🌐
Reviewed
reviewed.com › sleep › features › costco-casper-select-vs-casper-original
Casper Select vs. Casper Original: The Costco version is leagues ahead - Reviewed
March 12, 2024 - The Casper Select memory foam mattress is a well-deserved challenger to the Original. Its price is seldom discounted—this is Costco, after all—but it’s already far cheaper than the Original. The mattress starts at $549 for a full (Costco doesn’t carry a twin or twin XL), and goes up to $649 for a queen or $849 for a king or California king.
🌐
Casper
casper.ca › en › casper-vs-costco-select
The Casper vs. Costco Casper Select Cooling Memory Foam Mattress
Thankfully, both Casper and Costco offer comprehensive mattress warranties to customers. All Casper mattresses are built to last. However, in the event that something goes wrong, you can rest easy knowing that your Casper Canada mattress is backed by a 10-year warranty. In other words, for ten years following your mattress purchase, you can receive a complimentary replacement or repair of the original product if a covered manufacturing defect arises.
People also ask

Can you purchase the Casper Select Mattress without a Costco membership?

No, the Casper Select Mattress can only be purchased through Costco. It needs to be purchased online, but you will have to sign into your Costco account to be able to make the purchase. If you don’t want to pay for the annual membership fee, you may be able to purchase the Casper Select Mattress with a membership trial. Make sure to check out your options on the Costco website to make sure.

🌐
madeinca.ca
madeinca.ca › home › reviews › mattress comparisons › casper original vs casper select mattress in canada
Casper Original vs Casper Select Mattress in Canada (2024) | Made ...
Which mattress is best for co-sleepers?

Between the Casper Original and the Casper Select, the Casper Select does a better job at motion isolation for those that co-sleep. Featuring an extra layer of transition foam, the Casper Select helps prevent motion transfer, ensuring a peaceful night’s sleep even with restless partners. Single sleepers may have better luck with the Casper Original, which comes in a Twin size.

🌐
madeinca.ca
madeinca.ca › home › reviews › mattress comparisons › casper original vs casper select mattress in canada
Casper Original vs Casper Select Mattress in Canada (2024) | Made ...
Which mattress is best for long-term durability?

Though similarly constructed, the Casper Select has the edge over the Casper Original for long-term durability. The Casper Select features an extra foam layer, helping prevent overall mattress breakdown over time. The Casper Select is also a great choice for those who need consistent support over time.

🌐
madeinca.ca
madeinca.ca › home › reviews › mattress comparisons › casper original vs casper select mattress in canada
Casper Original vs Casper Select Mattress in Canada (2024) | Made ...
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › casper vs costco casper in 2020...
r/Mattress on Reddit: Casper vs Costco Casper in 2020...
August 19, 2020 -

Has anyone tried both the 2020 version of the Casper Original AND the Casper Select from Costco? How do they compare in terms of feel?

Why I ask:
My fiance and I went to try the Casper at a local store today and actually loved it. While doing some more shopping though, we found that Costco also had a Casper Queen mattress that was $400~$500 cheaper than what Casper was offering both online and in-store.

Upon reaching out to Casper support to ask what the difference was, they told us that the Casper Select (Costco one) is in fact the older version of the current Original. The main differences are:
Casper Select/Older Original - 4 layers, top layer is breathable open cell foam, 12" height. Zip-off cover
Current Original - 3 layers, top layer has their new 'Airscape' foam for breathability. 11" height. They also removed the zipper on the cover so the top is no longer removable.

Again, I'm wondering if anyone's tried both of these and knows the difference in feel. We like the current original but if we can save $500 for a product that feels basically the exact same, then its a no-brainer. (Sleeping hot isn't an issue since it doesn't get crazy hot where we are)

-edit- To clarify, I havent tried the Costco Casper so dont know if it feels the same or not. Thats the part I'm hoping to get lucky and clarification on.

-edit2- The Costco Select Casper (aka the 2019 Casper Original) arrived two days ago. There was some chemical off-gassing scent, but not as much as others make it seem. It felt extremely soft during the first 24 hours and my body was slipping off everytime I sat on the edge.

