CARBXN Works
carbxn.com.au › blogs › news › hall-effect-vs-tmr-thumbsticks
Hall Effect vs TMR Thumbsticks – CARBXN Works
October 10, 2024 - As the thumbstick moves, magnets ... on-screen. TMR Electromagnetic Thumbsticks: Tunneling Magnetoresistance (TMR) is another electromagnetic effect but operates differently....
HYPR Controllers
hyprcontrollers.com › home › hall effect vs tmr thumbsticks – anti-drift performance explained
Hall Effect vs TMR Thumbsticks – Anti-Drift Performance Explained - HYPR Controllers
May 18, 2025 - Hall Effect and potentiometer sticks both read analog positions precisely, but Hall Effect ensures minimal drift over time, maintaining consistent recentering for peak performance.
tmr vs hall effect what is better
If you are talking about the present, the potential for TMR is higher than Hall Effects. However, at the moment, TMR is benefiting only a year of research/implementation (for controllers--it's been used in other industries for decades) while Hall Effects has had a few years (while Potentiometers have decades). This is like asking if you prefer a 6th-level Fighter vs. a 1st-level Wizard. Also in practice, it's not reliable to generalize. Different companies manufacture different models of both Hall Effect sensors and TMR. Each model will perform differently compared to other models. Not all Hall Effect modules are identical, just as not all TMR modules are identical. This is like asking if SSDs are better than HDDs and then you go out and buy a DRAM-less SSD that doesn't use SLC/MLC/TLC as a buffer, and are surprised that it gives out in a year or so. More on reddit.com
13
4
September 21, 2024Hall effect vs TMR; What is the real difference for a normal player?
Ohw prepare to be bombarded with comments about TMR being the best thing since sliced bread. I have been saying exactly this for a while now. 99% of normal gamers will never experience any difference. The biggest difference is in the tension and linearity of the stick. I install both hall and tmr and I use tmr since they use less lower and the cheap ones are practically the same price. But most people want aknes X halpi tmr since these are the most to the original alps and they come with pretty decent thumb caps. More on reddit.com
38
7
September 21, 2025Difference between Hall effect and TMR joysticks in actual use?
Tmr are lower power, less prone to interference and more precise and require smaller magnets Tmr sticks commonly come in 12bit where most halls are 8bit. Xbox is 10bit alps and Sony uses 9bit alps. Vader 4 pro uses 12bit halls though. In actual gameplay 12bit tmr vs 12bit hall should feel similar. But most halls are not 12 while most tmr are 12. Tmr allows more controller features due to less power constraints and often means better latency but too many variables go into that. Halls are just getting good now while tmr are just coming to market. Vader 4 was first hall effect to beat alps in precision. Now tmr are here and Vader 5 pro will be tmr next year. More on reddit.com
24
8
July 8, 2024Is hall effect starting to get replaced by tmr sticks?
Both "Hall Effect" and "TMR" are buzz words with hype surrounding them. The reason TMR is around is because Hall Effects didn't live up to the hype--to a certain extent--in the first place. However, most people are focused on the buzzwords instead of nuanced discussions--in the same sense that some people look at 1K (or now, 8K) polling rates and presume those controllers have low latency when that is not necessarily the case. The reality is, there are different implementations of Hall Effects and TMR, in the same way that there are different implementations of Bluteooth and 2.4 Ghz dongles--all of which lead to different results from manufacturer to manufacturer, from brand to brand. Compounding this is focusing solely on the module used; unless you are modding your controller--in which case the joystick module used can be isolated--usually what makes a controller great is a variety of factors, including the hardware and the software. If a controller has low latency and great precision, it's not solely because of the joystick module used, but includes the other factors as well. For example, in 2024, some of the "best" controllers are the 8BitDo Ultimate 2C, Flydigi Vader 4 Pro, and Gamesir Cyclone 2. Two out of the three controllers use Hall Effects. More on reddit.com
73
33
January 15, 2025What is the difference between Hall effect and TMR joysticks?
