Fiber cement @ 3x the cost to vinyl seems in the ballpark. Hard to say precisely without more details. Vinyl is one of the cheapest possible options and fiber cement is one of the most expensive possible options. You have steel, wood, and aluminum options in-between, with outliers here and there depending on location and precise product. Answer from spezizabitch on reddit.com
Reddit
reddit.com › r/homebuilding › vinyl siding vs. james hardie siding cost
r/Homebuilding on Reddit: Vinyl siding vs. James Hardie Siding Cost
March 12, 2021 -
I assume hardie plank is twice the material cost vs. average Vinyl siding?
For a 1,500 square foot new construction ranch vinyl siding came in between $13k-$15k.
What do you think I would cost for James Hardie Cement siding?
Mike
Top answer 1 of 5
16
👍Fiber-concrete siding is 50 year product. There are many brands(Hardie,LP, etc. ) to bid. You will not regret using fiber-concrete siding . I would never use vinyl.
2 of 5
5
My husband and I are building and we did hardie board it came in the color, no painting. It was 6800 more for that than vinyl on our 2000 sq ft
Alsco Metals
alscometals.com › homepage › blog › hardie board vs. vinyl siding: cost, durability, pros and cons
Hardie Board vs. Vinyl Siding
February 18, 2025 - A large Hardie Architectural Panel from the HZ5 series that is 4 feet by 8 feet costs about $43 per panel. A single panel from your average vinyl siding supplier will cost around $9 for a board that is 150 inches long and 8 inches wide (6 inches longer than the Hardie Plank board above).
Videos
05:08
James Hardie vs. Vinyl Siding: Which Is Best for Your Home? - YouTube
02:59
Cost of James Hardie Vs. Vinyl - YouTube
06:42
Vinyl Siding vs. FiberCement: Pros and Cons of Each - YouTube
08:41
Hardie Fiber Cement vs Vinyl Siding | Everything you need to know!
04:35
Vinyl Siding vs Fiber Cement Siding - YouTube
Elite Home Exteriors NW
elitehomeexteriorsnw.com › blog › siding › a price comparison: vinyl siding vs hardieplank
A Price Comparison: Vinyl Siding Vs HardiePlank- EHE
March 30, 2024 - Generally, installing HardiePlank ... The cost to have vinyl siding professionally installed starts at $3+ while the cost to have HardiePlank, or fiber cement siding, installed starts at $5+ per square foot....
Contract Exteriors
contractexteriors.com › posts › fact-or-fiction-james-hardie-siding-is-more-expensive-than-vinyl-siding
Fact or Fiction: James Hardie Board Siding Is More Expensive
It’s true that James Hardie siding is more expensive than vinyl siding. Vinyl siding is popular in part because it’s a very economical option. The cost of materials and installation for vinyl siding is lower than for Hardie .
Commonwealth Contractors
commonwealthcontracts.com › guides › hardie-board-vs-vinyl-siding
Hardie Board vs Vinyl Siding: A Decision Guide For Your Home Build
Hardie Board has a higher upfront cost, but its durability and long-term value can offset the initial investment, especially for those planning to stay in their home for many years.
Address 222 Court Square, 22902, Charlottesville
Reddit
reddit.com › r/homebuilding › hardie board vs. vinyl
r/Homebuilding on Reddit: Hardie Board vs. Vinyl
March 11, 2021 -
So, I’m building a home and have hit a snag. My contractor has informed me that we will not finish on time due to siding availability. He has 3 different options to choose from and I’m at an impasse. Vinyl siding (wrong color) at $0 increase, Hardie board facing with lap siding on sides and back of house at a $2500 increase (paint included), or Hardie board all around at $6500 increase (paint included). Which option would be the best or what are the pros and cons? This is our first home and I don’t want to choose wrong.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/homebuilding › upgrade cost for vinyl to hardie for new build?
r/Homebuilding on Reddit: Upgrade cost for vinyl to hardie for new build?
October 26, 2025 -
Hoping to get a gut check on the upgrade cost for vinyl (included) to hardie for my new build.
My build has approx 40-42 squares of exterior surface to cover. The home is pretty tall... approx 38ft tall to the ridge and has some minor complexity in the front with dormers.
I received a quote from the builder for +$50k to upgrade from vinyl to board and batten pre-finished hardie siding.
I am not too familiar with costs... so I am rough estimating the vinyl job is approx $25k ($600 per square, but is this accurate?) which would mean the total cost of the hardie job is approx $75k or ~$1800 per square.
Does this seem about right for the difference between the vinyl (included) and hardie cost?
Top answer 1 of 9
6
Fiber cement @ 3x the cost to vinyl seems in the ballpark. Hard to say precisely without more details. Vinyl is one of the cheapest possible options and fiber cement is one of the most expensive possible options. You have steel, wood, and aluminum options in-between, with outliers here and there depending on location and precise product.
2 of 9
3
I don't know about cost but we have Hardie board it's bullet proof. Takes paint well and doesn't peel.
