One common place where pointers are helpful is when you are writing functions. Functions take their arguments 'by value', which means that they get a copy of what is passed in and if a function assigns a new value to one of its arguments that will not affect the caller. This means that you couldn't write a "doubling" function like this:
void doubling(int x)
{
x = x * 2;
}
This makes sense because otherwise what would the program do if you called doubling like this:
doubling(5);
Pointers provide a tool for solving this problem because they let you write functions that take the address of a variable, for example:
void doubling2(int *x)
{
(*x) = (*x) * 2;
}
The function above takes the address of an integer as its argument. The one line in the function body dereferences that address twice: on the left-hand side of the equal sign we are storing into that address and on the right-hand side we are getting the integer value from that address and then multiply it by 2. The end result is that the value found at that address is now doubled.
As an aside, when we want to call this new function we can't pass in a literal value (e.g. doubling2(5)) as it won't compile because we are not properly giving the function an address. One way to give it an address would look like this:
int a = 5;
doubling2(&a);
The end result of this would be that our variable a would contain 10.
Videos
Could anyone recommend a video that provides a clear explanation of pointers in C programming? I've been struggling to understand them, and I'm looking for a resource that breaks down the concept effectively.
One common place where pointers are helpful is when you are writing functions. Functions take their arguments 'by value', which means that they get a copy of what is passed in and if a function assigns a new value to one of its arguments that will not affect the caller. This means that you couldn't write a "doubling" function like this:
void doubling(int x)
{
x = x * 2;
}
This makes sense because otherwise what would the program do if you called doubling like this:
doubling(5);
Pointers provide a tool for solving this problem because they let you write functions that take the address of a variable, for example:
void doubling2(int *x)
{
(*x) = (*x) * 2;
}
The function above takes the address of an integer as its argument. The one line in the function body dereferences that address twice: on the left-hand side of the equal sign we are storing into that address and on the right-hand side we are getting the integer value from that address and then multiply it by 2. The end result is that the value found at that address is now doubled.
As an aside, when we want to call this new function we can't pass in a literal value (e.g. doubling2(5)) as it won't compile because we are not properly giving the function an address. One way to give it an address would look like this:
int a = 5;
doubling2(&a);
The end result of this would be that our variable a would contain 10.
A variable itself is a pointer to data
No, it is not. A variable represents an object, an lvalue. The concept of lvalue is fundamentally different from the concept of a pointer. You seem to be mixing the two.
In C it is not possible to "rebind" an lvalue to make it "point" to a different location in memory. The binding between lvalues and their memory locations is determined and fixed at compile time. It is not always 100% specific (e.g. absolute location of a local variable is not known at compile time), but it is sufficiently specific to make it non-user-adjustable at run time.
The whole idea of a pointer is that its value is generally determined at run time and can be made to point to different memory locations at run time.
Let's assume an 8 bit computer with 8 bit addresses (and thus only 256 bytes of memory). This is part of that memory (the numbers at the top are the addresses):
54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69
+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+
| | 58 | | | 63 | | 55 | | | h | e | l | l | o | \0 | |
+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+----+
What you can see here, is that at address 63 the string "hello" starts. So in this case, if this is the only occurrence of "hello" in memory then,
const char *c = "hello";
... defines c to be a pointer to the (read-only) string "hello", and thus contains the value 63. c must itself be stored somewhere: in the example above at location 58. Of course we can not only point to characters, but also to other pointers. E.g.:
const char **cp = &c;
Now cp points to c, that is, it contains the address of c (which is 58). We can go even further. Consider:
const char ***cpp = &cp;
Now cpp stores the address of cp. So it has value 55 (based on the example above), and you guessed it: it is itself stored at address 60.
As to why one uses pointers to pointers:
- The name of an array usually yields the address of its first element. So if the array contains elements of type
t, a reference to the array has typet *. Now consider an array of arrays of typet: naturally a reference to this 2D array will have type(t *)*=t **, and is hence a pointer to a pointer. - Even though an array of strings sounds one-dimensional, it is in fact two-dimensional, since strings are character arrays. Hence:
char **. - A function
fwill need to accept an argument of typet **if it is to alter a variable of typet *. - Many other reasons that are too numerous to list here.
How do pointers to pointers work in C?
First a pointer is a variable, like any other variable, but that holds the address of a variable.
A pointer to a pointer is a variable, like any other variable, but that holds the address of a variable. That variable just happens to be a pointer.
When would you use them?
You can use them when you need to return a pointer to some memory on the heap, but not using the return value.
Example:
int getValueOf5(int *p)
{
*p = 5;
return 1;//success
}
int get1024HeapMemory(int **p)
{
*p = malloc(1024);
if(*p == 0)
return -1;//error
else
return 0;//success
}
And you call it like this:
int x;
getValueOf5(&x);//I want to fill the int varaible, so I pass it's address in
//At this point x holds 5
int *p;
get1024HeapMemory(&p);//I want to fill the int* variable, so I pass it's address in
//At this point p holds a memory address where 1024 bytes of memory is allocated on the heap
There are other uses too, like the main() argument of every C program has a pointer to a pointer for argv, where each element holds an array of chars that are the command line options. You must be careful though when you use pointers of pointers to point to 2 dimensional arrays, it's better to use a pointer to a 2 dimensional array instead.
