Hi all,
Currently embarking on my first "professional" python module build for work. Plenty of scripts and the odd python module for personal use or minor things, but this is "the big one".
We were talking about which docstring format to use. I like the Numpydoc format, mostly because I use a lot of Numpy/Scipy/Astropy and thats the format I see a lot, while my colleague prefers Google format. Nothing major, and I am tempted to go Google format just to align with another team's project.
But I found this article which gives a table of several docstring formats. Both Google and Numpy are accepted by Sphynx (which is great), but it says that Numpy has a Formal Specification while Google does not. Yet I cant find any mention in the rest of the article about what that actually means.
I would assume its something like Numpydoc being more rigid in what you call things, but Google seems pretty rigid to me. What am I missing? (And does anyone here have a preference between the two?)
My company is currently deciding between using ReST or the Google style for writing docstrings. What do you all use? What do you like/dislike about it?
Formats
Python docstrings can be written following several formats as the other posts showed. However the default Sphinx docstring format was not mentioned and is based on reStructuredText (reST). You can get some information about the main formats in this blog post.
Note that the reST is recommended by the PEP 287
There follows the main used formats for docstrings.
- Epytext
Historically a javadoc like style was prevalent, so it was taken as a base for Epydoc (with the called Epytext format) to generate documentation.
Example:
"""
This is a javadoc style.
@param param1: this is a first param
@param param2: this is a second param
@return: this is a description of what is returned
@raise keyError: raises an exception
"""
- reST
Nowadays, the probably more prevalent format is the reStructuredText (reST) format that is used by Sphinx to generate documentation. Note: it is used by default in JetBrains PyCharm (type triple quotes after defining a method and hit enter). It is also used by default as output format in Pyment.
Example:
"""
This is a reST style.
:param param1: this is a first param
:param param2: this is a second param
:returns: this is a description of what is returned
:raises keyError: raises an exception
"""
Google has their own format that is often used. It also can be interpreted by Sphinx (ie. using Napoleon plugin).
Example:
"""
This is an example of Google style.
Args:
param1: This is the first param.
param2: This is a second param.
Returns:
This is a description of what is returned.
Raises:
KeyError: Raises an exception.
"""
Even more examples
- Numpydoc
Note that Numpy recommend to follow their own numpydoc based on Google format and usable by Sphinx.
"""
My numpydoc description of a kind
of very exhautive numpydoc format docstring.
Parameters
----------
first : array_like
the 1st param name `first`
second :
the 2nd param
third : {'value', 'other'}, optional
the 3rd param, by default 'value'
Returns
-------
string
a value in a string
Raises
------
KeyError
when a key error
OtherError
when an other error
"""
Converting/Generating
It is possible to use a tool like Pyment to automatically generate docstrings to a Python project not yet documented, or to convert existing docstrings (can be mixing several formats) from a format to an other one.
Note: The examples are taken from the Pyment documentation
The Google style guide contains an excellent Python style guide. It includes conventions for readable docstring syntax that offers better guidance than PEP-257. For example:
def square_root(n):
"""Calculate the square root of a number.
Args:
n: the number to get the square root of.
Returns:
the square root of n.
Raises:
TypeError: if n is not a number.
ValueError: if n is negative.
"""
pass
I like to extend this to also include type information in the arguments, as described in this Sphinx documentation tutorial. For example:
def add_value(self, value):
"""Add a new value.
Args:
value (str): the value to add.
"""
pass