This is old, but for the sake of any future info seekers, here’s been my experience over 18 months of using the wallet: Magnet strength is pretty good. I only use the wallet, no phone case (Magback or otherwise). I can say it is far better than the apple branded wallet in terms of magnet strength. I bought an extra magstrip that I attached along my dash, and that has worked as an unobtrusive car mount. Phone has never fallen off it. The only thing with it, is wanting to be mindful of pulling the phone off of that strip, as the magnetic connection can be stronger than the 3M adhesive that attaches the strip to my dash surface. I’ve pulled it off before and had to attach a new adhesive strip (that came with it). That hasn’t happened in over a year now though. Don’t have to be super gentle, just mindful is all. I can hold my iPhone 13 Pro (not Max) upside down by the wallet loop and it will stay attached. If I tried to shake the wallet off though, it would detach. I carry 4 cards in it. It is very tight at first, but loosens up. However, once it’s stretched to accommodate those 4 cards, it becomes too loose if I want to hold less (I.e. I take one out, the wallet doesn’t snap close to those now 2 or 3, they can/will slide out; though will gradually shrink back over time (to a degree). Not to the point you could only slide in 1 card and be good, but if I took them all out, could use 3 the next day instead of 4 and be good. As for loosening up over time and becoming too loose to hold even the 3-4 cards I regularly keep in it, I have not had that issue. I don’t worry about anything falling out of it. I regularly carry my DL, debit card, and 2 cc’s. My complaint lies in the quality of construction. Now the warranty service is great, I’ve had no issues or hassle there. Send an email with an explanation and a photo, next day new wallet is shipped out, 2-3 days later it’s in hand. Unfortunately I’ve had to utilize that twice now. First one the stitching started coming apart along the right side of the wallet after 6-8 months or so. The replacement wallet then had the leather trimming along the wallets edges start to peel off within about 4-5 months. The third wallet I’m on now has been fine for the 3 months I’ve had it. The one blog review I read about it had the same problem with theirs (leather trim along the top edge peeled off) and got a replacement too. So- warranty replacement has been hassle free, but looks like there’s a common theme here. Hoping this one lasts, but we’ll see. More on reddit.com

What ruined the Magsafe wallet for me is actually the rest of the ecosystem, like the Magsafe Duo, the battery, and the Magsafe pucks that I put in the car and nightstand.

In the car is the best example: I hang my phone on the Magsafe car mount when I get in. With the wallet on, I have to remove it first, and then remember to put it back on when I get out. Same thing if I need to top off with MagSafe Battery Pack.

Basically, the convenience having a couple of cards right there has turned into having a couple of cards always in the way. :)

More on reddit.com

If you use an Apple Leather case, it will never fall off. It even sticks so hard to the case that I have to use a lot of force to get it off. It’s almost like the leather case and leather MagSafe Wallet are glued together

EDIT: proof for those who don't believe me.

More on reddit.com

Spigen is also great for the money. However the only drawback with Spigen is the Apple Logo cutout in my opinion for some of their most popular cases.

More on reddit.com