react map gl vs mapbox gl reddit

When to use react-map-gl or plain mapbox-gl in React app?

reddit.com › r › gis › comments › q7bo7v › when_to_use_reactmapgl_or_plain_mapboxgl_in_react

I'm working on a react application with mapbox-gl for the first time and I have the same question. I would transition over to react-map-gl or react-mapbox-gl, but I haven't found any compelling reasons to. So far, plain mapbox-gl and redux have been a powerful combo and I've had no issues linking map state to the general application's state. This could be my person bias coming from a lack of react experience and working previously with leaflet.js, but I'd love to hear any other perspectives Answer from Reedfiend on reddit.com

reddit.com › r/gis › when to use react-map-gl or plain mapbox-gl in react app?

r/gis on Reddit: When to use react-map-gl or plain mapbox-gl in React app?

October 13, 2021 -

I'm working on a React app with a mapbox component and am trying to understand the use case for react-map-gl vs the examples on the Mapbox site that just use mapbox-gl. From the React GitHub issues they mention this in regards to performance -

React may decide to render more than necessary than Mapbox would on its own, failing to account for how expensive the draw call is.
If you are using mapbox as nothing but a map display, generally speaking you do not need this library. If you are trying to match the map with any other React component, you will eventually run into the same issue.

But then the entire Mapbox studio is written I believe without any react wrappers...and there are plenty of React components in Studio besides the map, so it does not seem like this argument holds true. Anyone have thoughts or experience they can share?

Top answer

1 of 3

2

I'm working on a react application with mapbox-gl for the first time and I have the same question. I would transition over to react-map-gl or react-mapbox-gl, but I haven't found any compelling reasons to. So far, plain mapbox-gl and redux have been a powerful combo and I've had no issues linking map state to the general application's state. This could be my person bias coming from a lack of react experience and working previously with leaflet.js, but I'd love to hear any other perspectives

2 of 3

1

having the same question 4 years later. Any answers?

reddit.com › r/learnprogramming › react-map-gl or mapbox-gl?

r/learnprogramming on Reddit: react-map-gl or mapbox-gl?

October 12, 2021 -

I'm really starting to get frustrated with this. I've seen a split between using react-map-gl and mapbox-gl usage in tutorials. It's all honestly kind of a mess cos no one tutorial/documentation is what I need it for. I thought I had figured something out but I realized my .js files arent acutally responisble for rendering the map. It's only rendering because of a <script> tag I found in one tutorial in the index.html file which is I feel like that's not what I want ultimately.

Ultimately I know I'm going to have to loop thru gelocation data in an API to add points on a map but if it's only because of that tag in html then why the hell use React to begin with? It's weird to me I can't find a striaght answer considering how popular React is.

I also hate JavaScript (cliche, I know) and am much more competent in Python so I'm considering scrapping this (honestly for like the sixth time now) and starting over in Django or Flask even thought I have zero experience with them.

Thoughts?

Top answer

1 of 1

1

I'm not sure you'll be able to do this project without JavaScript. It might be possible, but seems like a stretch. I also don't quite understand exactly what's going wrong. react-map-gl looks like a simple wrapper around mapbox-gl, so if you're not planning to use React in this project, you won't want to include react-map-gl either. Perhaps you want to do something like this ?

reddit.com › r/reactjs › mapbox and react-map-gl

r/reactjs on Reddit: Mapbox and react-map-gl

July 2, 2020 -

Does anyone have any experience incorporating mapbox with plotted points from their json in a react app? There are a serious lack of tutorials out there, and the docs for Mapbox are insane.

Top answer

1 of 5

3

Yeah, use layers. There is also direction api so you don’t have to manually get the coordinates. The docs is actually pretty good for plain react. With typescript it gets a bit messier. You can also use hooks, may be easier.

2 of 5

2

I have done this I think, I'l check tomorrow on my pc if nothing is posted by then

reddit.com › r/reactnative › react-native-mapbox-gl vs react-native-maps in 2019

r/reactnative on Reddit: react-native-mapbox-gl vs react-native-maps in 2019

May 14, 2019 -

Hi all,

Now that it's 2019, I'd like to know your take on the performance of react-native-mapbox-gl vs react-native-maps. There was a post last year that react-native-mapbox-gl still had lots of issues but could be production-worthy in 2 months since that post. I'm seriously considering using react-native-mapbox-gl because I don't want to create a billing account in the google maps API, but I'm not sure if it's already a package that can be used in production.

Right now I just need the maps and showing pins functionality. Has any of you used react-native-mapbox-gl and how does it hold up in terms of performance and design/UI?

