OP needs to shop for insurance first. ETA: Insurance average for a 16-yo is $2511 (minimum coverage) to $7625 (full). Answer from gin_bulag_katorse on reddit.com
Car and Driver
caranddriver.com › rankings › best-cars-for-teens
Best First Cars for Teens and New Drivers in 2026, Tested
Car and Driver's rankings are arrived at from the results of our extensive instrumented testing of several hundred vehicles each year and from our expert editors' subjective impressions gained in real-world driving. We've ranked the Best Cars for Teens based on roughly 200 data points encompassing acceleration, handling, comfort, cargo space, fuel efficiency, value, and how enjoyable they are to drive.
What are the most reliable cars?
The BMW 3-series, Subaru Crosstrek, and Toyota Corolla are among the most reliable cars on sale today, according to Consumer Reports.
caranddriver.com
caranddriver.com › rankings › best-cars-for-teens
Best First Cars for Teens and New Drivers in 2026, Tested
Are SUVs good for a teen's first car?
Larger vehicles such as SUVs and trucks offer more metal and weight to protect occupants in accidents, but that doesn't mean they're inherently safer. Some may be too large for new drivers to handle, as they're physically wider and longer than the average sedan or coupe. Taller vehicles also have higher centers of gravity which may make them more prone to rollover-type accidents.
caranddriver.com
caranddriver.com › rankings › best-cars-for-teens
Best First Cars for Teens and New Drivers in 2026, Tested
What are the safest cars?
The Honda CR-V, Honda Accord, and Honda Odyssey rank among the safest vehicles on sale today, according to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.
caranddriver.com
caranddriver.com › rankings › best-cars-for-teens
Best First Cars for Teens and New Drivers in 2026, Tested
Videos
14:16
10 BEST Cheap First Cars - YouTube
02:14
Safe and affordable vehicles for teens - 2025 list - YouTube
10:42
Best Cars For New Drivers & Teenagers That Are Reliable & Affordable ...
What's the Best Car For a Teenager?
03:06
Looking for a safe first car? Here are the top picks for teen drivers ...
02:47
What are the best cars for teens? | NBC 7 San Digo - YouTube
C For Cars
cforcars.com › home › info › top 10 best cars for teenagers in canada: safe, affordable, and reliable choices
Top 10 Best Cars for Teenagers in Canada: Safe, Affordable, and Reliable Choices - C For Cars
September 18, 2025 - Even older models have strong crash-test results. Insurance: Insurance rates are generally moderate, as the Civic is classified as a compact car rather than a sports vehicle. Maintenance: Known for bulletproof reliability, the Civic is inexpensive to maintain, with parts readily available across the country. Fuel Economy: Expect around 7–8 L/100 km combined, which helps stretch a student budget. A used Civic (3–5 years old) can be found in Canada for $18,000–$25,000, depending on condition and mileage.
Reddit
reddit.com › r/whatcarshouldibuy › what car should i buy as a 16 year old
r/whatcarshouldIbuy on Reddit: What car should I buy as a 16 year old
January 29, 2024 -
Hello r/whatcarshouldIbut , Im sure you guys get lots of posts like this but im about to turn 16 and am looking for a car to buy. Im looking for something
- Not to expensive, around $6000-$9000 tops
- Won't cost me a fortune in repairs and something I could maybe repair myself with a bit of knowledge since I do take auto shop class
I would be a responsible driver and as for what type of cars I like, here's a few: Honda civic type r hatchbacks, bmw e30, bmw e36, Nissan 350 and 370z, and stuff like that.
Whatever recommendations you guys have and reasons why, please leave them below I would appreciate it a lot
Top answer 1 of 56
51
OP needs to shop for insurance first. ETA: Insurance average for a 16-yo is $2511 (minimum coverage) to $7625 (full).
2 of 56
27
I would be a responsible driver and as for what type of cars I like, here's a few: Honda civic type r hatchbacks, bmw e30, bmw e36, Nissan 350 and 370z, and stuff like that. While that's great that you like those cars, just know that it's going to be rare for you to find those types of vehicles in decent condition for your price range nor will they be cheap for upkeep. Not to mention you have to consider that if your insurance company deems your vehicle is a sports car you are going to be paying a lot more money than if they see you driving a beater. An insurance company sees a 16 year old driving a sports car as a disaster waiting to happen. I would say a Honda Accord coupe, Lexus SC300, or Scion tC could fit your criteria. The insurance companies aren't going to associate them with being a sports car and they are going to be in your price range.
