The spout and showerhead are both open to the atmosphere, meaning that when the valve is on the water could travel either out the spout or up through the shower head. Because the spout is a shorter distance and at a lower elevation than the showerhead, water takes the path of least resistance out through the spout. When you pull up on the slider, the cup blocks the water from going to the spout, so the only way to go is through the showerhead. The pressure of the water holds the cup in place. The hole was possibly this manufacturer's method of relieving the pressure in the riser when the valve is off allowing the diverter slider to return to open. Answer from Genericname187329465 on reddit.com
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/plumbing › how does a tub diverter spout send water up to the shower?
r/Plumbing on Reddit: How does a tub diverter spout send water up to the shower?
December 11, 2022 -

How does it work? The slider rides very loosely. The slider has a recess that captures a rubber "cup" the cup has a hole in it. Why does the slider and cup get pulled against the spout bulkhead rather than be pushed away? Is there a moving part in the rough-in that moves and directs water up to the shower when I pull up the diverter handle.

My spout was letting too much water dribble/leak out when the slider was up and water was diverted up to the shower. My repair was to place an o-ring inside the cup. The spout still dribbles, but much less.

🌐
Mr. Rooter
mrrooter.com › home › about/blog › how does a shower diverter work
How Does a Shower Diverter Work? | Mr. Rooter Plumbing
This device is often a pin or switch on your bathtub faucet that diverts water from your tub spout toward your showerhead, enabling you to take a shower or a bath in the same location.
Discussions

plumbing - Does a bathtub spout with a diverter have to be on the same side as the valve, or can I move it over to the side of the tub? - Home Improvement Stack Exchange
Bring the best of human thought ... at your work. Explore Stack Internal ... I'm putting in a shower/tub unit and we want to have the tub spout on the side of the tub in the middle. The valve unit will be in the usual place on the end of the tub, with the shower head above it. The diverter is in the ... More on diy.stackexchange.com
🌐 diy.stackexchange.com
March 27, 2018
How does a tub diverter spout send water up to the shower?
The spout and showerhead are both open to the atmosphere, meaning that when the valve is on the water could travel either out the spout or up through the shower head. Because the spout is a shorter distance and at a lower elevation than the showerhead, water takes the path of least resistance out through the spout. When you pull up on the slider, the cup blocks the water from going to the spout, so the only way to go is through the showerhead. The pressure of the water holds the cup in place. The hole was possibly this manufacturer's method of relieving the pressure in the riser when the valve is off allowing the diverter slider to return to open. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/Plumbing
6
3
December 11, 2022
Does leaving a tub spout diverter up make it more likely to break?
Most that I have used do not stay up unless there is water pressure. I think this is the standard. Currently, the one I use does not fall down on it's own and I believe it's just because it's older and out of rig. I am not worried about it. I am also not a plumber. I hate turning on the shower and having water come out the shower head immediately, so I manually push the diverter down after a shower. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/fixit
4
7
November 12, 2011
Tub Spout w/Diverter
BIFL? I’ve never bought this. It just comes with every house like a foundation. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/BuyItForLife
13
13
March 23, 2024
🌐
NIcks Plumbing
nicksplumbing.com › home › nick’s plumbing blog › what can go wrong with a shower diverter?
Shower Diverter: Common Problems & How to Fix Them | Nick's
July 28, 2025 - There are a couple of different styles of shower diverters. Still, the one most homeowners are familiar with is the diverter valve, controlled via a simple “pull-up” handle at the end of the bathtub faucet. The control mechanism for the diverter valve can be found near the open end of your bathtub spigot, appearing as a metal pin with a small handle.
🌐
Physics Forums
physicsforums.com › classical physics
How does a bathtub/shower diverter valve work? • Physics Forums
November 6, 2022 - The other trick is that the diverter is designed in such a way that once it is positioned to block the spout, water pressure will hold it there. That’s why after you lift it to start the shower it stays that way, and you have to push it down ...
Top answer
1 of 3
1

A normal tub diverter valve works because when the tub spout is open, it requires less force for the water to come out of the spout than it does for water to get pushed up to the shower head. The water takes the path of least resistance. When the tub spout diverter is closed, the water is naturally forced up the pipe to the shower head.

The reason the instructions say to only use one elbow and to limit the distance is to reduce the resistance of the water flowing out of the spout. If the plumbing to the spout is too complex and provides too much resistance, you could have some water get pushed up to the shower head no matter what.

So, this plan might work, or there might just be too much resistance in the pipe snaking around the tub to the other side. It's hard to say for sure. If the valve is installed lower, I think you chances are better. Also the tub spout pipe will have to go around the tub and not over it because water would certainly flow out of the head all the time if you did that. Try to use only 3-4 fittings on the pipe - don't make any extra bends.

I looked around a little and found this forum post where a plumber used PEX pipe and three elbows even with the tub spout on the same side. That was enough to make water dribble out of the shower head. PEX could have made this problem worse because the fittings don't have a full 1/2" inside diameter so they restrict flow more than copper would. Still, doesn't look good for your plan since you'd also have a minimum of 3 elbows (with PEX, 4 elbows using copper).

2 of 3
1

Since you have the wall open you should consider replacing the shower/tub valve assembly to include the diverter in the valve assembly instead of in the spout. (Seems like from something you said that you are already familiar with).

