I have a DIY setup that will meet anybodys needs. Let me find the post. brb Answer from Possible_Usual6146 on reddit.com
🌐
Casper Sleep
casper.com › home › dreamer's digest › dreamer's digest
Foam vs. Spring Mattress: Which Is Best for You? | Casper Blog
March 11, 2022 - Here’s a quick breakdown of each ... both innerspring and foam mattresses can suit your sleep position Back Pain: foam is great for back pain, and higher-end innerspring mattresses may provide relief...
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/mattress › should i move to a spring mattress or give another try with a foam?
r/Mattress on Reddit: Should I move to a spring mattress or give another try with a foam?
January 1, 2025 -

Hello,

I’ve spent my whole life sleeping on spring mattresses—both cheap and expensive ones—without any issues. However, when I moved out and started living on my own, I switched to foam mattresses. I first tried one from IKEA and later a $300 one from Amazon, but both became saggy after 2–3 years and started causing back and neck pain.

I thought the problem was due to buying cheaper mattresses, so about three years ago, I invested in a Tempur-Pedic LuxeAdapt Firm. At the time, there were only two options (soft and firm) and I chose the firm one, assuming it would last longer and resist sagging. I even purchased their matching bed base.

Now, here I am with a mattress that sags in the center and feels nothing like it did when I first tested it at Mattress Firm. I’m experiencing neck pain and feel like I sleep much better on spring mattresses, as I noticed when using one during a recent trip.

  1. Could it be that memory foam mattresses just aren’t a good fit for me?

  2. Do you have any recommendations for spring or foam mattresses that won’t sag or cause pain? I’m willing to pay whatever it takes for a mattress that lets me sleep through the night and wake up pain-free.

Discussions

Should I move to a spring mattress or give another try with a foam?
I have a DIY setup that will meet anybodys needs. Let me find the post. brb More on reddit.com
🌐 r/Mattress
34
14
January 1, 2025
Spring Better Support Then Foam?
I had a similar thing happen. Slept at a hotel with an old crappy spring mattress and felt better then my 4 year old crappy $239 Amazon Basics memory foam mattress. I'm switching to the WinkBed hybrid instead of Sedona Elite since it is a little cheaper. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/Mattress
31
46
August 19, 2023
People also ask