Thank you

Top answer

1 of 1

2

Hi! I recently had to make this decision as well, and I ended up choosing react-native-maps primarily due to its larger community support in comparison to react-native-mapbox-gl. Aside from that, it will ultimately depend on what your use case is. Both are used in production, but they do offer some different feature sets(e.g. polygon drawing is available in react-native-maps but not react-native-mapbox-gl). Based on what you stated, you can't go wrong with either one really, their API's are fairly similar and performance should be about the same as well from what I can remember. For me, long term support was the deciding factor, since the future of react-native-mapbox-gl is uncertain as mapbox no longer officially supports it IIRC. They recently forked the repo and placed it under a new "official" repository, but you can read the discussion(and concerns brought forth) here to get a better understanding of the situation and to help you make your judgement :-)

reddit.com › r/reactjs › which react libraries do you use for maps

r/reactjs on Reddit: Which React libraries do you use for maps

March 15, 2020 -

I want to generate maps but I have found d3.js to be quite difficult for something basic, in my case, a map showing europe with a popup when you press a country giving some information about it. I have used React-leaflet but I don't like the tiles, I want something abit more basic in a way, that doesn't show all the roads and stuff

Top answer

1 of 7

10

Mapbox. Specifically Uber's react bindings + Deck.gl. you can do amazing stuff...

2 of 7

5

I'm pretty sure you can choose different maps with react leaflet. Hell, I once worked on an app where I initially used OSM tiles but then they blocked public access to their tiles and so I switched the source to a different "tile provider". I'd recommend looking into that before switching to a more obscure library that may not be as well-supported. Personally, I cache the tiles in my own backend (to ensure good performance - which OSM didn't offer) and then use it like so:

npm Trends

npmtrends.com › mapbox-gl-vs-react-map-gl-vs-react-mapbox-gl

mapbox-gl vs react-map-gl vs react-mapbox-gl | npm trends

Comparing trends for mapbox-gl 3.16.0 which has 1,892,414 weekly downloads and 11,969 GitHub stars vs. react-map-gl 8.1.0 which has 931,499 weekly downloads and 8,306 GitHub stars vs. react-mapbox-gl 5.1.1 which has 74,683 weekly downloads and 1,991 GitHub stars.

LogRocket

blog.logrocket.com › home › react map library comparison

React map library comparison - LogRocket Blog

June 4, 2024 - React-map-gl Exposes the entire Mapbox GL JS functionality to React apps. React-map-gl also integrates seamlessly with deck.gl. This means that this library is packed with functionality.

Mapbox

mapbox.com › blog › mapbox-gl-js-react

Mapbox GL JS + React

August 13, 2025 - ... A mapboxgl.Marker instance is used to display the collected data on the map (Mapbox GL JS controls its position on the map) but the contents of the marker is React powered using ReactDOM.render.

Medium

medium.com › @majalijunyc › phase5-using-mapbox-and-or-react-map-gl-aka-the-end-of-the-road-3438fd4742ae

Phase5: Using Mapbox and/or React-Map-Gl; aka the End of the Road | by MAJ ALIJU | Medium

May 1, 2023 - What I implemented for the map, is MapBox GL JS, which you can find here. However I went for a deeper option, given that I had to use Create-React-App (which I do have some qualms with) and use Uber’s implementation of a wonderful React wrapper for Mapbox called React-Map-GL.

Find elsewhere

Google Bing Mojeek

React Map GL

visgl.github.io › introduction

Introduction | react-map-gl

You can create and host your own map tiles and use them with maplibre-gl for (almost) free, if you are comfortable of using open source tools and setting up a cloud storage account. Visit Mapbox and MapLibre websites for examples and documentation. Each library offer unique features that may not exist in another. ... react-map-gl was first created by Uber's Visualization team, where Mapbox was used as a component to build powerful web tools such as geospatial analytics and self-driving data visualization.

React Map GL

visgl.github.io › react-map-gl

Home | react-map-gl

Comes with additional React interfaces such as context and hooks to support custom components. Use together with e.g. deck.gl to render performant and compelling 2D and 3D WebGL visualizations on top of your MapLibre GL JS and Mapbox GL JS based maps.

GitHub

github.com › visgl › react-map-gl › issues › 1151

question: Considerably lower FPS with react-map-gl compared to mapbox-gl · Issue #1151 · visgl/react-map-gl

July 13, 2020 - I'm having a considerably lower frame rate with react-map-gl components compared to only using mapbox-gl. In Chrome, sometimes rendering takes twice as much time with react-map-gl.

Author benknab

reddit.com › r/webdev › preffered mapbox library for react + vite use

r/webdev on Reddit: Preffered Mapbox library for React + Vite use

April 25, 2023 -

Hello, I can't decide between using react-map-gl or mapbox-gl. I have limited knowledge in this aspect, which do you think is more optimized/better overall?

