Different tools for different jobs. Long stews, long tomato sauce simmers, breads, braising beef, etc - Enamled pan / dutch oven Eggs, steak, general cooking, etc - "regular" cast iron all day. a cost effective 10 or 12" lodge is the best! Answer from Salyare on reddit.com
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/castiron › staub cast iron vs. my $30 lodge?
r/castiron on Reddit: Staub Cast Iron vs. my $30 Lodge?
December 5, 2023 -

To start, I love my lodge cast iron, I literally cook with it every day and its seasoned to perfection, nothing ever sticks to it. However, due to negligent care on my part the bottom of my lodge began rusting, which is repairable, but I saw this Staub cast iron on sale for Black Friday and thought it looks amazing and with an enameled bottom I wouldn’t have to worry about rust.

I’ve read into the Staubs a bit and people seem to love them. Well I just did a fried egg test on my new Staub, after letting it heat up on low with some oil before putting the egg in, and am frankly a little dissappointed with the non-stick performance of this pan. My cast iron can fry an egg with no oil and it doesn’t stick, I wasn’t expecting that level of performance but for such an expensive pan I was hoping for the egg to not completely stick and make a mess.

Since I’m a newbie with these pans, I didn’t know that the top was coated with enamel as well, which means it doesn’t need to be seasoned, but it also means I can’t use my cast iron scrubber to clean or use any metal utensils. I kind of loved being able to throw anything at my lodge cast iron and never have to worry about scratches. This pan seems to need more care.

So, maybe the staub just isn’t for me? Is it not intended to be used as a true cast iron since its got an enameled top? Maybe I’m just completely using it wrong? Please let me know because it is a gorgeous pan

Thanks!