Why it's dangerous?
void test()
{
double **a;
int i1 = sizeof(a[0]);//i1 == 4 == sizeof(double*)
double matrix[ROWS][COLUMNS];
int i2 = sizeof(matrix[0]);//i2 == 240 == COLUMNS * sizeof(double)
}
Here is an example of a pointer to a 2 dimensional array done properly:
int (*myPointerTo2DimArray)[ROWS][COLUMNS]
You can't use a pointer to a 2 dimensional array though if you want to support a variable number of elements for the ROWS and COLUMNS. But when you know before hand you would use a 2 dimensional array.
You have pointers and values:
int* p; // variable p is pointer to integer type
int i; // integer value
You turn a pointer into a value with *:
int i2 = *p; // integer i2 is assigned with integer value that pointer p is pointing to
You turn a value into a pointer with &:
int* p2 = &i; // pointer p2 will point to the integer i
Edit:
In the case of arrays, they are treated very much like pointers. If you think of them as pointers, you'll be using * to get at the values inside of them as explained above, but there is also another, more common way using the [] operator:
int a[2]; // array of integers
int i = *a; // the value of the first element of a
int i2 = a[0]; // another way to get the first element
To get the second element:
int a[2]; // array
int i = *(a + 1); // the value of the second element
int i2 = a[1]; // the value of the second element
So the [] indexing operator is a special form of the * operator, and it works like this:
a[i] == *(a + i); // these two statements are the same thing
There is a pattern when dealing with arrays and functions; it's just a little hard to see at first.
When dealing with arrays, it's useful to remember the following: when an array expression appears in most contexts, the type of the expression is implicitly converted from "N-element array of T" to "pointer to T", and its value is set to point to the first element in the array. The exceptions to this rule are when the array expression appears as an operand of either the & or sizeof operators, or when it is a string literal being used as an initializer in a declaration.
Thus, when you call a function with an array expression as an argument, the function will receive a pointer, not an array:
int arr[10];
...
foo(arr);
...
void foo(int *arr) { ... }
This is why you don't use the & operator for arguments corresponding to "%s" in scanf():
char str[STRING_LENGTH];
...
scanf("%s", str);
Because of the implicit conversion, scanf() receives a char * value that points to the beginning of the str array. This holds true for any function called with an array expression as an argument (just about any of the str* functions, *scanf and *printf functions, etc.).
In practice, you will probably never call a function with an array expression using the & operator, as in:
int arr[N];
...
foo(&arr);
void foo(int (*p)[N]) {...}
Such code is not very common; you have to know the size of the array in the function declaration, and the function only works with pointers to arrays of specific sizes (a pointer to a 10-element array of T is a different type than a pointer to a 11-element array of T).
When an array expression appears as an operand to the & operator, the type of the resulting expression is "pointer to N-element array of T", or T (*)[N], which is different from an array of pointers (T *[N]) and a pointer to the base type (T *).
When dealing with functions and pointers, the rule to remember is: if you want to change the value of an argument and have it reflected in the calling code, you must pass a pointer to the thing you want to modify. Again, arrays throw a bit of a monkey wrench into the works, but we'll deal with the normal cases first.
Remember that C passes all function arguments by value; the formal parameter receives a copy of the value in the actual parameter, and any changes to the formal parameter are not reflected in the actual parameter. The common example is a swap function:
void swap(int x, int y) { int tmp = x; x = y; y = tmp; }
...
int a = 1, b = 2;
printf("before swap: a = %d, b = %d\n", a, b);
swap(a, b);
printf("after swap: a = %d, b = %d\n", a, b);
You'll get the following output:
before swap: a = 1, b = 2 after swap: a = 1, b = 2
The formal parameters x and y are distinct objects from a and b, so changes to x and y are not reflected in a and b. Since we want to modify the values of a and b, we must pass pointers to them to the swap function:
void swap(int *x, int *y) {int tmp = *x; *x = *y; *y = tmp; }
...
int a = 1, b = 2;
printf("before swap: a = %d, b = %d\n", a, b);
swap(&a, &b);
printf("after swap: a = %d, b = %d\n", a, b);
Now your output will be
before swap: a = 1, b = 2 after swap: a = 2, b = 1
Note that, in the swap function, we don't change the values of x and y, but the values of what x and y point to. Writing to *x is different from writing to x; we're not updating the value in x itself, we get a location from x and update the value in that location.
This is equally true if we want to modify a pointer value; if we write
int myFopen(FILE *stream) {stream = fopen("myfile.dat", "r"); }
...
FILE *in;
myFopen(in);
then we're modifying the value of the input parameter stream, not what stream points to, so changing stream has no effect on the value of in; in order for this to work, we must pass in a pointer to the pointer:
int myFopen(FILE **stream) {*stream = fopen("myFile.dat", "r"); }
...
FILE *in;
myFopen(&in);
Again, arrays throw a bit of a monkey wrench into the works. When you pass an array expression to a function, what the function receives is a pointer. Because of how array subscripting is defined, you can use a subscript operator on a pointer the same way you can use it on an array:
int arr[N];
init(arr, N);
...
void init(int *arr, int N) {size_t i; for (i = 0; i < N; i++) arr[i] = i*i;}
Note that array objects may not be assigned; i.e., you can't do something like
int a[10], b[10];
...
a = b;
so you want to be careful when you're dealing with pointers to arrays; something like
void (int (*foo)[N])
{
...
*foo = ...;
}
won't work.