Perhaps what you find confusing is the use of set-builder notation to define : Included in between { ... } are the condition(s) that any "candidate" element must satisfy in order to be included in the set, and a set defined by set-builder notation contains all, and only, those elements satisfying all the conditions given.

In each of , set-builder notation is used to provide the conditions for inclusion in each set, respectively. Note: unless otherwise stipulated, you can take conditions separated by a comma to be a conjunction of conditions; that is: $$X = \{x : \text{(condition 1), (condition 2), ...., (condition n)}\}$$ means is the set of all x such that x satisfies (condition 1) AND x satisfies (condition 2) AND ... AND x satisfies (condition n).


The only solution to are or , neither of which is odd. Hence there are elements in ; that is, .

$$Q= \{x: x^2 = 9, x \text{ is even}\}$$

The only solutions to are or , neither of which is even. Hence, there are no elements in ; that is, .

is the only solution to , but is not a solution to , (and neither nor is a solution to ). Hence, there are no elements in ; that is, .


NOTE: As an aside, regarding notation - sometimes instead of a colon :preceding the defining characteristics of a given element, you'll see | in place of the colon. E.g.,

Answer from amWhy on Stack Exchange
🌐
Cuemath
cuemath.com › algebra › empty-set
Empty Set - Definitions, Properties, Examples | Null Set
A set that does not contain any element is called an empty set or a null set. An empty set is denoted using the symbol '∅'. It is read as 'phi'. Example: Set X = {}. It is also called a void set or null set.
🌐
Study.com
study.com › standardized tests courses › gmat study guide and test prep
Null Set Definition, Properties & Examples - Lesson | Study.com
July 7, 2016 - Therefore, your set contains no elements and is the null set. Another example of the null set is the set of all even numbers that are also odd.
Discussions

ELI5: What is a null set?
Depends on context. I've only heard 'null set' in the context of measure theory. Here it is a set which has measure 0. One way of thinking about it is geometrically, a null set is a set with 0 area. For example on a 2d plane a line has 0 area so is a null set. If you are doing probability then a null set is a set such that the chance of randomly picking an element from it is 0. For example if you were picking a random number between 0 and 1 inclusive, then the set {0.5} would be a null set because the chance of picking exactly 0.5 is 0 (this may be counterintuitive). More on reddit.com
🌐 r/explainlikeimfive
13
1
April 19, 2021
Why do we consider the null set to be a subset of all sets? Could we define it otherwise?
If you have an apple, an orange, and a kiwi and you tell me to take any subset of them that I want, it's a valid choice to take none of them. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/maths
22
3
April 13, 2024
Empty Set and NULL Set part of a define set?

X is a subset of Y means every element of X is an element of Y.

And in fact, every element of C is an element of B. If you don't believe me, can you find me an element of C that isn't an element of B? Since there is no such element, every element of C is an element of B, and so C is a subset of B.

Now B is not a subset of C, because it is not the case that every element of B is an element of C. For example, the element 2 is an element of B but not an element of C. So B is not a subset of C.

More on reddit.com
🌐 r/learnmath
13
2
February 6, 2017
elementary set theory - Null Sets $\{\{\emptyset\}\} \subset\{\emptyset, \{\emptyset\}\}$ - Mathematics Stack Exchange
So we can write, for example, $\{\emptyset\} \in \{\{\emptyset\}\}$. $\{\emptyset, \{\emptyset\}\}$ is a set with two elements: one element is the null set, and the other element is a set containing the null set. More on math.stackexchange.com
🌐 math.stackexchange.com
People also ask

What is a null set called?
A null set is also called an empty set. These terms are used interchangeably to describe a set that contains no elements.
🌐
study.com
study.com › standardized tests courses › gmat study guide and test prep
Null Set Definition, Properties & Examples - Lesson | Study.com
How do you define a null set?
The null set is the set containing zero elements. So, any set containing no elements is defined to be the null set.
🌐
study.com
study.com › standardized tests courses › gmat study guide and test prep
Null Set Definition, Properties & Examples - Lesson | Study.com
Is ø an empty set?
This symbol is used to represent the empty set (or the null set). The empty set is unique and it is the set containing zero elements. The symbol in question is one of several that can represent the null set.
🌐
study.com
study.com › standardized tests courses › gmat study guide and test prep
Null Set Definition, Properties & Examples - Lesson | Study.com

Perhaps what you find confusing is the use of set-builder notation to define : Included in between { ... } are the condition(s) that any "candidate" element must satisfy in order to be included in the set, and a set defined by set-builder notation contains all, and only, those elements satisfying all the conditions given.

