At a basic level, Redshift is a columnar database, focussed on analytical workloads. Depending on the size of data going into the DB and the workload, most RDBMSs function just fine as a DW/ODS, but Columnar DBs are particularly designed for analytics on large data sets and will perform better in those scenarios, but are NOT designed for transactional workloads. Answer from dontmakemeplaypool on reddit.com
🌐
Oracle
oracle.com › ai database › mysql heatwave
MySQL HeatWave vs Amazon Redshift | Oracle
Better performance and price performance: Oracle HeatWave MySQL is 4X faster than Amazon Redshift, delivering 10X better price-performance. The query performance of HeatWave Lakehouse is 15X faster than Amazon Redshift, delivering 11X better ...
Discussions

Opinions on Amazon Redshift versus other RDBMS?
At a basic level, Redshift is a columnar database, focussed on analytical workloads. Depending on the size of data going into the DB and the workload, most RDBMSs function just fine as a DW/ODS, but Columnar DBs are particularly designed for analytics on large data sets and will perform better in those scenarios, but are NOT designed for transactional workloads. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/SQL
14
5
November 7, 2018
Help with data warehouse selection - on-prem Oracle vs AWS Redshift
To me, option 1 means massive vendor lock-in, expensive to scale, and less interoperable (Redshift and similar cloud options are going to play nicer with other tools as you build out your infra). The limited experience I have with Oracle has been horrible and I don't think I've ever seen someone positively recommend them. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/dataengineering
17
3
July 28, 2023
Interactive Analytics: Redshift vs Snowflake vs BigQuery

Main takeaways:

  • Redshift has higher compute per dollar saving you more money for the same amount of total compute time

  • Snowflake's advantage is that it makes managing a distributed cloud database easier (I think it actually uses redshift under the hood, not 100% sure). The premium is for the less overhead in maintaining a distributed database environment, the ability to elastically change your compute and storage size and being only billed for usage (at the hour level).

  • BigQuery is more expensive per compute than either, but is also easier to manage than snowflake

  • Think of the three as a gradient of how much hand holding you want and paying for that.

More on reddit.com
🌐 r/programming
11
45
October 20, 2016
Google BigQuery vs Amazon Redshift (my take on Quora)

Biggest distinction I've found is that you can't update schemas or do deletes in BigQuery. Depending on your data set, those things might be critical, or might not matter. In Redshift, both of these are possible (and depending what you're doing, can be very efficient)

More on reddit.com
🌐 r/bigdata
13
3
December 30, 2015
🌐
Quora
quora.com › What-are-the-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-Amazon-Redshift-compared-to-SQL-Server-MySQL-and-PostgreSQL
What are the advantages and disadvantages of Amazon Redshift compared to SQL Server, MySQL, and PostgreSQL? - Quora
Answer: It’s a tough game but: RDS is a lower cost Oracle installation with the majority of its benefits and lesser drop outs. Telling this, there no comparison with PostgreSQL that has lesser options mostly related to ‘programmability items’. ...
🌐
Quora
quora.com › What-is-the-difference-between-Amazon-Redshift-and-Oracle
What is the difference between Amazon Redshift and Oracle? - Quora
Answer (1 of 3): There’s a ton of ways to answer this because the two are vastly different platforms by two different vendors trying to solve different problems. At a very high 30,000 foot level, RedShift is a cloud only offering from Amazon which looks to solve data warehousing use cases (batch...
🌐
StackShare
stackshare.io › stackups › amazon-redshift-vs-oracle
Amazon Redshift vs Oracle | What are the differences? | StackShare
Amazon Redshift - It is optimized for data sets ranging from a few hundred gigabytes to a petabyte or more and costs less than $1,000 per terabyte per year, a tenth the cost of most traditional data warehousing solutions. Oracle - Oracle Database is an RDBMS.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/sql › opinions on amazon redshift versus other rdbms?
r/SQL on Reddit: Opinions on Amazon Redshift versus other RDBMS?
November 7, 2018 -

Has anyone used both Amazon Redshift and at least one other major RBDMS like PostgreSQL, MySQL, Microsoft SQL Server, or Oracle SQL? I just joined a new company and the first project that we've been tasked with is building out an ODS for our Marketing, Sales, Finance, and Product data. I'm arriving just in time to help them decide on the RDBMS and one of the suggestions from another team member is Amazon Redshift.