Bogleheads.org
bogleheads.org › board index › community › personal consumer issues
re-siding house - vinyl or hardiplank? - Bogleheads.org
High Maintenance ... or plastic? ...seguy.com/vinyl-siding/ Low Maintenance ... deanbrew wrote: Mon Mar 05, 2018 4:12 pm I know cement board (Hardie is just one brand) has been EXTREMELY popular for several years, but the fact that it needs painting is a HUGE downside IMO. In that respect, it's similar to owning a house with wood siding, isn't it? Hardie says it won't need painting for 15 years, but I'm curious if that is true. And what is the cost to have it ...
Peakhomeexteriors
peakhomeexteriors.com › siding installation › vinyl siding vs. hardie board cost: a comprehensive comparison
Vinyl Siding vs. Hardie Board Cost: A Comprehensive Comparison
June 20, 2025 - In this section, we’ll break down the costs associated with vinyl siding and Hardie board, helping you understand the financial aspects of each option.
HomeAdvisor
homeadvisor.com › r › fiber-cement-vs-vinyl-siding
Fiber Cement and Hardie Board vs. Vinyl Siding: Which Is Better?
December 23, 2022 - When it comes to fiber cement siding versus vinyl, the biggest differences relate to their costs, aesthetics, and upkeep. Vinyl might be an affordable, low-maintenance option, but it doesn’t have the natural appearance of fiber cement (sometimes known as Hardie board).
Contract Exteriors
contractexteriors.com › posts › siding-showdown-vinyl-vs-hardie-board
Siding Showdown: Vinyl vs. Hardie Board Siding
Let’s break down the cost factors. Vinyl is the most budget-friendly siding option in most cases. Installed costs for basic vinyl siding and trim boards start around $6-8 per square foot.
Houzz
houzz.com › discussions › 6357210 › vinyl-siding-vs-hardee-board-siding
Vinyl Siding vs. Hardee Board Siding
That also means you may be trying to align product and installer, so you aren’t getting a someone who grudgingly tried to install Hardie board , does a crappy job and installer saying, see, this is why I don’t like Hardie. So in some communities there would not be good competition from which to select and that effectively limits your options. If you get one of the factory painted ( Or however they do it) colors then there’s no initial painting cost of course. Supposedly the finish lasts something like 10-20 years- I’d have to re-check that. You wouldn’t want to use the painting advice from a vinyl salesman since vinyl , “ never needs painting “is their baby.
WoodNet
forums.woodnet.net › showthread.php
Hardiboard type stuff vs premium vinyl?
Hello There, Guest! Login Register · Sponsored Content · Woodnet Forums › › Active › Home Improvement · « Previous 1 … 58 59 60 61 62 … 169 Next » · Hardiboard type stuff vs premium vinyl · Pages (3): 1 2 3 Next » · View a Printable Version · Subscribe to this thread · ...
Rennison Roofing
rennisonroofing.com › home › rennison roofing blog › cost of vinyl siding vs hardie board
Cost of Vinyl Siding vs Hardie Board - Rennison Roofing and Exteriors
September 21, 2023 - Even if you’re planning on moving, the longer life offered by Hardie Board helps with resale value. With an upfront cost just 25% higher than vinyl, but a lifespan that is more than double, James Hardie products are a sound investment for ...
Acadian Windows & Siding
acadianwindows.com › blog › james-hardie-siding › comparing-james-hardie-siding-cost-vs-vinyl
James Hardie Siding Cost vs. Vinyl: Which Offers Better Value? - Acadian Windows & Siding
March 5, 2025 - James Hardie Fiber Cement Siding costs vary a little more since there are a variety of different kinds. Those who choose Hardie Board can expect to pay $5 to $15 a square foot after material and labor costs.
Sidingcost
sidingcost.org › home › vinyl siding vs. fiber cement siding cost: side by side comparison
Vinyl Siding vs. Fiber Cement Siding Cost: Side by Side Comparison
May 16, 2023 - Premium vinyl or insulated foam-back vinyl will run $9.50 to $12.50 per sq.ft. installed. Expect to pay between $11.00 to $14.00 per square foot for the installation of standard fiber cement siding like HardiePlank or Allura.
Facebook
facebook.com › groups › AskCalgarians › posts › 1709960776444930
What is the cost difference between Hardie board and vinyl ...
We cannot provide a description for this page right now
SmardBuild
smardbuild.com › blog › hardie-board-vs-vinyl-siding
Hardie Board vs Vinyl Siding: Which is Better for Your Chicago Home? | SmardBuild
May 15, 2025 - Over time, the reduced need for ... option for long-term homeowners. Vinyl siding is more budget-friendly, typically costing between $3 to $7 per square foot, including installation....
New Look Roof
newlookroofs.com › new-look-roof-blog › pros-and-cons-of-hardie-board-vs-vinyl
Pros and Cons of Hardie Board vs Vinyl Siding • New Look Roof Blog • Louisville, Kentucky — New Look Roof
December 29, 2023 - Not only is the material itself more costly because of its composition and quality, but the price of installation is also higher. The biggest reason for the price difference between Hardie board and vinyl siding is the challenges that come with installing it on your home.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/carpentry › vinyl siding or hardi board siding?
r/Carpentry on Reddit: Vinyl siding or hardi board siding?
October 28, 2022 -
My 23 year old house needs a new exterior. It currently has vinyl siding and I’m not a huge fan of it. I’m considering hardy board and I would like the sub Reddit’s opinion on which is better. Thanks and I appreciate the response.