In each of , set-builder notation is used to provide the conditions for inclusion in each set, respectively. Note: unless otherwise stipulated, you can take conditions separated by a comma to be a conjunction of conditions; that is: $$X = \{x : \text{(condition 1), (condition 2), ...., (condition n)}\}$$ means is the set of all x such that x satisfies (condition 1) AND x satisfies (condition 2) AND ... AND x satisfies (condition n).


The only solution to are or , neither of which is odd. Hence there are elements in ; that is, .

$$Q= \{x: x^2 = 9, x \text{ is even}\}$$

The only solutions to are or , neither of which is even. Hence, there are no elements in ; that is, .

is the only solution to , but is not a solution to , (and neither nor is a solution to ). Hence, there are no elements in ; that is, .


NOTE: As an aside, regarding notation - sometimes instead of a colon :preceding the defining characteristics of a given element, you'll see | in place of the colon. E.g.,

Answer from amWhy on Stack Exchange
Top answer
1 of 3
20

Perhaps what you find confusing is the use of set-builder notation to define : Included in between { ... } are the condition(s) that any "candidate" element must satisfy in order to be included in the set, and a set defined by set-builder notation contains all, and only, those elements satisfying all the conditions given.

In each of , set-builder notation is used to provide the conditions for inclusion in each set, respectively. Note: unless otherwise stipulated, you can take conditions separated by a comma to be a conjunction of conditions; that is: $$X = \{x : \text{(condition 1), (condition 2), ...., (condition n)}\}$$ means is the set of all x such that x satisfies (condition 1) AND x satisfies (condition 2) AND ... AND x satisfies (condition n).


The only solution to are or , neither of which is odd. Hence there are elements in ; that is, .

$$Q= \{x: x^2 = 9, x \text{ is even}\}$$

The only solutions to are or , neither of which is even. Hence, there are no elements in ; that is, .

is the only solution to , but is not a solution to , (and neither nor is a solution to ). Hence, there are no elements in ; that is, .


NOTE: As an aside, regarding notation - sometimes instead of a colon :preceding the defining characteristics of a given element, you'll see | in place of the colon. E.g.,

2 of 3
10

A Null Set is a set with no elements. While the author of your book uses the notation , I prefer to use to emphasize, that the set contains nothing. The example sets and are all null sets, because there is no , that can satisfy the condition of being included in the set.

🌐
Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Null_set
Null set - Wikipedia
1 month ago - It is uncountable because it contains ... of the previous set, thereby multiplying the length by 2/3 with every step. The set of Liouville numbers is another example of an uncountable null set....
Find elsewhere
🌐
CK-12 Foundation
ck12.org › all subjects › cbse math › sets and its types › what is a null set in maths?
What is a null set in maths? - Symbol & Definition | CK-12 Foundation
September 11, 2025 - In mathematics, a null set, also known as an empty set, is a set that contains no elements. It is denoted by the symbol @$\begin{align*}\emptyset\end{align*}@$ or @$\begin{align*}\{\}\end{align*}@$. For example, the set of all integers that are both even and odd is a null set, because no integer ...
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/explainlikeimfive › eli5: what is a null set?
r/explainlikeimfive on Reddit: ELI5: What is a null set?
April 19, 2021 - If you are doing probability then ... is 0. For example if you were picking a random number between 0 and 1 inclusive, then the set {0.5} would be a null set because the chance of picking exactly 0.5 is 0 (this may be ...
🌐
A Maths Dictionary for Kids
amathsdictionaryforkids.com › qr › n › nullSet.html
null set ~ A Maths Dictionary for Kids Quick Reference by Jenny Eather
Quick Reference from A Maths Dictionary for Kids - over 600 common math terms explained in simple language. Math glossary - definitions with examples. © Jenny Eather 2014.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/maths › why do we consider the null set to be a subset of all sets? could we define it otherwise?
r/maths on Reddit: Why do we consider the null set to be a subset of all sets? Could we define it otherwise?
April 13, 2024 -

From the Fundamental methods of mathematical economics (4th ed.) by Chiang and Wainwright, page 10:

“The smallest possible subset of S is a set that contains no elements at all. Such a set is called the null set, or empty set, denoted by the symbol Ø or {}.”

“The reasoning for considering the null set as a subset of S is quite interesting: If the null set is not a subset of S (Ø ⊄ S), then Ø must contain at least one element 𝑥 such that 𝑥 ∉ S. But since by definition the null set has no element whatsoever, we cannot say that Ø ⊄ S; hence the null set is a subset of S”

Question:

Why do we define a subset this way, leading to the inclusion of the null set? Could we not (more intuitively) define a subset of S: containing at least one element 𝑥 such that 𝑥 ∈ S AND no one element 𝑥 such that 𝑥 ∉ S?

My intuitive thinking:

If I have an apple, an orange, and a kiwi, I usually don’t also go around thinking that I also have a ‘no fruit’. Feels wrong to claim that ‘no element’ is a good description of my set that definitely contains elements.