What is the best mattress type for back pain?
There’s no one best mattress type for back pain, but generally mattresses that provide a combination of pressure relief and support are ideal. This makes hybrids and latex hybrids good, since these beds tend to offer a close conforming comfort layer that relieves pressure, while at the same time having a study coil support core underneath. I would avoid soft all-foam beds or overly firm innerspring beds.
🌐
sleepfoundation.org
sleepfoundation.org › best mattress
The Best Mattress for Back Pain in 2026: Expert Tested
Is a firm or soft mattress better for back pain?
This really depends on you. Since back pain relief is all about proper support and spinal alignment, your sleeping position and weight will determine whether a firm or soft mattress is right for you. As a general rule of thumb, the heavier you are, the firmer a mattress you need. Back and stomach sleepers also tend to prefer firm mattresses, whereas side sleepers like something a little more plush. Refer to the “Sleep Ratings” section in the above product cards to see whether a bed fits your needs.
🌐
sleepfoundation.org
sleepfoundation.org › best mattress
The Best Mattress for Back Pain in 2026: Expert Tested
Can a mattress topper help with back pain
In some ways, a mattress topper can help with back pain, particularly by adding pressure relief to the surface of the bed. A close conforming foam or latex mattress topper can relieve pressure on your body, easing pain. That being said, most pain caused by mattresses result in poor support and spinal alignment, which a topper isn’t going to fix.
🌐
sleepfoundation.org
sleepfoundation.org › best mattress
The Best Mattress for Back Pain in 2026: Expert Tested
🌐
Sleep Foundation
sleepfoundation.org › best mattress
The Best Mattress for Side Sleepers in 2026: Expert Tested
Back sleepers up to 230 pounds and stomach sleepers under 130 pounds also found the CopperFlex comfortable and adequately supportive. The medium firm (6) feel with plush surface layers and zoned support ensures a balanced design with consistent pain and pressure relief. Our tests also show the mattress is a strong choice for couples due to its excellent motion isolation. All six foam layers absorb movement and prevent ripples of motion transfer from traveling across the surface, so you should be able to change sleep positions or get up during the night without waking your partner — and vice versa.
Published   5 days ago
🌐
Sleep Foundation
sleepfoundation.org › best mattress
The Best Mattress for Back Pain in 2026: Expert Tested
Feel: Responsive give and take coupled with a plushness in the top layers gives you balanced support and comfort for your back, hips, and shoulders. What It’s Made Of: Zoned pocketed coils with thicker springs around the edge of the bed. Most models feature an adaptive polyfoam surface layer and a layer of denser foam. The Plus models feature zoned latex. What We Don’t Like: Can be too firm for some. Heavy and can be difficult both to move and to find sheets that won’t pop off during the night. ... The following ratings show how suitable this mattress is for different sleeping positions and sleeper weights.
Published   5 days ago
🌐
The Telegraph
telegraph.co.uk › recommended › sleep › best-mattress-back-pain
The best mattresses for back pain in 2026, recommended by an osteopath
5 days ago - “Keeping the spine, neck and mid-back aligned theoretically means your muscles are going to relax.” · Soft mattresses, he warns, may worsen the pain by allowing the spine to dip out of alignment. At the right firmness, both pocket sprung and memory foam mattresses can be effective. “What you really need is good support from springs or foam, and which type you choose is a personal preference,” says Gibson.
🌐
Mattress Clarity
mattressclarity.com › home › best mattress
Best Mattresses for Back Pain (2026) - We Tested 500+ Beds
The Helix Midnight Luxe is a hybrid mattress that features a plush mattress topper, multiple proprietary foams, and innerspring coils so any sleeper can feel supported and comfortable while they rest. Currently, you can order it with an ErgoAlign layer—an upgraded top layer of foam that’s denser and firmer underneath your lower back and midsection. This additional support for the lumbar spine can be a reliable defense against back pain.
Published   1 day ago
Find elsewhere
🌐
B&Q
diy.com › home › ideas & advice › home & furnishing › bedroom › foam vs spring mattress
Choosing between foam vs spring mattress at B&Q
Spring mattresses are firm, durable, and breathable - great for deep sleepers or those needing extra support. If you’re comparing foam vs spring for back pain, springs offer firmer resistance, while foam moulds to ease pressure points.
🌐
Leesa
leesa.com › home › blog › how to choose between a memory foam vs. spring vs. hybrid mattress
Memory Foam vs Spring vs Hybrid | Leesa Sleep
October 28, 2025 - Spring mattresses tend to be less expensive than foam or memory foam. Metal coils offer less back support and pressure relief than foam beds.
🌐
The Independent
independent.co.uk › extras › indybest › home & garden › mattresses
Best mattresses for better rest in 2026, tested by The Independent’s sleep expert | The Independent
