Reddit
reddit.com › r/mechanicalkeyboards › mechanical vs optical switches
r/MechanicalKeyboards on Reddit: Mechanical vs Optical Switches
October 17, 2022 -
I am quite new into mechanical keyboards. How to choose between them? Please advice, thank you.
Also, low profile vs normal mechanical keyboard, which to choose?
Top answer 1 of 5
21
Mechanical and normal is the default. Unless you have a specific reason to choose it, you're limiting yourself to a much smaller pool of possibilities and in general are considered worse, which is why they're not the default. For mechanical vs optical: Mechanical was the default and still is because nothing else offers a good enough trade off to switch. Optical does offer some benefits, but wasn't enough for the entire market to swap. As far as I know, the most common selling points are: 1. They last longer because they use light instead of electrical contacts (While it might be technically true, in most cases people aren't replacing keyboards or switches because a switch dies from regular use. You're probably replacing it for other reasons, so in most cases switch lifespan shouldn't affect your decision IMO. If you're able to swap switches anyway whether because you can solder or it's hotswap, it's not really a big deal to replace dead switches. Even if you're not going to fix dead switches, if you used your keyboard down to actually wear out a switch, you're probably more than happy with how long it lasted anyway) 2. They actuate faster (Sometimes, but not always as this just depends on the actuation distance. Some mechanical switches, often called speed switches, offer shorter actuation points, but it isn't always desired since it can also increase the frequency of fat finger mistakes) 3. They have less latency (I don't know too much, but apparently using optical switches can offer lower latency than mechanical switches because they have to work around something called debounce. So while it technically can reduce latency, I haven't seen anything regarding the difference in latency and whether it's an amount that someone would or could even notice in the context of everything else that adds latency.) As for low profile, I don't know if you mean low profile cases or low profile switches. Low profile cases is almost purely an aesthetic choice, one that most people don't like. Me personally I used to use low profile cases exclusively because I used my palm to press left ctrl. I've since swapped my left ctrl to where caps lock normally is and have moved away from low profile cases. They're super limited in choice, so unless you have a specific desire, it's generally not recommended. Unless you REALLY want to see your switches from the side or something (even then, just get something with a clear case). If you're talking low profile switches, I don't have personal experience in these. As far as I know, most low profile switches require low profile keycaps as well, though I believe I have seen cherry compatible low profile switches. You'd only really look for low profile switch keyboards if you really wanted it for it's thinness. Nobody picks and uses low profile switches for any other reason. (Basically they offer nothing other than its lack of thickness, but you are giving up a lot such as a lot of options, lower travel time, etc.)
2 of 5
11
All I’ll say is, I was global elite in csgo when I had a £30 ordinary msi keyboard, than a razer huntsman elite with optical switches. You’re all deluded and take this subject way too far.
Do optical clicky switches feel like mechanical clicky switches? | Overclockers UK Forums
Hi, I'm thinking of getting my first mechanical keyboard the gk61 in blue clicky switches, I know optical switches are faster but was wondering if the switches optical switches feel like true mechanical switches? I am switching from mecha dome switches and as it is my first mechanical keyboard I... More on forums.overclockers.co.uk
Optical vs mechanical switches noise level?
