a zoned support layer which is firmer in the middle which should in theory help with my problem but I think that's a cheaper or less durable brand 🙄
2 of 5
1
Being that you’re a heavier person, I would say the Supreme Firm should work just fine for you, as it not only will it offer the firm support you need while not too firm as tempur reliefs pressure points pretty well. The Supreme Firm is more like the Tempurpedic Adapt then the ProAdapt, what I don’t like about the Supreme Firm is that it uses Tempur ES as it’s transition layer, which doesn’t makes sense to me, however the top layer if very firm initially when you lay on the bed. So it’s not gonna be as firm as the ProAdapt but a little firmer the Adapt medium, so in between the two. This however might be a pro to you depending if you don’t like how firm the ProAdapt firm is. I would give it a try, I have the Tempurpedic Supreme Medium Hybrid, that mattress is basically the same as the adapt medium hybrid just with a cheaper cover I guess, the bed works well for me, I don’t think you’ll be disappointed going with Tempurpedic.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › tempur-pedic or casper?
r/Mattress on Reddit: Tempur-Pedic or Casper?
August 25, 2024 -

Looking to upgrade my mattress for the Labor Day sales. Am currently looking at the Casper Snow Max and TEMPUR-adapt and can’t make a decision, was wondering what people think between the two brands.

Top answer
1 of 2
3
From what I understand the Snow max uses lower density 2.5pcf memory foam, then has a couple of what are imo gimmicky cooling features such as graphite infused foam and phase change materials. It is a hybrid though and has air channels through the foam to allow heat to dissipate, so it still might not sleep especially hot. Then the Tempur adapt is their entry level mattress. It will have a polyfoam core instead of pocketed coils(unless you mean the adapt hybrid) and the memory foam Tempur uses will be a bit denser and higher quality. Especially once you start looking at their pro and luxe line of mattresses. I feel like Tempur overcharges quite a bit for what you are getting, but at least with them you know you're getting decent materials. The casper snow is also pretty expensive for what you are getting as well I would say. One downside to the all foam Tempur is it will likely build up heat much more than the Casper snow hybrid would. I would trust the durability of the Tempur more though. Another option Id like to throw out there, there is a company called Tempflow who makes mattresses to compete with TempurPedic. What I like about them is they are transparent about the materials in their mattresses, you know you will be getting nice high density foams and that they havent been decreasing the quality over the years like so many others have. What I dislike is the lack of feedback. This is a company that has been around for like 20 years and there is very little customer feedback online. You can find a few mentions on Reddit, a little bit more on The mattress underground, but thats really about it. Another option which I think is a great deal for the price, If you have an Original mattress Factory by where you live they sell the Serenity and Serenity Plush . This mattress has a super dense memory foam comfort layer, much more so than modern Tempur's even. 2" of 8lb memory foam, then 3" of 5lb memory foam, and a 2.25lb polyurethane foam base. imo if want to go Tempur Adapt and dont want their higher end mattresses. Look at the Costco models . With these you get Costco's return policy, which is basically they will take it back no questions asked, no return fees, no exchange only policy or sleep trials.
2 of 2
2
I would not recommend Casper. They are overpriced and use cheap materials.
🌐
Pillow Specialist
pillowspecialist.com › Tempur-Pedic-vs-Casper
Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Cloud Pillow vs. Casper Original Pillow: An In-depth, Hands-on Comparison
Extra soft but also extra thick. For back-sleepers who want a supportive, soft pillow ... The Casper Original Pillow uses a pillow-in-pillow design with two layers, both made of polyester fiber, at slightly different firmness levels. This creates a thick but soft pillow that is great for back-sleepers who want a polyester fiber pillow.
Find elsewhere
🌐
Reviewed
reviewed.com › sleep › features › casper-vs-tempur-pedic-which-well-known-brand-best
Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic: Which well-known brand is best? - Reviewed
October 15, 2021 - This winner also mainly comes down to one reason: The Casper Original mattress is not a good bed. In our opinion, it lacks a supportive and comfortable sleep surface, and our tester couldn’t wait to see it go. Nonetheless, if you’re bent on the podcast-sponsoring brand, you should consider its Costco-exclusive mattress, the Casper Select, which our tester loved.
