Consider the difference between discussing two people who started dating 11 months ago, (let's call them Couple I) vs people who started dating 12 months ago (Couple II).

Couple I will have been dating for a year now once another month passes by (this tense is known as Future Perfect).

Couple II has been dating for a year now (this is known as Present Perfect Continuous).

Answer from David McKnight on Stack Exchange
🌐
Thesaurus.com
thesaurus.com › e › grammar › has-been-vs-have-been
“Has Been” vs. “Have Been”: When To Use Each One | ...
June 30, 2022 - Has been is the form used with a third person singular subject (including the pronouns she, he, and it—but not singular they). Have been is the form used with any other subject (including the pronouns I, we, and they).
🌐
Grammar Book
grammarbook.com › home › verbs › have been vs. has been vs. had been: how to use each one correctly
Have Been vs. Has Been vs. Had Been: How to Use Each One Correctly - The Blue Book of Grammar and Punctuation
August 1, 2023 - As the post states, “We would use have been when the sentence subject is I, you, we, or the third-person plural (the children have been studying grammar all morning; they have been studying all morning).” The pronoun “those” is third-person ...
🌐
EnglishClass101
englishclass101.com › lesson › english-grammar-made-easy-196-how-to-use-have-been-and-has-been
How To Use "Have Been" and "Has been" - EnglishClass101
In this lesson, you'll learn how to use "have been" and "has been"Visit EnglishClass101 and learn English fast with real lessons by real teachers.
🌐
MyEnglishMatters
myenglishmatters.com › 2018 › 06 › 28 › whats-the-difference-between-has-been-have-been-and-had-been
What’s the difference between “has been”, “have been” and “had been”?
“Have been” and “has been” are used to mean that something began in the past and has lasted into the present time. 1. “had been” – something began in the past, lasted for some time, then ended. It is entirely in the past. ... They had been talking for over an hour before Laila arrived.
🌐
EngVarta
engvarta.com › correct-use-of-has-been-have-been-and-had-been-in-spoken-english
Correct Use Of Has Been, Have Been And Had Been In Spoken English
June 30, 2025 - Similar to “has been,” “have been” is also used in the present perfect tense. However, it is used with the pronouns “I,” “you,” “we,” and “they.”
Top answer
1 of 2
1

I agree with user 772922, but here is a fuller explanation of the grammar rules.

"Have" and "has" are conjugations of the auxiliary verb used in the present perfect tense. The choice of which one to use has nothing to do with the tense. It is simply dictated by the subject of the verb -- in other words, "who" has or have or had been.

The present perfect tense is used to convey an action that began in the past and continues in the present.

Here is the conjugation of the verb "to be" in the present perfect tense: I have been We have been You have been He/She/It has been They have been

The past perfect tense is used to convey something that happened in the past, a past that occurred before another, later action in the past that you happen to be discussing, as in, "I had made the cookies before we ate."

Here is the conjugation of the verb "to be" in the past perfect tense: I had been We had been You had been He/She/It had been They had been

And that's the rule!

Regarding the original question, it does seem that the subject is not the singular Mrs. Jones, but a plural "they" that includes both Mrs. Jones and a lot of other teachers. So you would use either "have been" or "had been" (but not "has been"). The choice is up to the author, depending on which tense is to be conveyed.

I hope that's helpful.

The site's rules ask for sources. Lots of sources, including the Chicago Manual of Style and a ream of English grammar textbooks I was given throughout my K-12 education, including the once ubiquitous Heath Handbook of English.

2 of 2
0

You have to use have been instead of has been if it is talking about present and had been if it is talking about past, because here we are talking about many others teachers with Mrs. Jones, and whenever we talk about more people we use have instead of has.