While both make use of magnets, Hall Effect sensors send signals based on the voltage difference when a magnetic field is applied across a semiconductor material. TMR joysticks, on the other hand, work on the phenomenon of tunneling magneto-resistance effect, where the electrical resistance changes when a magnetic field is applied.
gamerant.com
gamerant.com › home › explainer › tmr vs hall effect joysticks explained
TMR vs Hall Effect Joysticks Explained
What is the difference between Alps and TMR?
ALPS makes potentiometer thumbsticks which is an older standard for controllers. TMR is a different type of magnetic sensing technology that works similar to Hall Effect but is even more accurate and power efficient.
gamerant.com
gamerant.com › home › explainer › tmr vs hall effect joysticks explained
TMR vs Hall Effect Joysticks Explained
Videos
10:28
Hall Effect VS TMR ~ Pick the Right Stick First Time - YouTube
15:35
Aim Controllers - TMR v Hall - YouTube
10:41
TMR, Hall Effect or ALPS? Joysticks For Dummies - YouTube
06:10
Hall Effect was cool... but its time for TMR - YouTube
16:06
The BEST PS5 Hall effects / TMR Controllers, NO DRIFT! - YouTube
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
Hall Effect vs TMR - What's the difference? - YouTube
In this video I break down all of the differences between potentiometer, hall effect and TMR joysticks! How do the Flydigi Apex 5 hall effect sticks perform ...
Published September 22, 2025
HYPR Controllers
hyprcontrollers.com › home › uncategorized › hall effect vs. tmr thumbsticks: what’s the difference?
Hall Effect vs. TMR Thumbsticks: What’s the difference? - HYPR Controllers
May 18, 2025 - Think of it this way. Hall effect is like a ruler, measuring how far a magnet moves and translating that distance into a signal readable by the game. TMR Sensors behave more like a radar.
HL Planet
hlplanet.com › hall-effect-vs-tmr-joysticks
Hall effect vs TMR joysticks - what's the real difference?
June 24, 2025 - TMR is an evolution of Hall Effect and it's better in most cases. Hall Effect really reduces the risk of developing stick drift in your joysticks, but it has
Game One
gameone.ph › blog › post › the-battle-of-sensors-hall-effect-vs-tmr-for-your-controller.html
Game One - The Battle of Sensors: Hall Effect vs TMR For Your Controller - Blog
October 24, 2025 - TMR sensors use a quantum trick called tunneling, where electrons pass through a super thin layer between two magnets. The sensor’s resistance changes depending on how the magnets line up. When a joystick’s magnet moves, it changes the magnet’s alignment, which changes the resistance. The sensor turns this change into a signal, so the controller knows exactly where or how the joystick is moving. ... Durability - Like Hall effect sensors, TMR sensors don’t rely on physical contact, so there’s no friction or wear and tear.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/controller › tmr vs hall effect what is better
r/Controller on Reddit: tmr vs hall effect what is better
September 21, 2024 -
My PS4 controller is drifting but what would be better to replace it with TMR or Hall Effect
Edit: I did try to calibrate them
Top answer 1 of 5
6
If you are talking about the present, the potential for TMR is higher than Hall Effects. However, at the moment, TMR is benefiting only a year of research/implementation (for controllers--it's been used in other industries for decades) while Hall Effects has had a few years (while Potentiometers have decades). This is like asking if you prefer a 6th-level Fighter vs. a 1st-level Wizard. Also in practice, it's not reliable to generalize. Different companies manufacture different models of both Hall Effect sensors and TMR. Each model will perform differently compared to other models. Not all Hall Effect modules are identical, just as not all TMR modules are identical. This is like asking if SSDs are better than HDDs and then you go out and buy a DRAM-less SSD that doesn't use SLC/MLC/TLC as a buffer, and are surprised that it gives out in a year or so.