48 hours later, it's definitely gotten more firm and is very close to the feel of the 2020 Casper we tried in stores. The edge support is also much better, although still lacking at the extreme edge of the bed (ie the last 2 inches).

I'll give it another 24 hours before making the call, but I'd say that the Costco was definitely the way to go vs the 2020 Original.

  • Similar edge support situation on both

  • Feel of 2019 is the same as the 2020 after expanding

  • 2019 still has the removable zipper-cover that got removed for the 2020

  • was $400 cheaper

🌐
NapLab
naplab.com › home › mattress reviews › casper select review
Casper Select Review - 10 Objective & Data-Driven Tests - NapLab
Casper Select Review
The Casper Select mattress is a 12″ foam mattress that is sold exclusively at Costco. It is designed as a budget-friendly alternative to the Casper Original and has a balanced feel with a medium-firm firmness. Update - This mattress has been discontinued. For Casper on a budget, click here to check out our review of the Casper One foam mattress. 8.12 Overall Score Tested With Scoring System 1.3 8.0 Cooling 7.0 Motion Transfer 9.0 Response Time 9.1 Edge Support 7.5 Sex 8.0 Pressure Relief 8.1 Off-Gassing 9.0 Company Learn how we test & sco
Rating: 4.1 ​
🌐
TechRadar
techradar.com › health & fitness › sleep › mattresses
CostCo? Amazon? Casper direct? This is the best place to buy a Casper mattress on Black Friday | TechRadar
November 23, 2023 - The main difference in build is that the Casper Select has an extra layer of pressure-relief foam. This gives it slightly better motion isolation, but less response. The Casper Select also resembles the Casper Original (see how we ...
🌐
Made in CA
madeinca.ca › home › reviews › mattress comparisons › casper original vs casper select mattress in canada
Casper Original vs Casper Select Mattress in Canada (2024) | Made in CA
August 26, 2025 - Mattresses shipped directly from Casper will come from North American warehouses, whereas the Casper Select ships from Costco locations throughout Canada. You may wait a little longer for the Casper Original Mattress when compared to the Casper ...
🌐
Mattress Nerd
mattressnerd.com › home › mattress reviews › casper select mattress review
Casper Select Mattress Review | Mattress Nerd
November 21, 2023 - The Casper Select and the original Casper are similar to each other: both are all foam mattresses with a similar feel and construction. However, the Casper Select is a Costco exclusive (and more affordable than the original).
🌐
Mattress Clarity
mattressclarity.com › home › mattress reviews
Casper Select Mattress Review – A Great Costco Bed?
The main construction difference is that the Casper Select features an additional memory foam layer below the top layer. Besides this, their constructions are nearly identical. The mattresses are also identical in terms of firmness and feel.
Published   March 6, 2025
Find elsewhere
🌐
Forbes
forbes.com › forbes homepage › forbes vetted › mattress & sleep › mattresses
Casper Original Mattress Review: All About The Internet’s Most Popular Mattress
October 2, 2025 - No, the Casper Select is similar to the Casper Original, but it’s a different mattress sold exclusively at Costco. It’s an all-foam mattress with a soft, stretchy cover that can be zipped off for easy cleaning. Similar to Casper mattresses sold directly on the brand’s site, the Casper ...
🌐
Sleepopolis
sleepopolis.com › home › mattress reviews › casper select mattress review
Casper Select Mattress Review (2026) | Sleepopolis
Casper Select Mattress Sleepopolis Score
Calling all Costco shoppers — there’s a mattress waiting for you in the bedding aisle. The Casper Select mattress is meant to be a similar version of the popular Casper Original, but is exclusively sold through Costco (so you can only get it with a Costco membership). Exclusively sold at Costco, the all-foam Casper Select mattress is meant to be a similar version of the popular Casper Original and is designed to bring sleepers both support and pressure relief.
Rating: 4.1 ​
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/costcocanada › casper mattresses from costco
r/CostcoCanada on Reddit: Casper Mattresses from Costco
September 16, 2023 -

I'm in the market for a King Casper mattress & I see that it's $400-$600 cheaper than from Casper direct, or Sleep Country.