Edit: Wow, THANK YOU everyone for such a robust discussion. Lots to think on, lots to turn over in my mind.

🌐
Teachoo
teachoo.com › 7018 › 1341 › Empty-or-Null-set › category › Null-Set
Empty or Null set - Symbol, Definition and Questions - Teachoo
If number of elements in set is 0, it is an empty set.It is also called null set or void set.Example:A = {x: x is a natural number less than 1}Since, natural number = 1, 2, 3, 4, …There is no natural number less than 1Hence,A = {}or A is an ...
🌐
Quora
quora.com › What-are-examples-of-a-null-set
What are examples of a null set? - Quora
Answer (1 of 10): * The set of answers to this question before it was asked * The set of flat earthers that have actually been to space * The set of people that have crossed me and lived * [] * The set of times I've gotten over 1 mil views for an answer * The set of people on Quora with mor...
🌐
Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Empty_set
Empty set - Wikipedia
April 23, 2026 - Since the empty set has no member when it is considered as a subset of any ordered set, every member of that set will be an upper bound and lower bound for the empty set. For example, when considered as a subset of the real numbers, with its usual ordering, represented by the real number line, every real number is both an upper and lower bound for the empty set.
🌐
Newgateuniversityminna
elearning.newgateuniversityminna.edu.ng › mod › book › view.php
Sets | Null Set | NUEL
Example 6.1: Let A be the set of people in the world who are older than 200years. According to known statistics A is the null set.
🌐
GeeksforGeeks
geeksforgeeks.org › mathematics › empty-set
Empty Set(Null Set): Definition, Notation, Properties, & Examples - GeeksforGeeks
October 29, 2025 - The empty set, null set, or void ... set and is written as Φ = { }. For example, the collection of possibilities for rolling a die and obtaining a number larger than 6....
🌐
TechTarget
techtarget.com › whatis › definition › data-set
What is a null set in mathematics?
The air quality data set contains air quality surveillance data for New York City. Example of a data set: Air quality surveillance data in New York city displayed in Microsoft Excel.
🌐
Toppr
toppr.com › guides › maths › sets › types-of-sets
Types of Sets: Null, Finite, Singleton Sets, Concepts, Videos and Examples
August 27, 2020 - Since, a Set is a well – defined collection of objects; depending on the objects and their characteristics, there are many types of Sets which are explained with suitable examples, as follows: – · Any Set that does not contain any element is called the empty or null or void set.
🌐
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
The Empty Set or the Null Set , Intermediate Algebra , Lesson 27 - YouTube
This tutorial explains the simple concept of the empty set, otherwise known as the null set.Join this channel to get access to perks:https://www.youtube.com/...
Published   November 18, 2012
🌐
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
Empty Set | Null Set | Void Set - YouTube
This video describes the empty set / null set with the help of some examples and a practice exercise.
Published   March 10, 2018
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/learnmath › empty set and null set part of a define set?
r/learnmath on Reddit: Empty Set and NULL Set part of a define set?
February 6, 2017 -

U = {N|N=All real number} A = {1,3,5,7,9} B = {2,4,6,8} C = {}

How is C a subset of U, A, and B but U, A, B is not a subset of C?

Please show me mathematically how a NULL or empty set is contained within a define set. Or use any deductive reasoning that makes sense.

All I got was this - You have a used car sale lot that sells car (U). In the used car sale lot, they have Toyotas (A). They also have Fords (B). They only have Toyotas and Fords. That is it. Nothing else. Because it is defined as having Toyotas and Fords but not empty, how can any empty set be a part of it? If we were to assume that an empty set can be a part of the dealer because it they can run out of cars, what is stopping someone to make the assumption that they can have a Chevy in there too at one point in time, since they are just a used car sale lot.

Am I making any sense? Please help me understand.

EDIT: I guess I look at things differently then the rest of the world... I always thought that a set define a group value. Key word, define. So when you have a set of, say P{Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, Pluto}, you have a set called P defining the planets within the Sol solar system. Since it did not define an emptiness, how can an empty set be contain within it? sigh In all honestly, I probably am thinking too deeply at this.

🌐
Duke University
webhome.phy.duke.edu › ~rgb › Philosophy › axioms › axioms › node18.html
The Null Set
So we can conceptually think of the null set as a ``black hole'' of set theory3.30. This concept of set theoretic (and other) contradictions are actually explored and developed more in Eastern philosophy and logic than in the West, and Zen logic3.31 is perhaps more suited to the sorts of oxymoronic construction that one associates with nonbeing as opposed to emptiness. For example, ``the sound of one hand clapping'' in a rather famous Zen koan is not the sound of clapping in the limit that the noise being produced by a clap goes to zero, it is not even no clapping at all - two hands sitting at rest.