Top answer

1 of 1

1

We use the first-party gl package. We did not get any benefit from the intermediary packages, and in some cases struggled to get complex config options passed through correctly.

GitHub

github.com › alex3165 › react-mapbox-gl › issues › 97

Comparison to Uber's react-map-gl · Issue #97 · alex3165/react-mapbox-gl

January 10, 2017 - has anyone compared this to react-map-gl by uber? if so, what were your findings? for example we are skeptical of building the style object and passing it in to control everything instead of using the semantic style of this library. any ...

Published Jan 10, 2017

Stack Overflow

stackoverflow.com › questions › 59848798 › what-is-the-underlying-architecture-between-mapbox-gl-deck-gl-and-react-map-gl

reactjs - What is the underlying architecture between Mapbox GL, Deck GL and React Map GL? - Stack Overflow

Top answer

1 of 1

2

I had worked recently on a project with exactly the same tech-stack that is open source. You can take reference from https://github.com/thevantageproject/foamviz/blob/dev/src/VizCartographerJourney/index.js

Also, you can learn from this tutorial: https://vis.academy/

reddit.com › r/reactjs › how do i write tests for my mapbox + react-map-gl app?

r/reactjs on Reddit: How do I write tests for my Mapbox + react-map-gl app?

March 13, 2024 -

I have a web app that is fairly simple, it's a map built with Mapbox and react-map-gl that displays a layer of tiles.

I'd like to write end-to-end tests for the map itself, and ultimately have these tests be a part of the CI/CD pipeline. The tests would be of the following, fairly basic nature:

it should load...
it should display a polygon with X name...
it should display polygons with a white fill color...

In other words, pretty simple stuff to ensure that new PRs don't break the basics.

The thing is that I'm having trouble finding information about how mapping apps like this one are actually tested.

The best lead I can find is that deck.gl has some testing features and can supposedly integrate with react-map-gl.

How exactly are tests written for mapping apps?

Top answer

1 of 3

2

Writing tests for a mapping app? You mean like one built-in with Mapbox and react-map-gl?? Start with unit tests for individual components that don't require rendering the map, use Jest or any other JS testing framework for this. For testing interactions between components, you might wanna try using the React testing library which works well with Jest. For end-to-end tests you'll want to simulate user interactions with the map, something like Cypress can be used to automate that and verify the behavior of your app. Since rendering an actual map can be resource-intensive asf and it usually really slows down tests, you might want to mock Mapbox's functionality using jest-mapbox-gl. Once your tests are written you can integrate them into your CI/CD pipeline using tools like Jenkins, GitHub Actions, or GitLab CI.

2 of 3

2

I’ll be following this thread closely as I have a similar question. In our projects we rely on visual regression checks when dealing with the canvas. I’d love to hear a better way to

reddit.com › r/reactjs › best react lib for maps ?

r/reactjs on Reddit: Best React Lib for Maps ?

March 12, 2017 - If you need to do general google maps sort of shit, it's by far the best lib for react. Everything else feels like a hackjob in comparison. That being said, if you need to do really crazy stuff, it will not suffice as it's ultimately just a ...

reddit.com › r/mapbox › a complete guide to sources and layers in react and mapbox gl js

r/mapbox on Reddit: A Complete Guide to Sources and Layers in React and Mapbox GL JS

April 26, 2021 - Understanding how to add data to a map and then visualize it is arguably one of the most important skills when building a quality mapping application. The workflow for adding data to a map and visualizing relies on two key concepts in the Mapbox GL JS library: sources and layers.

reddit.com › r/reactjs › map libraries

r/reactjs on Reddit: Map Libraries

August 22, 2025 -

Any good map rendering libraries for React or Next.

Top answer

1 of 5

6

We've used Leaflet for a large project, its well documented, easy to use and well supported by community: https://react-leaflet.js.org/

2 of 5

4

React-maplibre

reddit.com › r/mapbox › is it not possible to use mapbox with react-map-gl?

r/mapbox on Reddit: Is it not possible to use mapbox with react-map-gl?

July 26, 2024 -

I followed the getting started guide and this error:

Fetch API cannot load mapbox://styles/mapbox/streets-v9. URL scheme "mapbox" is not supported.

Even if I use a URL like this: https://api.mapbox.com/styles/v1/mapbox/streets-v11

I get an error because it seems like the mapbox style contains "mapbox://". The example provided in the react-map-gl repo does not work

Top answer

1 of 2

1

you should have something like inside of your component

2 of 2

1

the issue was I did not have