2 of 5
4
TMR use less power as well
The Screen Surgery
thescreensurgery.com › news › understanding the difference between hall effect, tmr, and alps joysticks in xbox and playstation controllers
Understanding the Difference Between Hall Effect, TMR, and ALPS Joysticks in Xbox and PlayStation Controllers
May 8, 2025 - While Hall effect and ALPS sensors are often the go-to choices for mainstream controllers due to their cost-effectiveness, TMR sensors offer compelling advantages where precision, power efficiency, and long-term stability are critical.
Game Rant
gamerant.com › home › explainer › tmr vs hall effect joysticks explained
TMR vs Hall Effect Joysticks Explained
October 14, 2024 - Not only is the technology more ... the durability of Hall effect joysticks. TMR joysticks have a resolution of 3000 points per axis, which is 10 times more than Hall effect....
GameFAQs
gamefaqs.gamespot.com › playstation 5 › hardware › console
Hall Effect vs "TMR" Analog Sticks - PlayStation 5
August 26, 2025 - For PlayStation 5 on the PlayStation 5, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Hall Effect vs "TMR" Analog Sticks".
Tom's Guide
tomsguide.com › gaming › gaming peripherals
So long Hall Effect - I'm only using controllers with TMR sensors from now on | Tom's Guide
October 7, 2024 - The Switch's JoyCons were a source of frustration due to the infamous stick drift epidemic, afflicting a large number of long term Switch user's controllers. The TMR thumbsticks on the Crush Defender are immune to this issue, and the added accuracy is huge. I noticed the difference over Hall Effect Pro controllers such as the 8BitDo Ultimate ($70), and I was able to pull off moves in Super Smash Bros.
GadgetHyper
gadgethyper.com › home › gadgethyper blogs › gadgethyper blogs
ALPS vs Hall Effect vs TMR: Which Analog Stick Is Actually Better for Gaming?
December 18, 2025 - Choose TMR (Blitz 2) if you want the rawest, most sensitive input possible and trust your micro-adjustment skills. Choose Optimized Hall Effect (Vader 5 Pro) if you want a complete package that allows you to mechanically tune physical resistance ...
Reddit
reddit.com › r/dualsense › hall effect vs tmr; what is the real difference for a normal player?
r/Dualsense on Reddit: Hall effect vs TMR; What is the real difference for a normal player?
September 21, 2025 -
After suffering severe stick drift in my 2 PS5 controllers (bought at release) I've installed in one controller some TMR sticks and in the another some Hall effect sticks.
I've been reading about how TMR is much better, more accurate and more power efficient than Hall effects.
I believe all of this to be true when you put them into a measuring rig or if you are a world class competitive player (which I'm absolutely NOT).
For me the power usage point is irrelevant because I predict power usage by the force resistance in the L2/R2 and the vibration system will reduce this to a negligible percentage.
Having played with both for a while (mostly Death Stranding 2) I have not been able to notice any difference between the two.
Given the price difference (I paid about 10 euro per stick for the TMR and about 2 euro for the Hall effect) I really wonder why to use TMR.
So what are the differences a normal casual player should notice (which I haven't yet)?
Perhaps I've been playing the "wrong game" (DS2) to notice the difference and it is noticeable if you play really fast game like Fornite or something like that?
What am I missing?
Top answer 1 of 10
9
Ohw prepare to be bombarded with comments about TMR being the best thing since sliced bread. I have been saying exactly this for a while now. 99% of normal gamers will never experience any difference. The biggest difference is in the tension and linearity of the stick. I install both hall and tmr and I use tmr since they use less lower and the cheap ones are practically the same price. But most people want aknes X halpi tmr since these are the most to the original alps and they come with pretty decent thumb caps.