Discussions

Le Creuset or Staub which is Best? - Cookware - Hungry Onion
What’s the difference between the two? Both are ECI and made in France. However, I’ve noticed that Staub is more reasonably priced. I remember Julia Child even commenting on how much Le Creuset had increased in price on one of her cooking shows. Why such a huge price gap? More on hungryonion.org
🌐 hungryonion.org
0
March 30, 2022
Staub vs Lodge cast iron "toys"
Temu Coupon Code 2025 40% Off {[ach903114]} "OR" {[ach903114]} – Get More $100 Off + Free Shipping for New & Existing Customers Temu offers a $100 More on chefsteps.com
🌐 chefsteps.com
October 31, 2015
Staub Cast Iron vs. my $30 Lodge?
Different tools for different jobs. Long stews, long tomato sauce simmers, breads, braising beef, etc - Enamled pan / dutch oven Eggs, steak, general cooking, etc - "regular" cast iron all day. a cost effective 10 or 12" lodge is the best! More on reddit.com
🌐 r/castiron
5
5
December 5, 2023
Staub cast iron?!
Nice pieces for sure! They’re enameled so they don’t get seasoned. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/castiron
31
126
April 12, 2023
🌐
The Kitchn
thekitchn.com › best-cast-iron-skillets-23200316
Best Cast Iron Skillets of 2024 (Lodge, Staub, More: Tested by Us) | The Kitchn
November 3, 2023 - Personally, I think it’s worth having both. But here’s the caveat: If you want the heat-retaining abilities of cast iron, but don’t want to worry about maintaining the seasoning, an enameled cast iron skillet (like my top pick from Staub) is a great option.
🌐
Williams Sonoma
williams-sonoma.com › products › staub-traditional-skillet
Staub Enameled Cast Iron Traditional Deep Skillet - 11-Inch | Williams Sonoma
Combining the best features of a sauté pan and a fry pan, this Staub skillet has high, straight sides that reduce splatters on the stovetop. Everything from cornbread and biscuits to fruit cobblers cook to golden perfection in the deep
🌐
ZWILLING
zwilling.com › home › cookware › pans › skillets
Staub Cast Iron Fry Pans/ Skillets 8.5-inch
Staub Cast Iron 8.5-inch, Traditional Deep Skillet, Citron
Staub Cast Iron 8.5-inch, Traditional Deep Skillet, Citron ►Free shipping on orders above $79 ✓ Order now directly from the manufacturer✓
(4.7)
Price   $99.99
🌐
TechGearLab
techgearlab.com › kitchen › cookware
The Best Cast Iron Skillet of 2025 | Tested & Rated
Lodge 10.25"
We put cast iron skillets to the test from Lodge, Le Creuset, Staub, Victoria, and more to find the best for your kitchen In the market for a quality cast iron skillet? We bought 15 of the best pans, and our experts spent weeks cooking all of their meals and baking various...
Rating: 4.8 ​
🌐
The Home Depot
homedepot.com › p › reviews › staub-Cast-Iron-12-in-Cast-Iron-Frying-Pan-in-Black-1004498 › 332030694 › 1
Reviews for staub Cast Iron 12 in. Cast Iron Frying Pan in Black | Pg 1 - The Home Depot
staub Cast Iron 12 in. Cast Iron Frying Pan in Black 1004498
The Staub fry pan browns foods beautifully, be it chicken breasts, potatoes, or bacon. The enameled black matte interior imparts texture, promoting exceptional browning. Cast iron offers steady, even heat distribution, so the temperature of the pan won't drop as you cook. Low, curved sides make it easy to flip the food, which releases easily. Staub enameled cast iron cookware is the choice of the world's best chefs. With exceptional durability, it is perfect for day-to-day use in both gourmet home kitchens and prestigious restaurants around the world. Each piece transitions beautifully from th
(5.0)
Price   $249.99
Find elsewhere
🌐
Serious Eats
seriouseats.com › best-enameled-cast-iron-skillets-6833276
The 3 Best Enameled Cast Iron Skillets of 2025, Tested & Reviewed
May 19, 2025 - It also seared steak well and cooked ... favorite enameled cast iron pan. ... The Staub skillet is fantastic in terms of quality, performance, and ease of use....
🌐
Amazon
amazon.com › STAUB-Pans-8-5-inch-Traditional-Skillet-Cherry › dp › B0CTCY162T
Amazon.com: STAUB Cast Iron 8.5-inch Traditional Deep Skillet - Cherry: Home & Kitchen
Proudly made in France, Staub has been the benchmark for premium cast iron cookware. Like all Staub fry pans, the Staub Traditional Skillet browns foods beautifully. Whether you’re searing chicken breasts, frying bacon, or caramelizing carrots, ...
🌐
Houzz
houzz.com › discussions › 5907160 › enamelled-cast-iron-skillets-staub-or-le-creuset
Enamelled cast iron skillets....Staub or Le Creuset?
April 30, 2020 - I'm in the market for some new high end enamelled cast iron skillets and am torn between Staub and Le Creuset. For those of you that have used them, I'd very much appreciate your input 1
🌐
Crate & Barrel
crateandbarrel.com › home › kitchen › cookware › frying pans & skillets
Staub 8.5" Matte Black Enameled Cast Iron Traditional Deep Skillet + Reviews | Crate & Barrel
Staub ® 8.5" Matte Black Enameled Cast Iron Traditional Deep Skillet
Enameled in modern matte black, this display-worthy cast iron skillet goes from stovetop to oven to table. The deep skillet combines the best of a frying pan and a saute pan, with even heat distribution over the entire base of the pan plus high sides that accommodate stirring and prevent spills. Spouts make it easy to pour sauces and gravies or remove fat. Staub's signature textured matte black enamel interior browns and caramelizes foods beautifully—plus it's scratch resistant, easy to clean and requires no seasoning. A beautiful addition to any table, the skillet particularly pops among whit
(4.7)
Price   $99.95
🌐
ZWILLING
zwilling.com › home › cookware › pans › skillets
Staub Cast Iron 11-inch, Traditional Deep Skillet, Cherry ...
Staub Cast Iron 11-inch, Traditional Deep Skillet, Cherry
Staub Cast Iron 11-inch, Traditional Deep Skillet, Cherry ►Free shipping on orders above $79 ✓ Order now directly from the manufacturer✓
(4.7)
Price   $279.99
🌐
Hungry Onion
hungryonion.org › cooking discussions › cookware
Le Creuset or Staub which is Best? - Cookware - Hungry Onion
March 30, 2022 - What’s the difference between the two? Both are ECI and made in France. However, I’ve noticed that Staub is more reasonably priced. I remember Julia Child even commenting on how much Le Creuset had increased in price …
🌐
Flavour Network
flavournetwork.ca › article › staub-daily-pan-honest-review
Our Honest Review Of The Staub Daily Pan
October 2, 2024 - There are a lot of things to love ... heat evenly. Unlike other cast iron pans we’ve used, it was able to brown meats and veggies really nicely without sticking....
🌐
Bon Appétit
bonappetit.com › shopping › shopping › staub vs. le creuset, which is better?
Staub Vs Le Creuset: Which Is Better? | Bon Appétit
August 8, 2025 - The Staub cocottes feature a matte black enamel interior in contrast to Le Creuset’s glossy off-white. Both interiors are nonstick-ish (they’ll never be quite as nonstick as a well-seasoned, uncoated cast-iron skillet), but the Staub’s black interior hides stains and signs of wear in ...
🌐
Houzz
houzz.com › discussions › 6376528 › my-most-used-staub
My most used Staub…
May 29, 2023 - I only bought this Staub skillet a few months ago and I love this thing! For steaks, my hubby has now converted me from ribeyes/tenderloins to Sirloin (have to be very thick though) and are perfect every time when seared and put into the oven-which is how we mostly use it. Great for thick chops too! For some reason it is so much better than my big cast iron skillet I’ve had for 30 years.
🌐
ChefSteps
chefsteps.com › forum › posts › staub-vs-lodge-cast-iron-toys
Staub vs Lodge cast iron "toys"
October 31, 2015 - Temu Coupon Code 2025 40% Off {[ach903114]} "OR" {[ach903114]} – Get More $100 Off + Free Shipping for New & Existing Customers Temu offers a $100
🌐
ZWILLING
zwilling.com › home › cookware › pans › skillets
Buy Staub Cast Iron Frying pan | ZWILLING.COM
Staub Cast Iron 12-inch, Fry Pan, Grenadine
Staub Cast Iron 12-inch, Fry Pan, Grenadine ►Free shipping on orders above $79 ✓ Order now directly from the manufacturer✓
(4.9)
Price   $249.99
🌐
Sur La Table
surlatable.com › home › products › cookware › stovetop › skillets
Staub Cast Iron Traditional Deep Skillet, 8.5
Enameled cast iron retains and distributes heat evenly and efficiently · Black interior enamel sears beautifully and is slightly textured for better browning · Spout ensures mess-free pouring of sauces, pan juices and rendered fat ... Dimensions and weights: 14.37" W x 8.7" W x 2.71" H; 4.5 lb. ... Small but mighty, this skillet from Staub is an essential piece for any kitchen.
🌐
Food & Wine
foodandwine.com › staub-cocotte-dutch-oven-review-8775124
Staub’s Cocotte Review: Tested by Food & Wine
January 22, 2025 - I’ve used enameled Dutch ovens ... there’s a reason pro chefs prefer Staub — its versatile cookware is built to last and is superior for braising, blanching, and baking....