Reddit
reddit.com › r/homebuilding › hardie board vs. vinyl
r/Homebuilding on Reddit: Hardie Board vs. Vinyl
April 14, 2021 -
So, I’m building a home and have hit a snag. My contractor has informed me that we will not finish on time due to siding availability. He has 3 different options to choose from and I’m at an impasse. Vinyl siding (wrong color) at $0 increase, Hardie board facing with lap siding on sides and back of house at a $2500 increase (paint included), or Hardie board all around at $6500 increase (paint included). Which option would be the best or what are the pros and cons? This is our first home and I don’t want to choose wrong.
Alsco Metals
alscometals.com › homepage › blog › hardie board vs. vinyl siding: cost, durability, pros and cons
Hardie Board vs. Vinyl Siding
February 18, 2025 - Hardie Boards are thick, with an average thickness between 5/16-inches and ¼-inches. This thickness allows for deep embossing. While embossing looks wood-like, it is very uniform on fiber-cement siding. The uniformity makes it less likely to be mistaken for real wood. Vinyl siding is a plastic exterior siding made of polyvinyl chloride (PVC) resin.
Vinyl siding vs Hardiplank - Fine Homebuilding
I finish wired each house and it seemed to me that the hardi-plank house was quieter. I have no scientific or quantifiable evidence other than my general and very subjective impression. Just my 2 cents worth. ... And I was timid about opining because I am very biased against vinyl siding even though I've never installed it or lived behind it. (I have replaced some windows in vinyl sided ... More on finehomebuilding.com
Vinyl siding vs. James Hardie Siding Cost
👍Fiber-concrete siding is 50 year product. There are many brands(Hardie,LP, etc. ) to bid. You will not regret using fiber-concrete siding . I would never use vinyl. More on reddit.com
38
15
March 12, 2021Siding quotes - what would people do - vinyl vs hardie and install techniques
my current home has concrete aka hardie board siding. Its over 20 years old and i am pretty sure its never been painted. It looks great. I hose it down with some spray on rinse off stuff with the hose once a year and thats it. I am mid 50s and i hope this is my last home and i almost think the siding will outlive me. If i had to replace it for some reaon i wouldnt even consider other kinds of siding.
More on reddit.com 7
3
March 13, 2021Hardie Board vs. Vinyl
Hardie looks nicer, and doesn't damage as easily. You can also paint it if your ever want to change the color. Id pick full Hardie if I had the budget. More on reddit.com
24
4
April 14, 2021Videos
05:08
James Hardie vs. Vinyl Siding: Which Is Best for Your Home? - YouTube
08:41
Hardie Fiber Cement vs Vinyl Siding | Everything you need to know!
06:42
Vinyl Siding vs. FiberCement: Pros and Cons of Each - YouTube
02:59
Cost of James Hardie Vs. Vinyl - YouTube
01:56
James Hardie Vs. Vinyl! Which Siding Products Should You Choose?
05:52
Vinyl Siding vs. James Hardie: Which One Is Best for Your Home? ...
Contract Exteriors
contractexteriors.com › posts › siding-showdown-vinyl-vs-hardie-board
Siding Showdown: Vinyl vs. Hardie Board Siding
However, cheap or lightweight vinyl is more prone to cracking, buckling, and puncturing that requires repairs. As a fiber cement product, James Hardie siding offers very high impact and weather-resistance.
Beissel Window & Siding
beisselwindows.com › home › how to decide between james hardie and vinyl siding
How to Decide between James Hardie and Vinyl Siding
August 23, 2024 - Vinyl siding – At 0.05 inches thick, vinyl siding gives your exterior a smooth finish that works well on modern-style houses. Hardie siding – Five times thicker than vinyl, Hardie siding offers authentic shadow lines that add visual interest ...
Commonwealth Contractors
commonwealthcontracts.com › guides › hardie-board-vs-vinyl-siding
Hardie Board vs Vinyl Siding: A Decision Guide For Your Home Build
July 8, 2025 - Vinyl siding, while resistant to ... years, depending on quality and maintenance. Hardie Board: High impact resistance, non-combustible, withstands winds up to 150 mph....
Address 222 Court Square, 22902, Charlottesville
Facebook
facebook.com › groups › 1665870953635958 › posts › 3991776387712058
How much more expensive is it to do hardie siding vs vinyl
We cannot provide a description for this page right now
Indy Roof & Restoration
indyroofandrestoration.com › home › blog › hardie board vs vinyl siding: pros & cons compared
Hardie Board vs Vinyl Siding: Pros & Cons Compared
July 24, 2025 - Hardie board: Requires repainting every 10–15 years if not prefinished. Needs occasional caulking and cleaning. Vinyl siding: Virtually maintenance-free. No painting required.
Dryhome
dryhome.com › news › hardie board versus vinyl siding
Hardie Board Versus Vinyl Siding - DryHome Roofing & Siding
June 7, 2024 - In fact, heat – whether from ... Alternatively, Hardie board siding is denser (usually more than a quarter of an inch thick), just like real wood siding, which makes it much more durable than vinyl....