2 of 10
2
There is almost no difference between the two sensors except how they detect magnetic field changes. Ive installed plenty of both, nobody has ever complained once the sticks are upgraded. Im sure there will be plenty of comments from people that have a. Never installed a set. B. Never compared or calibrated side by side. My personal edge controller uses a tmr sensor on the right and a hall effect on the left. You cannot tell any difference at all. When people Talk about power saving of tmr you are talking about fractions of amps. Is so small it’s not even noticeable. The guli kits are nice but overkill price. They managed to market them as “the solution”. The new Ginfull tmr and halleffects are buttery smooth. I use Ginfull the most, favor union sensors are also handy for conversions from alps sensors. I don’t like how the stock sticks are built. They have mechanical disadvantages that make them inferior, not just the sensors . Sometime people want the exact same feel as stock, so i will normally do a set of new alps sticks with favour union sensors
Scuf Gaming
customercare.scufgaming.com › hc › en-us › articles › 38740238950289-FAQ-TMR-vs-Hall-Effect-What-s-the-Difference
FAQ: TMR vs Hall Effect: What’s the Difference?
Hall Effect: Reads stick movement accurately, suitable for a wide range of gaming styles. TMR: Reads movement differently, offering fine-grained detection of joystick positions.
Keychron
keychron.com › blogs › news › tmr-vs-hall-effect-what-s-the-difference-in-magnetic-keyboards
TMR vs. Hall Effect: What’s the Difference in Magnetic Keyboards?
September 25, 2025 - Compared with TMR, it consumes more power under the same conditions. ... Weak signals require amplification and are susceptible to noise interference. ... Not suitable for matrix scanning methods with row-by-row or column-by-column power supply ...
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
DualSense Battery Life Comparison Hall vs TMR - YouTube
I decided to take some current measurements to see if there would be a noticeable run time difference between a DualSense controller with Hall effect versus ...
Published January 20, 2025
Aimcontrollers
us.aimcontrollers.com › home › tmr vs hall effect sticks
TMR vs Hall Effect Sticks - Aimcontrollers
April 18, 2025 - TMR gives you tighter aim – no more over-correcting in clutch moments. Zero drift. Seriously. Even over time. Feels next-gen. You’ll feel it the second you move the stick. Built for sweats, grinders, and ranked demons.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/controller › difference between hall effect and tmr joysticks in actual use?
r/Controller on Reddit: Difference between Hall effect and TMR joysticks in actual use?
July 8, 2024 -
What is the difference in terms of gameplay between Hall effect and TMR joysticks? Games that I play are games like Call of duty, Destiny 2, Forza, GTA online etc. would I notice a actual difference in gameplay?
Top answer 1 of 5
13
Tmr are lower power, less prone to interference and more precise and require smaller magnets Tmr sticks commonly come in 12bit where most halls are 8bit. Xbox is 10bit alps and Sony uses 9bit alps. Vader 4 pro uses 12bit halls though. In actual gameplay 12bit tmr vs 12bit hall should feel similar. But most halls are not 12 while most tmr are 12. Tmr allows more controller features due to less power constraints and often means better latency but too many variables go into that. Halls are just getting good now while tmr are just coming to market. Vader 4 was first hall effect to beat alps in precision. Now tmr are here and Vader 5 pro will be tmr next year.
2 of 5
2
It may be hard to compare since there’s tuning of the sticks and software that comes into play, but I found TMR to feel the closest to potentiometer so far coming from Vader 4, Apex 4 and even the polyshine Bigbig Won Rainbow 2 SE sticks. Blitz 2 with software upgrades has been a huge difference accuracy wise.
Windows Central
windowscentral.com › gaming
What are TMR sticks, and are they better than Hall-Effect? | Windows Central
October 27, 2025 - TMR is another form of contactless magnetic sensing, so it operates just like Hall Effect, but it works a little differently under the hood. Instead of detecting magnetic fields through voltage changes (as Hall Effect does), TMR sensors measure ...
ELO Gaming
eloesports.com › blogs › general › tmr-vs-hall-effect-gaming-joystick-comparison
Which is Better: TMR vs. Hall Effect Gaming Joysticks
December 3, 2025 - Consistency: Hall has more real-world track record; TMR depends heavily on implementation quality. A Hall joystick uses a fixed magnet + sensor pair: A magnet is attached to the base of the joystick shaft. A Hall Effect sensor sits nearby on the PCB.