Which down jackets are better/comparable to REI? - Bogleheads.org
Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody vs REI Co-Op 650 Down Jacket
Sierra Designs Women's Down Jacket $40 - Backpacking Light
Any feedback on women’s Campwell down parka?
I'm trying to decide between the Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody and the REI Co-op 650 Down Jacket. I know the Patagonia one is pretty expensive compared to the REI jacket, so I’m curious if the extra cost is really worth it.
For those who have tried either or both, what are the pros and cons? How do they compare in terms of warmth, durability, and packability? Does the Patagonia justify the price tag, or is the REI one a solid option for the value?
Also, has anyone been able to score either of these jackets on sale recently? Would love to know about any deals if they’re out there.
Thanks in advance for any advice!
P.S. I live in Atlanta, so it's not crazy cold all winter, however it does get pretty frigid for a few weeks. I'd also be using this during travel to colder places.
I need a good and warm down jacket to wear in NY and was eyeing up the Campwell down parka as it looks slightly more fitted than the Stormhenge parka (which had some bad reviews about its double zipper failing) and it’s also cheaper. However the Campwell only has like three reviews so I wanted to see what anyone here thinks of it. I’m a plus size woman who runs cold and has long arms if that matters. Thanks!
Has anyone tried this jacket on or purchased it? The reviews say it sheds like crazy, but then other reviews say it’s fine. Also curious about the zipper - it’s not a double and I’m wondering if the bottom hem of the jacket stretches since it can’t be unzipped, or if it might be at risk of ripping with too much strain.
I know I can buy it and return it if need be, but I’d rather get a more definite do/do not buy first. Open to alternatives as well - looking for something a little warmer and longer than my Jack Wolfskin hip-length coat for a midwestern winter. Hood is a must!
I see it's for sale at $99. Does anyone have one? Just looking for some reviews. Was thinking about grabbing a Patagonia Nano puff but this one is cheaper. Some of the reviews on the website aren't the best.