AutoNation USA
autonationusa.com › home › used car guides › top 10 cars for teen drivers
Top 10 Cars For Teen Drivers | AutoNation USA
The Hyundai Elantra has quickly gained a reputation for offering modern tech, sharp styling, and impressive safety. The 2021 redesign introduced standard safety features that rival luxury vehicles. Elantra is frequently featured on lists of top 10 cars for 16 year olds because of its combination ...
IIHS
iihs.org › ratings › safe-vehicles-for-teens
Safe vehicles for teens
Prices, provided by Kelley Blue Book and rounded to the nearest $100, are average U.S. values from April 19, 2024, for the lowest trim level and earliest applicable model year. The estimates are based on the following criteria: vehicle in good condition, typical mileage and private party purchase. ... All listed vehicles are winners of the 2025 IIHS Top Safety Pick or Top Safety Pick+ award and come with standard vehicle-to-vehicle automatic emergency braking and good-rated seat belt reminders.
CarGurus
cargurus.ca › Cars › articles › best-cars-for-students-canada
The Best Cars for Students in Canada 2025 - CarGurus.ca
If you really want a compact SUV like a Toyota RAV4 or a Honda CR-V on a budget, take a look at our recommendations in our list of the best used SUVs in Canada for under $10,000. Note: Images may show US models. ... Stephanie Wallcraft is a multiple award-winning professional automotive journalist based in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Ystauto
blog.ystauto.ca › 10-best-first-cars-for-teenagers-in-canada
10 Best First Cars for Teenagers in Canada for 2025 – YST Auto Sales Blog
If you’re looking to upgrade, use your old car as a trade-in for a new one from our extensive selection. YST Auto Sales will even handle the simultaneous pick-up and drop-off for both vehicles. This also saves your valuable time and saves more on your new car—a win-win! ... The Honda Civic has ...
Consumer Reports
consumerreports.org › cars › best used cars under $20,000 for teens
Best Used Cars Under $20,000 for Teens via @ConsumerReports
September 8, 2025 - The third group (available to Consumer Reports members only) are the safest cars that are also CR Recommended. This means that these vehicles also meet our stringent requirements for road-test performance, reliability, and owner satisfaction. • Good for Safety Under $10,000 • Best for Safety Under $20,000 • Recommended Used Cars for Teens
EchoPark
echopark.com › articles › best-cars-for-teens
Best Cars for Teenage Drivers - Top 10 Rankings | EchoPark
View the best cars for teens in 2023. Ranked on affordability, maintenance costs, safety, and tech features. Find cheap cars for teens with EchoPark Automotive.
Motor Axle
motoraxle.com › home › top 10 cars for 16-year-olds that are cheap, safe, and cool to drive
Top 10 Cars for 16-Year-Olds That Are Cheap, Safe, and Cool to Drive
September 8, 2025 - Must Check: 10 Affordable Cars with 360 Degree Camera for Easy Parking and Safety ... The 2023 Honda Civic would also be perfect for a 16-year-old’s first car. It is rated five stars overall for crash protection by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), and it is a IIHS Top Safety Pick, highlighting robust crash protection and comprehensive safety equipment.
Ramsey Solutions
ramseysolutions.com › home › articles › insurance › home and auto insurance
What Every Parent Should Know When It Comes to the Best Cars for Teens
May 1, 2025 - IIHS made it a Top Safety Pick+, and as a midsize vehicle, it offers more protection than a small car. It holds its value well and earns an 85 out of 100 from J.D. Power for reliability. With a sporty-looking front grill, this four-door still has enough cool factor for your teen. And because it’s five years old, it’s already taken its biggest hit in depreciation.
isure
isure.ca › home › the best cars for teen drivers: safety and affordability
The Best Cars for Teen Drivers: Safety and Affordability
July 16, 2025 - You’ll want to give your teen access to a car but also want the car insurance rate to be affordable. So, what are the best cars for teen drivers? The IIHS and CR agencies partner each year to identify the best new and used cars for teens to help shoppers choose dependable and safe vehicles.
Capital One
capitalone.com › auto learning center › finding the right car › the 10 best cars for teen drivers, according to science
The 10 Best Cars for Teen Drivers, According to Science | Capital One Auto Navigator
December 11, 2023 - Then there is the peace of mind you’ll enjoy thanks to its industry-standard warranty and five-year roadside assistance program. Your teenager will like the Limited trim level’s upscale look and feel, as well as the wireless smartphone charger and premium sound system. Fact that might surprise you: Thanks to its standard LED headlights, the Elantra Limited gets a “Top Safety Pick+” rating from the IIHS. It is one of two vehicles on our list to earn this distinction. ... Why it makes the list: A midsize car with lots of interior and trunk room, an industry-standard warranty and roadside assistance program, free connected services, and attractive design, the Kia Optima S is a well-equipped vehicle that should last a long time.