Magazines.com

EDIT: I got everything sorted out. Thank you everyone for your help and replies!

In early April, I went to FYE to buy a figure. At checkout, the worker told me I can now sign up for 4 free magazines. I didn’t want to, so I told her no thank you, but she would not listen. So now I have 4 magazine subscriptions I don’t want. Whatever. I am very tight on money, and I checked my bank account today, and it was in the negatives. I never allow it to get in the negatives, no matter what. It turns out that I am now being charged for these magazines! The charge had a website on it, so I went to the website, mags.com, and it is the fishiest thing ever. I google it, and there is nothing but terrible things about it. I have tried calling FYE’s support number, it’s only for members. I have called the store, they did not help whatsoever. I have emailed support, absolutely nothing. I don’t know how to deal with this, and I am scared I am getting scammed. I just think it’s wild that a big, trusted store that I’ve shopped at in person my whole life would do this.