First of all, it is not true that is . In fact, this is never true (note that is undefined). For example:

  • .

  • .

  • And so on.

What is true is that but this doesn't say that there is a specific value of such that ; rather, it says intuitively that by picking really really close to we can make really really close to .

The precise definition of the limit is a bit more complicated: when we say what we mean is that for any (the "degree of accuracy") we can guarantee that is within of just by making sure that is close enough to ; fully formally, that for all there is some such that (There is a slight asymmetry here, namely the "" on the -side but not on the -side, but that's best ignored at first.)


Re: your other question, this is a specific property about . For example, is undefined (from the left it approaches and from the right it approaches ).

Answer from Noah Schweber on Stack Exchange
🌐
Rutgers Math
sites.math.rutgers.edu › ~greenfie › summer_135 › verification_sine.html
Verification that the limit of sin(h)/h as h-->0 is 1
Let's put the inequalities we have together: cos(h)<=[sin(h)/h]<=1. We are interested in what happens as h-->0. Well, here is a valid use of the squeeze theorem, since both cos(h) and 1 approach 1 as h-->0. So we can finally conclude that limh-->0[sin(h)/h]=1.
🌐
Quora
quora.com › Why-is-the-limit-as-h-approaches-0-of-sin-h-over-h-equal-to-one
Why is the limit as h approaches 0 of sin(h) over h equal to one? - Quora
Answer (1 of 7): |\sin x| \le |x| \le |\tan x| You can show this geometrically: The area of the green triangle is \frac 12 sin x the section of the circle \frac 12 x and the larger triangle is \frac 12 \tan x 1 \le \frac {x}{\sin x} \le \sec x\\ 1\ge \frac {\sin x}{x} \ge \cos x And ...
🌐
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
A Special Limit - sin(h)/h as h goes to 0. - YouTube
Course Web Page: https://sites.google.com/view/slcmathpc/home
Published   September 27, 2013
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/calculus › is lim h->0 sinh/h = -1 ?
r/calculus on Reddit: Is lim h->0 sinh/h = -1 ?
February 24, 2022 - L’hospitals shouldn't be used for this. To find the derivative of sin itself, you needed to know (or rather assume) that lim h -> 0 sin(x+h)/h = 1.
🌐
Eli Bendersky
eli.thegreenplace.net › 2009 › 01 › 13 › the-limit-of-sinhh-or-deriving-the-sine-function
The limit of sin(h)/h, or deriving the sine function - Eli Bendersky's website
Which indeed goes to 1 as There's nothing wrong with using L'Hopital's rule in general, but we can't use it here, because we're creating a circular argument! We can't just assume that (for applying L'Hopital) when we're trying to prove it! We'll have to find another method.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/math › does a proof of lim[h->0] sin(h)/h = 1 exist without using l'hopital's rule or the taylor series definitons of sin(x) and cos(x)?
r/math on Reddit: Does a proof of lim[h->0] sin(h)/h = 1 exist without using l'hopital's rule or the taylor series definitons of sin(x) and cos(x)?
February 3, 2016 -

I've been trying to prove that the derivative of sin is cos, and have managed to prove using the definition of limit that the derivative of sin(x) is cos(x) * lim[h->0] sin(h)/h; I know the limit is 1, but I can't prove it.

I can think of ways to prove the limit using taylor series and l'hopital's rule (also I can't use l'hopital's b/c I havent proved this), but not without accepting that the derivative of sin(x) = cos(x) in the first place.

To be clear- I DONT WANT TO KNOW how to actually prove the thing, I just want to know if a method exists which I could use having only taken AP Calc

Find elsewhere
🌐
Carleton
mortimer.math.carleton.ca › pdf › Scripts › Special Topics › CUTuts-ST1-Limit_sin_h_over h.pdf pdf
sinh h = 1 - lim - Brian Mortimer
lim · !→! sin ℎ · ℎ · = 1 · Prof. Brian Mortimer · School of Mathematics and Statistics · Carleton University · Ottawa Ontario Canada · [email protected] · March 2012 · h · r · a · b · Here · 𝑠= sin ℎ · 𝑤= tan ℎ · 𝑡= ℎ · 𝑠< 𝑡< 𝑤 · sin ...
🌐
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
A Special Limit - (1-cos(h))/h as h goes to 0. - YouTube
Course Web Page: https://sites.google.com/view/slcmathpc/home
Published   January 8, 2015
🌐
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
Limit of (sin(a + h) - sin(a))/h as h approaches zero (Two Solutions) - YouTube
Limit of (sin(a + h) - sin(a))/h as h approaches zero (Two Solutions)If you enjoyed this video please consider liking, sharing, and subscribing.Udemy Courses...
Published   November 2, 2020
🌐
Socratic
socratic.org › questions › math-help-using-the-fact-that-limh-0-sinh-h-1-and-lim-h-0-cos-h-1-h-0-compute-th
Math Help? Using the fact that limh->0 sinh/h=1 and lim h- ...
Stuck on a problem? Quickly find explainers, videos, and results from the web for math, history, chemistry, biology, physics, and more.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/learnmath › [calc] how to think about lim h->0 (cos(h)-1)/h and lim h->0 sin(h)/h
r/learnmath on Reddit: [Calc] How to think about lim h->0 (cos(h)-1)/h and lim h->0 sin(h)/h
August 3, 2015 -

I'm having some trouble with the intuition with limits.

lim h->0 (cos(h)-1)/h = 0. But how do you reason to arrive at that? I could just plug in numbers and see what it approaches but it feels like a weak strategy. I know that cos(0) = 1. This means that the numerator will approach 0. So will the demoninator. But is that enough to say that the limit is 0? If it is, then the next limit is a little troubling.

lim h->0 sin(h)/h = 1. If we use the same reasoning as above and given that sin(0) = 0, then we have something approaching 0 in the numerator and something approaching 0 in the denominator. Quite the same situation as above with the cos expression. But the real answers to the limits are not equal. In one case it's 0 and in the other it's 1.

I'm feeling a little lost in how to reason about this. Any help is appreciated.

🌐
Mathway
mathway.com › popular-problems › Calculus › 512737
Evaluate the Limit limit as h approaches 0 of h/(sin(3h)) | Mathway
Apply L'Hospital's rule. Tap for more steps... ... Evaluate the limit of the numerator and the limit of the denominator.
🌐
Quora
mathresources.quora.com › Why-is-the-limit-as-h-approaches-0-of-sin-h-over-h-equal-to-one
Why is the limit as h approaches 0 of sin(h) over h equal to one? - Math Resources - Quora
Lim (sinh / h) is a common problem that students find a bit awkward. Here are 3 ways to think of it.http://www.quora.com/Why-is-the-limit-as-h-approaches-0-of-sin-h-over-h-equal-to-one/answer/Philip-Lloyd-2
🌐
Quora
quora.com › What-is-the-limit-h-0-cosh-1-h
What is the limit h->0 [(cosh-1) /h]? - Quora
Answer (1 of 7): Let y=\displaystyle\lim_{h\to0}\dfrac{cosh-1}{h} =\displaystyle-\lim_{h\to0}\dfrac{1-cosh}{h} =\displaystyle-\lim_{h\to0}\dfrac{2sin^2\frac{h}{2}}{h} =\displaystyle-\lim_{h\to0}\dfrac{hsin^2\frac{h}{2}}{2\frac{h^2}{4}} =\displaystyle-(0)\left(\frac{1}{2}\right) =0