🌐
GoodBed
goodbed.com › mattress-questions › 421 › help-choosing-the-right-memory-foam-mattress-from-costco
Mattress Question: "Help choosing the right memory foam mattress from Costco?" - GoodBed.com
I use a tempurpedic pillow which I can't live without, but can't afford that brand in mattress. I am seeking a medium firmness, not too soft not too hard. I would be using the mattress with slats, not using a box spring. Any help appreciated, I chose 3 from Costco below, please tell me why one is better for support and pain issues over another.
🌐
Mattress Clarity
mattressclarity.com › home › mattress comparison › casper vs tempur-pedic: which should you pick?
Casper vs Tempur-Pedic (2026 Update) - Mattress Clarity
Check out our latest Casper vs Tempur-Pedic mattress comparison where we discuss their construction, performance, and which is best for you!
Published   January 11, 2022
🌐
Mattress Nerd
mattressnerd.com › home › mattress comparison › casper vs tempurpedic mattress comparison
Casper vs Tempurpedic Mattress Comparison (2026) | Mattress Nerd
November 18, 2022 - The Casper original is a better fit for sleepers wanting more pressure relief and side sleepers too, while the Tempur-Adapt is better for couples and heavyweight sleepers.
🌐
Sleepopolis
sleepopolis.com › home › 10 best mattresses of 2026: over 500 tested by sleep experts › best costco mattresses (2026): a whole lot of quality at wholesale prices
Best Costco Mattresses (2026) - Tested by Experts
2 days ago - The TEMPUR-Contour is more pricey than other Costco mattress options. ... We rate each mattress on a scale from 1 to 5 to reflect its overall quality. This number is comprised of individual scores from hands-on testing of materials, firmness, ...
🌐
Sleep Foundation
sleepfoundation.org › mattress comparisons
Casper One vs. Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Adapt Mattress Comparison
March 24, 2025 - Choosing between Casper and Tempur-Pedic mattresses? Our comparison of their pricing, sizing, and performance puts these two powerhouse brands head-to-head.
🌐
College Confidential
talk.collegeconfidential.com › parent cafe
Tempurpedic? Casper? Purple? Any Reviiews? - Parent Cafe - College Confidential Forums
August 9, 2017 - It’s time to replace our old traditional mattress/box spring and foam topper. I’m leaning toward a memory foam type mattress. Not interested in any bed that requires electricity or is remote adjustable, so the Sleep Number bed isn’t in the running. We just want a firm (but not hard) support ...
🌐
Mattress
mattress.review › mattress reviews › costco mattress reviews
Costco Mattress Reviews [2025 Update] - Best Mattress Reviews
February 19, 2023 - The Casper mattress is a bit more firm than some of the other Costco Mattresses we’ve looked at. On a scale from 1 to 10, with 10 being the firmest, a Casper rates at about a 7. That means it’s going to be a good option for standard American sleepers, who generally expect a bed to have a firmness in the 6.5 range.
🌐
NapLab
naplab.com › home › best mattress 2026 – 380+ beds tested & reviewed by our experts › best costco mattress: we test 17 costco mattresses
Best Costco Mattress - 17 Mattresses Objectively Tested
June 27, 2025 - As far as price is concerned, this is one of the most affordable Tempurpedic models on the market. However, at $1,900, it is the most expensive model on this Costco list by a wide margin.
🌐
SleePare
sleepare.com › home › my pillow vs purple.4 vs tempurpedic cloud supreme breeze vs casper
My Pillow vs Purple.4 vs Tempurpedic Cloud Supreme Breeze vs Casper: Which One Is The Best For YOU? | SleePare
Comparison Tool analysis of My Pillow vs Purple.4 vs Tempurpedic Cloud Supreme Breeze vs Casper. Comparison of pricing, features, 5026 expert & 776 user insights - Best prices guaranteed!