1 week ago - With her expert insight, Lauren ... foam and pocket springs. The mattress is separated into five sections to provide “different levels of support for each area of the body: head, shoulders, lower back, thighs and feet,” she wrote in her review. “So, as long as you don’t sleep in any strange positions (i.e. your head where your feet should be), you’re sure to have just the right amount of support needed to sleep soundly. And none of the usual nagging neck or back pains were felt ...
🌐
NYTimes
nytimes.com › sleep › mattresses › the best mattress for back pain
The 5 Best Mattress for Back Pain of 2026 | Reviews by Wirecutter
3 weeks ago - Who it’s for: Time after time, the Saatva Classic Mattress (Luxury Firm) comes out on top in our testing. It’s a great innerspring choice that works well for people with back pain who need to easily shift positions to get comfortable, and it’s suitable for sleepers of most shapes and sizes. We also love the foam-and-fiber Euro top, which provides a pillowy place for sore joints to land.
🌐
Sleep Foundation
sleepfoundation.org › best mattress
Best Innerspring Mattresses of 2025: Coil & Spring Support
With a stunning 15-inch profile, seven inches of which are polyfoam found in the comfort layer, the Nolah Evolution 15 is a highly durable mattress. Beneath that are 8-inch coils to give the bed more support. If longevity is your main concern, going with the firmer of the three options may extend the life a bit more. Otherwise, you can generally expect around eight or nine years of comfort. ... The Nolah Evolution 15 is a luxury Euro-top hybrid with a balanced feel we found extremely effective at reducing back pain. The thick foam comfort system has an adaptive feel that closely contours to the body to alleviate pressure-prone areas, while the robust coil system helps you maintain healthy sleep posture.
Published   3 weeks ago
🌐
Nectar Sleep
nectarsleep.com › posts › memory-foam-vs-spring-mattress
Memory Foam vs Spring Mattress - Pros, Cons & Differences
Offset coil and pocket coil spring mattresses are often best for back pain because they offer a reliable combination of conformity, softness, and bounciness. Experts suggest a memory foam mattress for reducing back pain significantly. Memory ...
🌐
Sleep Advisor
sleepadvisor.org › home › mattress information
Memory Foam or Spring Mattress? Which Is Better For You?
September 24, 2024 - Hybrids are often a popular choice for people torn between the two since many hybrid beds include coils and memory foam. ... Most high-quality innerspring beds should help mitigate back pain. The steel coils in their construction offer solid support, especially in firmer models. Good body support is key to treating back pain, which often arises from poor spine alignment. ... Some people say they can never return to spring mattresses after using foam-based ones.
🌐
DreamCloud
dreamcloudsleep.com › posts › memory-foam-vs-spring-mattress
Memory Foam Vs Spring Mattress
If you are one of them who complains about back pains, then a convoluted foam mattress seems like a good choice. Spring mattresses were introduced in 1871 and became popular due to their bouncing property.
🌐
Medical News Today
medicalnewstoday.com › articles › memory-foam-vs-spring
Memory foam vs. spring mattress: Side by side comparison
August 28, 2020 - The thickness, number, and type of coil vary between different spring mattresses. Layers of foam or natural fibers give the mattress further cushioning and provide comfort. They also improve back support.
🌐
NCOA
ncoa.org › product-resources › sleep › best-mattresses-for-back-pain
Best Mattresses for Older Adults With Back Pain in 2026
3 weeks ago - In general, the best mattresses for pressure relief on your back are hybrid or memory foam, as they provide an ideal mix of comfort from the foam and support from the springs. A mattress with good pressure-relieving properties on the back can ...
🌐
My Next Mattress
mynextmattress.co.uk › blog › foam-or-spring-mattress-which-one-is-better
Foam or Spring Mattress - Which One is Better? | My Next Mattress Blog
August 12, 2025 - While both types of mattresses offer excellent support there is a difference in the type of support they provide. Spring mattresses have firmer support which makes them better for people with aches and back pain...
🌐
Mysleepyhead
mysleepyhead.com › blog › orthopedic-vs-spring-mattress
What's the Best Mattress for You: Orthopaedic or Spring?
Shop best quality mattresses, beds, sofa sets and recliners online. Get free delivery, up to 100 night trial and 10 years warranty, only on Sleepyhead
🌐
Forbes
forbes.com › forbes homepage › forbes vetted › mattress & sleep › mattresses
The Best Mattresses For Back Pain: These Beds Offer Superior Support
Unlike most cooling mattresses that have a handful of temperature-regulating features, the Aurora Luxe has one in nearly every layer. Its hybrid design also makes it a great fit for people with back pain—the coils offer exceptional support, while the comfort foam layers up top excel at pressure relief.
Published   1 month ago
🌐
SleePare®
sleepare.com › sleepare blog › foam vs spring mattress [2025 guide]
Foam vs Spring Mattress [12 Pros & Cons]
December 10, 2025 - Commonly, spring mattresses offer ... Foam Mattress: Foam mattresses alleviate back pain because layers of foam offer continuous support and do an excellent job of maintaining healthy spinal alignment....