Call (703) 230-7663
Address 45921 Maries Road, Suite 100, 20166, Sterling
WoodNet
forums.woodnet.net › showthread.php
Hardiboard type stuff vs premium vinyl?
November 3, 2019 - « Previous 1 … 58 59 60 61 62 … 169 Next » Hardiboard type stuff vs premium vinyl? Pages (3): 1 2 3 Next » · Pages (3): 1 2 3 Next » · View a Printable Version · Subscribe to this thread · Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s) Contact Us · Woodnet Forums ·
Peakhomeexteriors
peakhomeexteriors.com › siding installation › vinyl or hardie board? the siding showdown every homeowner should read
Hardie Board vs. Vinyl Siding: Pros, Cons, and What Homeowners Should Know🏠
June 20, 2025 - Choose Hardie for long-term value and realism; choose vinyl for cost savings and ease of upkeep. Thinking about updating the exterior of your Ann Arbor home but stuck between two top options?
First American Roofing
firstamericanroofing.com › home › how to decide between hardie board vs vinyl siding?
How To Decide Between Hardie Board Vs Vinyl Siding?
January 16, 2025 - Additionally, it resists moisture and won’t warp or swell over time, provided it’s properly maintained. Vinyl: Vinyl siding is durable in normal weather conditions but can become brittle in extremely cold climates, leading to potential cracking.
Southwest Exteriors
southwestexteriors.com › blog › 2024 › august › james-hardie-siding-vs-vinyl-siding-a-comparison
James Hardie Siding vs Vinyl Siding: A Comparison
January 23, 2025 - This makes it about five times thicker than vinyl siding. The increased thickness contributes to its superior durability, as well as its ability to create more pronounced shadow lines that add depth to the siding.
Address 2430 Freedom Dr.,, 78217, San Antonio
SmardBuild
smardbuild.com › blog › hardie-board-vs-vinyl-siding
Hardie Board vs Vinyl Siding: Which is Better for Your Chicago Home? | SmardBuild
May 15, 2025 - The robust nature of this material ensures that your home remains protected for decades, with minimal maintenance required. Additionally, Hardie board is often backed by long-term warranties, providing further assurance of its quality and performance. Vinyl siding is known for its affordability and ease of maintenance.
Festool Owners Group
festoolownersgroup.com › general discussions › home improvement & other projects
Hardie Board -vs- Engineered Wood (LP) Siding (-vs-painting) | Festool Owners Group
May 17, 2022 - Vastly superior to traditional vinyl. My parents have it on the back of their brick home and it has held up well. Additionally the color is still holding up after close to a decade. ... We have used Hardie Shingle siding on our projects here and a large garage project.
Cobexcg
cobexcg.com › home › hardie board vs vinyl siding: which is best for your california home?
Hardie Board vs Vinyl Siding: Which Is Best for Your California Home? - Cobex - Sacramento Roofer
November 4, 2025 - They note that Hardie Board offers superior fire resistance, longevity and a higher-end wood-like texture, making it a smart long-term investment, while vinyl siding stands out for its lower upfront cost and minimal upkeep.
Josephketnerconstruction
josephketnerconstruction.com › blog › the-differences-between-james-hardie-siding-vs-vinyl
The Differences Between James Hardie Siding vs Vinyl | Joseph Ketner Construction
November 21, 2023 - When comparing Hardie board siding to vinyl siding side by side, the main difference is immediately clear. The James Hardie fiber cement board is five times as thick as vinyl and is made from durable materials.
Fine Homebuilding
finehomebuilding.com › forum › vinyl siding vs hardiplank
Vinyl siding vs Hardiplank - Fine Homebuilding
June 28, 2002 - I finish wired each house and it seemed to me that the hardi-plank house was quieter. I have no scientific or quantifiable evidence other than my general and very subjective impression. Just my 2 cents worth. ... And I was timid about opining because I am very biased against vinyl siding even though I've never installed it or lived behind it. (I have replaced some windows in vinyl sided ...
James Hardie
jameshardie.com › product-catalog › exterior-siding-products › hardie-plank-lap-siding
Hardie® Plank Lap Siding | James Hardie
Hardie® siding is noncombustible—it will not burn.** It resists damage from moisture and holds no appeal for pests like woodpeckers or termites.
New Look Roof
newlookroofs.com › new-look-roof-blog › pros-and-cons-of-hardie-board-vs-vinyl
Pros and Cons of Hardie Board vs Vinyl Siding • New Look Roof Blog • Louisville, Kentucky — New Look Roof
December 29, 2023 - Hardie board is fire retardant, waterproof, pest resistant, and weather-resistant, meaning that not only will the siding continue to look great for years upon years, but it will also protect the inside of your home for longer than traditional ...
Houzz
houzz.com › discussions › 5717875 › hardie-board-versus-vinyl
Hardie Board versus Vinyl
June 9, 2019 - During the winter this house gets blasted with salt water spray from winter storms. Winds can get up to 50 mph with higher gusts. In all these years there has never been a problem with the Hardy siding and the house still does not require re-painting. Paint adheres to the Hardy board far better than to wood.