In general Reds would tend to be a tad quieter than Browns but if you get a hot-swap mechanical switch board then you can choose from a huge range of other brand switches that include silent/dampened switches too. More on reddit.com
Mechanical vs Optical Switches
Mechanical and normal is the default. Unless you have a specific reason to choose it, you're limiting yourself to a much smaller pool of possibilities and in general are considered worse, which is why they're not the default. For mechanical vs optical: Mechanical was the default and still is because nothing else offers a good enough trade off to switch. Optical does offer some benefits, but wasn't enough for the entire market to swap. As far as I know, the most common selling points are: 1. They last longer because they use light instead of electrical contacts (While it might be technically true, in most cases people aren't replacing keyboards or switches because a switch dies from regular use. You're probably replacing it for other reasons, so in most cases switch lifespan shouldn't affect your decision IMO. If you're able to swap switches anyway whether because you can solder or it's hotswap, it's not really a big deal to replace dead switches. Even if you're not going to fix dead switches, if you used your keyboard down to actually wear out a switch, you're probably more than happy with how long it lasted anyway) 2. They actuate faster (Sometimes, but not always as this just depends on the actuation distance. Some mechanical switches, often called speed switches, offer shorter actuation points, but it isn't always desired since it can also increase the frequency of fat finger mistakes) 3. They have less latency (I don't know too much, but apparently using optical switches can offer lower latency than mechanical switches because they have to work around something called debounce. So while it technically can reduce latency, I haven't seen anything regarding the difference in latency and whether it's an amount that someone would or could even notice in the context of everything else that adds latency.) As for low profile, I don't know if you mean low profile cases or low profile switches. Low profile cases is almost purely an aesthetic choice, one that most people don't like. Me personally I used to use low profile cases exclusively because I used my palm to press left ctrl. I've since swapped my left ctrl to where caps lock normally is and have moved away from low profile cases. They're super limited in choice, so unless you have a specific desire, it's generally not recommended. Unless you REALLY want to see your switches from the side or something (even then, just get something with a clear case). If you're talking low profile switches, I don't have personal experience in these. As far as I know, most low profile switches require low profile keycaps as well, though I believe I have seen cherry compatible low profile switches. You'd only really look for low profile switch keyboards if you really wanted it for it's thinness. Nobody picks and uses low profile switches for any other reason. (Basically they offer nothing other than its lack of thickness, but you are giving up a lot such as a lot of options, lower travel time, etc.) More on reddit.com
Do people actually prefer optical switches over mechanical?
I like opticals more mainly for the peace of mind knowing it will never double click with or without 0 debounce timing setting. Opticals are also improving a lot and are starting to feel more and more like feel like mechanical switches. The omron opticals in my beastx max are the best ones I’ve used yet and if someone told me they were mechanical switches I’d believe them lol. More on reddit.com
Videos
08:01
Gateron Switches: Mechanical VS Optical! (Sound Test) - YouTube
14:13
Membrane vs Mechanical vs Optical Keyboards | Everything You Need ...
Are Optical Keyboards Better Than Mechanical Keyboards?
01:17
Mechanical vs Optical Switches —Feel the Difference. - YouTube
14:40
The mechanical switch is dead. - YouTube
12:01
How to Choose the Perfect Keyboard Switch For YOU. - YouTube
Hirosart
hirosarts.com › home › optical vs mechanical switches – which is better?
Optical vs Mechanical Switches – Which is better? - Hirosart
June 13, 2024 - On the other hand, in the refraction method (known as the Flaretech switch), the light takes a detour through a prism lens before reaching the sensor. ... Mechanical switches use a physical switch mechanism.
Overclockers UK
forums.overclockers.co.uk › hardware › gaming peripherals
Do optical clicky switches feel like mechanical clicky switches? | Overclockers UK Forums
November 12, 2020 - (Switching from Logitech G213) Any help is appreciated ... The fact they are optical don’t reply change how they feel, it’s purely/mostly down to the switch manufacturer how they feel (eg flaretech wooting) Most of the time they will feel similar to their counterparts and some won’t, eg flaretech blues are much smoother and the click isn’t as aggressive.
Ranked
ranked.gg › blogs › news › the-difference-between-mechanical-switches-and-optical-switches
The Difference Between Mechanical Switches and Optical Switches – Ranked
August 16, 2022 - Mechanical switches are also highly durable, with a lifespan that can range from 50 million to 100 million keystrokes. They are also customizable, with a wide range of switch types available, including linear, tactile, and clicky switches. This allows users to choose the switch that best fits their typing style and preferences. Optical switches, on the other hand, use infrared light to register a keystroke.
Overclock.net
overclock.net › home › forums › components › keyboards
Optical vs. Mechanical Keyboards. Which do you prefer? | Overclock.net
November 25, 2018 - What do you guys think and do you have a preference/reasons for liking mechanical over optical keyboards (vise versa)? Click to expand... Only problem I personally have with optical is the lack of choice and the fact that you can't really swap out the switches for very different ones.