I also think you should think really hard about moving the spout along the center of the long side of the tub. That is a nasty accident or injury waiting to happen.

🌐
Allora USA
allorausa.com › home › blogs › blogs
Complete Guide to Shower Diverters: Types, Functions, and Installation Tips
April 16, 2025 - A shower diverter is a valve that redirects water from one outlet to another—most often between a tub spout and showerhead, or among multiple showering components such as a handheld sprayer, body jets, or rain shower.
🌐
RBROHANT
rbrohant.com › home › what’s a shower diverter valve and how does a shower valve work?
What’s a Shower Diverter Valve and How Does a Shower Valve Work?
A shower diverter valve is a plumbing device that directs water flow from one outlet to another in a shower valve system. It allows you to switch between different showering options, such as a showerhead, handheld sprayer, or tub spout.
Find elsewhere
🌐
DIY Home Improvement
diychatroom.com › home › forums › home improvement › plumbing
How does a shower spout diverter work? | DIY Home Improvement Forum
March 21, 2018 - For theoretical understanding, ... exit the tub spout. When you pull up on tub spout and divert water to the showerhead, you change the path of least resistance from the tub spout to the showerhead....
🌐
Hunker
hunker.com › 13408216 › how-does-a-tub-diverter-valve-work
How Does A Tub Diverter Valve Work? - Hunker
February 1, 2022 - Tub diverter valves work by blocking the natural flow of water out of the tub spout. As pressure builds, the water travels in the only available direction: up.
🌐
Absolute Plumbing
absoluteplumbingonline.com › home › blog › how does a shower diverter work?
How Does a Shower Diverter Work? | Absolute Plumbing
November 13, 2024 - Pulling up on the post at the top of the spout activates the diverter, blocking the water flow to the spout and redirecting it to the shower head. Two-Valve Diverter: Found in setups where the faucet has separate handles for hot and cold water, the diverter is typically located between these ...
🌐
Armadillo
armadillo.one › home › resources › what is a plumbing diverter and why yours might be failing
What Is a Plumbing Diverter and Why Yours Might Be Failing | Armadillo
November 14, 2025 - When you pull up the small lever ... the diverter on your tub spout—that action closes off the pipe to the tub and forces water to flow up through the showerhead instead....
🌐
Mrrooterpittsburgh
mrrooterpittsburgh.com › how-does-a-shower-diverter-work-p-623.html
How Does a Shower Diverter Work? | Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Pittsburgh
You only need to install it at the end of the tub spout. ... It can be installed at the center to divert water between two faucets and a showerhead.
🌐
PlumbingSupply.com
plumbingsupply.com › home › diy plumbing tutorials › tub spouts index › how to choose & replace a tub spout
How to Replace a Tub Spout
October 2, 2013 - Learn the differences between tub spout types, how to determine which style you have, and how to replace one.
🌐
AHS
ahs.com › home-matters › quick-tips › what-is-a-diverter-valve
Shower Diverter Valve: Repair & Replace | AHS
The primary function of a diverter valve is to control the path of water in your plumbing. When engaged, it redirects water from its default path (usually the tub spout) to an alternative outlet (typically the shower head).
🌐
US EPA
epa.gov › watersense › bath-and-shower-diverters
Bath and Shower Diverters | US EPA
May 6, 2025 - A bath and shower diverter is a device that diverts the flow of water either toward the tub spout (i.e., to the bathtub) or toward the showerhead.
🌐
Elite Rooter
eliterooter.com › home › what is a shower diverter and how it works?
What is a Shower Diverter and How It Works?
August 14, 2025 - It operates by changing the direction of water flow using a mechanical or pressure-activated mechanism. When you turn the lever or knob on the diverter valve, it either blocks the flow of water to one outlet while allowing it to flow to another ...
🌐
Cass Plumbing
cassplumbingtampabay.com › home › what you should know about shower diverters
What You Should Know About Shower Diverters | Cass Plumbing
February 25, 2023 - Shower diverters come in three ... The latter is identified by a handle that pulls straight up from the tub faucet, and when pushed down, it opens the flow of water to the tub spout....
🌐
Roto-Rooter
rotorooter.com › frequently asked questions › plumbing › what is a shower diverter valve
What Is a Shower Diverter Valve? | Roto-Rooter
A shower diverter valve can come in a few different forms, but they all share the same purpose. The diverter may appear as a pin pulled upward from the bathtub faucet spout, it could come in the form of a third (middle) faucet handle, or it might be a button that has to be pushed or pulled that is located right around the faucet itself.
🌐
Terry Love
terrylove.com › home › forums
How does shower line drain through tub spout when valve is ...
April 3, 2016 - Terry Love Plumbing Advice, Remodel DIY & Professional Forum. The best plumbing forums in the USA and Canada. A place for home owners to ask questions and for professionals to share information.
🌐
This Old House
thisoldhouse.com › this old house › bathrooms
How To Repair a Shower Diverter
April 18, 2024 - Turn Off the Water Supply Remove ... the Diverter Reinstall the Shower Spout · Locate the shutoff valves for your shower before starting work on the repair. These valves are usually situated beneath the faucet handle or behind an access panel faceplate. Turn the valves clockwise to stop the water from flowing into the shower. You can unscrew most tub spouts by ...