I've had plenty of experience working within the four db's mentioned above and I'm very comfortable in what they're capable of. I've worked inside of a large ODS built in Microsoft SQL Server that supported multiple databases with tables that had tens of millions of records. The schemas were well designed and the database rarely suffered any performance issues or hiccups. More recently, I architected a smaller marketing/sales database in MySQL, hooked it up to Zapier for data inputs and Chartio (BI tool) for reads, and it worked like a charm. I'm confident that with the data we're looking to capture and report off of, a "traditional" RBDMS would work just fine.

That said, I want to be open to Redshift though and give it a fair shot. What can Redshift bring to the table that db's like PGSQL and MySQL cannot? What would we sacrifice by choosing Redshift? How easy will it be for me to become comfortable designing and working within Redshift if I already know PostgreSQL? I could go on asking questions but generally I'm just looking to understand if Redshift has any distinct advantages over the db's I've worked with before.

🌐
StackShare
stackshare.io › stackups › amazon-redshift-vs-mysql
Amazon Redshift vs MySQL | What are the differences? | StackShare
Amazon Redshift - It is optimized for data sets ranging from a few hundred gigabytes to a petabyte or more and costs less than $1,000 per terabyte per year, a tenth the cost of most traditional data warehousing solutions. MySQL - The MySQL software delivers a very fast, multi-threaded, multi-user, and robust SQL (Structured Query Language) database server.
🌐
Airbyte
airbyte.com › data integration platform › data engineering resources › amazon redshift vs mysql- a comparative analysis
Amazon Redshift vs MySQL- A Comparative Analysis | Airbyte
August 29, 2025 - Redshift suits big data analytics, business intelligence, and ML workloads with massive parallel processing and serverless options. MySQL excels in operational applications, web back-ends, and smaller datasets requiring real-time consistency and flexible deployment...
Find elsewhere
🌐
Oracle
oracle.com › ai database › heatwave
HeatWave on AWS vs. Aurora and Redshift or Snowflake | Oracle
Better price-performance: HeatWave MySQL provides up to 10X better throughput than Amazon Aurora, 7X better price-performance than Amazon Redshift, and 10X better price-performance than Snowflake on AWS.
🌐
Hevo
hevodata.com › home › learn › data warehousing
Amazon Redshift vs MySQL: Key Differences
May 29, 2025 - Amazon Redshift is a large-scale ... analysis using Business Intelligence tools. MySQL on the other hand is an open-source Relational Database Management System developed by Oracle....
🌐
Hevo
hevodata.com › home › learn
Learn about data integration, migration, replication, and strategic data practices.
May 13, 2024 - Redshift · Kafka · Versus · Database Management System · MySQL · PostgreSQL · MongoDB · SQL Server · Versus · Platform · Product · Tutorials · Data Replication · MySQL · PostgreSQL · SQL Server · AWS · HomeLearn · April 28th, 2026 By Shiny Vineetha in Data Integration ·
🌐
TrustRadius
trustradius.com › compare-products › oracle-mysql-cloud-service-vs-redshift
Oracle MySQL Cloud Service vs Amazon Redshift | TrustRadius
Compare Oracle MySQL Cloud Service vs Amazon Redshift. 208 verified user reviews and ratings of features, pros, cons, pricing, support and more.
🌐
StackShare
stackshare.io › stackups › amazon-redshift-vs-microsoft-sql-server
Amazon Redshift vs Microsoft SQL Server | What are the differences?
Regardless, you'd certainly only ... open in terms of what you'll do with them. See more ... Coming from "Big" DB engines, such as Oracle or MSSQL, go for PostgreSQL....
🌐
InfluxData
influxdata.com › home
Compare MySQL vs AWS Redshift
December 10, 2021 - Oracle Corporation acquired MySQL in 2010, but it remains open source software with an active community of contributors. Amazon Redshift is a fully managed, petabyte-scale data warehouse service in the cloud.
🌐
TrustRadius
trustradius.com › compare-products › mysql-vs-redshift
MySQL vs Amazon Redshift | TrustRadius
Compare MySQL vs Amazon Redshift. 1188 verified user reviews and ratings of features, pros, cons, pricing, support and more.