Find elsewhere
🌐
Quora
quora.com › Which-one-is-correct-They-have-been-gone-or-They-were-gone
Which one is correct: “They have been gone” or “They were gone”? - Quora
Answer (1 of 9): Both are correct, but they mean different things. They have been gone: Prior to the present time, they have not been here. The implication is that their past absence has some effect on the present, e.g. I haven’t yet paid them, because they have been gone. They were gone: They ...
🌐
ThoughtCo
thoughtco.com › languages › english as a second language › grammar
Understand the Difference Between 'Have Gone to' and 'Have Been to'
October 26, 2020 - Both have been to and have gone to can be used in future and past perfect forms. Had been to indicates that someone has gone to another place and returned. On the other hand, had gone to indicates that the person was not present at some time in the past. ... I'd been to a restaurant, so I wasn't hungry when he invited me out to eat. They'd gone to the shopping mall, so they weren't home when I arrived.
🌐
Ludwig
ludwig.guru › s › have+they+been
have they been | English examples in context | Ludwig
You can use it when asking a question about the past, for example 'Have they been to the beach this summer?'.
🌐
Love You English
loveyouenglish.com › home › blog › use of has been, have been & had been – rules with examples
Use of Has Been, Have Been & Had Been – Rules with Examples
July 30, 2025 - Here, “have been” serves the same purpose as “has been” but is used with different subjects. “Had been” is used in the past perfect continuous tense. It describes actions that were ongoing in the past up until another point in the past. This form is used to show that one action was in progress before another action took place. She had been living in New York before she moved to Los Angeles. They had been dating for five years before they got married.
🌐
Bab.la
en.bab.la › sentences › english › have-they-been
have they been example sentences - Use have they been in a sentence
English There have indeed been changes. volume_up more_vert ... English They have probably been killed.
Top answer
1 of 1
2

To begin with, look at your sentence:

"Members of the 16th Lok Sabha worked harder in the budget session than they have in the last 10 years, parliamentary data shows.

I recommend looking at it in two parts:

  1. Members of the 16th Lok Sabha worked harder in the budget session
  2. than they have in the last 10 years, parliamentary data shows.

Sentence 1 tells you that members of the 16th Lok Sabha worked harder in the budget session. The "budget session" refers to the present budget session, that happened just now, or during the 16th Lok Sabha, if you will.

Sentence 2 introduces a comparison- with how much they have worked in the last 10 years. Now, the idea behind using "have" is to introduce a continuum, a matter of fact that "has been happening" regularly over the past 10 years.

If you use "had" instead, it gives the idea that something HAS happened at a certain point in time, and then that's it. It didn't happen anymore. For instance:

They studied harder this term than they had last year.

Notice how "had" is used to indicate what they did just once, that is last year.

Again, if you now use "have" in the same sentence, see how you get a different meaning:

They studied harder this term than they have in the last five years.

Here, "have" tells you about something that hasn't occurred just once, but has been occurring regularly over a course of time, that is five years.

It's interesting to note that using "had" in part 2 of your original sentence wouldn't make it incorrect, technically. There is a very fine line between using "have" and "had" to denote a continous action in the past tense. As I explained with my previous example, if you use "had" in sentence 2, it indicates that the members of the Lok Sabha had worked up until now, which doesn't fit in well with sentence 1.

And lastly, do take a look at this question on the EL&U site: How do the tenses and aspects in English correspond temporally to one another?. It should give you a clear picture about everything.

🌐
Quora
learninglanguages.quora.com › What-is-the-difference-between-were-and-have-been
What is the difference between “were” and “have been”? - Learning Languages - Quora
Answer (1 of 2): Were is past simple tense as there were many in the hall before we came. Have been is present perfect tense as I have been living in London for five years now.
🌐
WordReference
forum.wordreference.com › english only › english only
have been/have been being | WordReference Forums
July 24, 2007 - She's being chatty She's been chatting all day She's been being chattty all day - As you can see, the problem is not with the tense itself. Otherwise sentence #2 would be equally wrong. It's the juxtaposition of "being" with "been" that makes the listener cringe. ... You cannot say "I have been being" in English, at least not in normal usage.
🌐
Ludwig
ludwig.guru › s › they+had+been
they had been | Meaning, Grammar Guide & Usage Examples | Ludwig.guru
For example, "they had been walking ... action, and the present perfect continuous tense ("they have been"), which describes an action that started in the past and continues into the present....