Does anyone know if the CostCo Casper is identical to the mattress from the manufacturer direct, or is it a CostCo special version with maybe a few corners cut?

TIA

🌐
House Beautiful
housebeautiful.com › shopping › furniture › casper mattresses have finally landed at costco—and they're cheap
Casper's Discontinued Memory Foam Mattress Is Back (and Super Cheap) at Costco
August 9, 2023 - So if you need an excuse to join the Costco club, here it is: The beloved memory foam Select mattress is $800 (for a king!). Though it has been discontinued by the brand, the most similar available alternative, The Casper, is $1,395 for the same size (it's currently on sale for $1,255).
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/costco › new casper select "cooling" mattress spotted
r/Costco on Reddit: New Casper Select "Cooling" Mattress Spotted
February 15, 2024 - Agreed, not a fan of foam mattresses but I know a lot of people who swear by their Caspers and this should at least be a slight improvement over the older model. ... They are only worth it for the price IMO, they are usually comfortable enough but nothing really special ... Not good for people with back problems or hot sleepers in my experience. ... I got a Dormeo through Costco a long time ago and it had a cooling top.
🌐
Costco
costco.ca › home › casper mattresses
Casper Mattresses | Costco
Casper Mattresses · Suggestions: Check for typos and spelling errors · Try more general keywords · Try different keywords · Costco carries items in our warehouses which may not be available online. Visit your local Costco warehouse for current product inventory and to see if we stock what you are looking for.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/costco › current sale on casper mattress - what's your experience?
r/Costco on Reddit: Current sale on Casper mattress - what's your experience?
September 16, 2025 -

Has anyone grabbed this mattress off the current sale? I have a old Casper I really like but am looking to upgrade to a Queen and $120 off is great

I like my current Casper because it’s firm and not bouncy, so motion transfer is minimal

Also curious if people have experience hauling it home from warehouse. Does it fit in your car? Thanks!

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › need advice: difference between casper 'original hybrid mattress' and 'casper select hybrid memory foam mattress' (costco version)
r/Mattress on Reddit: Need advice: Difference between Casper 'Original Hybrid Mattress' and 'Casper Select Hybrid Memory Foam Mattress' (Costco version)
December 24, 2023 -

So I'm a side sleeper with a very firm mattress that has been screwing up my shoulder/upper back for almost a year; I tested out a casper hybrid mattress in store and it felt very soft/plush but still with some support.

(Ive tried several toppers for my firm mattress before including the casper one and sink right through / hate them!)

I know the costco casper hybrid version is different (and some reddit reviews says its firm, which I likely dont want) but Im wondering if anyone knows the actual difference between these 2 models, besides the price...

any advice or knowledge would be much appreciated!

🌐
RedFlagDeals
forums.redflagdeals.com › costco-casper-select-memory-foam-mattress-599-queen-2690880
[Costco] Casper Select Memory Foam Mattress ($599 Queen) - RedFlagDeals.com Forums
May 10, 2024 - They offer better cooling properties and better value for money if you get a deal <$1000 for good mattresses (dont buy anything over $1000ish range or you're getting scammed with snake oil, under <$500 usually means it wont be a long term mattress if it comes in a box and the warranty is the only thing that'll save you with some other companies - Goodmorning who makes the Juno has replaced one of mine with a brand new one and offered me 50% off any future mattress when they didnt need to, a fair and stand up company in the corrupt and crooked mattress world - based in Alberta btw. Casper's original retail price was never justified, and it remains overpriced compared to its competitors. Costco provides a safer option with their return policy, allowing you to try out the mattress before committing.
🌐
Slumber Search
slumbersearch.com › costco-mattress-reviews
Costco Mattress Reviews: Guide To The Best Brands (2025)
The Costco Casper mattress is based on their original mattress design, which is no longer sold directly by Casper. Its benefit is its affordable price for the brand name.